Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I'm a creepy man magnet

117 replies

Shadowmallow · 06/08/2022 13:44

It doesn't matter where I go, whenever I'm alone, I seem to get weird men (often middle aged) coming over to talk to me/cornering me and it makes me feel uncomfortable. I hate it and dread being approached. I'm 35, very plain looking, size 10. Day to day I wear jeans and t shirts/midi skirts and t shirts, very casual. Nothing remotely attention grabbing about me.

I'm currently at a large park, enjoying the sun, reading a book. There are plenty of empty benches everywhere, but of course some creepy guy comes and sits right next to me on a bench and starts asking me what I'm up to, how's my book, with a creepy smirk on his face. A couple of weeks ago I was sitting outside a coffee shop reading and a man decided to come and sit and my table without asking, started talking AT me, and said he liked my trainers - he wasn't even a customer of the coffee place. I had to tell him sorry but I've come here to read my book so not really up for chatting today. This has been happening all my life - is it just me or do all women get this?

Also I can't work out their intentions - do they just want to chat, or actually make women feel intimidated?

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 07/08/2022 13:01

Don’t apologise ask them to leave you alone

I found it hard to be direct as it’s not in my nature, many women have been conditioned to not cause a fuss try not to offend but we shouldn’t be worried about offending them. I soon got used to it being more direct and not caring how I may come across

Many men (and it is many) feel women are there for their own entertainment.

some women/girls are or appear to be more vulnerable than others this is something predatory men often pick up on unfortunately (obviously all girls are vulnerable)

TammyOne · 07/08/2022 12:54

My mum used to attract these weirdos when we were small and for her it was usually much older men, knowing that she was unlikely to throw up a fuss in front of 2 small kids and instead indulge whatever they wanted to talk about while they letched over her.

Oh gosh that just unlocked lots of memories for me! Yeah, when my mum was young I remember her getting chatted up/bothered all the time when she had us kids with her. Followed too actually. I do remover feeling anxious about it, being very small.
OP, you are young and slim and therefore they see you as unthreatening. It used to happen to me a bit but not as much as my friend who was smaller, slimmer and more natural looking than than me. I was always a big hair, big attitude type and probably looked like I might be more trouble than I was worth. Thats not at all victim blaming -these sad losers go for the ones they think won’t make a fuss.
It does get better as you get older. For now just cultivate a steely stare and a curled lip and don’t engage.

milkyaqua · 07/08/2022 12:52

As a single dad and a male, you are talking rubbish.

Oh, you're so naive! Do you also, as a single dad and a male, get followed around the streets, or have random women lurch up to you and tell you to smile when you are minding your own business, preoccupied, or grieving; do you have lecherous men 'just being friendly' to you then touching you up, do you get called a bitch if you don't cooperate with these friendly strangers, do these friendly strangers rape and bash you, no...

hangrylady · 07/08/2022 12:27

Solokidydad · 06/08/2022 14:39

As a single dad and a male, you are talking rubbish. Funnily enough I get both men and women sit next to me when I take kids to the park and start asking questions. If I want leaving alone I politely ask and for reference no I would not sit down invited with any one reading a book. Classic male attitude may be I'm just not a classic male single father then 🥱

As a male, you don't know what the fuck you're talking about mate. As a male you will never experience being intimidated, sexually harassed and feeling like you have to be polite to dickheads for your own safety. Jog on.

brighteyesburninglikefire · 07/08/2022 12:21

Wouldloveanother · 07/08/2022 09:55

Exactly, I would believe that it’s ‘loneliness, just wanting a chat’ if they also did it to big blokes and groups rather than exclusively lone females.

for me the worst is when they sit next to you, blocking you in, for long public transport journeys. I pretend I’m getting off at the next stop if it’s a train, then re-board into a different carriage. But you can’t do that with a bus/coach. I’ve had men talk at me (and like I said it’s rarely truly reciprocal) for hours in such circumstances. It’s mind numbing and spoils your peace.

Yes, public transport is awful. I never use it anymore

jeaux90 · 07/08/2022 10:29

98% of sexual crimes are committed by men (ONS statistics)

So not only creepy but dangerous.

OP just walk away. Or if you are in a cafe for example say "No, please move away" loudly.

Creepy men rely on our socialised niceness, so I've always taken the embarrass them route if it's safe to do so.

Wouldloveanother · 07/08/2022 09:57

And yes it’s horrible if you have a baby with you. I remember pushing Dd in the pram and some weird bloke following me through the town centre shouting abuse at me. Something to do with the council not housing him, but he seemed to think I was the person responsible for this. it was really frightening and made DD cry.

Wouldloveanother · 07/08/2022 09:55

Exactly, I would believe that it’s ‘loneliness, just wanting a chat’ if they also did it to big blokes and groups rather than exclusively lone females.

for me the worst is when they sit next to you, blocking you in, for long public transport journeys. I pretend I’m getting off at the next stop if it’s a train, then re-board into a different carriage. But you can’t do that with a bus/coach. I’ve had men talk at me (and like I said it’s rarely truly reciprocal) for hours in such circumstances. It’s mind numbing and spoils your peace.

ShinyMe · 07/08/2022 09:55

Solokidydad · 06/08/2022 14:39

As a single dad and a male, you are talking rubbish. Funnily enough I get both men and women sit next to me when I take kids to the park and start asking questions. If I want leaving alone I politely ask and for reference no I would not sit down invited with any one reading a book. Classic male attitude may be I'm just not a classic male single father then 🥱

And have you ever, after asking someone politely to leave you alone, been told that you're a fucking bitch, or that you're fat and ugly anyway, or that if they wanted to, they could rape you there and then? I bet the answer is no. Most women are cautious at the very least about politely asking men to leave them alone, because we don't know for sure what the reaction will be.

RedToothBrush · 07/08/2022 09:48

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 07/08/2022 08:59

I attract these weirdos too. I think some of it comes down to whether you look like you'll stick up for yourself. At the point I attracted most of them I was very quiet, looked like I wouldn't tell them to fuck off and would take whatever letchy bullshit they were going to pull just so I was less likely to be attacked or sexually harassed. Now I'm pushing 40, have a don't piss me off face and overweight I don't get harassed as much, funny that.

My mum used to attract these weirdos when we were small and for her it was usually much older men, knowing that she was unlikely to throw up a fuss in front of 2 small kids and instead indulge whatever they wanted to talk about while they letched over her.

Oh absolutely.

I'm 5'2" and v petite. I get it a lot even in my 40s.

You can be minding your own business doing anything and someone butts in.

Its often intrusive and not just making conversation.

Its extremely difficult to get out of. Being rude often isn't an option because you don't know how someone will react to that. Its more a question of 'how can I make my excuses and exit the situation'. This means that you end up self limiting your own behaviour and freedom if you are able to exit because someone else is unable to read body language which says 'this is not an appropriate situation to approach me'. If you are not able to exit its extremely difficult...

DH didn't realise how much differently I'm treated in life compared to him. When I started to point it out, he started to notice little things. From both men and women. We are assessed based on physical appearance in various ways.

I get poorer service for just about everything compared to him. Not because I do anything wrong or differently. But because he's a big dude and people don't want to deal with him complaining - cos thats the expectation; he will complain. I am perceive as a doormat who won't complain, therefore I'm fair game.

It affects everything.

Creepy weirdos don't do the same to everyone. There is a reason for this.

RedToothBrush · 07/08/2022 09:35

DontBlameMe79 · 06/08/2022 15:28

I mean this is another “aren’t men crap” thread. Not complicated.

There are thousands on here and most of them follow the same theme - Describe alleged poor behaviour then get the chorus going.

Yaaaaawn.

Ok. Lets go with what you are saying. Its another thread about men being crap.

Have you ever stopped to think WHY thats the case?
Or exam why women feel fearful and intimidated by certain behaviour from men?
And if you haven't, have you considered how men might unwittingly engage in such behaviour not realising they are behaving in a manner that concerns women?

You cannot get away from the sheer prevailence of abuse and violence towards women from men as part of this.

Whether women are reasonable or not in their response, deliberately misses the point. It's based on experiences and genuine statistical risk.

Minimising or dismissing what women say without analysing what and why they are saying it, isn't ok.

Hopeandlove · 07/08/2022 09:25

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 07/08/2022 09:20

Thats a bit victim blamey

I mean you are right when you say you don't owe anybody a dialogue

But the 'I feel like you attract what energy you project' is verging on blaming the OP for a mans actions. How do you 'stand taller' when sitting on a bench reading a book?

And no telling someone to fuck off is not ott and ridiculous. They are just words.

Exactly men need to stop doing it

regarding my ear post I just shake my head if anyone gestures to me in that situation or I mouth ‘I’m busy’ I never take it out.

anon666 · 07/08/2022 09:25

I get it.

Men won't experience creepy guys coming up to them randomly like this, so they have no means of understanding that it exists.

So that guy commenting on here is right from his perspective, just a bit sad that he feels entitled to comment as if his personal experience is universal.

OP came on here to see if she was alone in experiencing it, or whether other women got it too. Not to slag off men in general. I'd say we all get it, especially as a young woman. It sadly feels as though any young woman is seen as fair game by a certain subset of men.

That doesn't mean I don't like talking to random people in public, I do. I love it when some random person starts chatting to me, male or female. However, women do develop a radar for people, usually men, behaving oddly, and experience has sadly taught me not to ignore those signals.

I've been flashed at more times than I care to remember, and my daughters have had the most unspeakable things said to them. I can understand women who just prefer not to take any risks with itby not engaging.

