Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government needs to something quickly to help families financially supporting children at Uni.

562 replies

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 08:41

Mortgages are going up( ours will by 300 when we remortgage v soon), energy bills will be going up hugely, ditto food, petrol etc…. Already making all the savings we can.

We have got to start paying our child £500 a month to live on from October on top. It was already going to be a squeeze.Her bills will be rocketing too so who knows if what we were planning to give her will be enough.

We don’t have a money tree and have 2 other children due to start Uni in the next few years. I know the poorest and the richest will be ok re funding for their child at Uni but there is a massive band in the middle who won’t. Whether or not you can go to Uni shouldn’t be decided on parental income( thanks Tories) but those already there and just starting are going to be in dire straits as are the families supporting them.

OP posts:
LargeLegoHaul · 10/08/2022 09:18

dianthus101 · 10/08/2022 09:08

Parents can't “cut off” their DC to avoid their income isn't taking into account the student loan. Don't you think people would have tried it if it was possible?

In theory, it’s possible, but it isn’t as simple as OP declaring her DD independent and isn’t the easy option. A student under 25 can be considered independent if:
-they have had no contact with their parents for over a year.
-they have supported themselves financially for at least 3 years.
-they have been married or in a civil partnership at any time before they start their course.
-they spent at least 13 weeks in the LA’s care before turning 16.

InMySpareTime · 10/08/2022 09:14

You can cut them off, but they need to have been living independently for (I think 2-3) years before starting university, or have got married.
DD will be eligible for a full loan because she moved in with her partner after Lockdown 1 and is taking a year out before starting university next autumn.

dianthus101 · 10/08/2022 09:08

Sandinmyknickers · 10/08/2022 08:49

Also I find it odd that you're referring to them as "kids" and clearly would continue to let your DD live at home in the summers (presumably rent free), but yet are insisting she is an adult who should be assessed independently of you and your circumstances and wealth? Which is it? If you truly think she is an adult and therefore isn't supported by her parents, then cut her off properly and legally- she'll get the full loan then. Would probably still have to work though....

Parents can't “cut off” their DC to avoid their income isn't taking into account the student loan. Don't you think people would have tried it if it was possible?

Sandinmyknickers · 10/08/2022 08:49

Also I find it odd that you're referring to them as "kids" and clearly would continue to let your DD live at home in the summers (presumably rent free), but yet are insisting she is an adult who should be assessed independently of you and your circumstances and wealth? Which is it? If you truly think she is an adult and therefore isn't supported by her parents, then cut her off properly and legally- she'll get the full loan then. Would probably still have to work though....

Sandinmyknickers · 10/08/2022 08:45

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:16

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet

Those on the lower end don’t have to pay their dc £500 a month. Their kids get the extra loans.

Yep I was that kid and my parents didn't top me up. I also worked throughout uni and summers.

But I didn't have the lovely large family house in a nice area with cars and my own room safeguarded rent- free to come home to in the holidays..... both me and my parents would have swapped with you and your DD in a heartbeat. £500 can be earned with a student job.... getting your family out of poverty and on the property ladder is a fair bit harder

Nothappyatwork · 10/08/2022 08:41

DrenchedandDrained · 10/08/2022 08:30

The amount of time as a student and trainee lawyer that I spent standing over photocopiers copying one page at a time of massive bundles, mountains of filing, making tea, cleaning toilets, answering phones, standing feeding pages through the fax machine, being sent out to buy an office worth of sandwiches. An endless stream of boring tasks. For a pittance. Crying in the toilets after getting screamed at for stuffing something up.

I am so grateful for that experience now as it toughens you up for life's inevitable challenges.

You’re grateful for being abused because it’s helped you to deal with being abused more is that what you’re suggesting ?

GoodThinkingMax · 10/08/2022 08:33

Fees were introduced over 10 years ago. There’s been a bit of time to plan, frankly.

And I’d rather see any government help targeted to the school pupils who won’t even contemplate universities because of cost. Or that group of some undergraduates I teach who have to work too many hours during term than is good for them or their studies.

DrenchedandDrained · 10/08/2022 08:30

The amount of time as a student and trainee lawyer that I spent standing over photocopiers copying one page at a time of massive bundles, mountains of filing, making tea, cleaning toilets, answering phones, standing feeding pages through the fax machine, being sent out to buy an office worth of sandwiches. An endless stream of boring tasks. For a pittance. Crying in the toilets after getting screamed at for stuffing something up.

