Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men hate women so much?

782 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 07/08/2022 11:09

Violence againt women, sexual harrasment.

Controlling women bodies.

Women’s sexuality: frigid prude if you don’t want sex, slut if you.

Porn, sex ”work”.

All the MRA’s, mgtow, incels etc.

Even historically speaking they have no reason to be angry at women, women never had any power, mostly tried to accommodate to men’s demand/ wants, I think it still goes on.

Many women still tip toe the line to placate men.

What reason do they have to be so angry at women?

OP posts:
ThePomegranateClause · 07/08/2022 20:01

How did a thread about why men hate women degenerate into a thread about how SAHMs are lazy good for nothings? Women denigrating women does nobody any favours.

Nothappyatwork · 07/08/2022 20:00

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:32

@Nothappyatwork

What does that have to do with benefitting society?

You could argue it benefits your child (I wouldnt) but how does it benefit society?

I've asked a couple of times but no one has answered.

To be utterly blunt children that are well cared for and looked after are more likely to be net contributors that has been pointed out repeatedly to you. It’s benefit society because children survive and thrive in a stable environment provided by an invested motivated care giver, we need them to survive and turn out to be well-adjusted mentally well people because then they won’t go around killing you or mugging you or beating the shit out of you for fun that kinda thing.

The recent case in Newcastle where a gang of 10 children ganged up on another child and stabbed him to death is an excellent example of how society would’ve benefited from those people being cared for correctly. Society has now lost one child that would’ve been a net contributor and gained 10 psychologically damaged people it now needs to incarcerate for 10 years.

DandyLandy · 07/08/2022 19:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ldontWanna · 07/08/2022 19:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Fuck me.

ldontWanna · 07/08/2022 19:56

@Topgub

There are some benefits,but I suppose you could argue that's for the individual children rather than society as a whole.That's not saying any other forms of childcare are wrong or less.

A 2014 study found that the benefits of having a parent at home extend beyond the early years of a child's life. The study measured the educational performance of 68,000 children. Researchers found an increase in school performance all the way to high school-aged children. However, the biggest educational impact was on kids ages 6 and 7.4

Studies from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the Institute of Child Development of the University of Minnesota found that children who spend a large amount of their day in daycare experienced higher stress levels and aggression as opposed to those who stayed home.

Subsequent studies also showed higher levels of stress in children in childcare settings compared with those who are cared for at home.10

Sadly , it does seem to come with adverse effects on the mums(as the majority of SAHP) not just financially, but mentally and emotionally as well, with a lot of studies showing they are less happy, more likely to be depressed,isolated etc.

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:55

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:44

@perfectstorm

No one said childcare didn't benefit society though.

Childcare does.

Childcare is provided by all sorts of people. Not just sahms

Whats being questioned is what benefit sah mums specifically have to society as a whole. Not their individual children or families

I think both forms have huge value. It's the next generation. But it's care, and care is usually performed by women, so it isn't valued. That's inherently misogynist, as clearly it does have great value.

It's interesting: IT workers and medical managers were women in the past, and they were low status and low paid roles. Then men started doing them - now, the NHS is full of managers, and IT workers are largely male. And they're well paid and high status.

The two facts are surely related.

gnilliwdog · 07/08/2022 19:55

@DandyLandy That is utterly ridiculous. Are you a man?

gnilliwdog · 07/08/2022 19:51

@perfectstorm Yes, I think it is misogyny to devalue the care of children, to say that their emotional wellbeing has no effect on society as a whole. It's misogyny to assume that it it women's work and therefore of no value. A loving father could do the same nurturing but this thread assumes that it is always the mother and therefore has no value. It's misogyny to assume that a woman should be more like a man by getting back to work and finding childcare. If caring for children is useless to society what sort of adults are we going to turn out? As @Nothappyatwork points out, a carer on a low wage, under difficult working conditions, with no relation to your child, just does not have the motivation to do a better job than a capable parent.

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:51

@perfectstorm

This whole conversation started because a woman said women would be better off sticking to being sahms (who should be valued more) and leaving the clever men alone (parahrase)

I think you're directing your annoyance in the wrong direction.

However, there is no denying that where it is a choice, chosing to be a sahm impacts societal equality in a negative way.

And yes that choice is impacted by systemic mysoginy.

But until we make men take as much responsibility for childcare as women do, little will change

MbatataOwl · 07/08/2022 19:49

Wow.

DandyLandy · 07/08/2022 19:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:46

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:42

@perfectstorm

think anyone caring for kids, actually, benefits society.

Well, yes. So why should we value the sahm role specifically?

Is it more worthy than what working parents do?

Being a carer is different to being a sahm.

How about we respect reproductive and caring labour

I'm not sure what you mean by reproductive labour.

I do respect caring labour. I just dont agree its women's work.

Men should be doing as much caring labour as women do.

Then we're probably on the same page.

(And reproductive labour is why we need paid maternity leave - which they do not have in many countries, including the USA).

I don't see the pay as what makes childcare valuable to society. I see it as caring for the next generation. But I do appreciate the point that with parent carers, it's not a choice (a friend is a consultant haematologist and having to give up work altogether because she has 2 disabled kids, too - that is in no way a choice and if she could afford the level of SEN nanny she would need, which on their income they couldn't, and living hundreds of miles outside London none at the right calibre would work for them anyway).

I just wish that some women wouldn't try to blame systemic misogyny, which has been created and baked in through millennia, on other women's childcare choices. Talk about doing the work of the patriarchy for them.

ldontWanna · 07/08/2022 19:45

Weird how a thread about the wrong doings of men has turned into women being in the wrong and attacking each other.

Even more ironically, it's men (overall) who truly benefit, be in from the labour in the home or at work and also from the shift in focus.

We stopped talking about porn,rape,abuse,violence,control ,sexism ,discrimination and instead we're focusing on exactly how little value does a poster have (or not).

It's fucking bonkers!

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:44

@perfectstorm

No one said childcare didn't benefit society though.

Childcare does.

Childcare is provided by all sorts of people. Not just sahms

Whats being questioned is what benefit sah mums specifically have to society as a whole. Not their individual children or families

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:42

DandyLandy · 07/08/2022 19:34

@perfectstorm if you're paid to care for your son that's a bloody job

Not to be conflated with being a SAHM

Ffs

It's expenses. I have to have a separate account, which is then audited by the LA to ensure none benefits me directly. It's OT, SLT, psych, lessons, transport, IT.

It's unpaid.

Any more attempts to sidestep? Or are you done, now?

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:42

@perfectstorm

think anyone caring for kids, actually, benefits society.

Well, yes. So why should we value the sahm role specifically?

Is it more worthy than what working parents do?

Being a carer is different to being a sahm.

How about we respect reproductive and caring labour

I'm not sure what you mean by reproductive labour.

I do respect caring labour. I just dont agree its women's work.

Men should be doing as much caring labour as women do.

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:41

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:23

There is no value in being a sahm to society that any other parenting choice couldn't also achieve

I dont know why sahms have to insist on being valued by society.

Or tbh what that has to do with the op

Someone has to look after a child. That someone is almost always a woman.

I object to anyone saying that childcare doesn't benefit society, because it's clearly untrue. That is SAHP and childcare worker alike.

I also agree that this is a bit of a derail.

I agree that society is hideously misogynist, our rights painfully recently won, and that things are getting worse, and not better, at the moment.

DandyLandy · 07/08/2022 19:34

@perfectstorm if you're paid to care for your son that's a bloody job

Not to be conflated with being a SAHM

Ffs

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:34

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:24

@perfectstorm

What does any of that have to do with sahms benefitting society?

I am one. What I do clearly does. And there are lots of other women I know in the exact same situation.

Kids left in mainstream schools end up in PRUs and SEMH placements. Those cost hideous amounts, and all too often those kids end up in YOIs and then prisons - or on benefits and in need of MH support for life.

