Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying a house with a “granny annex” and having DM move in

110 replies

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 13:25

Good idea?

YANBU - Yes
YABU - No

Experiences welcome :)

I’m thinking about selling up and buying a larger house with a detached granny annex. I own both my house and the house DM lives in, I lived there before moving to my current house.

DM is 60, independent and keeps herself to herself. Although she is struggling to keep up with the 3 bed house she is in as it has a large garden and she is not capable of keeping on top of it. She isn’t a rich lady and works a minimum wage job, no way could she afford a cleaner or Gardner.

It doesn’t seem a bad idea and I know she would be willing to but it’s a jump that’s not easily reversed.

OP posts:
925XX · 06/08/2022 15:36

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 06/08/2022 15:25

I would love to be able to do this OP. My mum lives with her husband and is 76 and lives a great life. Volunteering, going into town to meet their friends for drinks, always off for weekends away, so I doubt she would want to 😂

Point being that at 76, she's not a doddery old woman who has lost all her faculties as some people seem to think on here. Honestly, according to mumsnet, if you're over 70, you can't take care of yourself and smell of piss and digestives. Also, old people are interfering old busybodies with no boundaries when it comes to their kids privacy 🙄The ageism is ridiculous.

60 is not old and you could have many happy years together. She might even like to babysit if kids are in your future.

Here here! I am sick of people on here who talk about people over 60 as though they all have dementia. All of you will be over 60 one day ( if you are lucky).

925XX · 06/08/2022 15:33

DeedIDo · 06/08/2022 13:51

OP, you might want to either re-post on the Elderly Parents board or ask @MNHQ to move this post over there, where there is vast experience on this sort of thing.

Elderly parents! her mum is only 60!

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 06/08/2022 15:25

I would love to be able to do this OP. My mum lives with her husband and is 76 and lives a great life. Volunteering, going into town to meet their friends for drinks, always off for weekends away, so I doubt she would want to 😂

Point being that at 76, she's not a doddery old woman who has lost all her faculties as some people seem to think on here. Honestly, according to mumsnet, if you're over 70, you can't take care of yourself and smell of piss and digestives. Also, old people are interfering old busybodies with no boundaries when it comes to their kids privacy 🙄The ageism is ridiculous.

60 is not old and you could have many happy years together. She might even like to babysit if kids are in your future.

Elsiebear90 · 06/08/2022 15:13

I wouldn’t do it, I’m your age and my mum is the same age. I think it would impact on our privacy and independence too much, also you’re pretty much setting yourself up to be her carers if she needs them. She’s only 60, so you could have another 30-40 years of living with her, and if she’s happy with the arrangement yet at some point you or your partner isn’t then it’s more than likely going to cause a lot of upset to move her out.

JaninaDuszejko · 06/08/2022 15:12

If she's working FT, it's not that she 'can't cope' with the garden, it's that she doesn't have time for the garden. DH and I are 10 years younger than her, both work FT and have 3 school age children, we don't spend much time on our garden but it's because we're in the prime of life and are busy living. If it's your property and want the garden maintained then pay a gardener, but don't move your Mum unless she wants to. My MIL is 85 and currently on a pilgrimage round Europe, she'd be very offended if we thought she needed care, it could be decades before your Mum needs care.

1idea · 06/08/2022 15:09

There are gadgets you can get to monitor people from a distance, for example i they haven’t put the kettle on for a certain time or walked over a pressure mat you would get an alert, this may help reassure her without you haven’t to respond to daily texts/calls which may just remind her of her worries.

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 15:06

@SuperCamp

Suppose you do enter into a relationship and also have kids? You would probably want to move at some stage, for schools, somewhere bigger, yours or partners job…

It would be a long term house as the cost of purchasing is huge when you consider the stamp duty. I would never need a bigger house even with a man and children.

I get your point though things do change and if it did then I’d have to make sure DM was ok.

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 06/08/2022 15:02

How on earth would a gardener cost £3k a year?

2 hours a week @£20 an hour for 6 months of the year should be more than enough unless she lives at Sissinghurst.

