Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend is marrying - is it a mistake?

142 replies

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 13:47

Friend met someone on a dating app during lockdown
She was keen to get married and settle down
He was still married but going through a divorce - he was 'taking his wife to the cleaners' financially which resulted in a longer process.

He was still on the dating app a year after they were dating - another friend told her and he said 'he forgot to delete the app'. I personally think he was still using it.

He suffers from mental health issues so subsequently comes across as 'odd' when you meet them together (her excuse for him - when he blatantly does not make eye contact and rolls his eyes when anyone talks). He has broken a few phones throwing them against walls due to his mental health issues. She had a new puppy when they met and he used to sulk that most of her attention was on the puppy during coffee dates.

I have said nothing but just supported her.
She is a wealthy professional woman who sold her flat and got loads of £ for it - she bought a house with him for over £750k and he is now living in it - 8/9 months after they initially met. She put down the entire deposit and pays more of the mortage as and he earns significantly less than her (She earns about 150k, he is on about 20k).

She was showing me around the property and showed me the 'man cave' she built for him. With his computer game console etc. She made his man cave prior to any other decoration of the property so he feels at home.

He got his divorced finalised last autumn - they were engaged the next week. Wedding is this weekend and I am dreading it. I just feel almost like a shit friend - I feel this situation has multiple red flags and everyone including myself is ignoring the elephant in the room that this could be a total disaster based on the red flags as above.

Please be honest with the best way to deal with this

YABU - this is clearly the love of her life and you are just a cynical old hag
YANBU - this guy has more red flags than the soviets and you could say something before its too late

(We are early 40s - no children involved)

OP posts:
Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 17:53

Wonnle · 07/08/2022 17:50

They have only been together 8/9 months yet he was still on the dating app a year after they met ?

How can that be

They bought a house together after 8/9 months following meeting on an app
Whilst they were living together and a year into their relationship a friend seen him on the same dating app they have initially met on

OP posts:
Wonnle · 07/08/2022 17:50

They have only been together 8/9 months yet he was still on the dating app a year after they met ?

How can that be

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 17:46

@AcrossthePond55

It is excatly the same story. Scary scary scary.

OP posts:
Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 17:44

SleepingAgent · 07/08/2022 17:41

@Ilovemycat1 you keep making little comments about other people's anecdotes to keep the thread running, but haven't actually said what you are going to do?
Are you going to talk to her?

Yep
I am going to mention a few things before the wedding

In the nicest possible way - I just need to think about my wording etc

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 07/08/2022 17:44

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 17:30

This is scarily similar to a woman I know and how she treated her partner.

I am starting to woman if it is the same couple I know.

Well, I'm NOT in the UK as you can tell from my name.

TBH, I think these are pretty common 'tactics' in both men and women who are controlling/narcs, whether it's for financial reasons or a psychological need to make themselves feel good by tearing others down.

Changechangychange · 07/08/2022 17:44

RustySwitchblade · 07/08/2022 17:00

Does she want to have kids? Is that why she is rushing to marry someone she doesn’t even want to shag?

would be worth exploring this with her. Tell her there’s nothing to stop her having a child with him and just not get married.

that way when the wheels come off, he can’t take her for half her assets.

if they don’t have kids, she would get away with a very small settlement when they inevitably get divorced. The minute they have kids, she is fucked. ( no pun intended!)

of course, a sperm donor would be cheaper and less emotionally draining. She wouldn’t even need to drink a bottle of wine.

This man is not going to have kids with her - it will take all her focus off him.

My cousin lives with a similar man - he inherited the house, but doesn’t work. She pays for everything but has no rights to the house if they split. He sits around drinking all day while she works and does all the housework.

She fell pregnant accidentally in her 40s - wanted kids but thought she couldn’t have them. Her parents provide wrap-around care while she works. He continues to do absolutely nothing around the house or in way of parenting, and just sits drinking and playing video games while she is out at work, and her parents look after their daughter around him (they all have to stay out of the living room so they don’t disturb his games). Madness.

SleepingAgent · 07/08/2022 17:41

@Ilovemycat1 you keep making little comments about other people's anecdotes to keep the thread running, but haven't actually said what you are going to do?
Are you going to talk to her?

Stripyhoglets1 · 07/08/2022 17:35

I'd just be blunt and say clearly to her that she doesn't need to get married even st this stage and it's massively financially risky if she does.

