Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dessert price query

61 replies

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 19:45

Name changed as outing.

I think part of what I did was unreasonable, but I would appreciate some opinions on whether I was entirely unreasonable.

Out in a restaurant, ordering dessert. Very limited in what I can order, due to a medical issue, though I realise that makes no difference to the restaurant staff. There’s only one part of one dessert, which is suitable, which is a sorbet. The total dessert is a scoop of sorbet with a shot of vodka.

I asked whether I could have just sorbet and the waitress said, “so you want the ‘name of dessert’ without the vodka” and I said yes.

An alternative dessert is two scoops of ice cream, which I think was cheaper than the sorbet plus vodka.

I was brought the single scoop of sorbet and was then charged full price for the dessert.

Was I unreasonable for thinking that was less than generous on the part of the restaurant? I thought the price might have been slightly reduced, or an extra scoop offered.

And second (where I think I was probably unreasonable) is that, when presented with the bill, with the full priced dessert, I decided not to give a tip. That was probably unreasonable as it probably wasn’t the serving staff who made the decision. I probably should have checked the price before going ahead. I’m not in the US and am in a country where tipping does occur, but where staff are undoubtedly paid properly, whether you tip them or not.

Your thoughts would be appreciated as the rather sour end seems to have spoiled what had been looking like a pleasant evening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
waterbotherer · 08/08/2022 08:07

PriOn1 · 08/08/2022 03:49

”And seriously not tipping is a shit act. In the US, tips are the staff's wages.“

Not in the US. Wages here are high and staff will be well paid. Not tipping is fairly normal here.

”in your situation I would ask what types of ice cream were available for the ice cream dessert and I bet sorbet would be mentioned.”

The ice creams available were listed in the menu and sorbet wasn’t there. I agree, though, with all those saying I should have asked differently and would do so next time, so all the helpful comments have been useful.

your name change was a bit pointless

SpindleTurning · 08/08/2022 05:33

Some people from where I’m from call it ‘sweet’. As in, ‘what’s for sweet?’

I don’t hear it much where I am now.

Nekomata · 08/08/2022 05:21

My son has autism, so he always asks for special dishes when we are out. We usually order the cheapest pasta on the menu and ask for no sauce. They always charge the full price for the pasta, which is fair enough.

So, I don't think what the restaurant did was wrong, but it was unfortunate that your dessert happened to be such an expensive one. in retrospect you and they should have clarified everything before confirming the order.

PriOn1 · 08/08/2022 03:50

Also, I would have said pudding when young, and possibly still would now, but one scoop of sorbet does not a pudding make…

PriOn1 · 08/08/2022 03:49

”And seriously not tipping is a shit act. In the US, tips are the staff's wages.“

Not in the US. Wages here are high and staff will be well paid. Not tipping is fairly normal here.

”in your situation I would ask what types of ice cream were available for the ice cream dessert and I bet sorbet would be mentioned.”

The ice creams available were listed in the menu and sorbet wasn’t there. I agree, though, with all those saying I should have asked differently and would do so next time, so all the helpful comments have been useful.

Arenanewbie · 08/08/2022 02:24

I think you were unreasonable to expect that they would charge you less. @SillyBub is absolutely right, you should always ask ‘to replace’ We do this sometimes : e.g extra salad instead of chips
in your situation I would ask what types of ice cream were available for the ice cream dessert and I bet sorbet would be mentioned.

NewBootsAndRanty · 08/08/2022 01:43

Afters, surely.

Testina · 08/08/2022 01:35

Isausernameavailable · 06/08/2022 20:24

YABU saying dessert. Pudding, always.

Even for a Royal Jubilee, where “pudding” is chosen for alliteration, there is reference to - the horror of it - dessert.
So do bore off back to watching Downton Abbey and pretending to be… well, I’m not quite sure what 🤣

Dessert price query
waterbotherer · 08/08/2022 01:22

Isausernameavailable · 06/08/2022 20:24

YABU saying dessert. Pudding, always.

who asked you? 🙄

Testina · 08/08/2022 01:17

Isausernameavailable · 06/08/2022 20:24

YABU saying dessert. Pudding, always.

What a fool you make yourself sound 🤣

Marynotsocontrary · 08/08/2022 01:05

Isausernameavailable · 06/08/2022 20:24

YABU saying dessert. Pudding, always.

Ah, stop it please...hardly the point of the thread!

Poppyseed14 · 08/08/2022 00:40

Even if they had given 2 scoops I'd still have begrudged paying £12 for it tbh. How much do they charge for 2 scoops of ice-cream OP? I don't think for one minute YABU.

maddening · 08/08/2022 00:02

I would have asked for ice cream but swap in sorbet instead of ice cream.

Kaiken · 07/08/2022 23:55

Variations on a food when you ask for one less ingredient doesn't bring price down. Say you order the meat lover pizza, but you don't want the hot sausage, only the other ingredients, your pizza will not detract the price of the sausage.

And seriously not tipping is a shit act. In the US, tips are the staff's wages.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 07/08/2022 23:52

I can understand that if you go out for a meal you want the whole experience, especially if you have dietary restrictions that make the whole experience more of an effort, but for the sake of one or two scoops of sorbet, I would not have had a dessert at all.

They are not in the slightest bit filling, they can be refreshing if you have had a very spicy meal, but if I was going to be charged £3 for a 2 scoop sorbet I would consider that excessive, and if I did want it with a shot of vodka, I would buy the vodka separately and add it to my sweet myself.

melj1213 · 07/08/2022 23:44

If you're modifying a dessert, which is what you had by agreeing that you wanted <Dessert option minus an ingredient> then I would expect to pay the advertised price unless otherwise agreed when ordering.