I am so grateful for that experience now as it toughens you up for life's inevitable challenges.

DrenchedandDrained · 10/08/2022 08:18

I was an idle sod as a teenager but even I managed to work part time at Uni and in holidays. You have to take chances in life. Of course it may feel daunting to her to apply and take a job but the mere act of working will give her confidence and help with social skills.

I live rurally and our local pubs are having to close early due to lack of staff. We have noticed that pretty much all hospitality staff where we are are now student age. I love it as typically so cheerful and bring energy to the job. A lot are in the same boat. Sometimes inertia is our biggest enemy.

I also think it is important to do low paid/unskilled work as a student, to give an appreciation of what life could be like if you don't work hard in studies/career development at this age.

Sunnyqueen · 10/08/2022 07:37

Yes there were some but now there are swathes. You’re talking about people ill enough to be admitted. Now, the majority seem to have an issue. What’s going on? Some of it is nonsense and attention seeking

No there are categorically not swathes of young people on psyche wards now at all. They don't get through to be admitted. It's mainly middle aged to pensioner ages with the minority in their 30s and 20s on the wards.

Iamthewombat · 10/08/2022 07:32

MarieG10 · 10/08/2022 05:55

Congratulations. You are in the big band in the middle whereby you get fuck all. We are still in the position in this country whereby there is little incentive to lift yourself up. Ie if at the bottom, to move up makes you worse....just seen how much additional loans my daughters friends get compared to her...£4500 more!!

I have staff in my team in the NHS...get a pay rise or promotion and want to reduce hours as they want to retain universal credit and all the bits it brings them....and then the ones that hit £50k for the first time on salary and realise that their marginal tax rates are now 40% tax, 9% student loan repayment and 11% payment of pension suddenly think I'm not paying 60% so apply to reduce their hours. Then they wonder why the NHS is so screwed staffing when all these things impact. Same...the doctors are all reducing their hours due to the pension tax issues as well....loads of ours have stopped working Fridays now and have a four day week rather than pay the tax.

When will someone in government actually do something!!!

You think that your daughters’ friends should rejoice because they have been allowed to borrow more, because their families are poorer?

As for your description of why some of your colleagues have reduced their working hours in the NHS: is this somehow expected to elicit sympathy?

People in your team earning well and paying higher rate tax, trying to pay less of it by going part time. How dare anyone expect them to pay higher rate tax!

Highly paid consultants stropping about the fact that their million pound, publicly funded pension pots might be subject to some tax if they breach the limits (the same limits that apply to everyone and were designed to stop wealthier people grabbing the lion’s share of the available pension tax relief). How dare anyone ask them to pay the same tax as anyone else. Their revenge will be working fewer hours, and sod the patients.

And this is somehow the government’s fault, is it?

dianthus101 · 10/08/2022 07:29

FamilFeaturesFun1 · 10/08/2022 05:01

"Supporting children"

If they are 18 or older, they are legally adults

Not when it comes student loans. Parental income is taken into account and that's not their fault.

theydontlikeitupem · 10/08/2022 06:02

OP I agree it's not fair but I don't see it changing any time soon.

Could your DD defer her course and work for a year to save up?

hotelp · 10/08/2022 05:56

Oh bloody hell OP you are a misery.

I worked 2 evenings a week and all uni holidays to support myself. And that was for medicine.

Stop modelling a defeatist 'woe is me' attitude. Start modelling a problem solving 'help your self' attitude.

MarieG10 · 10/08/2022 05:55

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:12

It’s not entitled to look ahead and be worried. We work hard and our taxes fund those who get full
loans which in the current climate the middle should get too.

Also my like many teens my daughter has been through a lot and just getting into Uni will be an achievement.

Congratulations. You are in the big band in the middle whereby you get fuck all. We are still in the position in this country whereby there is little incentive to lift yourself up. Ie if at the bottom, to move up makes you worse....just seen how much additional loans my daughters friends get compared to her...£4500 more!!

I have staff in my team in the NHS...get a pay rise or promotion and want to reduce hours as they want to retain universal credit and all the bits it brings them....and then the ones that hit £50k for the first time on salary and realise that their marginal tax rates are now 40% tax, 9% student loan repayment and 11% payment of pension suddenly think I'm not paying 60% so apply to reduce their hours. Then they wonder why the NHS is so screwed staffing when all these things impact. Same...the doctors are all reducing their hours due to the pension tax issues as well....loads of ours have stopped working Fridays now and have a four day week rather than pay the tax.

