Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say that DS should have the spare room?

167 replies

SplunkPostGres · 07/08/2022 21:41

I’ve just had the second anxious call at bedtime from DS at his Dad’s house. He has to sleep on inflatable mattress in the living room because his Fathers daughter (18) from his first marriage is sleeping in the spare room.

This always happens. He doesn’t have a proper room at his Dad’s because it’s kept as a spare room. Whenever both children are there, it’s always DS who sleeps in the lounge. Tonight they’re packing for a holiday tomorrow and DS with a bad knee can’t go to bed until they do. He is 9. He has ASD. He needs to go to bed. And I’m 250 miles away and unable to do anything about it.

AIBU to say that DS should have a proper bed at his Dad’s house?

OP posts:
TheWayoftheLeaf · 08/08/2022 11:38

Tbh I'd say an 18 year old girl has more need of privacy than a 9 year old boy... it does seem harsh but those are the ropes I'm afraid

aSofaNearYou · 08/08/2022 11:31

TommySaid · 08/08/2022 11:20

For me I think that the older child gets priority of the room.

However I do agree with many of the PPs about him having the spare room so he can go to bed earlier etc.

So surely the most obvious solution would be to have bunk beds in the spare bedroom so they can both use it whenever they are there and no one needs to sleep on the sofa or stay up late.

If I were her it wouldn't cross my mind to share a room with a 9 year old boy over sleeping in the living room by myself, so it wouldn't be the obvious solution to me!

MiauzenKatzenjammer · 08/08/2022 11:27

The dad is the person who allowed the spare room to become double booked. It's fairly obvious that he should sleep on the sofa.

MRex · 08/08/2022 11:24

The girl should be given the privacy she needs to undress and/or change sanitary wear without having to do it in the family area of the house with men around.
It would be usual to undress and change sanitary wear in the bathroom.

Dad could share with either child, that isn't a safeguarding risk unless he is an incestuous pervert, which is an entirely different issue. The suggestion wasn't for her to share with a random man, but her own dad. The kids could also share. Otherwise dad should sleep in the living room, or put the airbed into a bedroom. What should happen is keeping the child awake when he's exhausted, for the convenience of the adults.

Still, this was last night. Hopefully they have got away without further upset OP. It's useful to use those working with your DS to help lay out what he needs at contact time, and to then share this with your ex. It should be focused on needs rather than wants, and may help him to understand how to make DS happier on visits.

TommySaid · 08/08/2022 11:20

For me I think that the older child gets priority of the room.

However I do agree with many of the PPs about him having the spare room so he can go to bed earlier etc.

So surely the most obvious solution would be to have bunk beds in the spare bedroom so they can both use it whenever they are there and no one needs to sleep on the sofa or stay up late.

aSofaNearYou · 08/08/2022 11:13

Society · 08/08/2022 10:44

The vitriol aimed at an 18 year old teenage girl on this thread is bizarre. The daughter is a red herring here. Their FATHER should make sure BOTH his children have a bed to sleep in when they stay. He should give his bedroom up for one of the children when they stay and the other in the spare room. The girl should be given the privacy she needs to undress and/or change sanitary wear without having to do it in the family area of the house with men around. And likewise his son should have a quiet room to himself to go to sleep and relax. I have ASD and still think it's inappropriate to expect an 18 year old girl to sleep in the living room. Their fathers inability to provide a bed for his children is the issue, not his daughter!

And it's absurd some of the suggestions that a female doesn't need any privacy or can sleep in bed with her dad! Quite an alarming safeguarding issue, if that's the kind of thing some people deem appropriate actually!

I don't see vitriol tbh, I think this is all a bit dramatic. An 18 year old of either sex should be fine to be pretty flexible about sleeping in the living room, whether that be on an air bed or the sofa, it just shouldn't be that big a deal for them. Uni is full of experiences like that, people of that age are generally equipped to cope and will have done things like this many times.

She doesn't have to get changed or change sanitary products in the living room, that's what bathrooms are for.

Yes the dad could give up his room so she could have it. I just think that it should be far less of a stretch for her to sleep in the living room than a 9 year old.

Society · 08/08/2022 10:44

The vitriol aimed at an 18 year old teenage girl on this thread is bizarre. The daughter is a red herring here. Their FATHER should make sure BOTH his children have a bed to sleep in when they stay. He should give his bedroom up for one of the children when they stay and the other in the spare room. The girl should be given the privacy she needs to undress and/or change sanitary wear without having to do it in the family area of the house with men around. And likewise his son should have a quiet room to himself to go to sleep and relax. I have ASD and still think it's inappropriate to expect an 18 year old girl to sleep in the living room. Their fathers inability to provide a bed for his children is the issue, not his daughter!

