Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government needs to something quickly to help families financially supporting children at Uni.

562 replies

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 08:41

Mortgages are going up( ours will by 300 when we remortgage v soon), energy bills will be going up hugely, ditto food, petrol etc…. Already making all the savings we can.

We have got to start paying our child £500 a month to live on from October on top. It was already going to be a squeeze.Her bills will be rocketing too so who knows if what we were planning to give her will be enough.

We don’t have a money tree and have 2 other children due to start Uni in the next few years. I know the poorest and the richest will be ok re funding for their child at Uni but there is a massive band in the middle who won’t. Whether or not you can go to Uni shouldn’t be decided on parental income( thanks Tories) but those already there and just starting are going to be in dire straits as are the families supporting them.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 07/08/2022 09:38

EmeraldShamrock1 · 07/08/2022 09:24

Yanbu.
Student loans should not be means tested on the families income.

Sorry but why should the taxes of people on NMW be used to subsidise the education of millionaires children? The future Boris Johnson’s, the Bullingdon Club wankers, the Rishi Sunaks of the world. Why should they get the same as children living on the breadline who had to work their arses off in much more difficult circumstances? That’s what happens if it’s not means tested

Ballcactus · 07/08/2022 09:38

Uni is exhausting for those that have no choice but to work. I worked in the morning cleaning a nightclub (utterly disgusting 🤮) went to uni all day, came home, went and worked in a shop until close (11pm)
friends that had financial help partied a lot and spent money in topshop!

Shyzebra · 07/08/2022 09:38

Yes I do want to pay more tax to subsidise students. I want the best quality doctors dentists teachers etc not just the ones that’s parents can afford to subsidise them.

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 09:38

Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 09:24

I thought that undergraduates at Oxbridge weren’t allowed to have term-time jobs. Does anyone know if this is still the case?

It’s still the case, but it’s also the case that they get about sixteen weeks off in the summer when they can work.

DH worked for the council grounds department during his summers there, who needed extra staff in the summer.

ShanghaiDiva · 07/08/2022 09:38

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:34

I am starting to think my job is no longer viable and we would be better off with the dc getting bigger student loans as a result of me not working.

Then she could be supported by my taxes...
you should all stop work, become poor and your dd would be fully funded, it’s a brilliant strategy!!

CoreyTaylorsbiggestfan · 07/08/2022 09:38

I done a very intense course (nursing), working full time then uni and didn't get many holidays (it was 8 weeks which is minimal for uni holidays) and everyone on my course had a part time job of some sort!
She needs a job! My parents would never be able to give us £500 per month and I would never take that from them. Is your daughter aware this is a hell of a lot of money??
Then again I think far too many people are going to university. Then when they finish uni they work in jobs that have nothing to do with their field or work in jobs that don't need a degree as they have no work experience! But that's a whole other thread!

BungleandGeorge · 07/08/2022 09:37

I’m not sure why you’re jealous of the young person entitled to a full student loan. They will start their working life in a much worse position with an enormous debt when compared to any student who has had a parental contribution. And I’d guess you will give your child money because you can afford to. Those less well off are getting more of a loan that needs paying back!

Testina · 07/08/2022 09:37

*her races = her taxes

You can pretty much assume anything that comes after the phrase “my taxes…” is going to be nonsense!

gogohmm · 07/08/2022 09:37

Oh and btw I'm not stopping eating out either - we bought a house we could afford and like most people with children in their early 20's, we are much more recession proof, might need to work a couple of extra years before retirement but my generation have it easier

Testina · 07/08/2022 09:36

EmeraldShamrock1 · 07/08/2022 09:24

Yanbu.
Student loans should not be means tested on the families income.

Despite me clearly having little sympathy for the OP, if the thread had been just that, I would probably have agreed.
I say probably, because although it’s the principle I’d want to start from, I suppose I can see a point where the tax receipt money really can’t stretch to the wealthiest getting it.

