Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ATM withdrawal wasn’t me!

180 replies

SingSweetNightingale · 06/08/2022 18:38

Hi all,

I’m looking for some advice as I can’t find much online that matches my current situation.

Whilst at work last Sunday I noticed two cash withdrawals at cash points had been made on my card. I immediately panicked as they totalled £300.
I contacted the bank and cancelled the card and they opened a dispute with the fraud team.

This is where my problem starts. The bank are refusing to refund me as they say it can’t be fraudulent. They said the transactions were made with my chip and pin card which can’t be cloned and whoever took the money used a cashpoint so must have known my pin.
I realised the last time I’d used the card was in Aldi the day before using chip and pin but these withdrawals weren’t made until the following day.
The location of the cashpoint is 30 minutes from my home however at the time I was an hour away from the location at work which I can prove.
Nobody uses my card or knows my pin but they’re adamant that it is not fraud and will not refund.

Has anyone been through something similar? Is it really impossible for cloning to happen on a chip and pin card? It seems like a complete mystery yet I’m being made out to be a criminal and I’m currently £300 down.

TIA

OP posts:
alnawire · 07/08/2022 12:16

luckylavender · 07/08/2022 11:54

Everyone is being horrible to the OP who is £300 out of pocket. Chill people, not everyone is so au fait with banking & cards. Be kind.

Be kind?

People are asking Op to clarify. People are asking why she is asking about cloning when that's not what has happened. That's not unkind.

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 12:13

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/08/2022 11:42

If I'm understanding correctly that couldn't happen because the op doesnt have money in the linked account

But like the whole scenario whoan be sure of the facts

No money on the card, has never used it, but carries it around with her all the time…

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 12:08

SingSweetNightingale · 07/08/2022 11:01

Nobody has replaced my card in my purse. The linked card was already in there but I don’t use it so mistook it for the main card. They’re the same colour, same bank account details, same name on the them.

You knew before your first post that it was stolen bit cloned, yet posted about cloning.

Why?

You claim that you have reported it to the ombudsman, but this is not how the ombudsman works, as they would have made clear if you really had contacted them.

i think you are rehearsing your story and that you know full-well how the money was withdrawn.

CecilyP · 07/08/2022 12:04

luckylavender · 07/08/2022 11:54

Everyone is being horrible to the OP who is £300 out of pocket. Chill people, not everyone is so au fait with banking & cards. Be kind.

Yes I feel mean being harsh and I do feel sorry her money has been taken. But it’s no use to the OP if she knows fine her card hasn’t been cloned but keeps going on about it. OP knows she does not have her main card, she knew before she posted, so she knows someone else has her card. They did not need clone it!

In addition, if she had been more up front with the bank, she may have had a refund already.

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 12:01

SingSweetNightingale · 06/08/2022 20:59

Sorry for the confusion everyone.

I initially reported it to the bank immediately as the notifications came through that a withdrawal had been made (I get notifications when there is any use on the card such as me purchasing something or a bill going out). Because I was so panicked they asked me if I still had the card and I said yes as I looked in my purse and saw my “card”. It wasn’t until later that I realised I only have my linked card and not my main card. This is why I initially thought it had been cloned.
I informed them straight away that I infact do not have my main card and only the linked one but their answer is the same.

Well yes, from their point of view you lied to them about the card still being in your possession, despite them knowing that it was that card which had been used to make the withdrawal.

You need to now write to them setting out the actual facts, making it a proper complaint, and give them time to investigate and respond.

Someone has your card and your pin, this is not the bank’s fault. You did not report it stolen. This is not the bank’s fault.

Despite this they will likely repay you the lost money if you get your story straight and make an accurate complaint.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/08/2022 11:59

luckylavender · 07/08/2022 11:54

Everyone is being horrible to the OP who is £300 out of pocket. Chill people, not everyone is so au fait with banking & cards. Be kind.

As has been pointed out by quite a few posters it's not about being au fait with banking it's the flakiness of the story and the inconsistencies

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 11:55

SingSweetNightingale · 06/08/2022 20:18

I have raised it with the ombudsman so I will wait to see what they say but I’m aware it’s a lengthier process than just the bank refunding me.

I don’t know anything about how cards can or can’t be cloned unfortunately so I’m really in the dark on the possibilities of how this could happen

The ombudsman will not consider a complaint to them unless you have exhausted the bank’s complaints procedure first.

Where is the relevant card?

luckylavender · 07/08/2022 11:54

Everyone is being horrible to the OP who is £300 out of pocket. Chill people, not everyone is so au fait with banking & cards. Be kind.

LibertyQ · 07/08/2022 11:54

It sounds like you lost/had stolen the main card in Aldi. I assume someone behind you in the queue saw you put your pin in.
you should probably raise a complaint with starling to get this re looked at. Try to explain clearly that you actually lost/had stolen your debit card and mistook another card for it (as looks the same)

StillHappy · 07/08/2022 11:52

MRex · 06/08/2022 18:42

I'm not sure why they are so sure the card wasn't cloned. Be clear with them that you have never shared the card nor pin, then go ahead and report to the police. Ask them to get photos of the person using the machine, that would show it isn't you.

You can’t clone the chip.

OP, are you saying that you still have your card, and have always had it?

purplecorkheart · 07/08/2022 11:50

Do you use the same pin as a code for other things like your phone, house alarm etc?

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/08/2022 11:47

Howdoidothisanymore · 07/08/2022 11:18

Absolutely this will be it- happens a lot. I only pay with contactless via my phone in supermarkets and am then very careful with the phone.
because of the packing in Aldi diene away from the till, it is very easy for people to hang around unnoticed, shoulder suturing. They watch you put your pin in, then expertly nick your card. All too common I’m afraid.

I've shopped in lots of different Aldis and at none of them would you not notice someone close to you at the packing shelf especially after covid where people are more aware of personal space.

Are you saying the criminals hang around in till queues pretending to be buying things? It doesn't make any sense, the way the tills work now one could be in a position to see your pin anyway

My money is on a much more mundane happening

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 11:45

Mennex · 07/08/2022 11:40

That's a bit harsh. You don't know 'which part of society' the OP is from. She's partnering a 2 year old alone, which is enough to make anyone feel frazzled, whatever demographic.

You do sound very confused OP and have been communicating entirely on the app. I'd take a breather, write everything down in order and then try and speak to someone at Starling on the phone - there will be a way.

I know that she posted a fee or he ago re how her dp lied to her multiple times about money and is in extremely serious debt

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 07/08/2022 11:45

Yes the someone who has stolen it also knows the pin so that someone can only be whoever was near you at Aldi or, as others t have said, your partner!!

Arewerelated · 07/08/2022 11:43

OP. Someone has stolen your main card out of your purse, someone who knows your pin. Be honest with yourself now, who was at your place/you at their place? Is your pin set to a memorable number like your dcs birthday?

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 07/08/2022 11:42

Is it really impossible for cloning to happen on a chip and pin card? It seems like a complete mystery yet I’m being made out to be a criminal and I’m currently £300 down.

But you know SOMEONE HAS YOUR CARD. Why are you talking about cloning, when someone clearly has stolen your card? Confused

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 07/08/2022 11:42

Jagoda · 07/08/2022 11:10

Are you certain you didn't use the shopping card in Aldi? I mean have you actually checked rather than just assuming.

Good point Miss Marple!

If I'm understanding correctly that couldn't happen because the op doesnt have money in the linked account

But like the whole scenario whoan be sure of the facts

Mennex · 07/08/2022 11:40

That's a bit harsh. You don't know 'which part of society' the OP is from. She's partnering a 2 year old alone, which is enough to make anyone feel frazzled, whatever demographic.

You do sound very confused OP and have been communicating entirely on the app. I'd take a breather, write everything down in order and then try and speak to someone at Starling on the phone - there will be a way.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 11:35

Op

you simply can not seem to present a clear depiction of what happened.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 11:34

a frightening insight in to how some parts of society seem to be financially illiterate

Mennex · 07/08/2022 11:28

Did you withdraw money on the Saturday to pay for shopping?. I sometimes withdraw money and it doesn't show on my bank statement to some random time the day after.

Hav you definitely established, for certain, that the 2 withdrawals were made a) on the main card, which you no longer have and havent seen since Saturday at Aldi when you used it to pay for shopping? And b) they were both made from a cashpoint machine that you did not go to either on Saturday or Sunday?

Do you ever go to that cashpoint?

If you don't have the card then it's been stolen and used by someone else. This has happened to me before and you immediately phone up and report this and cancel it. They ask you when you last had it then read out a list of any transactions that have occurred since that time and ask you if you recognise them. If you don't, they do whatever they do in the background, cancel the card and refund those transaction. I don't understand what that hasn't happened here. I also don't understand why you didn't check very carefully which cards you had in your purse before reporting as obviously, the situation is very different if you still have the card, which you didn't, but said you did by mistake.

goingtotown · 07/08/2022 11:27

Going around in circles here. I can understand why the bank will not refund you £300.

Glitteratitar · 07/08/2022 11:20

In a previous thread you mentioned your partner betrayed you re finances. What happened there?

Howdoidothisanymore · 07/08/2022 11:18

Ontomatopea · 06/08/2022 20:42

Someone might have pinched it off you at aldi after shoulder surfing you putting your pin in. Can you remember what time you were there? I don't know if they can check the footage for you?

Absolutely this will be it- happens a lot. I only pay with contactless via my phone in supermarkets and am then very careful with the phone.
because of the packing in Aldi diene away from the till, it is very easy for people to hang around unnoticed, shoulder suturing. They watch you put your pin in, then expertly nick your card. All too common I’m afraid.

JenniferAllisonPhillipaSue · 07/08/2022 11:17

So between using your main card in Aldi on the Saturday, and the cash withdrawals on Sunday, who could have had access to that card - is your DP still around? if not, might he still have a key to your house? do you have children (and how old)? did any friends come over on Saturday night? did you go out of your house without the purse/cards on Saturday night (possibly burglary)? did you go out of your house with the purse/cards but not use them (possible accidental loss)?

Swipe left for the next trending thread