And it's absurd some of the suggestions that a female doesn't need any privacy or can sleep in bed with her dad! Quite an alarming safeguarding issue, if that's the kind of thing some people deem appropriate actually!

Maybeebebe · 08/08/2022 10:44

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 06:38

You are being ridiculous. An adult female should always have a room over a child

It's like giving up a seat on the bus.

It's School holidays. He is fine

Have you actually even read the thread?

DuchessDarty · 08/08/2022 10:40

I do agree but in this case I wouldn't consider it to be about privacy but about practicality? It doesn't make sense for a young child to have to stay up way later than they can really manage when there is a room they could be in.

Yes it should be about practicality but more importantly here, it should be about minimising change for an autistic child. He is used to sleeping in the spare room. Even if he was able to go to sleep at a normal time in the living room, he still would have been discombobulated if not distressed by sleeping in a different room. Especially on the night before he flies to a different place.

OP, as a mother of an autistic DC, you have my sympathy. It is awful hearing your autistic child distressed. I hope he is feeling better today and you’re able to speak to him before he goes.

voldr · 08/08/2022 10:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Thinking like making accommodations based on disability?

You sound bitter.

maddy68 · 08/08/2022 10:14

yellowcarpetflair · 08/08/2022 07:57

@maddy68

Especially if he has asd you should be equipping him with emotional capacity to deal with the changes not cause him additional anxiety.

Do you also tell wheelchair users that they need to learn to walk too? Given how spectacularly ignorant and ableist this comment is, you probably do.

No. I have an asd child and I work iwoth asd children.

They need strategies to cope with changes to routine the parent here is not helping.

It's like having a wheelchair user and putting the brakes on

Iamthewombat · 08/08/2022 10:00

Itslookinggood · 08/08/2022 07:12

OP. I’ve been where you are. Your EXH sounds a lot like mine.

we don’t have the ASd but the rest of it is thr same. Child sobbing down the phone etc.

If your EXh has parental responsibility DS can’t legally be removed from his care. But the closer DS gets to 14, the more his views will be taken into account.

I’d say you’ve got a 2 step process here. 1. Holiday: Text DS today and find out how he’s feeling about the hol. Try to reassure, encourage etc, it’s only a week, etc. If he’s adamant he can’t go/ is distressed, he’ll have to tell his dad he can’t go because he is too anxious, and you’ll have to back him explaining that his ASD won’t allow him to go, etc.

then be prepared for the fight but be clear it’s the ASD up that’s the issue. If your EXh is anything like mine, he’ll need something to blame. That will probably he you, but you can deflect some of it through the ASD.

step 2, revisit contact. It isn’t your EXh who has rights, it’s your son. He’s now 9 and has a voice. It’s an awful process to go through, but it will be different now from when he was little.

my DS is 14 now and has no contact with his dad. There is not a thing EXH can do about it. For you, it really is just a question of hanging in there and trying to get through as best you can, with DS needs and wishes at the forefront, for the next 2-3 years.

Reading this was actually a chilling experience. The spite and resentment against the ex partner, and the desire to land one on him by any means possible, just oozes out. I’m sensing something similar from the OP.

Kids of divorced parents ‘sob down the phone’ for all kinds of reasons. My friend’s stepson, aged 10, sobbed down the phone to his mother for three hours because his dad took him to a different sweet shop, rather than the shop the kid wanted to go to, which was 2 miles away. Encouraged by his mother, of course, who should have let her exH get on with the parenting. Or, as others have pointed out, children absorb tension from their parents.

The OP still hasn’t told us whose choice it was to move 250 miles away from where she and her ex-husband previously lived, and hence whose choice it was that the child should have a 500 mile round trip to his dad’s house. I wonder why that is?

Herejustforthisone · 08/08/2022 09:54

So many posters on this thread are outing themselves as ignorant fools by showing no understanding of ASD and yet ironically, assuming full understanding of the court ordered contact order and the OP’s past relationship.

It’s more important for a 18 year old woman to have a bedroom, rather than a nine year old with autism who isn’t allowed to go to bed until the adults decide they want to, because his blow up bed has been put in their living room? Really?

I really fucking hate AIBU, it’s populated by such inadequate people whose sole intent is to spew vitriol at every OP, regardless of the circs.

30mph · 08/08/2022 09:50

It's really not a matter of adult priority over children, it's about need. A 9yr old child shouldn't be sleeping in a family room, where they are kept awake until late, when the two adults can sleep in bedrooms. Let alone a child with SEN.

Given the real distress this is causing the child, the situation needs to be addressed by the adults and resolved sensibly. One solution would be for the Dad to sleep in the family room.

I think you need to raise the issue as objectively and neutrally as possible, and ask Dad to consider other options. If he won't engage then you possibly need to balance the benefits of the relationship against the upset the situation is causing. Is it causing more harm than good? It really won't be long before DS can vote with his feet.