I have dietary requirements so if I am out somewhere and can't have any menu items I ask directly for substitutions to the best value (ie the icecream/sorbet substitution) and if they say no then I will ask directly for price reductions on modifications (Vodka sorbet minus the vodka) .

So I'd ask something like "I can't have any of the dishes on the menu due to my dietary restrictions, is there any way to have the 2 scoop ice cream dessert but with sorbet instead of ice cream?" If they say no and offer a modification of the vodka sorbet dish instead then I'd respond with, "Thanks but I don't really want to pay £12 for a single scoop of sorbet, as its only half a dish. Can I either get a second scoop instead of the vodka or is there any way to get a price reduction if I'm only having part of the dessert?" That then sets out plainly what I am requesting and it's clear what the options are so the server can speak to whoever makes the decisions (if they can't) to decide if either option is acceptable to them.

MichelleScarn · 07/08/2022 23:25

Pudding, what, sitting room, loo here

Isausernameavailable · 07/08/2022 23:18

Dessert is similar to pardon, lounge and toilet. We say pudding, what, sitting room, and lavatory.

Ccoffee · 07/08/2022 11:19

Isausernameavailable · 06/08/2022 20:24

YABU saying dessert. Pudding, always.

Pudding sounds like something served up hot in a 1950s boarding school, not a sorbet in a restaurant in 2022.

Jibberty · 06/08/2022 23:37

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 21:39

”I am curious as to how this is outing though”

Obviously it’s a distinctive situation. My son knows I use Mumsnet. I don’t want him to know my username.

And no, it’s not a hill to die on. In the grand scheme of things, it’s tiny. It was blown out of proportion by the comment and ended up being embarrassing.

There’s background I’m not going into. I just wanted to know if others thought I was unreasonable. Some do, some don’t. Others have offered useful perspective on it. Therefore, to me it was useful. If you start calling me names, troll hunting or insisting I’m an asshole, then you’re projecting. Simple as that.

I’m not entirely sure it’s distinctive, but here we are.

Meh, it’s just not a battle to have even raised imo.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 06/08/2022 23:20

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 23:07

”Well, a bottle of vodka is around £20 and is 750ml, and a shot is 25ml (unless your in Scotland in which case it’s 35ml), so 30 to a bottle. Or £0.60odd a shot to them. Which isn’t really very much, so I’m not sure I’d be bothered making a fuss as it probably is quite similar to the cost to them of a scoop of ice cream or a serving of cream.”

Not in the UK, and alcohol costs a lot here.

The most expensive place in the world to buy vodka seems to be Malaysia, but even there’s it’s only double the cost in the U.K., so I think my point stands.

www.globalproductprices.com/rankings/vodka_smirnoff_price/

We’re talking about a cost price to the restaurant of the equivalent of not much more than £1 or so. How much would you expect them to knock off the price of the desert? Surely not more than the ingredient cost…?

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 23:07

”Well, a bottle of vodka is around £20 and is 750ml, and a shot is 25ml (unless your in Scotland in which case it’s 35ml), so 30 to a bottle. Or £0.60odd a shot to them. Which isn’t really very much, so I’m not sure I’d be bothered making a fuss as it probably is quite similar to the cost to them of a scoop of ice cream or a serving of cream.”

Not in the UK, and alcohol costs a lot here.

OP posts:
Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 23:05

”Yes but you picked a dessert with alcohol so obviously that's going to be more expensive.”
”It's not the same as asking for no cream.”

”If you didn't want to pay £12 pick a cheaper dessert or go without.”

I asked if I could have the sorbet on its own, I didn’t ask for the specific dessert. As another poster pointed out, it was the person waiting who linked my request to the vodka and sorbet dessert, rather than the two scoops of ice cream, which (in my mind, and obviously in the minds of others on this thread) was closer to what I asked for.

I doesn’t compare to removing a minor side item, as far as I’m concerned. It’s more like if there was a dessert with two equal elements and I asked if I could have one of them on its own.

It was bad communication on both sides. This wasn’t a young, inexperienced person waiting tables, it was a competent adult, who should probably have considered how it would look to a customer to only get half a dessert for the full price.

Yes, I probably should have challenged it, but I chose not to tip, which would have been fine and is perfectly acceptable here, if my son hadn’t stuck his oar in.

It’s a bit shit all round. Not a big deal, obviously, but sometimes it’s good to talk to other people when something frustrating has happened.

OP posts:
Tryingtokeepgoing · 06/08/2022 22:56

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 22:11

”My dh enjoys a dessert when we go out , most come with cream or ice cream , he does not like them so asks for without . He still pays whatever the advertised cost is.”

As would I, without a moment’s thought. Does a bit of cream or ice cream really compare with a shot of alcohol though?

Well, a bottle of vodka is around £20 and is 750ml, and a shot is 25ml (unless your in Scotland in which case it’s 35ml), so 30 to a bottle. Or £0.60odd a shot to them. Which isn’t really very much, so I’m not sure I’d be bothered making a fuss as it probably is quite similar to the cost to them of a scoop of ice cream or a serving of cream.

Hopefullysoon2022 · 06/08/2022 22:37

Spoilerd · 06/08/2022 22:11

”My dh enjoys a dessert when we go out , most come with cream or ice cream , he does not like them so asks for without . He still pays whatever the advertised cost is.”

As would I, without a moment’s thought. Does a bit of cream or ice cream really compare with a shot of alcohol though?

Yes but you picked a dessert with alcohol so obviously that's going to be more expensive.
It's not the same as asking for no cream.

If you didn't want to pay £12 pick a cheaper dessert or go without.