I appreciate that these are outlier situations. But they're also far more common than most seem to realise. 10% of kids is not a low number, and that's just the neurodiverse. Disability is a lot broader than that.

I think anyone caring for kids, actually, benefits society. And I don't see that it matters if it's a parent or a loving and engaged paid childcarer. What I do think is that the contempt shown for anyone performing labour linked to women's reproduction is inherently misogynist - as, too, is the effort to force women to do nothing but that labour.

I'm not interested in replicating a male-dominated society, where all that shuffles are the women despised for caring roles. That's what they have in the USA as far as I can see - no paid maternity leave and no abortion rights now, either. How about we respect reproductive and caring labour, while respecting that nobody should be confined to it?

Pallisers · 07/08/2022 19:33

Men not feel like they just exist to be used in the workplace to provide jobs for women.

you actually know more than one man who thinks like this? Bizarre.

Considering it is HER majesty's government in the UK, aren't all those male civil servants just leeching off a woman? Shouldn't they have set up their own systems? Lazy gits.

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:32

@Nothappyatwork

What does that have to do with benefitting society?

You could argue it benefits your child (I wouldnt) but how does it benefit society?

I've asked a couple of times but no one has answered.

Nothappyatwork · 07/08/2022 19:30

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:23

There is no value in being a sahm to society that any other parenting choice couldn't also achieve

I dont know why sahms have to insist on being valued by society.

Or tbh what that has to do with the op

what are the parenting choices have you got in mind exactly ? That you think would compete equally with the person most invested physiologically in psychology in the welfare well-being and survival of the child.

because I can tell you having worked in summer camp childcare settings along time ago none of the childcare providers give a shit if your kids lives or dies, they’d be sorry for about 24 hours but they’ve get over it quite quickly. I saw children with dairy allergies given dairy on a regular basis luckily without consequences and a bit of a oooops moment but kids have died in those scenarios.

perfectstorm · 07/08/2022 19:29

DandyLandy · 07/08/2022 19:16

@perfectstorm

Even if you're the only person on the planet to make your child happy

That still doesn't benefit society

You removing your child from school and saying you're saving society paying for their education is really not how it works.

So how does it work?

The LA pay me to educate him, agreeing no school at all can do it. In law, they can't agree to me doing it if there is any school that can, and his EOTAS was ordered by a judge. So yes: no school. Fact.

Agencies providing what I do cost £100,000 a year plus. Often more. My son's package is £45,000. So you think I should work while an agency profits from the taxpayer, costing vastly more, while offering my son less, yes?

Why?

You can sidestep and restate things you now know are not true or you can seek to engage - preferably with a modicum of integrity and intelligence.

What would a better option be? NO school - LA and judge agreed. Agency costing vastly more, and offering my child much less. Again, all sides agreed.

Yet you feel society would benefit more were I to return to work and allow an agency to educate my child with a rolling sequence of professionals, rather than my doing it to what all sides agree is a very high standard? When he is recovering, and improving, and making great gains, and the aim is in fact to enable him to return full time to the lone possible school, within a year?

A lot of women locally are in this situation. It's a lot less unusual than you probably realise - the difference is the EOTAS, which is that funded educational package, and that package is why I can hope that my son can return to a school.

What is the preferable alternative? If what we are doing is wrong, what should we be doing, instead?

Topgub · 07/08/2022 19:28

@gnilliwdog

Well thats ridiculous

Lots of choices are worth criticism. That remains true even when women make them

I dont see saying being a sahm has no value to wider society as an attack.

gnilliwdog · 07/08/2022 19:26

@Topgub Actually, I used the term SAHP in my pp. As in, it would be good if parents of either sex had the flexibility to stay at home with children if they wish. I most certainly have never attacked women who want to work, but people on this thread have definitely attacked women who want to stay at home. I work from home and support my family as a lone parent, so I have no axe to grind. Just do not think women should criticise other women for their choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread