Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ATM withdrawal wasn’t me!

180 replies

SingSweetNightingale · 06/08/2022 18:38

Hi all,

I’m looking for some advice as I can’t find much online that matches my current situation.

Whilst at work last Sunday I noticed two cash withdrawals at cash points had been made on my card. I immediately panicked as they totalled £300.
I contacted the bank and cancelled the card and they opened a dispute with the fraud team.

This is where my problem starts. The bank are refusing to refund me as they say it can’t be fraudulent. They said the transactions were made with my chip and pin card which can’t be cloned and whoever took the money used a cashpoint so must have known my pin.
I realised the last time I’d used the card was in Aldi the day before using chip and pin but these withdrawals weren’t made until the following day.
The location of the cashpoint is 30 minutes from my home however at the time I was an hour away from the location at work which I can prove.
Nobody uses my card or knows my pin but they’re adamant that it is not fraud and will not refund.

Has anyone been through something similar? Is it really impossible for cloning to happen on a chip and pin card? It seems like a complete mystery yet I’m being made out to be a criminal and I’m currently £300 down.

TIA

OP posts:
bluebell34567 · 07/08/2022 13:25

CrystalCoco · 07/08/2022 12:26

I'm pretty sure either you or the checkout operator at Aldi would have noticed someone standing close enough to you to see you insert your PIN - with social distancing not so far behind us I find it really really unlikely that this is where the PIN was observed.

Based on the PPs quoting previous posts of yours ref your partner and his debts I'm firmly in the camp that you need to look much closer to home for your answer:

Is there any way your partner (or ex if he is now an ex) could know your PIN? (or make a good guess at it if it's a memorable date you've used)

Could your partner (ex) still have access to your house?

If the answers to these questions are YES (even if you didn't see him physically take the card) then you can be as sure as can be that your partner has stolen the card and used it to steal money from you.

probably.

Fadeout83 · 07/08/2022 13:18

alnawire · 07/08/2022 13:13

OP wanted people to validate the cloning thing. Clutching at straws to try and get back the money that has been stolen by someone she knows.

Gotcha. My assumption was far more nefarious towards the OP! 🤣

alnawire · 07/08/2022 13:13

Fadeout83 · 07/08/2022 13:11

This is all very odd. Why did you fail to mention in your original post that in fact your card is lost? Why even mention cloning since it is irrelevant?

hmmmmmm

OP wanted people to validate the cloning thing. Clutching at straws to try and get back the money that has been stolen by someone she knows.

LucieLemon · 07/08/2022 13:12

Verifying with the bank your whereabouts when the money was withdrawn (ie it wasn't you who withdrew the money out in person) isn't going to be enough to demonstrate you weren't involved.

As PPs have said this isn't fraud or obtaining money by deception, it's straight up theft and needs to be handled as such.

Fadeout83 · 07/08/2022 13:11

This is all very odd. Why did you fail to mention in your original post that in fact your card is lost? Why even mention cloning since it is irrelevant?

hmmmmmm

bluebell34567 · 07/08/2022 13:10

SingSweetNightingale · 07/08/2022 11:01

Nobody has replaced my card in my purse. The linked card was already in there but I don’t use it so mistook it for the main card. They’re the same colour, same bank account details, same name on the them.

dont know if said before but it doesnt look like a good idea to keep them together in your purse.

LucieLemon · 07/08/2022 13:05

As you've established the card has been stolen can you now get a crime ref number from the police?

rarelyontime · 07/08/2022 13:04

OP, have you checked your Starling PIN when out and about?

What some other posters may not realise is that Starling is a challenger bank (you can only use a mobile app to manage the account) and it has all sorts of features like being able to check your PIN in the app by popping in your app password or using your phone security (e.g. fingerprint scan, Face ID). If you've looked at your PIN on your phone, someone could have seen it over your shoulder, for example, if you were sitting on the bus and someone was in one of the higher seats behind you.

If someone had spotted your PIN, they might have targeted you to swipe the card out of your purse. If you normally put all of your cards in the same purse and don't, for example, sometimes put a card in a bag pocket, it seems unlikely that a stranger would have taken your card - mainly because it's harder to steal one card than it is the entire purse/bag.

Starling lets you have a 'connected card' which is effectively a pre-paid joint card you give to someone to buy stuff for you, if you don't trust them enough for a 'real' joint account or, say, they're a volunteer doing your shopping. The connected card looks the same as the normal debit card, but the debit card holder has to move funds across each time (so the person with the connected card doesn't have unlimited access to the main account funds). It's a bit of a confusing concept if you're only used to traditional banks!

The face of each card is identical.

It sounds like the OP has a normal debit card and a connected card (possibly because she gives this to her partner to do the shopping sometimes, given the justified trust issues). When someone started spending on her debit card, she got the automatic notifications on her phone, she wasn't expecting anyone to be buying stuff for her, and she panicked. When she looked in her purse, she saw a Starling card and assumed it was her debit card, but it was actually the connected card. Easy mistake to make - she would have had to take it out and turn it over to see it was the wrong card.

I completely understand the muddle, and also why the OP is so hard to follow.

It's not impossible that a stranger was able to steal the PIN and the main debit card, but given only one card was taken, I'm afraid it's much more likely that it's someone who knows you, OP.

Elsiid · 07/08/2022 13:04

Your partner has stolen your money. It's not the bank's fault. Call the police on him.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 13:02

The op won’t be back

i just hope she stops pursuing this. She will be found to be attempting to defraud her bank otherwise.

I suspect she has triggered their fraud checks in any event already

alphons · 07/08/2022 13:02

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:19

I’d put money on this happening

the OP’s DP (who she previously has posted has lied to her many many times about money and is in horrific debt) nicked the money.

The Op knows it is him.

she is desperate for the money back but knows no chance from him.

so she has orchestrated this lie in the hope she will be refunded.

you won’t be OP. But you may well be arrested for attempting to defraud your bank.

Oh God. I’m so naive 🤦‍♀️

Lurkerlot · 07/08/2022 13:01

I have been through something similar with HSBC. Cash point withdrawals were being made from an online savings account, which had never had a card issued on it, so it was relatively easy for them to recognise it as a fraud. But at the same time proved their security systems can easily be bypassed.

alphons · 07/08/2022 12:58

You say that you know nothing about cards etc as though that’s an excuse or an explanation.

It’s neither.

This is YOUR card. YOUR money. YOUR banking relationship.

It’s YOUR responsibility to know about these things. Nobody owes it to you to forgive your ignorance.

In addition, your story on this one thread on this single day is so muddled, so confused, it’s become entirely lacking in credibility. Linked card, main card, Aldi, work, topping up for shopping, too much of a pain….. none of this is of any relevance. Frankly, even now, it’s impossible to know which card you think you’re missing, or even whether you think a card is missing!

Starling are not at fault here. Doesn’t mean you are either. But right now, you need to get your story sorted out. The facts will lead you to the culprit. Hint: it’s not fraud or chip cloning 🙄

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 07/08/2022 12:42

Someone took your card and used it while you were elsewhere.

They knew your pin

  • so it is most likely that the taker is someone who is close to you and has (in the past) had opportunity to see you use it/can work out the number/knows where to find it recorded.

Do you have someone in your life who is short of money and either desparate enough or dishonest enough or entitled enough to take money from you?

If you know who took the money - do you want to take this further?

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 07/08/2022 12:41

They’d have to reword because that makes bugger all sense

😆
I know the one she means.
We can never be sure the OP is who they say. So anyone offering the OP money make sure it is never more than you can afford to lose.
Summut like that 😉

BordoisAgain · 07/08/2022 12:41

Friday I receive my final message from starling saying they will not refund as the withdrawals are not fraudulent.

Well, yes. As the card has been lost/stolen no fraud had occurred.

I have passed it to the ombudsman as their job is to review decisions and this is the only way I can now receive my refund.

And they will likely agree with your bank that no fraud had occurred as your card is lost/stolen.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/08/2022 12:40

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 07/08/2022 12:38

Absolutely this.
I guess OP is just looking for ways to get the bank to refund her, which of course they won't because she should've reported the card as lost/stolen asap.

@Yesthatismychildsigh you need to report the thread to mnhq to get them to post that message.

Thanks, Richard. Not been back on here long, after leaving after a security lapse.

RichardOsmansXraySpecs · 07/08/2022 12:38

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:19

I’d put money on this happening

the OP’s DP (who she previously has posted has lied to her many many times about money and is in horrific debt) nicked the money.

The Op knows it is him.

she is desperate for the money back but knows no chance from him.

so she has orchestrated this lie in the hope she will be refunded.

you won’t be OP. But you may well be arrested for attempting to defraud your bank.

Absolutely this.
I guess OP is just looking for ways to get the bank to refund her, which of course they won't because she should've reported the card as lost/stolen asap.

@Yesthatismychildsigh you need to report the thread to mnhq to get them to post that message.

CrystalCoco · 07/08/2022 12:26

I'm pretty sure either you or the checkout operator at Aldi would have noticed someone standing close enough to you to see you insert your PIN - with social distancing not so far behind us I find it really really unlikely that this is where the PIN was observed.

Based on the PPs quoting previous posts of yours ref your partner and his debts I'm firmly in the camp that you need to look much closer to home for your answer:

Is there any way your partner (or ex if he is now an ex) could know your PIN? (or make a good guess at it if it's a memorable date you've used)

Could your partner (ex) still have access to your house?

If the answers to these questions are YES (even if you didn't see him physically take the card) then you can be as sure as can be that your partner has stolen the card and used it to steal money from you.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/08/2022 12:25

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:23

They’d have to reword because that makes bugger all sense

Yes, I know, I hold my hand up, but they’ll know which message I mean. I just couldn’t remember the wording properly. Something about people not always being who they seem.

PseudonymPolly · 07/08/2022 12:24

I have passed it to the ombudsman as their job is to review decisions and this is the only way I can now receive my refund

Who gave you the final decision? It sounds like a response from fraud, not a complaint outcome.

You can't simply 'pass it to the ombudsman'. It doesn't work like that.

The ombudsman are there to independently investigate complaint outcomes - you need to raise a complaint with the bank first and receive your final response letter with right of escalation to FOS. The bank have 8 weeks in which to investigate and respond. Once you receive your FOS rights only then can you escalate to the ombudsman.

If you've contacted the FOS before making a complaint to your bank, the FOS will simply forward it to your bank and ask them to investigate. 8 weeks still apply. THEN if you're unhappy the FOS can be contacted after you've had your complaint outcome.

If you've not yet complained to your bank and had an official response letter with FOS escalation rights, do this today. Otherwise you're just adding a few weeks onto the timescale whilst the FOS raise the complaint with your bank on your behalf.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:23

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/08/2022 12:21

@mnhq please could you post the warning you put on threads about only giving what you can afford to lose.

They’d have to reword because that makes bugger all sense

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:21

The Rizen was a diabolical British horror film

nice one op

Yesthatismychildsigh · 07/08/2022 12:21

@mnhq please could you post the warning you put on threads about only giving what you can afford to lose.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 12:19

I’d put money on this happening

the OP’s DP (who she previously has posted has lied to her many many times about money and is in horrific debt) nicked the money.

The Op knows it is him.

she is desperate for the money back but knows no chance from him.

so she has orchestrated this lie in the hope she will be refunded.

you won’t be OP. But you may well be arrested for attempting to defraud your bank.

Swipe left for the next trending thread