Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be offended by a comment my friend made?

689 replies

creamysauce · 06/08/2022 17:31

Hello :)

So I am getting a gorgeous French Bulldog puppy in a couple of weeks. I was discussing this with a very good friend of mine, about how I'm excited.. yadayada. So I then asked her "Would you ever get a dog or want to own a pet?". She immediately began to burst out laughing and said "No! I want to enjoy my life". A bit Confused I asked "What do you mean by that?"- she then said "As I said it... I want to enjoy my life, owning a pet- particularly a dog, I wouldn't get the spontaneity back, I would be worried about leaving it in the house for too long, paying for this and that, having to take it for walks when I don't feel like it. Sometimes- out of the whim, I just want to book a holiday but with a pet, I will have to think about who is going to take care of it, dog sitters...I may get a cat as they are a bit more independent but still, a pet comes with a lot of responsibility".

I think subconsciously she is trying to sway my decision from getting a pet or do you think she's a tad jealous. I was a bit offended by her comment but she can be very out there/too honest for my liking. What do you all think?

OP posts:
Sciurus83 · 06/08/2022 18:36

Sounds like she makes some good points

Rebelmcstreettuff · 06/08/2022 18:36

Think very long and hard about getting a French bulldog.
Ours is 8 now and has cost us a fortune on vets bills,wouldn't be without him but wouldn't buy another one.
We got him before they were that popular, did our research but still ended up with one with health problems.
We are lucky as in-laws have him if we want to go out or on holiday.

PersonaNonGarter · 06/08/2022 18:36

You describe her as ‘draining’ and ‘jealous’ but OP she sounds like exactly the friend you need.

Stop imagining she is a bad person and listen to the content of what she is saying. You might come to a different conclusion - but it sounds as though she has valuable things to say.

WeAreBob · 06/08/2022 18:35

She didn't say anything offensive. Nothing at all.

TimeTravelExpert · 06/08/2022 18:35

What checks did you do to ensure it was a reputable breeder?

Genuine question.

Thehop · 06/08/2022 18:33

creamysauce · 06/08/2022 18:04

I am a bit offended as I feel like she always has a say on things I want to do in my life. When I told her that I was considering getting a dog. She was like "....personally I wouldn't, you have two teenagers with one who has significant needs, and the other you are homeschooling, it would just be an extra strain for you. Your boys may be excited about the dog but the novelty would wear off and they would want to be doing their own thing. But it's your life".

Then another situation where I told her that myself and my partner were saving up to buy a house, she said "creamy?! Are you crazy! Why would you want to buy a house with a man who doesn't bother paying for the bills and racks up so much debt. It wouldn't get better when you own a house, in fact, the stress would be entirely on you as you would be the one fretting about mortgage payments".

Sometimes I don't tell her things as she always rains on my parade.

Yes, this would be my first time dog and and about the French bulldog. I have researched loads about the animal and have went to a respectable breeder. I am very conscious about the health needs of these dogs but I feel the money would be worth plus, myself and my partner, are in a comfortable financial position to pay the upcoming costs, concerning, health needs that the dog may eventually have.

It’s not about affording it’s care it’s about getting a dog that will have a pain filled unhealthy existence until it finally does and can rest.

getting these dogs is incredibly cruel and most dog owners will judge you.

dustandroses · 06/08/2022 18:32

Shes not jealous she's right. You're offended because you dont like being given some home truths. She probably finds you just as draining.

TheNinny · 06/08/2022 18:31

None of this sounds like jealousy. I wouldn’t want a dog for exactly the reasons she gave. And re. The house and your partner,
no way would I buy with someone who you described like that. She sounds like a good friend, trying to avert oncoming bad decisions.

butterflied · 06/08/2022 18:30

She's right based on what I'm seeing from my friends with dogs. It's a huge commitment. Why on earth would she be jealous? You asked a question, she answered honestly.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/08/2022 18:29

It sounds like you have your head in the clouds and she is speaking the truth trying to bring you back down to Earth. I understand it’s not always nice to have your illusion shattered, but better she highlights the reality of a situation now so that you can consider her points than realise after you’ve committed to something that the reality of it wasn’t like you’d imagined it. I would say you are lucky to have a friend who is able to be honest with you.

Gazelda · 06/08/2022 18:28

She seems to have her head screwed on.

And seems to care enough to offer an opinion when she sees you making a decision she doesn't think is right for you.
But you don't seem to have a very high opinion of her for whatever reason, so why don't you cool the friendship?

Xmasbaby11 · 06/08/2022 18:28

It's not offensive and it's what I think.

However, i have many friends who have dogs and I wouldn't be so blunt, I'd just say a dog wouldn't suit my lifestyle.