RethinkingLife · 06/08/2022 15:01

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 14:33

@RethinkingLife

id be delighted for her if he’s a good man.

It's more a comment on the finances, particularly if the partner has children/grandchildren. My MiL had offers from partners who very plainly wanted free accommodation and household services with no responsibilities (I can see how that would be excluded by your definition of "a good man").

As it is, over time, you might want to consider the impact on your resources. It's not only your mother you might be supporting or for whom you'd be managing care but a partner with dementia (it's happened to my MiL x2) or similar chronic long-term conditions.

nokidshere · 06/08/2022 15:01

MIL moved into the house next door to us when she was in her 80s. Way too big for her but she loved it and, most importantly, it meant that we weren't having to do a 3hr round trip on a regular basis with two young children. Being able to pop in and out for 20 mins or half an hour over the day was a godsend.

It worked because she was a fairly private lady and we had got on well for 30yrs already by that point. However we still had very clear discussions on how it would work. Communication is they key. She had lived next door for 12yrs when she died at 96 and, although occasionally stressful, they were very happy years.

Ducksinthebath · 06/08/2022 15:00

How accessible is the small house, both in terms of facilities and actually getting to it? I raise this because it’s very common where I live to have grandma in a little bungalow at the end of the garden but come winter they all have to move into the main house rather than struggle along the garden path in the snow and ice/slippery leaves. And would she find it disruptive to move now then perhaps have to move again if the house can’t be customised for future accessibility needs?

SuperCamp · 06/08/2022 14:57

There is no way I would do this in your shoes!

Suppose you do enter into a relationship and also have kids? You would probably want to move at some stage, for schools, somewhere bigger, yours or partners job…

60 is no age.

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 14:56

@DatingIsDifficult

Do you need to sell her house in order to move to the one you really want?

It would help and be beneficial financially to only have one house. But it’s not going to make a big difference to my life.

What is the annual price of a gardener?

It would be about £3,000 a year.

What is your relationship like and how has it been in the past and how might it develop in the future?

Yeah it’s fine, I’ve never had any issues. She’s not perfect but she always did the best for us as a single mum and always put us first.

For me personally, I’d rather clean public toilets all weekend for minimum wage to pay for a gardener but that’s MY relationship with MY mother.

Is it just the large garden she is having trouble with?

Yep the house is clean and tidy, she’s stopped using rooms to keep it easier to manage.

Is moving her to a (for example) smaller bungalow with a much smaller garden a solution?

Maybe. Finding one isn’t easy and they have large plots.

Is she lonely?

She isn’t lonely.

I’d work really hard on answering these questions before I did anything. And can you get a gardener in temporarily while you mull it all over?

the gardener will probably have to happen as I don’t want to spend more of my days off helping out

OP posts:
chocaholic73 · 06/08/2022 14:55

What happens if you want to move in the future and she is nicely settled in her annex? If you are planning to move to the country won't that isolate her? Does she drive? Even if she doesn't see local friends, she may still want to pop to the shops or wherever. She may be happy to move to somewhere near you but surely it would be more sensible for her to be in a small village/town with services nearby.

IDrinkCoffee · 06/08/2022 14:51

If your relationship is good, then I would say 'go for it'! I always wanted to do that but sadly my mum died before I got a chance.

Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 06/08/2022 14:50

My mum and I contemplated throwing in our hands together when I divorced and we even looked at a few but in the end, at that point in her mid-70s and still working, she decided it wasn't what she wanted.

8 years later I was grateful. As her dementia advanced she became very difficult to manage and my only options were to care for her or out her in a home. I really don't think I could have cared for her - it was a truly awful time in my life and a dreadful decision to have e to make. I do feel if she had been under the same roof, it would have been even harder. I would urge you to consider the long term and the what-ifs before making a decision.

DatingIsDifficult · 06/08/2022 14:48

Re her fear of dying and not being found, get her to text or email every day. And if you don’t hear from her by 11am you’ll investigate. Would that make her feel better?

DatingIsDifficult · 06/08/2022 14:46

Do you need to sell her house in order to move to the one you really want?

What is the annual price of a gardener?

What is your relationship like and how has it been in the past and how might it develop in the future?

For me personally, I’d rather clean public toilets all weekend for minimum wage to pay for a gardener but that’s MY relationship with MY mother.

Is it just the large garden she is having trouble with?

Is moving her to a (for example) smaller bungalow with a much smaller garden a solution?

Is she lonely?

I’d work really hard on answering these questions before I did anything. And can you get a gardener in temporarily while you mull it all over?

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 14:44

Thanks again. I’m going to reread all comments.

she doesn’t socialise other than with very close family members and then only briefly as she finds it hard.

she mostly talks to her sister and mother by phone

i probably cocked it up by saying annex, without sounding like an arsehole it’s more a small bungalow in the grounds of a larger house.

at the moment she lives around an hour from me and about the same from my brother

she mentioned living at the bottom of my garden ages ago, not for the first time. Also she tells me she is worried about dying and no one realising for weeks.

she is a capable women but to be fair she works full time and the garden is around 1/3 acre and has trees, hedges, flower beds.

selling and buying her a flat did cross my mind although may as well go for ground floor which limits the options.

also she does want a garden

OP posts:
Ilikewinter · 06/08/2022 14:36

If she doesnt drive and youre in a rural location will she feel isolated - or does she already live in the area anyway?

Could it be possilbe to sell the house and buy her a flat or smaller house that keeps her independence?

Penguinfeather781 · 06/08/2022 14:34

Rural can make it harder for her to be independent- what happens once/if she can’t drive, will she be able to walk or catch a bus to facilities like doctors, library, shops, cafes? Will she have any social circle except you and your partner? Will you struggle to get carers if you need them (can be an issue if you’re remote)? Can she get to work still? Does she actually want to do this?

FWIW I watched my “independent”, “never wanted to be a burden”, “keep themselves to themselves” Grandparents as they aged - they changed. Once they got elderly and frail (albeit much much older than sixty!) they got scared, their social circle got ever smaller, they got physically less capable and they became very needy, demanding, quite child like and bluntly, selfish. Still nice and lovely people but expected a lot of caring for. (And that was before one had dementia which was a whole other dimension.) I don’t think that’s uncommon and I see my parents, who just as my grandparents did swear that after the experience of their parents they’ll never be like that, going exactly the same way.

I also wouldn’t underestimate how you having children might change how you feel - I am far more “territorial” for want of a better word now I have my own children and while I have good relationships with my parents and in-laws they are more complicated than they were.

If she’s only sixty, still independent and working and the only reason you are considering it is the garden, can you afford to pay for a gardener for her? Or even sell her house and buy a flat with a terrace for her to live in? It just seems a big decision with a lot of potential for future unhappiness, to solve a relatively minor issue - I’d happily help house my parents in a financial sense (though it’s unlikely they’d need my help) but I wouldn’t house them with me.

fizzywat · 06/08/2022 14:34

Who has suggested this arrangement, you or both of you?

That's the starting point.

If you are concerned about her ability to do the garden etc. then in time agree to sell her house, and let her choose a smaller property that is future proofed in the event that she gets ill. It would still be in your name of course.

All I can say is that if she is considered vulnerable and elderly at 60, (60?????), well there is no hope for me! I live alone, three bed, large garden, great neighbours, and no way would I move into an annexe at 65 (my age now).

I have an enduring power of attorney so my attorneys will make all decisions for me should I get ill and become incompetent. If I stay ok and feel the house is too much, I'd sell and move to a bungalow nearby. Lots of former neighbours have done this. They are in their 80s.

BowiesJumper · 06/08/2022 14:34

Does she work? Does she have health concerns that mean she needs additional support?

perhaps selling the house she lives in and buying a flat or bungalow with a much smaller garden, which is closer to you might work better than all on the same property? She’s got plenty of years in her yet! And you’re only 32, your life will get busier if you have kids, change job etc?

It’s a bit early to be thinking about this?

toomuchlaundry · 06/08/2022 14:33

Would she be relying on you for socialisation? How would she get to her job?

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 14:33

@RethinkingLife

id be delighted for her if he’s a good man.

OP posts: