Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men hate women so much?

782 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 07/08/2022 11:09

Violence againt women, sexual harrasment.

Controlling women bodies.

Women’s sexuality: frigid prude if you don’t want sex, slut if you.

Porn, sex ”work”.

All the MRA’s, mgtow, incels etc.

Even historically speaking they have no reason to be angry at women, women never had any power, mostly tried to accommodate to men’s demand/ wants, I think it still goes on.

Many women still tip toe the line to placate men.

What reason do they have to be so angry at women?

OP posts:
Lunar270 · 08/08/2022 08:42

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 07:57

@YesJess

I think an ambitious and financially solvent woman wants and needs a man who is somewhere in the middle: both solvent and motivated enough that he will not seek to depend on the woman financially and progressive enough to understand that her career and her money-earning potential is as important as his.

The fact that these sorts of men are so vanishingly rare speaks to how difficult it remains for women to find a compatible compromise.

If I think of my contemporaries I can think of perhaps one couple where the partners are genuine financial equals where both careers get equal weight in the marriage. In the vast majority of cases either the woman is more or less totally dependent on the man financially or the woman out-earns the man and the man sits back and takes his foot off the pedal, with resentment growing on the part of the woman. Or, of course, the woman is single (and probably happier).

I have to say my personal experience is that women who go it alone financially are usually happier and more fulfilled than those who enmesh themselves with a man. That's not to say that women need to forego relationships, love and sex. But I think for ambitious, motivated women, being financially tied to a man is rarely a positive thing. It's a lose lose: either you sacrifice your own career and become dependent or you become more and more frustrated as the man fails to match your own ambition and drive.

Being a single parent has its downsides for sure but if you can make it work through the tough and expensive bit when childcare is expensive and everything is relentless, the long-term rewards are great.

It must be incredibly rare, in general, to find two partners who earn broadly the same money. I definitely didn't choose my wife based on salary and salary changes over time, so makes things even more difficult. Nowadays I'd have to find a Dr. Solicitor or Account etc if I were to look for financial equality and that would really narrow the pool. Fortunately there's no need as I'm still happily married but the money thing is quite interesting.

What you're saying is interesting and looks like men will need to adapt, mainly to not get put out by a high earning wife/girlfriend/partner but also to accept a new dynamic. I personally can't imagine why it'd be an issue if my wife earned the same or more than me. It would benefit the household no end and she would feel more empowered/independent. We pool our money anyway but think it would make a difference.

Anecdotal but I know a woman who's very successful but is very unhappy single. She would very much love a relationship/marriage but her problem is that high earning men in the city tend to be dicks (or at least the ones she's meeting are). High level execs who are entitled as hell and don't like a high earning woman.

I'm interested in your comment about a woman not wanting a man to be dependent. Men have been doing this for ages and my wife is currently dependent on me for the lifestyle we live. Obviously this is mainly because of children and choices we've made but it wouldn't bother me if I met a woman who earned less. I appreciate that this has sexist history (men looking after women) but why would it be a problem for a man to be financially dependent?

Topgub · 08/08/2022 08:41

Nothappyatwork · 08/08/2022 08:08

The early experience of intense maternal affection is the basis for the development of a conscience and moral compassion for others.6) According to Chuck Smith, a Kansas State University child development expert, “as a child grows and matures, the mother—whether biological or a stepmother—plays an important role in her child's development, character and attitudes.”7) If a child's emotional attachment to their mother is disrupted during the first few years, permanent harm can be done to the child's capacity for emotional attachment to others. The child will be less able to trust others and throughout his or her life will stay more distant emotionally from others. Having many different caretakers during the first few years can lead to a loss of this sense of attachment for life and to antisocial behavior.8) Separation from the mother, especially between six months and three years of age, can lead to long-lasting negative effects on behavior and emotional development. Severe maternal deprivation is a critical ingredient of juvenile delinquency. As John Bowlby, the father of attachment research, puts it, “Theft, like rheumatic fever, is a disease of childhood, and, as in rheumatic fever, attacks in later life are frequently in the nature of recurrences.”9) A child's emotional attachment to their mother is powerful in other ways. For example, even after a period of juvenile delinquency, a young man's ability to become emotionally attached to his wife can make it possible for him to turn away from crime.10) This capacity is rooted in the very early attachment to his mother. We also know that a weak marital attachment resulting in separation or divorce accompanies a continuing life of crime.11)

Many family conditions can weaken a mother's attachment to her young child. Perhaps the mother herself struggles with emotional detachment.12) The mother could be so lacking in family and emotional support that she cannot fill the emotional needs of the child. She could return to work, or be forced to return to work, too soon after the birth of her child. Or, while she is at work, there could be a change in the personnel responsible for the child's day care. The more prevalent these conditions, the less likely a child will be securely attached to their mother and the more likely they will be hostile and aggressive.13)
www.marripedia.org/effects_of_parents_on_crime_rates

The single biggest indicator of poor outcomes for a child is lack of maternal bonding, returning to work reduces the physical attachment that cannot be disputed.

What absolute sexist claptrap.

Yes, why don't we listen to these men spouting their mysoginist bullshit that working mothers are to blame for the agreesive natures of some men.

Returning to work didn't affect the bond I have with my kiss.

brookstar · 08/08/2022 08:32

The single biggest indicator of poor outcomes for a child is lack of maternal bonding, returning to work reduces the physical attachment that cannot be disputed..

Actually, the biggest indicator of poor outcomes is poverty.

Topgub · 08/08/2022 08:29

@Nothappyatwork

The study doesn't acknowledge that though.

I dont actually even know what that means?

The mothers lack of ability to put the child’s needs above her own?

You sound traumatised by having to go to work. But that's not really an excuse to suggest wm are harming their children.

Its total nonsense.

And of course totally ignores dads and their input.

No one says dads lack ability to put the child’s needs above his own when they go back to work after a few weeks

brookstar · 08/08/2022 08:28

curious about biology not making women take on more childcare and housework, asking an academic, you can probably, hopefully correct me!

breastfeeding surely does? and then sets a precedent?

Yes, of course only women can give birth and breastfeed. Which is why we have protected maternity rights and rights around breastfeeding. However, beyond that stage there is no biological reason for women to do a higher proportion of childcare. The reason women do is down to societal expectations around the the role of men and women in the home and at work.

With regards to housework…
I feel women take on more housework because they prefer a cleaner environment, isn’t feeling grossed out by something biology?

There is no sex based biological reason for you wanting a cleaner environment. That's just your preference as an individual.

Genuinely interested in this as I do the majority of the housework and would love my other half (a man who doesn’t seem to see or be bothered by mess) to do more. If I can understand the reasons behind it, I can try to make changes without resorting to nagging and threats!

The fact your partner doesn't do his share of housework is nothing to do with biology. Having a penis doesn't make you incapable of cleaning a house. It's very much down to societal expectations around the role of women.
Unfortunately lots of men (and women) believe that cleaning and childcare is womens work.

It's nothing to do with biology.

I imagine in early humans, women would naturally take on the majority of the child rearing while men would hunt. Is that a huge misconception, or socialisation at it’s beginning for humans?

It's not a clear cut as people believe and anyway, society evolves. On a societal level there is no reason why men can't do their fair share of childcare or housework.

Nothappyatwork · 08/08/2022 08:12

@Topgub and if the study acknowledges that the mothers lack of ability to put the child’s needs above her own can have a long lasting negative affect I think we can safely conclude that having to put the corporation of the employers needs before both her own and the child’s is going to have a negative affect.

I speak very much from experience to having to return to work when my child was six weeks old.

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 08:11

Guardian800 · 08/08/2022 05:01

Speaking as a man on here, the level of venom and hatred towards men is truly shocking. For those contributors are saying “I didn’t mean all men “ but …. “ it is most men” that already conveys the point of view that you are saying “all men”. I complete agree some men are truly abominable towards women - the idea being strongly advocated on here that half the population are predominantly made up of testosterone fuelled, women hating species is just ridiculous.

Whilst I do agree with some of the comments on here, some are just outrageous and without foundation

A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏

As a PP pointed out:

The fact you think women discussing their oppression should be tempered so as no to upset poor men says it all.

If I wanted to be kind to you I'd say substitute "men" for "patriarchy". We're not talking about individual men, we're talking about men as a class. Men as a class have treated women abominably throughout history and that isn't up for debate.

But tbh this isn't your thread and I shouldn't have to spell this out. That doesn't mean you can't participate. It does mean its a safe space for women to discuss millennia of structural disadvantage which at its worst includes violence and rape but at a minimum includes huge financial disadvantage for almost every woman in any walk of life. As a starting point you need to understand that we're not here to prioritise your hurt feelings.

Nothappyatwork · 08/08/2022 08:08

Topgub · 07/08/2022 22:37

@Thepeopleversuswork

And still no reason given as to why being a sahm should be valued more. (More than what?)

Except some rubbish about sahms not bringing up stabby 10 yos ams being more heavily invested in their kids

The early experience of intense maternal affection is the basis for the development of a conscience and moral compassion for others.6) According to Chuck Smith, a Kansas State University child development expert, “as a child grows and matures, the mother—whether biological or a stepmother—plays an important role in her child's development, character and attitudes.”7) If a child's emotional attachment to their mother is disrupted during the first few years, permanent harm can be done to the child's capacity for emotional attachment to others. The child will be less able to trust others and throughout his or her life will stay more distant emotionally from others. Having many different caretakers during the first few years can lead to a loss of this sense of attachment for life and to antisocial behavior.8) Separation from the mother, especially between six months and three years of age, can lead to long-lasting negative effects on behavior and emotional development. Severe maternal deprivation is a critical ingredient of juvenile delinquency. As John Bowlby, the father of attachment research, puts it, “Theft, like rheumatic fever, is a disease of childhood, and, as in rheumatic fever, attacks in later life are frequently in the nature of recurrences.”9) A child's emotional attachment to their mother is powerful in other ways. For example, even after a period of juvenile delinquency, a young man's ability to become emotionally attached to his wife can make it possible for him to turn away from crime.10) This capacity is rooted in the very early attachment to his mother. We also know that a weak marital attachment resulting in separation or divorce accompanies a continuing life of crime.11)

Many family conditions can weaken a mother's attachment to her young child. Perhaps the mother herself struggles with emotional detachment.12) The mother could be so lacking in family and emotional support that she cannot fill the emotional needs of the child. She could return to work, or be forced to return to work, too soon after the birth of her child. Or, while she is at work, there could be a change in the personnel responsible for the child's day care. The more prevalent these conditions, the less likely a child will be securely attached to their mother and the more likely they will be hostile and aggressive.13)
www.marripedia.org/effects_of_parents_on_crime_rates

The single biggest indicator of poor outcomes for a child is lack of maternal bonding, returning to work reduces the physical attachment that cannot be disputed.

Topgub · 08/08/2022 08:03

@Guardian800

Oh do fuck off

There has been no venom or hatred towards men

And even if there had been it probably would have been justified

Women who have been sexually assaulted raped and suffered DV have every right to hate men.

The fact you think women discussing their oppression should be tempered so as no to upset poor men says it all.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 08/08/2022 08:00

I think the emphasis on the [some] ‘men wanting sex’ point and seeing women primarily as providers of sexual favours is spot on. I am now of pension age and it is many years since I was catcalled, groped etc etc - because I am now clearly seen as ‘past it’.

AdamRyan · 08/08/2022 07:57

Guardian800 · 08/08/2022 05:01

Speaking as a man on here, the level of venom and hatred towards men is truly shocking. For those contributors are saying “I didn’t mean all men “ but …. “ it is most men” that already conveys the point of view that you are saying “all men”. I complete agree some men are truly abominable towards women - the idea being strongly advocated on here that half the population are predominantly made up of testosterone fuelled, women hating species is just ridiculous.

Whilst I do agree with some of the comments on here, some are just outrageous and without foundation

A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏

Are the hurt feelings of you and other men more important than the number of women killed, physically and emotionally harmed by male violence?

I'd have a lot more time for NAMALT if men started doing more to stop the bad apples from wreaking carnage.

As they don't, I can only assume they don't think the apples are that bad after all

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 07:57

@YesJess

I think an ambitious and financially solvent woman wants and needs a man who is somewhere in the middle: both solvent and motivated enough that he will not seek to depend on the woman financially and progressive enough to understand that her career and her money-earning potential is as important as his.

The fact that these sorts of men are so vanishingly rare speaks to how difficult it remains for women to find a compatible compromise.

If I think of my contemporaries I can think of perhaps one couple where the partners are genuine financial equals where both careers get equal weight in the marriage. In the vast majority of cases either the woman is more or less totally dependent on the man financially or the woman out-earns the man and the man sits back and takes his foot off the pedal, with resentment growing on the part of the woman. Or, of course, the woman is single (and probably happier).

I have to say my personal experience is that women who go it alone financially are usually happier and more fulfilled than those who enmesh themselves with a man. That's not to say that women need to forego relationships, love and sex. But I think for ambitious, motivated women, being financially tied to a man is rarely a positive thing. It's a lose lose: either you sacrifice your own career and become dependent or you become more and more frustrated as the man fails to match your own ambition and drive.

Being a single parent has its downsides for sure but if you can make it work through the tough and expensive bit when childcare is expensive and everything is relentless, the long-term rewards are great.

ldontWanna · 08/08/2022 07:50

Guardian800 · 08/08/2022 05:01

Speaking as a man on here, the level of venom and hatred towards men is truly shocking. For those contributors are saying “I didn’t mean all men “ but …. “ it is most men” that already conveys the point of view that you are saying “all men”. I complete agree some men are truly abominable towards women - the idea being strongly advocated on here that half the population are predominantly made up of testosterone fuelled, women hating species is just ridiculous.

Whilst I do agree with some of the comments on here, some are just outrageous and without foundation

A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏

When we talk about men/male violence, we talk about men as a class. There is no need for NAMALT or "Not my Nigel".

We also don't just talk about the "truly horrible men" we talk about it all.. porn, "banter", harassment ,discrimination etc. It all adds up.

Cantbeliveyoufakeit · 08/08/2022 07:34

'Speaking as a man on here, the level of truth spoken about men is truly shocking.'

There, fixed that for you Smile

Sunnydayz · 08/08/2022 07:28

@brookstar

curious about biology not making women take on more childcare and housework, asking an academic, you can probably, hopefully correct me!

breastfeeding surely does? and then sets a precedent? I’m now interested in seahorses…. As the males carry the young… (my next read after this thread).

With regards to housework…
I feel women take on more housework because they prefer a cleaner environment, isn’t feeling grossed out by something biology?
Genuinely interested in this as I do the majority of the housework and would love my other half (a man who doesn’t seem to see or be bothered by mess) to do more. If I can understand the reasons behind it, I can try to make changes without resorting to nagging and threats!

I imagine in early humans, women would naturally take on the majority of the child rearing while men would hunt. Is that a huge misconception, or socialisation at it’s beginning for humans?

YouAreNotBatman · 08/08/2022 07:06

@Guardian800

I’m more worried about the fact that women discussing about male behaviour is seen as ”man hating”.
I’d say that’s shocking, but it’s really not that suprising, sadly.

But yeah, ”A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏”, indeed.
Maybe one day men can give that to women….
Maybe.

OP posts:
Guardian800 · 08/08/2022 05:01

Speaking as a man on here, the level of venom and hatred towards men is truly shocking. For those contributors are saying “I didn’t mean all men “ but …. “ it is most men” that already conveys the point of view that you are saying “all men”. I complete agree some men are truly abominable towards women - the idea being strongly advocated on here that half the population are predominantly made up of testosterone fuelled, women hating species is just ridiculous.

Whilst I do agree with some of the comments on here, some are just outrageous and without foundation

A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏

YouAreNotBatman · 08/08/2022 04:17

@perfectstorm
I prefer to hope that the OP is having a rage surge, rather than expressing genuinely held beliefs.

I have no idea why you’d be worried about me.
Everything I wrote is real life.
The was / is no rage, there is no beliefs I hold about this or about men.
It’s real, actual life.
I’m not afraid to see it.

OP posts:
YesJess · 08/08/2022 01:12

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/08/2022 23:35

Lots of studies show that women prioritise 'status' and 'financial security' in a partner much more than men do.

That's probably true still on balance, but that presupposes that a woman sees a man as her primary means of support.

For women who seek and gain financial independence, a man with high earning capacity is a much more ambiguous proposition. If you have your own money and career and want to continue working, a man who is determined to put his career advancement ahead of yours is not an attractive proposition. Because men like this tend to have certain expectations of their women and those are generally not compatible with the goals of ambitious women. Personally I would find a man who believed his career was more important than mine a real turn-off.

It is also true that a skint and poorly motivated man is not attractive to an ambitious woman. But the idea that a high-powered man is the ultimate goal of all women is less true than it used to be.

I'm not sure how much one can generalise on this point tbh. On one hand, we have the stereotype of the 'Very Important Man' who according to mumsnet dogma usually wants a trophy wife/housewife to support him.

However, on the other hand, the typical mumsnet response to posters seeking a rich partner nearly always seems to be 'good luck with that, high flying men usually want a high earning woman/intellectual equal or somebody from their own circle and aren't interested in unambitious women.'

Both cannot be universally true but they're seemingly the two most common views on here, depending on the angle of the discussion.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 07/08/2022 23:37

Deadringer · 07/08/2022 13:48

I said men have no incentive to change things as love as 'their women' are safe, I was including their daughters in that. Ensuring the safety of your own wives/sisters/daughters isn't tackling the problem though.

And I’m saying that my daughters will never be safe unless the wider problem is tackled. That’s an incentive.

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/08/2022 23:35

Lots of studies show that women prioritise 'status' and 'financial security' in a partner much more than men do.

That's probably true still on balance, but that presupposes that a woman sees a man as her primary means of support.

For women who seek and gain financial independence, a man with high earning capacity is a much more ambiguous proposition. If you have your own money and career and want to continue working, a man who is determined to put his career advancement ahead of yours is not an attractive proposition. Because men like this tend to have certain expectations of their women and those are generally not compatible with the goals of ambitious women. Personally I would find a man who believed his career was more important than mine a real turn-off.

It is also true that a skint and poorly motivated man is not attractive to an ambitious woman. But the idea that a high-powered man is the ultimate goal of all women is less true than it used to be.

YesJess · 07/08/2022 23:18

Regarding the pay gap, I think there are things both sexes do to exacerbate it TBH.

Men are competitive, likely by nature of testosterone, so they aren't likely to stop vying for power/money anytime soon. However, a big contributor IMO is the societal worth we place on high earning men as partners.

People tend to downplay it on here but there's plenty of evidence to show it's still a huge factor. Lots of studies show that women prioritise 'status' and 'financial security' in a partner much more than men do. It's also documented that women are more likely to divorce a lower earning partner or a man that becomes a SAHD.

I'm a bit conflicted about some elements tbh, because I generally believe that couples should individually do what works for them, even if it's the women taking a back seat to support the partner's higher earning capacity, if this genuinely benefits the family as a whole and is her desire.

However, on the other hand, this ideally needs to work the other way round too, and right now it doesn't.

I feel that our arguments for equal pay are somewhat undermined when you have many of the powerful high earning men thinking "hmm, well my wife does pretty well from my massive salary and hard work, with her enjoying a very comfortable lifestyle despite working part time."

YesJess · 07/08/2022 22:58

Suetodo88 · 07/08/2022 15:59

@YesJess

I think gay people (also applies to lesbians observing men) can probably see the other gender clearer in some ways, they’re not blinkered by either being one of the group they’re looking at or attracted to that group and influenced by either positive or negative emotion relating to that attraction.

I think gay men and lesbian women are probably less likely to gloss over what they see as the flaws of the other gender with a coat of attraction.

Indeed. This is a great explanation of what I was trying to get at. We still have a sock dynamic where the man chases the women in many cases. A fair number of women like to exploit this to varying degrees, and I think men who aren't attracted to women see through this.

Sirius3030 · 07/08/2022 22:50

DenholmElliot1 · 07/08/2022 11:12

I don't know but I can honestly say that if I was physically stronger than a man , i'd have had a lot of fights because I wouldn't have just timidly walked away from confrountations.

And that is exactly it. Men are physically stronger than women so altercations can easily lead to violence. I think you have just said that it is human nature?

Topgub · 07/08/2022 22:37

@Thepeopleversuswork

And still no reason given as to why being a sahm should be valued more. (More than what?)

Except some rubbish about sahms not bringing up stabby 10 yos ams being more heavily invested in their kids