Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why men hate women so much?

782 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 07/08/2022 11:09

Violence againt women, sexual harrasment.

Controlling women bodies.

Women’s sexuality: frigid prude if you don’t want sex, slut if you.

Porn, sex ”work”.

All the MRA’s, mgtow, incels etc.

Even historically speaking they have no reason to be angry at women, women never had any power, mostly tried to accommodate to men’s demand/ wants, I think it still goes on.

Many women still tip toe the line to placate men.

What reason do they have to be so angry at women?

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 12:24

@perfectstorm yes, thank you for that considered response. Education is not a waste of time, I don't think, but as you say , changing things affects men's convenience. Obviously there will be resistance.

brookstar · 08/08/2022 12:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Have you read all of their posts?

Coming onto a thread where people are discussing male violence towards women to declare that 'women are cruel too!' is the very definition of whataboutery.

Suetodo2 · 08/08/2022 12:23

@KettrickenSmiled

Woman can create companies. My point was that if there is ever equality in a work sense women will have to do that on a level similar to men, otherwise the men who create more of those things will always have a higher position in them and say how they are run, which is fair since they made them.
Maybe that will happen, maybe it won’t. There isn’t really any good reason to think it will happen naturally on an exactly alike level, after all men and women are different. If it doesn’t then why would you expect an equal amount of control over industry between the genders?

I was commenting that in general rather than original creation in that way much of womens equality at work was and is gained through a forced attachment to what men make. Not just what they made but also new things (companies and technology) that they make. I find it has a very gendered aspect to it, almost like seeking out a male provider. Except instead of a single man in marriage it applies to workplaces.

If a woman is invited to join an all male board then obviously that is fine, but I said if they are forced to hire a woman that is wrong. In that case they are being forced to give up creative control of their creation by adding a new voice who will change it despite what they want. You can say that she’s adding value to it and she can agree but it’s hardly fair if the men who actually made the company don’t agree and don’t like the changes she brings. She is clearly far less entitled to control over what they have made than they are (in fact she isn’t at all).

Her (or you) saying “your not losing control by being forced to hire me and let me change your company, I’m adding value whether you agree or not” is like something out of a authoritarian dystopia sci fi. I find saying that (which is basically what forced gender hiring amounts to) unlikely to create a lasting equality at work. Just a volcano of bitter angry men waiting to go off. And they still will have way more control because they’re still the ones making the majority of stuff.

Yes I know womens work has sometimes been undervalued. Not always. I think probably from the start of time some men did appreciate what women do as far as traditional work and childcare and then some others were abusive assholes. Same as today I guess. However as of late I’ve only found other women (specifically on this board) who don’t appreciate all women do in child rearing and all the good it does society.

I write as though (some) work is something that men bestow or women force their attachment to because frankly that is how I see a large part of equality at work as having played out. To the point I really couldn’t call it equality or even view it as much of an achievement because I think as soon as you stop forcing it it naturally falls apart. You saw that in a small way with the pandemic.

That’s why I’m saying if we want more work equality in a lasting way women have to create more in the working world, like men have done, rather than just push to fill positions in things men make. Otherwise it will never happen. It doesn’t effect me but that’s my opinion. But it’s like many don’t even want to try and think it’s crazy to try. Men wouldn’t think that.

Anyway I think the whole idea of equality in work is silly. I’m more for women following their own inclination and doing things that suit them at work if they’re that way inclined rather than having a goal of trying to match up men and women wages so they’re exactly equal by making sure men always provide them with half the jobs. That’s a pretty leeching kind of equality imo.
Id rather we make something our own and be happy with it and know we deserved it and stop giving a shit about pointless equality that can’t last.

perfectstorm · 08/08/2022 12:21

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 12:08

@Mooshamoo I think it is probably true that humans often abuse those in a weaker position. It's uncomfortable to say, but women were complicit with segregation in America and slavery. A few spoke out, as did some men. I suppose you could say that women were subordinate themselves, but I think you may have a point that there is a tendency in the hierarchy to abuse the ones on the next rung down, while being abused from the ones above.

