Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in this wrong in this situation re diary

341 replies

Theresnolimit505 · 06/08/2022 23:22

At my parents' house with a boyfriend of a few months and in my old room. We come across my old diary in which I wrote a ton of hideously cringy things as you do when you're a teenager. Very personal stuff too.
He wanted to read it but I said I'd prefer him not to. He was insisting he read it and wrestling it off me.
In the end he gave up and went to the toilet. Whilst he was out, I ripped out the two most embarrassing pages in my eyes.
He came back and said can I read it now? So I said ok then..he opened it and noticed the 2 ripped out pages and went mad.
Saying, "If you lie about this, it makes me wonder what else you lie about?"
Who was in the wrong here? Surely I have a right to privacy

OP posts:
Chooksnroses · 07/08/2022 07:32

I voted you are unreasonable, but only because you let him read it. dump him. You have a right to privacy.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 07/08/2022 07:32

i meant to add after you have gone your off spring may come across things,
good reminder to get rid if you dont want your off spring to read things after you have gone

MrsLargeEmbodied · 07/08/2022 07:30

good idea to get rid of diaries that you dont want your off spring to find
but your current boyfriend, how dare he

Softplayhooray · 07/08/2022 07:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Is this a joke? He craps all over her boundaries in the first place by pressuring her to do something she's really uncomfortable doing, then when she tries to at least make the situation a bit better for herself after clearly being backed into a corner (removing the pages), he uses anger to punish her, then insults her. And over something so small. Life with him would be miserable and exhausting.

Petty, controlling, tiring, with red flags everywhere. OP you should not be dating this person.

AMIAMIBU · 07/08/2022 07:26

@ulteriorbread I think you need to check yourself, you seem to want to own a partner, not respect their right to privacy? That like the OPs DP is totally wrong? Do you have issues in relationships, do your partners feel overwhelmed by your need to have total knowledge of their teen years? Do you judge people a lot for things they did as a teenager? It's childish have a diary?

OP YANBU!

ArcheryAnnie · 07/08/2022 07:22

You are allowed to have boundaries, OP. Your boyfriend doesn't believe you should be allowed boundaries, and is prepared to use emotional manipulation (casting doubts on your honesty) and his physical strength to overcome them.

He's awful. Just awful. You deserve someone who will respect you. Bin him.

BowiesJumper · 07/08/2022 07:10

It’s fucking weird that he has insisted on reading it. Urrrg. Get rid.

PinaColadaSunset · 07/08/2022 07:02

He is well out of order. It’s an old diary and very personal to you. Doesn’t have any impact on your relationship at all. His response is very controlling and intended to make you feel as though you are not being fully open with him which is simply not true.

It is most definitely a red flag. Be careful how you proceed.

Thefruitbatdancer · 07/08/2022 06:53

www.freedomprogramme.co.uk/online.php

Read this, it will help you spot an abusers red flags.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 07/08/2022 06:48

This has just reminded me of a boy I dated in my early teens. We ended up in his bedroom paying a computer game. I noticed some paper beside his bed with my name written on it. I figured it was his diary or something private. When he went down to eat his dinner with his family, I told him I was going to go home and have mine and left. I didn’t want the temptation of reading what he’d written about me to overwhelm me.
Even at 12 I understood he had thoughts that he was entitled to keep private and they were current thoughts. Not ones from a life time ago when he didn’t even know me.

Norwegiancopice · 07/08/2022 06:37

Get rid of this boyfriend asap. He will try and gaslight you when you tell him it's about the diary so just tell him you don't fancy him any more. I've had a very similar bf and it escalates, today teenage diary, tomorrow "who were you talking to?" whilst lieing and cheating and denying it to your face.

Suetodo88 · 07/08/2022 06:26

@Aprilx

Everyone's different I guess. I just can’t imagine wanting to keep a diary from a boyfriend I liked much less a husband. I’ve always thought of wanting that kind of stuff private as more of a man thing, like they would get embarrassed by their feelings lol. I’d find it weird to have daily secrets from a partner.

Aprilx · 07/08/2022 06:05

Your boyfriend is definitely in the wrong here, he also seems nasty and willing to use his physical strength against you. I think it is wrong that you were pressured into letting him read all but two pages when you didn’t want him to. You should get rid of this awful man now before it gets worse.

