Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government needs to something quickly to help families financially supporting children at Uni.

562 replies

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 08:41

Mortgages are going up( ours will by 300 when we remortgage v soon), energy bills will be going up hugely, ditto food, petrol etc…. Already making all the savings we can.

We have got to start paying our child £500 a month to live on from October on top. It was already going to be a squeeze.Her bills will be rocketing too so who knows if what we were planning to give her will be enough.

We don’t have a money tree and have 2 other children due to start Uni in the next few years. I know the poorest and the richest will be ok re funding for their child at Uni but there is a massive band in the middle who won’t. Whether or not you can go to Uni shouldn’t be decided on parental income( thanks Tories) but those already there and just starting are going to be in dire straits as are the families supporting them.

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 18:40

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 18:27

Of course they don’t say students will definitely get it, as everyone’s circumstances are different and not everyone will be eligible, I never said all students would get free prescriptions, but those with a low income and low/no savings are eligible. There are plenty of students who do get free prescriptions via the low income scheme. Posting “Students can't get free prescriptions.” is incorrect when those with a low income and no or little savings can.

What is a “low income”? In the example it is defined as less than £106.65 a week which would be much less than loan plus expected parental contribution (whether or not the parents do contribute). I don't think it's clear at all that they be considered to have a low income even without a job.

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 18:34

Mistlewoeandwhine · 07/08/2022 18:28

Not all kids are able to make up the shortfall with a job. My eldest is intellectually very bright but has ADD, autism and dyspraxia. No way could he work and study.

I was a student at the start of loans. My parents refused to give me any money and (due to abuse) I left home permanently. This meant that my money had to stretch over 52 weeks every year. Even when I did my PGCE, I worked in Royal Mail every day from 4pm, got home at 10.30, made my dinner, then did my work until at least midnight before getting up at 6am. I used to cry from exhaustion. Why should anyone need to live like that to better themselves? What sort of society do you want your kids to grow up in?

He gets a summer holiday though, doesn't he? Why can't he work then?

If he'd not capable of working even in the holidays then there's really no point in him doing a degree.

dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 18:29

TipTopTurvy · 07/08/2022 17:33

We cannot afford to send 500 each month to dc for Uni. we too have children spaced closer together. DC will not however get the maximum loan.
They know this. So, at 16, they have got a job. This summer they have been working over 20hrs per week to 1) afford the commute to their chosen 6th form , we support their choice and they were fully aware we could not afford the commute when they chose and that they would have to work and 2) hopefully put aside some money for unit as they are hoping to go to an oxbridge.
I have no idea why people think that it is okay for their kids not to work? It is a luxury for them if they dont have to. Even then, I would prefer if they did to gain some work ethic and understanding of how the world works and appreciate money.

Of course it's OK for them to not work during term time in a paid job! Some university courses are quite intensive and students are advised to limit paid work. They can get work experience during the holidays.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 07/08/2022 18:28

Not all kids are able to make up the shortfall with a job. My eldest is intellectually very bright but has ADD, autism and dyspraxia. No way could he work and study.

I was a student at the start of loans. My parents refused to give me any money and (due to abuse) I left home permanently. This meant that my money had to stretch over 52 weeks every year. Even when I did my PGCE, I worked in Royal Mail every day from 4pm, got home at 10.30, made my dinner, then did my work until at least midnight before getting up at 6am. I used to cry from exhaustion. Why should anyone need to live like that to better themselves? What sort of society do you want your kids to grow up in?

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 18:27

dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 18:13

They don't actually say students will get it though! They only state they can apply which is pretty obvious and applies to everyone. If the loan and “expected contribution to the loan” (presumably this is the parental contribution) are over the deemed “living requirements” they won't be able to get free prescriptions.

Of course they don’t say students will definitely get it, as everyone’s circumstances are different and not everyone will be eligible, I never said all students would get free prescriptions, but those with a low income and low/no savings are eligible. There are plenty of students who do get free prescriptions via the low income scheme. Posting “Students can't get free prescriptions.” is incorrect when those with a low income and no or little savings can.

dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 18:13

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 17:16

Confirmation from the University of Manchester students’ union students on low incomes with little/no savings can get free prescriptions available here.

They don't actually say students will get it though! They only state they can apply which is pretty obvious and applies to everyone. If the loan and “expected contribution to the loan” (presumably this is the parental contribution) are over the deemed “living requirements” they won't be able to get free prescriptions.

latetothefisting · 07/08/2022 18:04

YABU - because when you say the government, there isn't a magic money tree, so what you really mean is 'the taxpayers.' why should an 18 y/o who leaves school and gets a full time job have to pay towards the housing and accommodation of their ex-schoolmate for the rest of their lives, particularly when the aim is that said schoolmate will end up getting paid more?