GlitteryGreen · 08/08/2022 09:34

I don’t know anyone who would prioritise their younger DC over their older ones when it comes to privacy.

I do agree but in this case I wouldn't consider it to be about privacy but about practicality? It doesn't make sense for a young child to have to stay up way later than they can really manage when there is a room they could be in.

I don't think the blow-up is inherently bad - you can get some pretty decent ones - but if he's going to be in the living room then the rest of the household needs to vacate that room early so he can sleep. If they won't do this then he should get the spare room.

GlitteryGreen · 08/08/2022 09:27

Regardless of ASD, it doesn't make sense that the youngest child should be forced to stay up until everyone else is ready to go to bed (assuming they're not going to bed early to accommodate him).

We live in a one-bed flat and when my SCs come they have our room and we sleep on a blow-up in the living room, mainly because of this exact reason - it wouldn't work for SD8 to have to stay up much later than 9pm, and it wouldn't work for everyone else to have to tiptoe around if she did go to sleep in the living room earlier.

That said though, it sounds like OP's DS visits his dad once a month AND the daughter isn't usually there - so this is a one-off? Which isn't too bad. Dad isn't handling it very sensitively but at least it seems it's just this one night.

imnotthatkindofmum · 08/08/2022 08:59

plinkypots · 07/08/2022 23:30

Telling him to tell a stranger at the airport to call his mum could cause all sorts of chaos and be fairly traumatic for him. I think you need to step back and let DS's dad parent him his way for these two weeks. I'd be making cheery breezy noises to DS. I think you have to be careful your not making it worse.

And this too

imnotthatkindofmum · 08/08/2022 08:59

Kite22 · 07/08/2022 23:30

There will always be issues when two people who don't like each other, and have different ideas about parenting are trying to share the parenting of a child.

Whereas I tend to agree with most, that I would put a 9 yr old to bed much earlier than an adult, so, if they only have one living room, on this occasion I would expect the 18 yr old to take the air bed for one night, YABVU to suggest that your ds has his own room at his Dad's. He should treat both of his dc the same and - just as his dd may have a room at her Mum's, your ds has a room at yours, and them taking turns in the spare room at your ex's seems fair as a starting point. Or are you suggesting you will fund a bigger house for him so they can have one room each which they don't use for most of the time ?

YABVU you suggest you will fetch him from the airport as they are about to fly off too. It is our job as parents to help the dc appreciate the positives of whatever they are doing with the other parent, however much the two adults might dislike each other. The point is this is still the child's other parent. Undermining him throughout your ds's time there with sneaky phone calls is really unhelpful.

This

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/08/2022 08:54

What is the sleeping set up on their holiday?

WelliesandWine88 · 08/08/2022 08:50

Dad should be giving son his bed and sleeping on inflatable or couch 🤷‍♀️

aSofaNearYou · 08/08/2022 08:46

@TommySaid Yes but she's not an "older child" going through puberty etc and this isn't a permanent arrangement. She's an 18 year old uni student who has probably slept in far worse places than the family sofa for a night during her time as a young adult who has already lived independently. What's she going to do for a night/couple of nights that she so desperately needs privacy for?

I can't think of anyone that would put a young child (let alone with with ASD but that's just the cherry on top really) in the living room so that somebody in her circumstances didn't have to sleep there. It should be no big deal to her at all,

Lollypop701 · 08/08/2022 08:46

A 9yo child will want to go to bed at 8/9pm. An 18yo and other adults much later … that’s ignoring the fact that a ND child NEEDS routine and really can’t cope without it. Plus an 18 yo uni student is probably used to sleeping on couches at friends houses after a night out ! Not sure why dad doesn’t understand his ds needs but I’d encourage him to go in the holiday and deal with it afterwards if you can op.

endofthelinefinally · 08/08/2022 08:41

The issue here is that a child who has already had a long journey, is in physical pain, anxious, who has ASD, is being kept awake long past his usual bedtime when a little bit of thought and logistics could have allowed him to be settled to sleep in peace. Ultimately this would be better for everyone. There are 3 rooms. A little bit of kindness and consideration would have been helpful.

TommySaid · 08/08/2022 08:34

I'm not seeing why there's any pressing need for her to have privacy. She's the near adult, she should be the one that's able to be flexible.

In social housing the rules are that children under 10 can share with the opposite sex. And children 10-16 can share with the same sex.
That’s because younger children have less need for privacy and are much more flexible.

In primary school all of the kids get changed in the same room but in secondary school the boys and girls have separate changing rooms.

If you have 3 kids the same sex, the older one would get their own room above the younger ones.

Whenever I visited my grandparents all the younger kids would share a room and sleep in the same bed/floor.

I don’t know anyone who would prioritise their younger DC over their older ones when it comes to privacy.

CherryColaRoller · 08/08/2022 08:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.