Where I have zero sympathy is the OP thinking her chosen shouldn’t have to work, choosing to live rurally then using that as an excuse, earning as a household at least £60K and most likely more unless one parent of teens isn’t working at all, claiming things about “her races” 🙄 (I doubt £60K with 3 children makes them net contributors personally) and worst - this acting like the “other side” is better off. I don’t doubt you can compare this one measure: do you get full loan - and find higher earners doing “worse”. But it’s cherry picking. I’m sure for example that the parent earning over £60K in their household is taking advantage of more pension tax relief (at 40%!) than the less squeezed lower income person.

There’s a thread for OP… limit pension tax relief to 20% for all contributions regardless of income.

Overthebow · 07/08/2022 09:36

gogohmm · 07/08/2022 09:34

By the way, employers are very impressed by students who actually bothered working. It shows initiative, sets them out from other students looking for graduate work. Particularly summer jobs - my friends dd has worked labouring on building sites each summer since 18 and the law firm who she has been recruited by were so impressed, most had internships daddy set up, my friends dd was so worried ... actually she's the one with the great work ethic.

Btw they need their construction site card to do this but after that it's fairly well paid

Yes I agree with this. We hire graduates every year and we mainly take the ones who have worked.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 07/08/2022 09:36

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:14

Mental health and lack of transport isn’t making excuses both are real.

So you think that those young people who live centrally (likely in cheaper housing than rural) and have good MH should get no help and work themselves, but you, who can afford to give your child £500pcm, should get help?

Thats ridiculous.

babbez · 07/08/2022 09:36

TommySaid · 07/08/2022 09:31

I agree OP, as usual the middle loses out as they’re expected to be able to ‘top up’ their child whereas the poorest get a higher maintenance amount.

I absolutely hate this entitled way of thinking.

‘How lucky the poor are that they get everything paid for them’

If the poor were better off then the people moaning about how good they’ve got it would get a job on NMW and have ‘everything paid for them too’.

As a parent if you physically do not have enough money coming in then you cannot support your child in going to uni. So that child cannot afford to go - that is not fair.

Why would you resent those who are poor a bit of extra help.

The loans were never designed so students could get free money for going to uni.

They we’re designed to make uni more accessible for those who don’t have the bank of mum and dad to help.
All of them would still need PT jobs.

It’s like you get more money to help with childcare costs, if you’re in care or disability costs - you can’t moan that your child isn’t getting the childcare loan if they don’t have children.

So why moan that your child doesn’t get the extra money because they’re not poor enough?

The comment you responded to was bizarre. Begrudging people with low incomes for getting more money, sorry but WTF.. so entitled, yet they complain about poorer people who have no choice.

I'm thrilled I got the max maintenance loan, cry about it pp. I'd be god knows where without it, it was life-changing.

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:35

ShanghaiDiva

Nice to see mental health dismissed as a bingo tick thus illustrating complete ignorance as to what it can involve.

OP posts:
NelStevHan · 07/08/2022 09:34

it is possible to work and still get a degree - I did shift work, 40 hrs a week, while at Uni FT, had a social life and still managed to get a degree.
inwouldnt want my kids to have to work that much but I absolutely would expect my kids to work in some capacity while at Uni. It’s great life experience, as well as being financially necessary.

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:34

I am starting to think my job is no longer viable and we would be better off with the dc getting bigger student loans as a result of me not working.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 07/08/2022 09:34

By the way, employers are very impressed by students who actually bothered working. It shows initiative, sets them out from other students looking for graduate work. Particularly summer jobs - my friends dd has worked labouring on building sites each summer since 18 and the law firm who she has been recruited by were so impressed, most had internships daddy set up, my friends dd was so worried ... actually she's the one with the great work ethic.

Btw they need their construction site card to do this but after that it's fairly well paid

ShanghaiDiva · 07/08/2022 09:33

Live rurally, no jobs available, mental health issues, pay my taxes
my mumsnet bingo card is complete

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:33

StillHappy

Thanks for your fire understanding of mental health and stress overload.

So I take it anybody struggling with the cost of living can just get a job then. Great, happy days, we’re all sorted. The oncoming recession looks just peachy.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 07/08/2022 09:32

I don’t believe that loans should be based on household income either. Everyone should be able to access enough money, after all it is a loan that is paid back with interest anyway! It’s not a freebie as some seem to think.
I don’t think students should be expected to do more hours than a full time job. Like everyone they need holidays, not really reasonable to expect someone to pull all stops out working for a levels and then work the entire summer. That’s the way to burnout. I would have encouraged working for some of the time but it wouldn’t bring in anywhere near 5k especially if taxis/bus fares to come off it.
if you’re above the child benefit cut off (60k after pension contributions) and have a £300 mortgage surely you do have enough cash to help your child somewhat though? Or would you rather reduce your household income to 20k or whatever the cut off is for student loans and see how easy it is to live on?

Chasingrainbows16 · 07/08/2022 09:32

etopp · 07/08/2022 08:50

Absolutely agree with this. It should have nothing to do with parental income. 18 year olds are adults, and we expect them to act as adults - while mid income parents are being crippled by having to pay for their education. And I say this as someone whose student children have full loans due to the fact that lockdowns have obliterated my income.

However, I think there's a wider problem, and it goes back to Tony Blair and his target of 50% of young people attending university. The whole system needs to be reformed; fewer young people should be going to university, and the alternatives ought to be much better, and better funded, than they are.

Yes, I agree with this re Tony Blair! And I actually said this at the time... Despite only being 14 then, I could see that this policy was ridiculous!

TommySaid · 07/08/2022 09:31

I agree OP, as usual the middle loses out as they’re expected to be able to ‘top up’ their child whereas the poorest get a higher maintenance amount.

I absolutely hate this entitled way of thinking.

‘How lucky the poor are that they get everything paid for them’

If the poor were better off then the people moaning about how good they’ve got it would get a job on NMW and have ‘everything paid for them too’.

As a parent if you physically do not have enough money coming in then you cannot support your child in going to uni. So that child cannot afford to go - that is not fair.

Why would you resent those who are poor a bit of extra help.

The loans were never designed so students could get free money for going to uni.

They we’re designed to make uni more accessible for those who don’t have the bank of mum and dad to help.
All of them would still need PT jobs.

It’s like you get more money to help with childcare costs, if you’re in care or disability costs - you can’t moan that your child isn’t getting the childcare loan if they don’t have children.

So why moan that your child doesn’t get the extra money because they’re not poor enough?

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 09:29

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 09:08

She is applying for jobs but has been struggling with poor mental health. Like many we’ve had a shit few years. We both work full time so can’t ferry her about. Petrol is ££££ now too , buses unreliable and £££.

So her mental health is good enough to manage an intensive degree, but not good enough to stack shelves in a supermarket or work as a waitress.

It sounds as though she, and you, need a bit of a kick up the backside and for all of you to learn about personal responsibility.

NelStevHan · 07/08/2022 09:29

‘I thought that undergraduates at Oxbridge weren’t allowed to have term-time jobs. Does anyone know if this is still the case?’

used to be. But not not anymore - not now they’re trying to look like they actually want WC to be able to afford to attend

I tuned down a place because of that ‘rule’ that and the college were acting like they were doing me a favour by accepting me in the first place. I needed to work FT hours at 18 to support myself and went to a UNi that understood and respected that.

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/08/2022 09:28

It sucks but don’t waste time moaning when it won’t help her or you. She should be working now, if she’s not then she can start looking tomorrow and save up whatever she earns. It’s not your sole responsibility to pay her way. You seem unaware a lot of people from all socio economic backgrounds have been doing this for decades.

Swipe left for the next trending thread