A lot of women support and defend misogyny, and always have done. I remember reading a batshit article from the 1970s, talking about the Women's Liberation Movement, where a woman journalist smugly opined that there was a certain look in the eyes of a woman when she knows herself to be truly and deeply loved by a man, and that that look was missing from the eyes of the Women's Libbers. She clearly thought that it was some fantastic gotcha, the claim that nice girls were loveable by men, not like those nasty feminists.

And yet the same arguments are still being made - just less overtly.

It's why the FiLiA conferences are such a breath of fresh air. Women discussing women's rights, across all areas and all issues. (With a free, and genuinely inclusive, creche, too!)

Things are getting worse, there's no question. But there's FiLiA, and also the amazing Centre for Women's Justice, leading the fightback. There are things we can do, and causes we can support, to try to effect change for our daughters.

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 12:17

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 11:50

@Thepeopleversuswork so do you think educating men about the history of women's oppression will only give them a superficial awareness of how to behave? Is that to say oppression of women is hardwired into men, do you think? And what can we do to change that, in your opinion?

It's a good question and I don't know the answer really. I think educating men about the oppression of women is probably beneficial but I don't think it necessarily solves the problem.

I think education does play a part. It certainly helps for it to be instilled into boys that casual sexism isn't acceptable from primary school. My DD has just left primary school and inevitably has come across low level sexism from her male peers and the school seemed to be quite good at cracking down on this and getting across to the boys that this wasn't going to be tolerated. Much more so than when I was at primary school in the early 80s. Just to give a really obvious example we were banned from playing football while my DD and her peers are actively encouraged to do it. That certainly doesn't hurt and I'm sure that's a net benefit.

I guess what I'm saying is that educating men about the oppression of women isn't enough and doesn't necessarily solve the deep-rooted problem which is that men are very unwilling to give up their power.

I've observed quite a lot of well-educated, intelligent men over the years who clearly understand that women have been oppressed, have superficial sympathy and are very good at paying lip service to it. But these men often take a very different perspective when it impacts on their own working lives and families. It's one rule for women in general to be "feminists" but quite another when its their wife, girlfriend or daughter. That's probably not an intellectual position but an emotional one.

I've known an awful lot of men over the years (and my father was a very good example) who seek out clever and opinionated women as friends and colleagues but who don't want their life partners to challenge them in this way. My dad surrounded himself with hyper ambitious, argumentative, independent women in his work and social life but my mum was basically a fairly meek, SAHM. This sort of thing is much much harder to shift because it boils down to a man's reluctance to make his domestic life harder than he feels it needs to be. And education may oddly make that harder in some ways because the bright entitled men still feel they are owed this double whammy of a great job plus a supportive spouse and also know their way to charm their way through an argument with a bolshy feminist.

Ultimately the way men choose to organise their domestic lives is still driven by selfish practical and emotional needs. No man is willingly going to make his life harder to further the cause of female emancipation. That's why we gots to fight 'em for it.

perfectstorm · 08/08/2022 12:14

KettrickenSmiled · 08/08/2022 12:04

Specious codswallop.

98% of violent crime is committed by men. Justifying that by pointing at the rare outlier women who are also violent is bullshit, & I can't imagine why you are pretending it's 'relevant' @Mooshamoo.

Now now, be fair. 98% is the stat for male perpetration rates for sexual offending. For murders, it's only 93%!

(It is true that men are far likelier to be murdered than women. But men are likely to be murdered by another man, whether that be that acquaintance or stranger - whereas women are mostly killed by a partner.)

FinneusMum · 08/08/2022 12:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Rosehugger · 08/08/2022 12:09

I really noticed it since becoming an adult in the 1990s. Then all the New Lad behaviour came about, as if young men my age suddenly realised that all the New Man stuff in the 1980s (which was really just about not behaving like a toxic arsehole) didn't get them more girls so they would behave like a twat instead.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/08/2022 12:09

@FOJN well said.

"I don't abuse women, but I get all butthurt when women talk about men being abusive to them because I'm unable to focus on a bunch of people who aren't me, without making it all about me" is just DARVO'ing the problem back at women.
www.banyantherapy.com/darvo/

It's a self-centred attitude at best. At worst, it's looking to shut women down because men don't wanna hear that men can be bastards to women. Diddums.

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 12:08

@Mooshamoo I think it is probably true that humans often abuse those in a weaker position. It's uncomfortable to say, but women were complicit with segregation in America and slavery. A few spoke out, as did some men. I suppose you could say that women were subordinate themselves, but I think you may have a point that there is a tendency in the hierarchy to abuse the ones on the next rung down, while being abused from the ones above.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/08/2022 12:04

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:23

I think it is relevant to ask why are women so cruel.

It's relevant first of all, to see the reaction of women. As it helps us to understand better the reaction of men.

If you say to women, : women can be extremely cruel. There are many accounts of women who have tortured, abused and murdered children, for example. Women will get defensive , and say "not all women"

The same thing happens if you say to men : there are loads of accounts of men torturing abusing and killing women.

They will say "well it wasn't me that did it"

Specious codswallop.

98% of violent crime is committed by men. Justifying that by pointing at the rare outlier women who are also violent is bullshit, & I can't imagine why you are pretending it's 'relevant' @Mooshamoo.

FOJN · 08/08/2022 11:54

Guardian800 · 08/08/2022 05:01

Speaking as a man on here, the level of venom and hatred towards men is truly shocking. For those contributors are saying “I didn’t mean all men “ but …. “ it is most men” that already conveys the point of view that you are saying “all men”. I complete agree some men are truly abominable towards women - the idea being strongly advocated on here that half the population are predominantly made up of testosterone fuelled, women hating species is just ridiculous.

Whilst I do agree with some of the comments on here, some are just outrageous and without foundation

A bit of balance and perspective please 🙏

Is there a reason you feel so offended by women discussing how the awful behaviour of men impacts there lives. Presumably you wouldn't take it so personally if we were talking about tax evaders being immoral, I'm assuming you're not a tax evader, so why get offended about this if you're one of the good guys.

When women murder and assault men at the rates that men murder and assault women I'll take your accusations of "venom and hatred" against men more seriously. Its almost like you don't give a shit what women go through as long as you don't have to hear about it. Well done, you're part of the problem.

Demanding that we preface every conversation about MVAW with NAMALT or you'll refuse to engage in good faith is misogynistic and narcissistic in the extreme. We'd have far less to talk about if male violence wasn't so prevalent in women's lives. Perhaps you could try talking to men about their behaviour rather than berating women for talking about it.

If you are not a violent arsehole towards women WE ARE NOT TALKING ABOUT YOU. Perhaps not being centred in the discussion hurts your feelings.

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 11:50

@Thepeopleversuswork so do you think educating men about the history of women's oppression will only give them a superficial awareness of how to behave? Is that to say oppression of women is hardwired into men, do you think? And what can we do to change that, in your opinion?

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 11:39

Education is irrelevant imo. Etonians anyone?

Education isn't totally irrelevant and it probably takes the edges off the crudest examples of day to day sexism. Most highly educated and cultured men would know an intelligent woman won't tolerate grossly sexist postures.

But it can compound the problem. Educated men know enough to know that neanderthal attitudes and values are unattractive to intelligent women so they learn early to conceal them better.

And being educated doesn't curb a sense of inherent superiority and can actually make it worse. Highly educated men can often be highly entitled men and highly educated men are more apt to think that a woman they pair with is obliged to facilitate and support them in their career, rather than developing her own.

KettrickenSmiled · 08/08/2022 11:32

Suetodo88 · 07/08/2022 12:24

@ParsleySageRosemary

Im talking more about modern work not caveman days. Like if some man and his friends create a company then it’s their space right? That seems fair. But now they’re kind of forced to hire a woman on the board or whatever and give up control of their own creation because a woman asks for it.

I don’t know I think women who want those things need to develop more female centric workplaces. Not just for mens sake but also because if men ever refuse them those places then they won’t have anything of their own.

You know women can create companies too, right @Suetodo88?
And that even if a woman joins an all-male Board, she's not actually taking control of their creation - but adding value to it?

You write as if work were in the gift of men, to be graciously bestowed upon women. Whereas in fact, women have worked for their livings since the dawn of time. Men have simply undervalued that contribution - especially when it concerns childrearing.

brookstar · 08/08/2022 11:32

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:23

I think it is relevant to ask why are women so cruel.

It's relevant first of all, to see the reaction of women. As it helps us to understand better the reaction of men.

If you say to women, : women can be extremely cruel. There are many accounts of women who have tortured, abused and murdered children, for example. Women will get defensive , and say "not all women"

The same thing happens if you say to men : there are loads of accounts of men torturing abusing and killing women.

They will say "well it wasn't me that did it"

Whataboutery doesn't help though.

It just seems like you're trying to minimise the issue of male violence by shouting about how women can be cruel too.
They're not two sides of the same coin.

Mississipi71 · 08/08/2022 11:31

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:15

I so agree with this. I was just looking at my own life recently.

One of the biggest mistakes that I bought into life was this: I was conditioned by society to see well educated men as good men. That I should aim to get a relationship with a well educated men. Society told me that the man's education was important, not his personality .

I've learned the hard way, not to see well educated men as great, just because they have a good education.

The two worst men that I have ever met, were very well educated.

I went out with both of them for a short while. One had a master's in finance. He is now a director of a bank. He was severely abusive to me and sexually assaulted me. I went to rape crisis Therapy after him for a long time.

The other man had a master's degree. He was abusive and a pervert.

I went out with both of these men because their education attracted me, I thought that they would be interesting and articulate. I was also very conditioned by my society to go out with a high achieving man.

I've learned now not just to look at their education, but to look at their personality.

So sorry you went through that trauma x

My experience, though nothing like yours was a relatively young professor, whose academic literature specialised in anxiety and stress, so the field of psychology. One day at work I broke down about the passing of my dog. Trivial to him, to the extent he said "oh not dead dog syndrome again". This bastard, of all people, didn't care that my experience triggered something which had happened in my childhood. A psychologist later told me that. Funny that - not. I see this tosser on tv now and I just find him repulsive. I won't name him, for obvious legal reasons. He is also sexist.

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 11:27

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:15

I so agree with this. I was just looking at my own life recently.

One of the biggest mistakes that I bought into life was this: I was conditioned by society to see well educated men as good men. That I should aim to get a relationship with a well educated men. Society told me that the man's education was important, not his personality .

I've learned the hard way, not to see well educated men as great, just because they have a good education.

The two worst men that I have ever met, were very well educated.

I went out with both of them for a short while. One had a master's in finance. He is now a director of a bank. He was severely abusive to me and sexually assaulted me. I went to rape crisis Therapy after him for a long time.

The other man had a master's degree. He was abusive and a pervert.

I went out with both of these men because their education attracted me, I thought that they would be interesting and articulate. I was also very conditioned by my society to go out with a high achieving man.

I've learned now not just to look at their education, but to look at their personality.

So sorry for your experience. Yes, education doesn't seem to help. I would have thought humanities do cover historic oppression of women. Literature and history certainly do. Of course, subjects like maths or science probably don't, though they should! Considering male academics will be assessing female students, the lack of awareness is very concerning.

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:23

I think it is relevant to ask why are women so cruel.

It's relevant first of all, to see the reaction of women. As it helps us to understand better the reaction of men.

If you say to women, : women can be extremely cruel. There are many accounts of women who have tortured, abused and murdered children, for example. Women will get defensive , and say "not all women"

The same thing happens if you say to men : there are loads of accounts of men torturing abusing and killing women.

They will say "well it wasn't me that did it"

ldontWanna · 08/08/2022 11:16

@AchatAVendre the PP cherry picked her arguments. The first line in the article starts with how the absence of fathers is the most influential factor in delinquency in later life. Relationship with the mother which the PP quoted was just one factor. Other factors were poverty, abuse in the home, breakdown of the family unit etc.

She also conveniently missed the part where the study - with the 44 thieves(that was criticised anyways and the methods were doubted as was the bias of the doctor) about maternal deprivation refers to prolonged periods of times (6 months) and children hospitalised or institutionalised with very little contact from their family. Not about children in childcare. It's not exactly rocket science to deduce that ACEs or early trauma will affect a child. That doesn't mean that children need a SAHP or that that parent must be the mum.

My mum was a shit mum. She was also a working mum. She would've been just as shit(because she was shit) if she stayed at home ,if not worse as I get blamed anyways for her lack of career progression.

I've been both a SAHM and a working mum. Overall I've been a much better mum and the only time I was shit for a while is because I tried to work like I didn't have kids and parent like I don't work and kept dropping balls and got overwhelmed. I was a dumbass.

brookstar · 08/08/2022 11:15

As an aside, there's a great Twilight Zone episode called "Not all Men". My daughter and I found it hilarious but this thread made me think of it. Not that make violence is funny but the end was quite clever. Worth a watch.

I'll look it up - thanks!

Mooshamoo · 08/08/2022 11:15

Mississipi71 · 08/08/2022 11:08

Education is irrelevant imo. Etonians anyone?

I so agree with this. I was just looking at my own life recently.

One of the biggest mistakes that I bought into life was this: I was conditioned by society to see well educated men as good men. That I should aim to get a relationship with a well educated men. Society told me that the man's education was important, not his personality .

I've learned the hard way, not to see well educated men as great, just because they have a good education.

The two worst men that I have ever met, were very well educated.

I went out with both of them for a short while. One had a master's in finance. He is now a director of a bank. He was severely abusive to me and sexually assaulted me. I went to rape crisis Therapy after him for a long time.

The other man had a master's degree. He was abusive and a pervert.

I went out with both of these men because their education attracted me, I thought that they would be interesting and articulate. I was also very conditioned by my society to go out with a high achieving man.

I've learned now not just to look at their education, but to look at their personality.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 08/08/2022 11:13

So the question could be: why are women so cruel?

///

Interesting question - perhaps start a thread? This one's about the damage MANY NOT ALL - popped that bit on for the NAMALT brigade - men do

Mississipi71 · 08/08/2022 11:12

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/08/2022 11:08

@AchatAVendre

I find the problem with a lot of men is that they are simply not intelligent enough for what they are trying to do. They want to walk into a well paid job - they aren't competent enough. They want a beautiful wife/girlfriend - they aren't good enough. This makes them angry and they think they are entitled to all of that.

I agree with this. And I think a lot of the recent rage directed at women (which at its most extreme takes the form of incel chat threads and violence but which is much more insidious at lower levels) is mainly men slowly waking up to the fact that the vast majority of their advantage comes from the massive structural privileges they have had in the past, not from some inherent superiority.

Until fairly recently women's position in western society was so circumscribed by laws and social mores that to some extent all women had make peace with this. You pretty much had to get married so you'd marry the least worst man you could find and tough it out unless it was so awful that you had to escape. You had to either have children (and thus sacrifice your financial independence forever) or remain single and childless and be regarded as a social outcast. Or if you were brave enough to continue working you were marginalised and subjected to the arbitrary risk of being fired at any moment.

Nowadays none of this is mandatory (although a lot of social pressure remains). Women can support themselves if they work hard enough and they can go back to work after having children. They can remain single and while the stigma hasn't disappeared it's much less than it was. We still have a long way to go but things are much better than they were 50 years ago.

And most men (obligatory NAMALT) are at some level uncomfortable with this. Even the ones who theoretically are "progressive" and the ones who are comfortable in theory with the idea of female equality. Because, to misquote Warren Buffett, when the tide goes out you can suddenly see who's swimming naked.

Fantastic post.

Mississipi71 · 08/08/2022 11:08

gnilliwdog · 08/08/2022 11:04

I wonder if education would help. Are men educated to degree level or beyond less likely to be sexist? Are women with higher education more likely to assert their rights to respect and equally?

Education is irrelevant imo. Etonians anyone?