I'm very confident but no-one is bulletproof. I have found the kindness of strangers including men to be incredible when I'm in trouble. But there is still a minority of weirdos.

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 07/08/2022 09:20

Marvellousmadness · 07/08/2022 00:24

I feel like you attract what energy you project. So it might be time to learn to stand taller and more self assured and send out big dick energy :)

And you dont have to tell the guys to FUCK OFF like some pp said cuz that is just ott and rediculous. But telling someone your are not interested in listening and ENDING the conversation right then and there is fine. You dont owe anybody a dialogue.

Stick up for yourself. These men will dissapear

Thats a bit victim blamey

I mean you are right when you say you don't owe anybody a dialogue

But the 'I feel like you attract what energy you project' is verging on blaming the OP for a mans actions. How do you 'stand taller' when sitting on a bench reading a book?

And no telling someone to fuck off is not ott and ridiculous. They are just words.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 07/08/2022 08:59

I attract these weirdos too. I think some of it comes down to whether you look like you'll stick up for yourself. At the point I attracted most of them I was very quiet, looked like I wouldn't tell them to fuck off and would take whatever letchy bullshit they were going to pull just so I was less likely to be attacked or sexually harassed. Now I'm pushing 40, have a don't piss me off face and overweight I don't get harassed as much, funny that.

My mum used to attract these weirdos when we were small and for her it was usually much older men, knowing that she was unlikely to throw up a fuss in front of 2 small kids and instead indulge whatever they wanted to talk about while they letched over her.

FOJN · 07/08/2022 08:50

Look love, they were just trying to being nice, you should be flattered. Try to be kind, you wouldn't want to hurt their feelings by ignoring them. It's women like you that make men afraid to even talk to women in case they are accused of being creepy.

Besides, nothing says receptive to conversations with random men quite like being a woman in public, reading a book and minding her own business, let's face it you were asking for it.

You'll miss the attention when you're older and men no longer notice you as an attractively packaged set of holes with the potential to service their penis.

(Sarcasm alert for anyone who missed it)

ShandaLear · 07/08/2022 08:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I can see why you’re solo.

ShandaLear · 07/08/2022 08:31

Oh look, the menz have arrived to deny a woman’s lived experience. Quelle surprise 🙄

picklemewalnuts · 07/08/2022 08:27

It's not even about aggression, Girlmom. It's the underlying assumption that a woman sat alone should indulge the desire of a random to chat.

I don't want to. I don't want to take the time to politely send them on their way. I want to be left alone.

If I want to talk to someone, I'll look around and make eye contact, smile at someone. Look at them warmly as they approach.
If I'm looking in my bag, at my phone, at the table or the view, I'm not interested in chatting with you. It's basic body language.

Perhaps they have never needed to read basic body language, so aren't good at it.

Plumtreebob · 07/08/2022 08:27

@girlmom21 that is not my experience at all. Men can get aggressive in a flash and there is no way to tell which ones will and which ones won’t. People may call them out online but in public most people just walk on by for their own safety.

balalake · 07/08/2022 08:24

It's wrong, you should object every time. Whilst of little consolation and not in any way justifying the behaviour you describe, I bet once you are over 40 you will get less of this.

YouAreNotBatman · 07/08/2022 08:17

@girlmom21

Men are aggressive.
The end.
It diesn’t matter what women do or don’t do or how women behave or don’t behave.
Men are just aggressive.
Women are not responsible of men's behaviour.

Yeall · 07/08/2022 07:59

To address your concern about being a creep magnet. It's male entitlement. You are an approachable and attractive woman, so therefore they are entitled to your time and attention. They have wrong thinking. They are not entitled to anything from you. Ignore them and walk away, if you need to. It does mean you can't relax outdoors and that is very sad.
Regarding the misogynistic comments, this has been happening more frequently in recent months. There seems to be an organised misogynistic group targeting women on Mumsnet. They appear to derail the thread to gain attention.

girlmom21 · 07/08/2022 07:34

KatherineJaneway · 07/08/2022 00:37

I now have a 'don't you dare mess with me' veneer.

These men mess with you as they sense you won't tell them to F off.

You don't need to be aggressive to men just wanting to talk. You can tell them you're not interested if you make a pass.

If men are instantly aggressive they get ripped apart and called all sorts. If we're constantly aggressive to men they'll be aggressive too. Your act isn't helping anyone.

Plumtreebob · 07/08/2022 01:15

@KatherineJaneway I need to learn this for random men and chuggers.

This thread reminded me of the time a man stopped me whilst I was on the phone to ask if we could be friends and when I gave him a confused look and carried on with my call called me a fat cow and followed me until I walked into a Tesco and spoke to the security guard and he gave up. But yeah obviously he was a nice guy.