Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so frustrated with DH

61 replies

Frogfrogphilip · 06/08/2022 08:40

Name changed for this I ended up in a huge argument with DH last night basically over "lad culture", it started with a conversation about stag dos and I made a comment like "I'm sure they are great fun to be part of but they are no fun for anyone else to be around", which he took offence to, and I tried to explain that for example if a woman is on her own in the same place as a stag do it would be likely to make her feel uncomfortable - they may well be a group who aren't going to bother you but how do we know that!? Experience tells us that often groups of guys together, after they have been drinking, might try to talk to women they don't know.

Anyway his answer was that his mates aren't like that, and am I saying he should never meet up with his friends, and asking me what the solution is as how can I expect him to single handedly fix the problem. Maybe my initial comment was a bit unnecessary but I still feel that it's true. This then went round and round in circles with him just taking everything personally and I tried to explain that I KNOW it's not him, but it's the whole culture that is a problem, and because I couldn't tell him exactly what the solution would be for him to personally fix it, he basically said my point was invalid. I ended up so so frustrated I was actually crying about it and then I did shout at him out of sheer frustration. And now all he is saying is that I owe him an apology for the way I spoke to him.

I am at my wit's end and just feel so disappointed that I can't seem to get him to understand, I know if was unreasonable for shouting at him - oh which by the way he's now saying makes me a hypocrite because shouting is an intimidating behaviour. I know I shouldn't have shouted, but that doesn't erase the rest of the conversation. We have a daughter, and since having her I feel more strongly about this, I think I'm just sad that he doesn't seem to feel the same.

OP posts:
gannett · 06/08/2022 10:08

YANBU.

It's incredibly frustrating to talk about a systemic problem in society - lad culture, toxic masculinity, white supremacy, heteronormativity - and the response derails and deflects by taking it personally. I shouldn't have to jump through a series of Not All Men or Not All White People or I Don't Mean You hoops to talk about these issues, especially not with a partner who I'd expect to understand where I'm coming from. If they don't get it they can at least listen without making it about them.

The exact character of an individual stag do is irrelevant. Yes, some are unthreatening and harmless - I have in fact been on stag dos like this, with friends (gender-segregated socialising isn't really a thing for us). But I've also been in places where stag dos have been incredibly obnoxious and overbearing. I haven't felt personally threatened but have been with a gay friend who they targeted in a really weird way.

There's a reason a lot of clubs won't admit groups of men who look like a stag do.

orangeisthenewpuce · 06/08/2022 09:59

I live in a city that gets lots of stag parties and they are mainly a good laugh and just up for fun. Not threatening at all.

IrisVersicolor · 06/08/2022 09:53

I mean no-one wants to be around stags or hens as they can be loud, drunk and annoying.

I’m not sure this was the hill to die on in a point about toxic masculinity in general.

But don’t apologise as it will only make him more insufferable.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 06/08/2022 09:51

I always found a group of men are usually out for a good laugh not anything threatening towards women at all, I would be more alarmed by a single man

Aprilx · 06/08/2022 09:44

Frogfrogphilip · 06/08/2022 08:50

Ok, thanks for the perspective. I'll go and apologise to DH now

It does sound like you caused this argument, yes. You were also incorrect and do not speak for all women. I for example have never had any opinions of stag dos either way, no woman I know has ever aired an opinion of them either.

At worst, I might be disappointed if there were a big stag do in the establishment I and I had gone to hoping for a quiet meal, but I would think that if there were a big hen do as well.

I am baffled as to why you started this conversation or why it escalated to such a degree. You both sound ridiculous.

Yeezytiger · 06/08/2022 09:35

Don't apologise, you'll only entrench his views

Hoppinggreen · 06/08/2022 09:32

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 06/08/2022 09:27

Hens are just as bad as stag doos a group of woman are just as likely to harass a man its the whole group affect but you were way over the top crying and shouting over crap

The fact that some women can behave as badly as some men doesn’t make women any safer from harassment

Comtesse · 06/08/2022 09:30

He’s projecting his uncomfortable feelings as anger. He’s also rubbish at debating. Why should you have to tell him what his contribution should be to solve the problem?

His first contribution ought to be not shouting at someone he loves when trying to explain how a situation makes then feel.

Apologise for shouting if you like but he needs to go and read Everyday Sexism more often to know how it feels. NAMALT yes sure, but a lot of them are. And big groups of shouty drunk men can be intimidating.

Mally100 · 06/08/2022 09:28

Dotcheck · 06/08/2022 08:55

As above- ridiculous premise for an argument.
If your hypothetical ‘woman alone’ is brave enough to go out alone ( assuming to a bar/club) I’m pretty sure she is either 1) brave enough to say no or 2) went out alone to meet men

OP what are you really upset about? Do you feel your husband hits on women when he’s out? Are his friends assholes to women?

To be honest, large single sex groups are always irritating to be around- no matter what the sex

This. fgs its a stag do, if you are uncomfortable about something that's nothing to do with you then get up and go. You seem to think it's only a group of men that are obnoxious and rowdy. How small minded are you. The worst I've been around are hen do's.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 06/08/2022 09:27

Hens are just as bad as stag doos a group of woman are just as likely to harass a man its the whole group affect but you were way over the top crying and shouting over crap

TedMullins · 06/08/2022 09:23

Your H is a misogynist. My partner and I discuss all sorts of social issues and he is very forthcoming in saying toxic masculinity and the huge number of men who’ve absorbed it are a massive problem. Seems your H is one of those men.