To the posters who don’t understand why you didn’t want him to read it, well maybe some people would think it cute and funny to read a teenage diary. But others would find it cringey and embarrassing, maybe they would even find it painful or sad, is that so hard to grasp? The point is a new boyfriend is not entitled to know all our past thoughts.

Incidentally I have an 18 year old diary, I was 34 when I wrote it and I wrote it for a few months when I took time out and went travelling. So it is partly about my travels and partly my private thoughts at the time. I cannot imagine a world in which my husband (who I met about 18 years ago, towards the end of travel) would a) think he had a right to read it or b) think there were something off with me if I said he couldn’t. Everybody knows diaries are private.

AllyCatTown · 07/08/2022 06:02

What’s most concerning is you didn’t want to show him it but instead of sticking to saying ‘no’ you felt the need to rip out pages and give into his request. It makes me wonder what else you won’t want to do but you’ll give into pressure and try to appease him. You shouldn’t be with someone who doesn’t take ‘no’ for an answer.

It’s a whole other discussion on whether it’s suspicious that a partner of a few months won’t share their teenage diary. Personally I don’t think it is and can’t see how it reflects badly on them.

Suetodo88 · 07/08/2022 05:45

It seems a little strange to not want an adult boyfriend to see your teen diary. I would think it was the kind of thing you would share openly and laugh about and probably find some cute stuff too. Can’t imagine keeping it from a man I liked.

Maybe he was wondering what was so bad about it that you had to keep it from him?

ohdelay · 07/08/2022 05:31

"You said no, he got mad" never ends well

ohdelay · 07/08/2022 05:25

This is an easy one OP, put this "boyfriend of a few months" back in the bin. Save yourself the years/months/days of trauma. You ripping out the pages shows you know he doesn't respect your wishes and you're willing to destroy your childhood possessions to placate him. Him being "mad" that he didn't control, you in exactly the way he wanted you to shows this is the start and there'll be more. Some people are trash and they show themselves early

DeborahVance · 07/08/2022 05:19

Dump him now. Horrible behaviour

aloris · 07/08/2022 05:17

Aren't teenagers immature by definition? Teenagers are allowed to be immature, it's in the job description.

Also, what woman wants her adult partner reading all the silly things she wrote as a teenage girl and using those private writings to ridicule or criticise her? Deceptive and secretive? Eh?

Ponderingwindow · 07/08/2022 04:53

here is an acceptable conversation

Him: oh, your diary, we should read it.
you: no
him: oh, come on, don’t you think it would be hilarious to read your teenage musings? <this is said in a very lighthearted tone>
you: gosh no, and definitely not with company.
him: ok,
him: I can’t believe your parents left your posters up on the wall……

and the conversation moves on. Because a decent guy might mention the idea because he does think you might find it enjoyable, but the second you disagree, he should back off and respect your privacy.

that you felt pressured into redacting the diary and handing it over is really concerning.

Londonrach1 · 07/08/2022 04:39

A diary is private and written at the time when you a teenager. No one has right to read it but you. I reread my teenager diary ten years after I wrote them then burnt them as that stage had gone but the act of writing the diary helped me understand the teenage years. Red flag re that boyfriend and I'd be very careful now

carefullycourageous · 07/08/2022 04:33

Break up with him. He sounds really fucked up. He doesn't have any right to your past thoughts.

strawberrymelon88 · 07/08/2022 04:10

BIG RED FLAG.

RUN FOR THE HILLS.

NumberTheory · 07/08/2022 04:09

sausage767 · 07/08/2022 01:49

@NumberTheory maybe it’s not something to laugh about? OP has only been with her boyfriend for a few months. She may not be ready to share this sort of detail with him. The relationship might not be that serious yet.

@sausage767

If you read my post you would notice that I did put in a caveat about serious things that happened that you haven’t yet shared.

To be fair, reading it again I’m probably over reaching in saying I’d be put off. I wouldn’t have gone past a BF/GF saying “I’d rather you didn’t.” Which I’d have respected, assuming it meant there was good reason. It’s the idea that she was just trying to hide cringey stuff that I would find unattractive. But OP doesn’t say that.

And I do think the important bit here is that the BF had no respect for the OP when she said no, coerced her into sharing something she didn’t want to and when she put a small boundary in place he accused her of lying, which is pretty controlling.

GoodThinkingMax · 07/08/2022 03:03

He was very wrong. It’s kind of an a par with the “How many people have you slept with?” question.