Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the government needs to something quickly to help families financially supporting children at Uni.

562 replies

Fl0renc3 · 07/08/2022 08:41

Mortgages are going up( ours will by 300 when we remortgage v soon), energy bills will be going up hugely, ditto food, petrol etc…. Already making all the savings we can.

We have got to start paying our child £500 a month to live on from October on top. It was already going to be a squeeze.Her bills will be rocketing too so who knows if what we were planning to give her will be enough.

We don’t have a money tree and have 2 other children due to start Uni in the next few years. I know the poorest and the richest will be ok re funding for their child at Uni but there is a massive band in the middle who won’t. Whether or not you can go to Uni shouldn’t be decided on parental income( thanks Tories) but those already there and just starting are going to be in dire straits as are the families supporting them.

OP posts:
123sunshine · 07/08/2022 10:24

Whilst I have some sympathy you are full of excuses. As a student many years ago (when student grants were still a thing) my parent finances were not in great shape and I was living in a tiny flat with my single parent mum. They couldn’t have afforded to support me through uni, instead I lived at home, got a small grant and worked 20-25 hours a week and commuted to the next town to university (rent was beyond finances without huge debt).
I have a stepson at university, he works to support himself through university (his mum is a low earner so he does get a full loan but still needs to work) he faces a lot of debt, we have committed to helping to repay that debt if need be. Unlike my kids his parents didn’t plan for the future.
My 2 children (from my first marriage) have had money saved from them since birth to provide a pot of money (not a lot £50pm but invested has grown to a very useful size, circa £20k each) this can be used to help through uni or whatever they decide upon, travelling, deposit towards a property etc. My 17 year old I have cajoled in to working as needs to learn hard working ethic, whilst initially reluctant with each working shift he’s learning new skills, dealing with co workers, difficult customers, etc life skills to build upon. I expect both mine to work through uni. With 3 children you should have planned for their future and if your daughter can’t sustain a part time job through uni and can only just manage to get herself there due to MH issues, i fear she may be one of those graduates who struggle to gain employment in the real world.
It is tough for middle earners I know, over the last 20 years I’ve been low earner, single parent, middle earner and higher earner it’s been quite a journey so understand all perspectives, but it’s also tough for low earners too. Bottom line is too many kids go to uni and the government cannot provide for all……if they do your taxes would be even higher. There is not a big money tree…

Mally100 · 07/08/2022 10:24

Overthebow · 07/08/2022 08:51

It is unfair that some students can’t access the full loan, but why do you have to pay so much a month? Didn’t your DC get a job at 16 to dave money for uni? Can’t they get a job at uni and in the summers?

I know things were cheaper when I went to uni but I wasn’t elegible for the full loan so I worked before and during uni to fund the gap myself.

Exactly, uni didn't spring up on you. She had at least a year or 2 to save up for this? And she could still get a job now?

Ragwort · 07/08/2022 10:24

Even one of my young relatives who is studying medicine managed to get a part time job at weekends (in a bar so it's very sociable) and works really hard during vacations - yes, even structured around medical placements - and still enjoys a couple of exotic holidays !

Eastangular2000 · 07/08/2022 10:23

Long and the short of it is, that looks if she can’t work due to ‘mental health’ then she is not fit for uni. The fact that you just say ‘mental health’ rather than any specific diagnoses or treatment plan is why I have put it in inverted commas. If she has a specific diagnosis and treatment plan I apologise but from what you have posted I suspect not

NelStevHan · 07/08/2022 10:22

Defer her place , let her work FT for a year and save. Don’t charge her rent and let her save that money towards her expenses.
Or she can do what many, many WC kids do - work for longer THEN go to Uni. Or work to support herself while studying.
WC kids don’t get everything paid for - they get to go into ENORMOUS debt that they won’t get help from parents paying off.
and that’s if they even get the chance to go in the first place.

I know lots of MC parents like you, complaining about how they’re caught up paying like this, but the reality is - they can afford to. They just don’t like it.
and the ones from MC or posh backgrounds really don’t like the idea of their child ‘having’ to work - they seem to think it makes them look like they can’t afford to put their kids through Uni.
The ones with WC backgrounds like me, fully expect their kids to get a job of some kind, including my friend who works in film and could literally pay for EVERYTHING for her kids - Uni, fees, housing. She could by them a house each. But she’s not. Because she knows that the best thing she can do for her DS is to let him have a job.

Ragwort · 07/08/2022 10:21

ABit none of this is 'news' surely you have been aware of the situation? Student loans and parental contribution has been around for a long time. In fact even in the 70s when I got a 'grant' for Uni (no charge for fees) it was broadly based on parental income.

babbez · 07/08/2022 10:21

FreiasBathtub · 07/08/2022 10:14

I'm baffled by all the people on this thread who think student finance shouldn't be decided on parental income. Baffled. The ONLY way this would work is if all parents were somehow banned from giving their kids money while at uni.

Otherwise you will absolutely entrench the privilege of students from wealthy backgrounds, and make the struggle even harder for kids from less advantaged backgrounds. As pp have said, the full loan doesn't somehow give you the ability to lay back and focus all your attention on your course. It's not enough, especially in London. Those students will be working part time, possibly living at home, possibly caring for younger family members so parents can work two or more jobs, quite possibly contributing to the family budget as they did when they were in sixth form.

Middle class people (of whom I am one) are blithely ignorant of the enormous advantage their children have accrued before they even start school, and the degree to which that advantage is embedded by the time they hit university. Universities are trying hard to unpick some of that advantage (with limited success, it has to be said) so that post-university outcomes are based on merit, not background. Your kid might have it tough but she really really doesn't have it tougher than most kids receiving the full loan. And pretending that they are starting on the same level and need the same help is just wrong.

Well said @FreiasBathtub

Cuck00soup · 07/08/2022 10:21

StillHappy

And why could she not work in the holidays to earn money towards this?

She definitely worked. It’s the realisation that I wouldn’t now be able to support her rent that makes me sad.

FWIW DD was also told her course would be intensive and to be fair, course placements made work tricky during term term and meant also she incurred extra costs. But she was able to work and gain relevant experience during the long holidays, meaning she didn’t need to use her loan until later in the year. I think the OP is being a bit defeatist here and should remember that most employers like to see more on a CV than Uni.

LargeLegoHaul · 07/08/2022 10:21

If the course is nursing or similar some work bank shifts as a HCA.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 07/08/2022 10:20

LIZS · 07/08/2022 09:23

Unless the course is Oxbridge or medical/Stem she will have time in holidays or weekends to work in her uni area. Student union for example, advertise for staff for its cafes, bars, events etc pretty early possibly in freshers week. If things are tight it is worth looking into any bursaries or hardship funding available.

Hardship funds aren’t for people whose parents can afford £500pm to give to their adult child

TommySaid · 07/08/2022 10:19

I am starting to think my job is no longer viable and we would be better off with the dc getting bigger student loans as a result of me not working.

Why don’t you and DH just quit your jobs and go on benefits?

You’d be entitled to the maximum loan amount, get your £20 a week child benefit and get housing benefit to cover some of your rent - you’d be laughing.

Just remember to update this thread to let us know how much easier your life is now you’re not a struggling middle class family.

TugboatAnnie · 07/08/2022 10:18

Look on the bright side op, the loan actually covers accommodation. Many students live in overpriced blocks (1st year) and overpriced dumps (following years). The first year you're extremely lucky if the loan is enough. That's where your anger should lie, fuckers like Unite that have waiting lists for basically cupboards, they should be regulated. You can tell I'm still angry and this is 10 years on! Goodness knows what it's like now!

£100 per week sounds a lot for food and entertainment. What happened to a bag of pasta lasting several meals? Smile

AndSoFinally · 07/08/2022 10:18

I did medicine at uni, courses don't come much more intensive than that. I still worked 18 hours a week as a care assistant to find my course.

I worked 60 hours a week during the holidays, because medical students don't get as long a holiday as others so I needed the hours.

It's possible to fund your own way through uni, no matter how intense your course is. It just depends how much you want it.

It's a good life lesson. Nothing should be handed to you on a plate, you have to work for everything. Sadly, it's not a lesson that gets taught very often now if the students I see are much to go by.

It might well be the making of your DD!

ABitCofused · 07/08/2022 10:16

cheninblanc · 07/08/2022 08:56

I totally agree, us in the middle are left really struggling. My daughter is working and is staying home and studying local. She's happy with that as are we and there's a lot less stress with this way but it's unfair her loans are based on my dh high wage, he isn't her dad, and yet his daughter will be able to get maximum loans as her mum doesn't work. Whole system is grossly unfair

I just discovered this today and agree that this is unfair

FreiasBathtub · 07/08/2022 10:14

I'm baffled by all the people on this thread who think student finance shouldn't be decided on parental income. Baffled. The ONLY way this would work is if all parents were somehow banned from giving their kids money while at uni.

Otherwise you will absolutely entrench the privilege of students from wealthy backgrounds, and make the struggle even harder for kids from less advantaged backgrounds. As pp have said, the full loan doesn't somehow give you the ability to lay back and focus all your attention on your course. It's not enough, especially in London. Those students will be working part time, possibly living at home, possibly caring for younger family members so parents can work two or more jobs, quite possibly contributing to the family budget as they did when they were in sixth form.

Middle class people (of whom I am one) are blithely ignorant of the enormous advantage their children have accrued before they even start school, and the degree to which that advantage is embedded by the time they hit university. Universities are trying hard to unpick some of that advantage (with limited success, it has to be said) so that post-university outcomes are based on merit, not background. Your kid might have it tough but she really really doesn't have it tougher than most kids receiving the full loan. And pretending that they are starting on the same level and need the same help is just wrong.

rumplestiltskinp · 07/08/2022 10:14

No because people at uni (they are not children) can support themselves with jobs. You don't have to live in halls, you can private rent with others. You can work at uni, they have employment agencies within the uni.

tkwal · 07/08/2022 10:14

Uni kids loans are not based on parental incomes. Because they are over 18 they are (or were when my daughter applièd) judged to be adults and assumed to be independent. That's why the loans exist and there are grants available for those on low incomes. The easiest way for you to support your daughter would be for her to choose a course at a uni close to home so she could lodge with you and encourage her to be independent by getting a part time job to fund her social life. At the moment

,while I admire your desire to provide her with the ultimate "uni experience" I'm afraid it's fast becoming unaffordable for most of us ,especially those of us with more than one child.

ContentInLife · 07/08/2022 10:13

Many don’t actually end up paying their loan back in full (some not at all) as they end up not earning enough. The threshold for auto repayments beginning is currently £27,295 a year, £2,274 a month or £524 a week in the UK. It was MUCH lower than that when I graduated (£10,000).

After 30 yrs it gets cancelled so if you never earn above the threshold you won’t pay it back at all. So this “saddled with debt” line people trot out isn’t as clear cut as one might think.

Bouledeneige · 07/08/2022 10:12

I don't agree I'm afraid. My DD worked throughout uni. All her housemates did too. The housemates who were on the full student loan were the worst off - once rent, bills and cost of living was taken into account they were the least well off and had to get jobs straightaway. They did a lot of hours doing cleaning, in care homes, delivering the post, bar work. They did a lot of hours and studied too. Quite a few had been supporting themselves since they were 16 and should only be admired for their hard work and commitment. Your DD had to do that?

Some of DDs friends gave some of their loans to parents who were on UC and they struggled to get a guarantor for rental agreements.

You still think your DD and your family have it worst? Get real. My DD had her eyes opened about privilege at uni - an excellent life lesson.

Beefcurtains79 · 07/08/2022 10:12

Excuse after excuse. How will these kids cope in the real world? Maybe uni isn’t for them.
Everyone works in the school holidays and at Uni, apart from the very well off and the work shy.

AntlerRose · 07/08/2022 10:12

I agree. I dont like the idea that an 18 year olds loan is based on their parents earnings, not the own 18 year olds ability to pay it back.

I d quite like to do a degree but tge amount i can borrow is based on my spouses salary - forcing me to be dependent on a man - something MN isnt in to.

Thataintnoetchasketch · 07/08/2022 10:11

I agree student loans shouldn’t be dependent on parental income but you lost me after that.

I chose a local uni - travelled an hour each way & was in 5 days a week. I worked 2-3 12hr shifts every week and on the holidays worked full time and then some. My friend did medicine and worked in a hospital kitchen. Nobody is going to hand money or solutions to you. But you’re setting your daughter up to expect it & feel hard done by when it doesn’t come.

drpet49 · 07/08/2022 10:10

“She was advised that her course is intensive and working probably not advisable.”

^Seriously? Because that is a weak excuse. When I was at uni practically everyone worked part time, either weekends or evenings and all worked throughout the summer holidays

CheshireCat1 · 07/08/2022 10:10

My sons went to local universities, lived at home and worked part time. I don’t see what the issue is.

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 10:09

Cuck00soup · 07/08/2022 10:03

It’s a good point OP. DD has graduated, but during her 3rd year we paid £7,000 for her rent. Although we have a reasonable income, we simply couldn’t do that now with ever increasing mortgage and bills. yet DD would still only be entitled to the minimum student loan.

Thousands of students are from families in similar positions.

And why could she not work in the holidays to earn money towards this?