Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government needs to something quickly to help families financially supporting children at Uni.

562 replies

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 08:41

Mortgages are going up( ours will by 300 when we remortgage v soon), energy bills will be going up hugely, ditto food, petrol etc…. Already making all the savings we can.

We have got to start paying our child £500 a month to live on from October on top. It was already going to be a squeeze.Her bills will be rocketing too so who knows if what we were planning to give her will be enough.

We don’t have a money tree and have 2 other children due to start Uni in the next few years. I know the poorest and the richest will be ok re funding for their child at Uni but there is a massive band in the middle who won’t. Whether or not you can go to Uni shouldn’t be decided on parental income( thanks Tories) but those already there and just starting are going to be in dire straits as are the families supporting them.

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 09/08/2022 15:52

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/08/2022 14:57

Totally agree with this.

And I’m sure there were plenty of young people in MH wards in the 90’s but what I don’t remember was 18yo’s bursting into tears and having a breakdown and declaring they can never work again, because they work in Asda and a customer was a bit rude to them. There’s absolutely no call for resilience any more, it’s expected that everyone pander to the most sensitive people going. And 100% anxious parents create anxious children.

I haven't seen any 18 year olds doing that now! I'm sure that there are some but there would have been some in the 90s. Many people in the 90s would have said teenagers were much less resilient than in the 60s. In the 60s they probably said they were less resilient then the 30s. It's all a case of some people being out of touch and looking back on the past with rose tinted spectacles and disparaging the “youth of today” and thinking they were superior when they were young.

Happyhibiscus · 09/08/2022 15:34

Not sure the “poorest will be ok” I think they’ll probably really struggle too or maybe they won’t even be able to consider uni for that very reason.

If the real reason she doesn’t get/ have a job is MH issues then that needs attention. But you also mentioned transport as a reason, so how do your other two kids get to work?

maybe there’s something local in your village she could do- babysitting, cleaning, dog walking, gardening?

LidlCinnamonBun · 09/08/2022 15:23

@mummymeister but it’s not fair if it’s a right for some people and a privilege for others, which is what will mean if only those with rich parents can afford uni.

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 15:17

poetryandwine · 09/08/2022 14:55

Several of us are with you,@ancientgran Really hope the OP is taking our comments under advisement

It feels like there is so much pressure to rush from school to university or to a lifelong career. I think there is more to learn in life and a year or two between school and university can be a very positive thing, particularly if there are MH issues. I also hope she is listening.

mummymeister · 09/08/2022 14:59

University is a priviledge and not a right. if you choose to attend then you have to sort out the funding. This is all down to Blair and his pushing for 50% of school leavers to go to Uni. completely unrealistic and the other labour decision to charge tuition fees was the opening of pandoras box and so obvious all they were going to do was go up and up. this recession is going to be long and its going to be deep and it really needs all adults to look critically at their finances. for some its going to mean delaying uni, for others selling up and moving to a smaller house or having less children than planned. this isnt 6 months and its over this is years and years.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/08/2022 14:57

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 11:35

Why are there now so many anxious teens and teens with “issues” precluding them from normal life? Where were these teens in the 90s? We’ve invented this issue. Any anxious child, you’ll see an anxious parent enabling it. Saw it over and over with Covid anxiety.
There’s a middle ground between 70s style “get a grip” and nowadays pandering to absolutely every emotionally fragile person. A bit of reality no?

Totally agree with this.

And I’m sure there were plenty of young people in MH wards in the 90’s but what I don’t remember was 18yo’s bursting into tears and having a breakdown and declaring they can never work again, because they work in Asda and a customer was a bit rude to them. There’s absolutely no call for resilience any more, it’s expected that everyone pander to the most sensitive people going. And 100% anxious parents create anxious children.

poetryandwine · 09/08/2022 14:55

Several of us are with you,@ancientgran Really hope the OP is taking our comments under advisement

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 14:51

We can't diagnose how serious MH issues are on here but I do think if an 18 year old has significant MH issues then delaying university might be the best/safest option. Uni isn''t all fun and giggles.

dianthus101 · 09/08/2022 14:39

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 12:23

Yes there were some but now there are swathes. You’re talking about people ill enough to be admitted. Now, the majority seem to have an issue. What’s going on? Some of it is nonsense and attention seeking

So you think only some of it is nonsense and attention seeking, but some of it is genuine. And yet you are telling all posters on this thread that they shouldn’t pander to their child’s mental health problems and that it does no one any favours. How do you know their child isn't genuinely ill given that even you think some people are?

Dalaidramailama · 09/08/2022 12:26

@Siameasy

I have worked in the MH sector for a long time and I can assure you there are many professionals with your opinion, it’s just not at all very PC to say out loud.

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 12:23

dianthus101 · 09/08/2022 11:58

I used to work in a psychiatric hospital in the 90s and there were plenty of teens and young adults with mental health problems. I also knew people who committed suicide in the 80s and a couple of people who attempted it. The difference in the past compared with now is partly the fact the people actually talk about it. In the 90s more people had your attitude so people knew to keep quiet but that doesn't mean they were all employed or in education. It just means you and others with your attitude didn't know about it.

Yes there were some but now there are swathes. You’re talking about people ill enough to be admitted. Now, the majority seem to have an issue. What’s going on? Some of it is nonsense and attention seeking

dianthus101 · 09/08/2022 11:58

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 11:35

Why are there now so many anxious teens and teens with “issues” precluding them from normal life? Where were these teens in the 90s? We’ve invented this issue. Any anxious child, you’ll see an anxious parent enabling it. Saw it over and over with Covid anxiety.
There’s a middle ground between 70s style “get a grip” and nowadays pandering to absolutely every emotionally fragile person. A bit of reality no?

I used to work in a psychiatric hospital in the 90s and there were plenty of teens and young adults with mental health problems. I also knew people who committed suicide in the 80s and a couple of people who attempted it. The difference in the past compared with now is partly the fact the people actually talk about it. In the 90s more people had your attitude so people knew to keep quiet but that doesn't mean they were all employed or in education. It just means you and others with your attitude didn't know about it.

Dalaidramailama · 09/08/2022 11:38

@Siameasy

Agreed. Pretty unpopular opinion though on here. It seems even the adults don’t want to take responsibility for their MH so their kids certainly won’t either.

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 11:35

Why are there now so many anxious teens and teens with “issues” precluding them from normal life? Where were these teens in the 90s? We’ve invented this issue. Any anxious child, you’ll see an anxious parent enabling it. Saw it over and over with Covid anxiety.
There’s a middle ground between 70s style “get a grip” and nowadays pandering to absolutely every emotionally fragile person. A bit of reality no?

TheSummerPalace · 09/08/2022 11:14

thing is, plenty of teens have mental health issues but it just seems very convenient that that impedes them from working but not doing things like going to University. Mental health is not another term for ‘cannot work’

See @Mistlewoeandwhine about her DC with ASD. Many students battle with hidden disabilities such as ASD, ADHD, ME, dyslexia, etc, which means they have to work twice as hard to achieve the same as “normal people” - but often depression and/or anxiety go hand in hand, with these conditions, due to feeling a failure in a society set up by and for neuro-typical people.

They can either work full time on their education or they can work full time in a job; what they can’t do is full time education, taking up all their waking hours and energy; then work part time on top.

I am amazed how some posters, who do not appear to be psychiatrists, seem to know at a glance, better than mental health trusts, with all their teams of professionals?

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 10:39

TheSummerPalace · 09/08/2022 10:22

I worked PT from 16 and took extra hours in summer. I see far fewer teens doing this now and it’ll be to their detriment and likely fuelling so-called MH issues (I think often it’s a fear of adulting, enabled by helicopter parents)

Thats akin to saying smugly, I can do 5k to someone in a wheelchair! I am not sure what it proves?

No it doesn’t, that’s ridiculous. It’s saying that I’m not sure enabling all these excuses is doing young people any good. By all mean keep pandering to it. It does no one any favours, least of all the afflicted person.

Dalaidramailama · 09/08/2022 10:31

@TheSummerPalace

What your son did was not stalking it was innovative. In my old job as en employment specialist it was one of the best techniques to find an interview (trying to get through the back door as opposed to the front).