Palmfrond · 07/08/2022 17:32

I don’t know why people are saying it’s too late. It’s not!
Whatever the monetary loss of fucking up her wedding, it will be a fraction of the emotional, social and also monetary cost of unfucking her life after the fact.
She’s entering into a binding legal contract with this wasteman. If she was buying a house or a car off of him you wouldn’t hesitate to have sword in her ear. Even if only to postpone and do a little more research.
ive seen a couple of friends and relatives in similar situations. Two divorced quickly and for predictable reasons, one remains in what appears to be a pretty dreary marriage to a schlub who is not , was not and never will be anything close to her equal.

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 17:30

AcrossthePond55 · 07/08/2022 17:16

Well, she's a damned fool, but then she's entitled to be if she chooses. From some of what you've posted it sounds as if she has an inkling of what she's letting herself in for. All you can do is be there to pick up the pieces, IF your friendship survives.

My DH's BFF (more like a brother) married a gold digger. Even her own brother cautioned him about marrying her, saying that she was (to put it mildly) 'high maintenance'. But BFF was desperate to be married, he was 40 and the sole remaining 'bachelor' . Although 2 of their friends were divorced by this time, that 'didn't count as they'd been married'. None of his friends really took him to task, but a few gently hinted that marriage was 'not the end all and be all' and that he needed to think carefully as to whether she was really 'right' for him, but he wouldn't listen.

She tried to stir up trouble amongst us 'couples' and ended up alienating all of his friends but one, who keeps in 'Facebook contact'. So now his only friends are her friends and her family. She's cut out all his sports and hobbies. He's miserable. But he hangs in there because he's still rather be "Mr Married Man". And most likely because he knows she'd take him to the cleaners.

Good luck to your friend. She'll need it.

This is scarily similar to a woman I know and how she treated her partner.

I am starting to woman if it is the same couple I know.

OP posts:
Eunorition · 07/08/2022 17:24

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 15:08

Did consider this. She says she does not find him physically attractive and has to drink a bottle of wine to have sex with him.

Well now she just sounds completely mental. Why on earth is she doing this to herself? She could quit a job and burn get cash in a bonfire without the shit sex.

Is she so desperate for a wedding she'll take any old troll?

AcrossthePond55 · 07/08/2022 17:16

Well, she's a damned fool, but then she's entitled to be if she chooses. From some of what you've posted it sounds as if she has an inkling of what she's letting herself in for. All you can do is be there to pick up the pieces, IF your friendship survives.

My DH's BFF (more like a brother) married a gold digger. Even her own brother cautioned him about marrying her, saying that she was (to put it mildly) 'high maintenance'. But BFF was desperate to be married, he was 40 and the sole remaining 'bachelor' . Although 2 of their friends were divorced by this time, that 'didn't count as they'd been married'. None of his friends really took him to task, but a few gently hinted that marriage was 'not the end all and be all' and that he needed to think carefully as to whether she was really 'right' for him, but he wouldn't listen.

She tried to stir up trouble amongst us 'couples' and ended up alienating all of his friends but one, who keeps in 'Facebook contact'. So now his only friends are her friends and her family. She's cut out all his sports and hobbies. He's miserable. But he hangs in there because he's still rather be "Mr Married Man". And most likely because he knows she'd take him to the cleaners.

Good luck to your friend. She'll need it.

Changechangychange · 07/08/2022 17:11

Look, she wanted to get married, and she is obviously happy to carry this man financially. She’s found herself a “trophy husband”/SAHH.

I doubt he’ll divorce her, he’ll more likely just give up work and let her support him. If she’s happy with that in exchange for his company, that is up to her isn’t it?

I agree she should get a pre-nup, but they aren’t enforceable and he’d have to stay married for a reasonable while to have a hope in hell of getting half her pension.

AMindNeedsBooks · 07/08/2022 17:10

I still think you should say something to her. Saying he's only after her money is obviously the wrong way to go about it because she will feel defensive, it would be like telling her she's not good enough to marry without her money (well, she would likely see it that wasy).

If you bring up the sex issue you could then tell her that the marriage may not work out long term if she's unhappy with that side of that side of things and if they divorce because of that, he will also take her to the cleaners. I'm surprised that comment about his ex wife wasn't enough for alarm bells to ring!