Plantstrees · 06/08/2022 18:28

YABVU Your friend is just giving sensible advice.

ISaidHeyWhatsGoingOn · 06/08/2022 18:28

You did ask.

Her answer is a sensible one covering many points to consider before getting a pet. Also, some people genuinely don't get the same enjoyment of having a pet as we do and can't understand the amount of sacrifices we choose to make for them. That's their right to feel that way and they shouldn't have to hide it, especially when asked questions on the subject.

ChristmasSirens · 06/08/2022 18:28

I think she is probably much more realistic than you about the reality of getting a puppy.

Furrydogmum · 06/08/2022 18:27

My dogs are a bigger commitment than my children in terms of planning holidays, days out etc. I didn't get them until the children were older - 8 & 12 ish - but they were, in their own way, more life changing than the children! Also the breed you have chosen is potentially very labour intensive in terms of health issues..

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 18:27

creamysauce · 06/08/2022 18:21

The issue with my partner, I agreed. So I have decided that we are going to rent a place together, with the kids, and see how he does paying for the rent. If all goes well, then we would plan again and buy a house.

I'm not sure if I'm being clear. But it's sort of like having a friend who gives an opinion in all aspects of your life. It's draining.

I do feel she's a bit jealous. She had always been the sensible one and is very risk adverse. I think because of that, it gets in the way of her decision making.

Gets in the way of her decision making?

You seem to be the one who has been making the bad decisions here, your poor friend must despair, giving you good advice that you ignore and that you then hold against her.

If it wasn’t for the site rules I’d be posting a speculative opinion about this thread at this point.

Please, don’t buy this dog, it is cruel to do so, and you seem incapable of managing your life as it is now let alone also looking after a distorted pet.

NumberTheory · 06/08/2022 18:26

I do feel she's a bit jealous. She had always been the sensible one and is very risk adverse. I think because of that, it gets in the way of her decision making.

None of the comments you’ve quoted her as saying make her sound at all jealous. But you sound like you want her to want to be more like you to validate your choices.

notforonesecond · 06/08/2022 18:26

Sounds like you have a smart friend who tells the truth and gives good, sound advice.

Perhaps you should listen to her.

GrandSlamFinalee · 06/08/2022 18:26

I'm not sure if I'm being clear. But it's sort of like having a friend who gives an opinion in all aspects of your life. It's draining.

But OP, what do you think a friend is, if not that? Someone who gives their opinion on what's going on in your life. Is that not what you look for in a friendship? I like the people I'm closest to to tell me exactly what they think. It helps me make decisions, it helps me to consider things more carefully and think with different perspectives.

Would you prefer a friend who just sits back, nods, and goes for dinner with you every now and then, instead? Because I wouldn't call that a friend.

A good friend cares about you. They will tell you their opinions, even if that makes them draining.

BlueKaftan · 06/08/2022 18:26

She’s not jealous. She just thinks you make questionable decisions and she’s right.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 06/08/2022 18:25

creamysauce · 06/08/2022 18:21

The issue with my partner, I agreed. So I have decided that we are going to rent a place together, with the kids, and see how he does paying for the rent. If all goes well, then we would plan again and buy a house.

I'm not sure if I'm being clear. But it's sort of like having a friend who gives an opinion in all aspects of your life. It's draining.

I do feel she's a bit jealous. She had always been the sensible one and is very risk adverse. I think because of that, it gets in the way of her decision making.

Why ask her opinion if you didn't want to hear it? 🙄

pjmasksitsthepjmasks · 06/08/2022 18:24

Sounds like she's quite switched on tbh. Everybody needs a friend like that who will be honest and talk some sense to them every now and then. 👍🏼

ZeroFuchsGiven · 06/08/2022 18:24

creamysauce · 06/08/2022 18:21

The issue with my partner, I agreed. So I have decided that we are going to rent a place together, with the kids, and see how he does paying for the rent. If all goes well, then we would plan again and buy a house.

I'm not sure if I'm being clear. But it's sort of like having a friend who gives an opinion in all aspects of your life. It's draining.

I do feel she's a bit jealous. She had always been the sensible one and is very risk adverse. I think because of that, it gets in the way of her decision making.

Ok so you are obviously on the wind up. Good job, you got me.

DarkDarkNight · 06/08/2022 18:24

She’s just being honest. It’s true, you don’t have the same spontaneity with a dog. You can’t be out of the house for a whole day, have a last minute weekend away or book a holiday without planning a dog sitter or kennel. In my family a couple of people have dogs and think it’s ok to dump them on relatives they know don’t really want to dog sit instead of make proper arrangements. Not everybody loves you dog like you do.

I know dogs bring a lot of joy and are part of the family, but having had them before I wouldn’t get another.