Graduates already aren't paying off their loans, so why give them more money?
We need to separate tuition fee loans and maintenance loans - one it's fair enough that it gets written off eventually if said graduate doesn't end up earning enough to pay it back. The other, the person has already lived in the accommodation, and eaten the food, (and drunk the beer!) they spent said loan on, so of course they should have to pay it back, even if it does take 40 years!

I would prefer to possibly give some sort of grant or extra loan to students who have 30plus hour weeks and are often expected to work during the holidays - e.g. medical students, teachers, etc. But for those who do humanities and have 6 timetabled hours per week, and 25 weeks holiday - just get a job! Speaking from my own experience, I did 16hrs p/w term time, and more in the holidays, and basically self-funded myself, and still got a 1st (and still went out multiple times a week, joined societies, spent the requisite full days watching tv, etc). I could easily have worked more hours, and had friends who worked pretty much full time and still got 2.1s.

Cherryonthetop2019 · 07/08/2022 17:49

Our DD starts this September. She is going local and living at home. She had a PT job in pizza express. Hoping to not need any loans and she can continue to live here rent free. It’s not mandatory that they live away from home. If the Uni education is the focus there ways round the finances.

fyn · 07/08/2022 17:35

My loan of about £4,000 didn’t ever cover my accommodation, I got a job and a student overdraft like everyone else. I worked in hospitality in term time, picked up temping jobs in the holidays doing anything from assembling calendars in the Christmas holidays to processing benefit forms over the summer. My parents didn’t contribute, nor did I expect them to.

TipTopTurvy · 07/08/2022 17:33

We cannot afford to send 500 each month to dc for Uni. we too have children spaced closer together. DC will not however get the maximum loan.
They know this. So, at 16, they have got a job. This summer they have been working over 20hrs per week to 1) afford the commute to their chosen 6th form , we support their choice and they were fully aware we could not afford the commute when they chose and that they would have to work and 2) hopefully put aside some money for unit as they are hoping to go to an oxbridge.
I have no idea why people think that it is okay for their kids not to work? It is a luxury for them if they dont have to. Even then, I would prefer if they did to gain some work ethic and understanding of how the world works and appreciate money.

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 17:16

Confirmation from the University of Manchester students’ union students on low incomes with little/no savings can get free prescriptions available here.

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 17:13

dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 16:59

Students can't get free prescriptions. Libraries don't have hundreds of copies of every textbook so if one is required by every student on a course, the great majority (if not all) will have to buy it. Accommodation is very expensive and the minimum loan is usually not enough to cover it.

Students can't get free prescriptions.

If they have a low income, as the minimum maintenance loan is, and no/low savings they can, which is what the OP is claiming her DD’s position will be.

Libraries don't have hundreds of copies of every textbook so if one is required by every student on a course, the great majority (if not all) will have to buy it.

As I and @poetryandwine posted, many resources are now online. For the ones that aren’t libraries often have enough of the majority of necessary texts for students to get by &/or it’s possible to buy them second hand so buying multiple new textbooks at £100 each isn’t necessary.

Accommodation is very expensive and the minimum loan is usually not enough to cover it.

OP says the loan covers DD’s accommodation.

Darkstar4855 · 07/08/2022 17:04

The kids I know from “poor” families choose unis close to home because they can only afford it if they live at home. They work part time, some even take a year out to work and save up money first. Yes they get a bigger loan but that just means more debt when they graduate.

Whereas middle class families seem to have this sense of entitlement that their kids should be able to go to whichever uni they want, not have to work because mental health, course too intense etc. and the taxpayer should foot the bill because why should they have to put aside part of their £60k+ salary to save up for uni for their kids? And then try and blame the poor people for their problems.

dianthus101 · 07/08/2022 16:59

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 14:35

Internet won’t be necessary as it will be included in the halls fees. DC can apply for free prescriptions if they have a low income and no/limited savings. They don’t constantly need new clothes or household items so they wouldn’t need a monthly budget for that. The majority of textbooks will be available in the library. Students don’t need £500 per month to live on.

Students can't get free prescriptions. Libraries don't have hundreds of copies of every textbook so if one is required by every student on a course, the great majority (if not all) will have to buy it. Accommodation is very expensive and the minimum loan is usually not enough to cover it.

Yourownpersonaljesus · 07/08/2022 16:57

OP I totally agree with you that the loan shouldn't be based on the parent's wage. My DD didn't get the full loan and as a single parent I could not afford to support her - I certainly couldn't afford give her a monthly allowance. I bought her an online shop once a month at the most (about £50). Although she struggles with her mental health (has been on anti-depressants since 6th form) she had a job throughout her degree and worked during the holidays. She made some good friends through her jobs (at one point she had 3 jobs at once) and I'm sure her experience in the workplace has helped her to get her first full time position. She got a first in her undergrad degree and went on to do a masters - not boasting but just wanted to show that is is possible to work and get good results. Good luck to your DD.

Minecraftatemychild · 07/08/2022 16:55

KangarooKenny · 07/08/2022 08:42

It’s always been disgusting that Uni kids loans are based on their parents income. They are adults.
It should be changed and they all should be treated the same.

This.

Fireflygal · 07/08/2022 16:53

the Loans count as income as does summer work so many don’t qualify for free prescriptions, internet isn’t always included in halls no, are you saying they don’t need any clothes?

If a student requires regular prescriptions then prepaid is the way to go..£2.50 a week. I have never heard of Internet not provided and in a shared house it's divided amongst the 4-5 students. Most have lots of data on their phones anyway.
Clothes should be charity or 2nd hand or ask for vouchers for birthdays.

If the expectation of students is to have the same standard of living in Uni that their parents have at home, then obviously parents will have to fork out. However most students know that their 3 years will involve work to pay their way.
In 2nd year if house sharing some students stay on, rather than go home for the whole summer and ramp up work. Where there is a will...there is a way.

Bank of mum & dad doesn't need to be there.

Markedforsl · 07/08/2022 16:52

My teenagers get all their clothes dirt cheap from charity shops and look great.

boys3 · 07/08/2022 16:52

@Fl0renc3 from what you've posted it seems that:

  • your DD will be going to a uni outside of London;
  • your household income is such that she will receive the minimum maintenance loan,
  • and, although the minimum, that loan will cover first year accommodation costs. Presumably self-catered, uni halls?
You've referenced £500 per month to be found; not sure if this just term time; or applies to a full twelve month period.

Assuming the latter might an alternative approach be for you to pay her accommodation costs (something less than £4500, although likely fairly near that amount I'd guess) and let her live, more than comfortably, off the minimum loan, which is just over £4,500 - assuming 31/32 wks actually away at Uni, that's leaves her just over £140/wk during term time. Which really is a very comfortable amount. If your finances are really tough leaving her with £100 per week; and re-directing c.£1200 towards hall costs could be another avenue to explore.

neverbeenskiing · 07/08/2022 16:14

Also you could apply this to those who eligible for the full loan. Shouldn’t they also “get jobs”?

I don't think anyone has suggested they shouldn't. Many do.

SeemsSoUnfair · 07/08/2022 16:10

BeeCyber8net · 07/08/2022 15:38

I believe if you have lived in Scotland for 3 years the university fees are greatly reduced, I am seeing 1.8K on the Internet

People outside of Scotland have to pay the 9k

Scottish residents are funded by the spending choices of their government and don't pay back the reduced £1.8k tuition fees that the government pays the university. They also manage the cost of this by capping the number of Scottish student places that are available. RUK and ROW pay the full tuition fee.

But, I don't think that is relevant to this thread which is about the cost of halls and maintenance during uni which is the same in Scotland. If England paid their students tuition fees that money would be removed from the loan, not given for halls/maintenance.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 07/08/2022 16:06

Most unis have digital libraries now where books, articles, academic journals etc can be accessed online

UndertheCedartree · 07/08/2022 16:05

@Fl0renc3 - what hours will she be doing at Uni? (Or placement?) How many weeks off a year?

Most students can work. My nursing degree meant almost full time in Uni or full time on placement and only 7 weeks off a year. Most did bank work at the hospital.

If there are mental health issues it could make it harder but she may be able to work a bit?

Rafferty10 · 07/08/2022 16:03

Sorry op l completely disagree, if your DD wants to study at Uni she has to make it work, l don't want to pay more tax to fund her.

I have two younger Dcs they will also have to find a way to make it work as we are also the 'middle' but they are also looking at apprenticeships, work training degrees etc.

UndertheCedartree · 07/08/2022 15:58

WhereAreMyAirpods · 07/08/2022 15:55

There’s generally one copy of a text in the library, the essential ones require purchase and can be around £100.

Not true. Essential ones are put in short-loan so that one person cannot take it out in October and keep it until May.

When I was doing my nursing degree it was impossible to rely on the library. You need different books based on your modules. So the book may become available after a couple of months but you don't need it anymore. I requested books before term started and still couldn't get hold of many. And as long as you are willing to pay the fine you can keep a book as long as you like.