I know young adults who fit your description. Their helicopter parents do not want them in lowly supermarket jobs or lowering themselves in other typical teenage jobs. Of course they’ll be at a disadvantage further down the line without a very basic work ethic.

I also know a lot of teens who are struggling to obtain jobs so it’s definitely a tough market out there. This thread makes for an interesting read.

TheSummerPalace · 09/08/2022 10:22

I worked PT from 16 and took extra hours in summer. I see far fewer teens doing this now and it’ll be to their detriment and likely fuelling so-called MH issues (I think often it’s a fear of adulting, enabled by helicopter parents)

Thats akin to saying smugly, I can do 5k to someone in a wheelchair! I am not sure what it proves?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 09/08/2022 09:38

thing is, plenty of teens have mental health issues but it just seems very convenient that that impedes them from working but not doing things like going to University. Mental health is not another term for ‘cannot work’

BungleandGeorge · 09/08/2022 09:36

@Siameasy
“due to so-called mental health”

you should be ashamed of this comment. Do you read the news about the state of teenagers mental health and the inadequacy of mental health services to deal with it. It’s not ‘imagined’ these are serious conditions. And caused in part by the cut backs in services, support and school funding. There is so much more pressure on teenagers these days, the amount of school work has increased. It’s also been made very difficult to work prior to getting a NI number. And teens can’t leave school at 16, a point where many used to start full time work, they’re now still
in training. Nonetheless I don’t know many over 16s not working this summer, do you honestly not see teenage workers when you go to a cafe or a supermarket or a shop? 😆

Ivalueloyaltyaboveallelse · 09/08/2022 09:33

Sorry Op but she needs to get a job no excuses. A family member is younger and at college doing a part time job saving and has had a very very terrible couple of years and is still holding it all together determined to get to Uni saving like crazy. I don’t know how they do it after everything that has happened but I’m definitely inspired by them. I worked had a child and a husband when I went to Uni it can be done as long as your organised. Nobody hands anyone anything for free you earn it.

BungleandGeorge · 09/08/2022 09:22

@Tha i agree there’s loads of job adverts around but not sure what is going on as my kids has applied for 10s of jobs and not heard a thing. Maybe there are also lots of jobseekers? The example you give isn’t really a student job as pharmacy staff have extra training and qualifications and obviously the pharmacist has a 4 year masters degree and a further year on the job to qualify…
unless you work on the job I don’t think you really know what training or qualifications are necessary. Nurses are expected to triage, to prescribe, to manage long term conditions. It’s now a degree level profession, those below that level are nursing associates or HCAs. I’m not sure why social work is identified as needing a degree when I’d say and nursing not? A teacher really should have a higher qualification than the student, I don’t see how a career is going to help you understand algebra enough to teach a level.
degree level apprenticeships are great. They are also very labour intensive for the employer so there aren’t many places. Those that get them are often mature students who have worked and who are selected from a large pool. So it may not be so
much that the apprenticeship is better but that they attract very well qualified and committed people..
i think it’s a great injustice if the expectation is that only well off students can go to certain cities (where coincidentally many top universities are). University of London is just for the well off, overseas students and a few who live nearby now? That’s not progress

Siameasy · 09/08/2022 08:39

Why should the taxpayer fund someone to swan off to uni but that same someone can’t be bothered to help themselves by getting a PT job due to so-called mental health ?
I worked PT from 16 and took extra hours in summer. I see far fewer teens doing this now and it’ll be to their detriment and likely fuelling so-called MH issues (I think often it’s a fear of adulting, enabled by helicopter parents)

portico · 09/08/2022 08:29

I agree to avoid London. DS1 starts 2nd year next month. I am guarantor, ie payee of his monthly rent of £1075. He does not get the full allowance from his Liam either. DS2 wants to go to London, too, in 2023. Am trying to deter him, and doing my best to encourage his applying to the furthest northern universities. Apprenticeships would be better - must look into these.

SweetSakura · 09/08/2022 08:13

@cloudygreyskies agreed. Some of the best lawyers in my team joined as apprentices... They have zero student debt and earned throughout. Not the easy option, but a great alternative