When will someone in government actually do something!!!

Lifeisbeautiful01 · 10/08/2022 05:49

WinterMusings · 07/08/2022 09:01

Has she been working these holidays???

no course is so intensive they can't work in the holidays At All 🤦🏻‍♀️🙇🏻‍♀️

I disagree. My DD is still on placement 90 miles from uni, working 3 shifts a week in a different hospital and in uni 2 days. She will have 10 days holiday this summer and had 5 at Easter. She worked last summer and during her 2 week Xmas break but cannot work term time as she is on shifts when on placement. She even has to wait months for her petrol to be reimbursed and is currently back in halls to cut costs. Some medical courses need seriously different funding!

FamilFeaturesFun1 · 10/08/2022 05:01

"Supporting children"

If they are 18 or older, they are legally adults

TheSummerPalace · 09/08/2022 22:57

And 100% anxious parents create anxious children.

That may be because anxiety can be genetic! According to the NHS website, people are 5 times more likely to develop generalised anxiety disorder, if they have a close relative with it:

www.nhs.uk/mental-health/conditions/generalised-anxiety-disorder/overview/

Its not one gene for anxiety.

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 18:01

As a retired HR manager I think bursting into tears if you get something wrong is pretty well spread across all ages. If I had a £1 for every time I've heard I've given someone a bollocking when I wasn't even telling them they'd done something wrong I'd be a very wealthy woman. I could never figure out if they really thought they'd been given a bollocking or if it was like some badge of honour so if they'd been called into my office it was an opportunity to join the "bollocked" club.

I do think that sometimes youngsters think they are more useful than they actually are. Lots of indignation if they are paid less than an adult but it is a rare 16, 17 or 18 year old that can perform as well as someone with some life experience, I'm not saying they aren't useful and I'm not saying that none of them can out perform their older colleagues but the reality is most need the edges rubbing off a bit. One of the things a gap year, or two, is very good at doing.

Jourdain11 · 09/08/2022 17:17

OP seems incredibly negative and prone to catastrophic thinking. I don't think this is a great example to set for DD heading off to uni, which is quite a challenging time for a young person. OP, please think about this and try to be positive for your DD. No wonder she's anxious if you are also like this with her.

dianthus101 · 09/08/2022 17:13

SeemsSoUnfair · 09/08/2022 16:29

I haven't seen any 18 year olds doing that now!

You must have a better recruitment policy than our place does! I don't know where they get them from, but I keep tissues in my desk now for the fragile teens who can't cope with the slightest, gentle constructive feedback (not from just me). They are smart cookies, but just can't seem to cope if they aren't told they are a star 100% of the time.

Perhaps your workplace is particularly crap or your feedback isn't quite as gentle or constructive as you think. My experience of 18 year olds (my DC are in their early 20s now so have known many) is that they aren't any more or less fragile now than 30 years ago in general.

MintJulia · 09/08/2022 16:53

I worked all three of my summers (80s), 8am - 4.30pm in a toy factory. It was grim but it meant I could eat in the autumn term and buy books 😊

gatehouseoffleet · 09/08/2022 16:40

I was a student back un the dark ages of grants in the early 90s and even then we ALL WORKED in the summer full time and most of us had a part time position in the term time too

I don't know where you were in the early 90s but we really didn't - there weren't the jobs. One summer I had a very part-time job in a gift shop and I got a decent full time summer job between the end of my degree and my Masters. Otherwise it was the odd two week placement here and there.

I had had Saturday jobs in the late 80s when I was at school but not while at university. The shops wouldn't employ students - I think they assumed we wouldn't get out of bed on a Saturday morning. Some students did bar work at the college bar, that was it.

However, I did end up at zero when I left university - no savings, but no debt.

gatehouseoffleet · 09/08/2022 16:35

I am always astounded by the general attitude in the UK that further education is mainly some kind of vanity project. Why does education stop beign valuable at 18? Globally, a less educated population will only make the UK less competitive

I totally agree. Tuition fees are totally wrong in my view. We need people to be well educated. But successive governments don't agree.

SeemsSoUnfair · 09/08/2022 16:29

I haven't seen any 18 year olds doing that now!

You must have a better recruitment policy than our place does! I don't know where they get them from, but I keep tissues in my desk now for the fragile teens who can't cope with the slightest, gentle constructive feedback (not from just me). They are smart cookies, but just can't seem to cope if they aren't told they are a star 100% of the time.