Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Buying a house with a “granny annex” and having DM move in

110 replies

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 13:25

Good idea?

YANBU - Yes
YABU - No

Experiences welcome :)

I’m thinking about selling up and buying a larger house with a detached granny annex. I own both my house and the house DM lives in, I lived there before moving to my current house.

DM is 60, independent and keeps herself to herself. Although she is struggling to keep up with the 3 bed house she is in as it has a large garden and she is not capable of keeping on top of it. She isn’t a rich lady and works a minimum wage job, no way could she afford a cleaner or Gardner.

It doesn’t seem a bad idea and I know she would be willing to but it’s a jump that’s not easily reversed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GoldenMalicious · 07/08/2022 01:10

18 years ago we moved to a house that we could share with my parents. My dad was 86 and my mum was 73 - I was 36 and had one DS with my husband. We had intended to find somewhere that we could be together yet independent of each other, giving us and my parents space, but in the end bought a house that offered enough separation but was not two separate properties. My dad died 20 months later but my mum is still with us at 91. Last year, Mum had a fall which has severely hampered her independence and with that it has altered our lives too. She cannot be left alone for long - last time we were all out she fell and lay on the floor for two hours until we got back. We have all benefited enormously from having mum here with us but right now we are living a much more limited life because she is here. I have no idea whether this is the way things will be for years, whether she might die soon or deteriorate to a point where she needs greater care than we can or are willing to give. If you’d asked me two years ago I’d have unequivocally said it was a great idea but right now we are in a rather different place and facing into a far more challenging period. By all means go ahead but be prepared for the bad as well as the good.

milkyaqua · 07/08/2022 00:48

HollowTalk · 06/08/2022 14:08

She is only 60 years old! If she is struggling then surely it's better that she's near to other people and a good bus route and local shops? If the house is too much for her and you own it, wouldn't it be cheaper for you to pay for the upkeep and a gardener?

I would have thought the last thing she would want is to be stuck out in the middle of nowhere. How would she even get to work? How would she make new friends?

You make very good points.

Why clip her wings so young, when you could pay for the upkeep of the house you own in a modest way.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 07/08/2022 00:43

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 19:16

@polka6 Yes I would like a family.

DM played a massive role for sure, it it wasn't for her I wouldn't be where I am today.

Shortly after my lil brother was born our father walked out to never be seen again, our dear mum did everything she could but we were dirt poor and life was really a struggle. She would always go without and put us first which was hard to see.

Mum always had to do everything herself there was no one around to help, so her attitude was always get stuck in and do it, if it was DIY, chopping down a tree, playing football with my brother or working all hours to try and put some food on the table. When you are younger you don't really know any different and I carried on in similar way, independent and working reasonable hard.

I started a business which did well and was bought out by a competitor, I'm still working but doing my own thing which although it doesn't pay mega money it keeps me busy which I like.

Your mum sounds bloody amazing and no wonder you want to look after her. You sound fab too. The apple hasn't fell far from the tree ❤

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 07/08/2022 00:39

Marvellousmadness · 06/08/2022 23:37

In 10s years time she might be super needy and might intervene with the kids all the time. And barge in all the time. And need physical help. My marriage wouldn't survive if my mil moved in...

Projecting much? Sorry if you have a bad relationship with your mum, but OP doesn't. Her mum is not elderly.

Not every older person needs their arse wiping and has a compulsion to interfere.

Adversity · 07/08/2022 00:37

@maddiemookins16mum thats lovely, my MIL is hoping to relocate near to us. I prefer her to my own Mother. Only issue I have is I really don’t want to live rurally again and most houses with annexes are rural.

alwayscheery · 06/08/2022 23:51

If I read correctly I think your mums mum is still alive. How old is your Grandmother and who looks after her. How far away is she? Apologies if I misread.

Marvellousmadness · 06/08/2022 23:37

In 10s years time she might be super needy and might intervene with the kids all the time. And barge in all the time. And need physical help. My marriage wouldn't survive if my mil moved in...

alwayscheery · 06/08/2022 23:33

It makes sense.
One house with an annexe will be your PPR , and therefore tax free should you sell.
Currently you live in your PPR and would potentially have a capital gains tax bill on the sale of your second property.
As your Mum gets older it will be easier to help her and keep an eye on her if she is living nearby.
Future grandchildren would enjoy a close relationship living close.
If your DM stays fit and healthy she might choose to help Look after grandchildren or babysit occasionally.
Always someone home to take deliveries ,deal With tradesmen or repair work.
Security if you are out all day.
Care for pets whilst in holiday etc.

JonahAndTheSnail · 06/08/2022 22:30

What does your DM think? Her living in a bungalow away from your main house, sited in several acres of land, doesn't sound like a terrible idea. It's very different from her being attached to your house and not dissimilar to living a few streets away from each other.

DeedIDo · 06/08/2022 22:16

Apologies to anyone I unwittingly offended. No, the DM in this case is not old. She is certainly younger than me, and I am still working, going to gigs etc and so are a lot of my contemporaries.

The point I was clumsily trying to make was that the issues here are basically the same as those experienced by people with properly elderly parents.

Is that better?

SaintHelena · 06/08/2022 22:12

Isn't 60 thenew 40.
You could redo the garden by paving or gravelling areas of lawn and filling flowerbeds with shrubs.

Wafflesnsniffles · 06/08/2022 21:36

Its a reason to watch "Last tango in Halifax" - for research purposes!