WinterMusings · 06/08/2022 09:22

Men have a totally different experience of life, the vast, vast majority never give their safety a thought, they've never needed to. Unlike the vast vast majority of women who have been brought up to 'be careful' of what they do, where they go & what they wear.

I don't think it's difficult to understand without the same lives experience they don't naturally understand the issues. Some men do when you explain it to them, but many still won't really get it, because it's so far from their lives experience.

if you want your DH to understand, starting off the way you did isn't going to work, but tbh, most men are wired to be 'problem solvers' & trying to get them to understand but not feel responsible for solving the problem is a big ask - he can't.

I'd concentrate on how you're going to bring up your DD (& any other children) rather than trying to make him understand something that's incredibly difficult if you haven't lived it.

Hoppinggreen · 06/08/2022 09:16

If he can’t see there’s a problem then he’s part of the problem.

My DH was a bit dismissive of things like this, he would never behave badly around women so he really couldn’t get his head around other men doing it. He thought that it was only a very small amount of men and a certain “type” that were a problem
Having a teenage daughter changed his perspective and he now understands that unfortunately a lot of men DO behave badly around women and as we can’t instantly tell if a situation is going to be a problem we often err on the side of caution.

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 09:14

In my experience of SA'd on a night out a fair few times its been mainly by men out on their own, never once on a stag

EyeSpyPlumPie · 06/08/2022 09:09

Crikey you’re getting some weird replies. For what it’s worth I agree with you. Large groups of males are intimidating and no fun to be in the vicinity of. There’s always this fear of something kicking off and the knowledge that you as a woman are pretty powerless to do anything.

TheTeenageYears · 06/08/2022 09:09

There was a mini drama about 6 months ago set in a fictitious sports company which would be a really good watch for someone who just doesn't seem to get the issues women have faced/continue to face. It provoked a very insightful conversation between DH and I on this type of topic. The male privilege of going out and not feeling intimidated in a reversed situation means the vast majority just don't understand sadly - they need to be educated.

puptent · 06/08/2022 09:04

I get you, OP.

My DH also hates 'lad culture' and would agree with me if I brought this up so I understand you wanted empathy, and a discussion. You told him how it made you feel and he took it as an attack against him.

Yikes, v frustrating, kind of proved your point, tbh.

Just nod and smile and then keep plowing your lonely furrow and plugging away for your DD.

My DD is 'going out out' age now and she always says the clubs would be so much better if no men were allowed in. She gets it. She sees it. She experiences it.

...it's tough out there...

FurAndFeathers · 06/08/2022 09:04

@Frogfrogphilip Your point is reasonable toxic masculinity and societal misogyny are real problems. Choosing stag dos as an example of that is an odd choice however .

your DP’s expectation that because you’ve discussed a societal problem you are personally responsible for providing him with a solution is ridiculous. He needs to learn to have a generally discussion without taking everything personally. Does his response mean you can never discuss toxic masculinity, misogyny or violence against women because if you do he’ll expect you to single handedly deliver a solution to him? What about poverty, hunger or rising energy bills? Are you responsible for solving those too? He sounds ridiculous and immature and if I were you I’d be pointing out that expectation is unreasonable.

also if he wants you to give him a solution - tell him to listen to Daniel Sloss m.facebook.com/FBJUST/videos/daniell-sloss-on-rape/310823971091542/

GrandSlamFinalee · 06/08/2022 09:01

If your hypothetical ‘woman alone’ is brave enough to go out alone ( assuming to a bar/club) I’m pretty sure she is either 1) brave enough to say no or 2) went out alone to meet men

Men on stag dos also use the public pavements and go on buses and trains. Those are instances where a woman walking alone might feel uncomfortable due to some rowdy behaviour from drunk men. I've been in this position enough times, and not because I was going out to meet men. I was coming home from work. I was going to work. I needed to go to the emergency pharmacy. I was picking up a family member.

To be honest, large single sex groups are always irritating to be around- no matter what the sex

Correct, they are irritating. Statistically, a large male group is also dangerous. Can't really say that about a female group.

CrossStitch87 · 06/08/2022 08:57

What…were you both drunk or something? What a weird argument to have.

gamerchick · 06/08/2022 08:55

I get where you're coming from OP. I wouldn't feel comfortable around a stag do.

Dotcheck · 06/08/2022 08:55

As above- ridiculous premise for an argument.
If your hypothetical ‘woman alone’ is brave enough to go out alone ( assuming to a bar/club) I’m pretty sure she is either 1) brave enough to say no or 2) went out alone to meet men

OP what are you really upset about? Do you feel your husband hits on women when he’s out? Are his friends assholes to women?

To be honest, large single sex groups are always irritating to be around- no matter what the sex

Frogfrogphilip · 06/08/2022 08:55

GrandSlamFinalee · 06/08/2022 08:52

and because I couldn't tell him exactly what the solution would be for him to personally fix it, he basically said my point was invalid

There is no magic fix that one single person could implement, to fix misogyny.

Stag dos are not the issue. The issue is that we are women. And we live in a society that is deeply misogynistic. Is this point also invalid?

I think this is the point I was trying to make - clearly very badly! I know it's not stag dos that are the problem

OP posts:
Tittyfilarious81 · 06/08/2022 08:53

I think you were in the wrong and have singled out a particular group saying they can make people uncomfortable. In my many years of going of out I've seen very large groups of women behaving far worse than some groups of men .

GrandSlamFinalee · 06/08/2022 08:52

and because I couldn't tell him exactly what the solution would be for him to personally fix it, he basically said my point was invalid

There is no magic fix that one single person could implement, to fix misogyny.

Stag dos are not the issue. The issue is that we are women. And we live in a society that is deeply misogynistic. Is this point also invalid?