And would she really want to have children with man who is violent? Phones first, then what?

category12 · 07/08/2022 17:01

But it doesn't take away from the fact you were right to say something. She may not have wanted to hear it and ignored it, but sometimes it's what someone needs to hear and they do appreciate it.

I've regretted saying nothing because I thought someone's mind was already made up, and later they said "so do I" when I remarked "I wish I'd said something!" 😃Who knows if she would have listened at the time, but I think it's right to be honest when you think someone is making a mistake.

RustySwitchblade · 07/08/2022 17:00

Does she want to have kids? Is that why she is rushing to marry someone she doesn’t even want to shag?

would be worth exploring this with her. Tell her there’s nothing to stop her having a child with him and just not get married.

that way when the wheels come off, he can’t take her for half her assets.

if they don’t have kids, she would get away with a very small settlement when they inevitably get divorced. The minute they have kids, she is fucked. ( no pun intended!)

of course, a sperm donor would be cheaper and less emotionally draining. She wouldn’t even need to drink a bottle of wine.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 07/08/2022 16:57

berksandbeyond · 07/08/2022 14:10

It's a bit late to say something now when the wedding is this weekend!
You should have said something ages ago

This. Why on earth didn't you say something sooner? He's awful and he's going to ruin her. Not much you can do now, she'll maybe assume you are jealous or just wrong and ignore you now.

Midlifemusings · 07/08/2022 16:54

category12 · 07/08/2022 16:52

At the end of the day she is a capable competent woman who knows all this better than OP does and she still wants this guy and wants to marry him. She is making a decision of her own free will. Women are more than able to make decisions for themselves and to make what I might consider to be a mistake or a bad decision. They have that autonomy to make whatever choice they want - good or bad.

Of course she is. But sometimes everyone is in need of a friend to say, "hang on, are you sure you want this, given x & y reasons? It's never too late to get cold feet, and I'll support you no matter what".

Especially with weddings being a bit of a juggernaut of expectations and costs once they get started.

For sure. However it is unlikely that what OP could say to her would change her mind. OP can absolutely voice her opinion. As I said in above response, I did that and it only irritated the bride!

Goodskin46 · 07/08/2022 16:54

Midlifemusings · 07/08/2022 16:52

It is really unfair of her to marry him if she doesn't like him and has to drink a bottle of wine to have sex with him.

She is the problem.

Nobody has to be " the problem" maybe they just shouldn't get married.

Midlifemusings · 07/08/2022 16:52

It is really unfair of her to marry him if she doesn't like him and has to drink a bottle of wine to have sex with him.

She is the problem.

category12 · 07/08/2022 16:52

At the end of the day she is a capable competent woman who knows all this better than OP does and she still wants this guy and wants to marry him. She is making a decision of her own free will. Women are more than able to make decisions for themselves and to make what I might consider to be a mistake or a bad decision. They have that autonomy to make whatever choice they want - good or bad.

Of course she is. But sometimes everyone is in need of a friend to say, "hang on, are you sure you want this, given x & y reasons? It's never too late to get cold feet, and I'll support you no matter what".

Especially with weddings being a bit of a juggernaut of expectations and costs once they get started.

Talia99 · 07/08/2022 16:52

It’s already been mentioned by one previous poster but it is much too late for a pre nup if one isn’t already in place. It has to be done without pressure of time months before the wedding. One she produced now would almost definitely be thrown out in any divorce as putting him under pressure of time due to the imminent ceremony.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 07/08/2022 16:52

He was still on the dating app a year after they were dating

That's a big nope from me. He's after her money.

Suggest she either calls off the wedding or gets an iron-clad pre-nup and asks him to sign it beforehand. His reaction should let her know...

Goodskin46 · 07/08/2022 16:51

Ilovemycat1 · 07/08/2022 15:08

Did consider this. She says she does not find him physically attractive and has to drink a bottle of wine to have sex with him.

This just goes from bad to worse for the love of all things Holly WHY ?

MissBPotter · 07/08/2022 16:51

She says she does not find him physically attractive and has to drink a bottle of wine to have sex with him

Apart from anything else, why is she marrying him if this is the case?!? I don’t see what she’s getting here, except a bit of company….

please say something to your friend and do it today, over the phone if you have to. It might not go down well and obviously say you’ll support her either way but tell her you’re really worried that she’s making a mistake financially etc.