GU24Mum · 06/08/2022 20:09

Is a (carefully selected) lodger a possible option to try before you do something more drastic. That would give her money to use on a gardener.

Plantstrees · 06/08/2022 20:06

I think its a great idea. It is much easier to deal with all the issues arising from having an aging parent if they are closer to home. If she is only 60 then maybe she would enjoy being close to you and involved in your family if you have children. I think more and more families are going to be looking for multi-generational housing in the future.

CecilyP · 06/08/2022 19:37

@HollyBollyBooBoo it would be rural so annex far from the main house and a few acres of land

So really just another small manageable house on piece of land that you own, so not quite a granny annex. Sounds fine if you want to live near each other and she is happy to move to this rural area. Dou you already have a property in mind? Does the annex need to be built?

If she works and has interests near her current home and would she be happy with this move? Does she drive? Sixty seems quite young to be considering this. Might it be better to downsize to somewhere near her current home. It would be better to ask her rather than us!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 06/08/2022 19:27

luckily she keeps herself to herself. Her mother has very interfering

Please be very careful, OP; I've known so many family members who start out like this, but revert to their parents' examples as they age - and that's with folk who weren't averse to going out, socialising, etc, in the first place

As PPs have said, you could be signing yourself up for an ongoing situation with almost no flexibility in time, and if you hope to have a family that's not something I'd personally be prepared to risk

FWIW I liked the idea about selling up and buying her a small flat a bit nearer to you (but not too near)

ulteriorbread · 06/08/2022 19:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Somethingsnappy · 06/08/2022 19:19

I have this and its wonderful! I do have a great relationship with my DM though. As do my DH and children. She's in her 70s and healthy and independent. It has enhanced all our lives.

cubicfeet · 06/08/2022 19:16

@polka6 Yes I would like a family.

DM played a massive role for sure, it it wasn't for her I wouldn't be where I am today.

Shortly after my lil brother was born our father walked out to never be seen again, our dear mum did everything she could but we were dirt poor and life was really a struggle. She would always go without and put us first which was hard to see.

Mum always had to do everything herself there was no one around to help, so her attitude was always get stuck in and do it, if it was DIY, chopping down a tree, playing football with my brother or working all hours to try and put some food on the table. When you are younger you don't really know any different and I carried on in similar way, independent and working reasonable hard.

I started a business which did well and was bought out by a competitor, I'm still working but doing my own thing which although it doesn't pay mega money it keeps me busy which I like.

OP posts:
CousinLucy · 06/08/2022 18:56

It's a great idea. My MIL lives in our enormous house. We share the kitchen and dining room - that's all. This is because she had a stroke at 66 and never regained the movement of half of her body enough to live independently again.

I have 2 boys, 8 and 12. I'm never alone which I hanker for sometimes, but apart from that in my experience it's ideal. We share all bills three ways (1/3 for her, 2/3 for us). Holidaying is a bit of an issue, but you know, we have managed one every year since this arrangement, with the exception of 2020, of course.

She usually makes me a cup of tea when I come in from work, which is a welcome routine she's got into! Plus we have carers twice a day, so I don't do any personal care for her (I'd be rubbish at it, plus it would be awkward).

I like it.

Lemonblossom · 06/08/2022 18:48

Have you actually found a property? Because properties where there are two detached houses on one plot but not right next to one another are few and far between.

polka6 · 06/08/2022 18:40

Its just whatever works best for you, your mother and your partner OP.

I'm a similar age to you and so is my DM to your DM. I think your proposed set up would work really well for us (DH and I both work full-time in demanding jobs, no kids yet but hopefully when this happens, theres no better childcare/influence than grandparents IMO but (?unfortunately) for us DM works full time also in a demanding career and is a "young" 60 year old. Although I suspect she'd consider retirement/ part-time working if grandchildren were on the horizon. How do you feel about that next chapter (assuming you also want a family)?

Can I be nosy and ask what you do for work that you have already got 2 what sounds like rather large houses with many acres of land and able to provide a home for your DM? Did DM have a role to play in you being so financially successful? Mine certainly did, but has a very good job herself, though I suspect my earning potential is similar just that I am a lot earlier on in my career to her.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 06/08/2022 18:25

I'm 60 and bought a house with annexe with DS and DIL because they can't get on the housing ladder. Works for us. I work full time.
We have VERY clear boundaries though.

fussychica · 06/08/2022 18:20

We did it soon after my mum died. We were living abroad so a bit of a different proposition . He loved it there and spending time with his grandson and we all decided it would be a great idea. We sold our house and bought another property in the same village which required lots of work. We renovated it to provide a self contained apartment for my dad, with his own front door and terrace. He adored living there and we loved having him so close to us and no longer having to worry about how he was coping.
Your mum is younger than I am now so she might feel this is a bit early to make that move. My dad was much older than your mum when he came to live with us and he was starting to need a bit of support, though still independent.
If you have great relationship with your mum though and she is happy to make that move now then it could work out well for both of you. It's a big decision for you both.

CakeCrumbs44 · 06/08/2022 18:14

If she works full time and doesn't have a mortgage/rent to pay then could she pay for a gardener?

It doesn't sound like a bad idea to me. You won't be in the same house but she is nearby to see grandchildren when they arrive, or for you to offer help if she needs it in later years. if you're all on board and happy with it then it doesn't really matter what people on Mumsnet think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread