Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so frustrated with DH

61 replies

Frogfrogphilip · 06/08/2022 08:40

Name changed for this I ended up in a huge argument with DH last night basically over "lad culture", it started with a conversation about stag dos and I made a comment like "I'm sure they are great fun to be part of but they are no fun for anyone else to be around", which he took offence to, and I tried to explain that for example if a woman is on her own in the same place as a stag do it would be likely to make her feel uncomfortable - they may well be a group who aren't going to bother you but how do we know that!? Experience tells us that often groups of guys together, after they have been drinking, might try to talk to women they don't know.

Anyway his answer was that his mates aren't like that, and am I saying he should never meet up with his friends, and asking me what the solution is as how can I expect him to single handedly fix the problem. Maybe my initial comment was a bit unnecessary but I still feel that it's true. This then went round and round in circles with him just taking everything personally and I tried to explain that I KNOW it's not him, but it's the whole culture that is a problem, and because I couldn't tell him exactly what the solution would be for him to personally fix it, he basically said my point was invalid. I ended up so so frustrated I was actually crying about it and then I did shout at him out of sheer frustration. And now all he is saying is that I owe him an apology for the way I spoke to him.

I am at my wit's end and just feel so disappointed that I can't seem to get him to understand, I know if was unreasonable for shouting at him - oh which by the way he's now saying makes me a hypocrite because shouting is an intimidating behaviour. I know I shouldn't have shouted, but that doesn't erase the rest of the conversation. We have a daughter, and since having her I feel more strongly about this, I think I'm just sad that he doesn't seem to feel the same.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thepeopleversuswork · 06/08/2022 13:55

I agree with you OP and I find some of the replies here a bit frustrating.

Of course stag dos aren’t the problem in themselves but they are symbolic of a tolerance of toxic masculinity which is a problem throughout society.

The issue is that obviously it’s not your DH’s fault that some blokes can’t be respectful to women. It’s the “when good people do no nothing” problem. It’s not down to any individual man to fix this behaviour but it is incumbent on all men to recognise the problem and to identify it and seek to address it within their own peer groups. If this behaviour is tolerated or laughed off it’s tantamount to tolerating it.

Very much in the same way as if I went out with friends and someone I was with made a racist remark it wouldn’t be my fault per se but I would be complicit if I didn’t challenge it.

Theres been a huge amount of recent attention paid to the responsibility of all men to challenge this behaviour in their friends and peers so I think your DH is being disingenuous.

Riapia · 06/08/2022 13:53

Stag and hen parties usually involve coarse, vulgar and lewd behaviour.
Greatly enjoyed by those involved.
Not so much by others.

neverbeenskiing · 06/08/2022 13:44

Aprilx · 06/08/2022 12:39

But OP did not start a discussion about misogyny in society, which is something I would imagine a large number of us would agree with. OP said that all women are intimidated by stag parties, which is clearly something that we don’t all agree with.

The behaviour of groups of men in public spaces, and the impact of this on others is very much related to misogyny. She was talking about how some groups of men behave inappropriately when in a group/drunk and that this is largely tolerated.

neverbeenskiing · 06/08/2022 13:41

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 12:37

Well my experience of being actually raped was far worse than what you've just described, I'm pleased you've not experienced that but I'm STILL not frightened of men in groups.

Why would you assume I've not experienced rape? You're wrong, by the way but it's not really the point as I was responding to your comment about only lone men being an issue. The fact that you're not frightened of men in groups doesn't mean other women don't have valid reasons to be.

Noideaatall · 06/08/2022 13:27

I agree with you. I find any large group of men intimidating, even worse if they're drunk.

BigFatLiar · 06/08/2022 13:05

Yep stag party - bad choice. In days gone by it was actually hen parties that were more likely to get banned. As for them not being fun to be around, that's generally true if any group of drunks (unless you're one of them).

Frogfrogphilip · 06/08/2022 13:01

Admittedly the stag party wasn't the best example and if I'd been making a decision to start a conversation on misogyny it's not the one I would have used but the topic of stag parties came up, and the conversation did then develop into lad culture being a problem in society, and the impact this has on women, perhaps I didn't include enough detail on the argument to make this clear, as it seems a lot of focus is being put on the (admittedly not the best) individual examples I used when trying to discuss a bigger issue with DH.

I'm not saying that every woman is scared of every group of men, or should be, so I'm sorry if it came across that way. Personally I don't like it when I'm on my own and a group of men try to start up a conversation with me for their own entertainment, I am totally fine with a man chatting to me but I have definitely been spoken to by groups of men where it does not feel like we are chatting on equal terms, they have made jokes, tried to get a reaction, made inappropriate comments or asked inappropriate questions and in those moments it feels very much like a power trip for the blokes, and I don't like that feeling. Even if statistically I'm much more likely to be physically harmed by a lone man, of still rather not be harrassed by a group of them. But that is just one personal example, and not really what this is about. I was just trying to explain to DH how even though he is a "good guy", he is still part of a certain culture, and the fact that he doesn't even have to think about it like that just goes to prove my point.

Anyway, I've apologised for shouting at him but did tell him I still stand by the point I was trying to make.

OP posts:
phishy · 06/08/2022 12:41

YANBU

In general groups of men (with or without alcohol) and especially outside the workplace = bad news for women.

pylonpal · 06/08/2022 12:41

Personally the harassing or/and potentially dangerous behavior I have experienced from men has been from guys by themselves, on in a group, but where one guy was the problem but his mates did not reign him in, (which makes his mates part of the problem, and that sadly includes guys in mixed sex groups).

Aprilx · 06/08/2022 12:39

neverbeenskiing · 06/08/2022 12:26

OP, i'm sorry so many posters are spectacularly missing the point. YANBU. There is nothing more frustrating than men who respond to you pointing out that misogyny exists and is a problem for us in society with a "but I'M not one of those men and neither are my friends!!!" It's so predictable. Not only centering themselves in a conversation about the experience of women but also absolving themselves of any responsibility. Not every man will behave inappropriately towards women, but every man will have seen a friend, colleague, relative, or acquaintance behave inappropriately towards a woman and probably stood by and said or done fuck all. The fact that your DH went on to tell you that your opinion is invalid unless you can tell him exactly what is needed to fix this deeply entrenched, societal problem speaks volumes. Men think that unless they're the ones doing the raping, harassing and intimidating they shouldn't have to take any responsibility for acknowledging, let alone addressing, casual sexism or male violence against women. The onus is always on women to find solutions or workarounds, to change our behaviour or remove ourselves from certain situations. Fuck that.

But OP did not start a discussion about misogyny in society, which is something I would imagine a large number of us would agree with. OP said that all women are intimidated by stag parties, which is clearly something that we don’t all agree with.

CourtneeLuv · 06/08/2022 12:39

Experience tells us that often groups of guys together, after they have been drinking, might try to talk to women they don't know

Oh my good heavens. I'd better never leave my house again, someone might try to talk to me 😲

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 12:37

Well my experience of being actually raped was far worse than what you've just described, I'm pleased you've not experienced that but I'm STILL not frightened of men in groups.

neverbeenskiing · 06/08/2022 12:32

This 100% I've only been attacked out by lone men. Its never subsequently made me fearful of either going on more nights out or stag dos. If you're intimidated by stag dos you shouldn't be out, simple.

So because you personally have only ever been attacked by lone men, women being harassed or intimidated by groups of men isn't a thing that happens? Having been on my own in a train carriage with a group of men on a stag do who decided to pass the time by loudly exchanging jokes about raping me, I'm pleased you've never had to deal with that but I take issue with your assertion that it means I "shouldn't be out". The problem was their behaviour, not me having the audacity to travel home by train after a late shift.

neverbeenskiing · 06/08/2022 12:26

OP, i'm sorry so many posters are spectacularly missing the point. YANBU. There is nothing more frustrating than men who respond to you pointing out that misogyny exists and is a problem for us in society with a "but I'M not one of those men and neither are my friends!!!" It's so predictable. Not only centering themselves in a conversation about the experience of women but also absolving themselves of any responsibility. Not every man will behave inappropriately towards women, but every man will have seen a friend, colleague, relative, or acquaintance behave inappropriately towards a woman and probably stood by and said or done fuck all. The fact that your DH went on to tell you that your opinion is invalid unless you can tell him exactly what is needed to fix this deeply entrenched, societal problem speaks volumes. Men think that unless they're the ones doing the raping, harassing and intimidating they shouldn't have to take any responsibility for acknowledging, let alone addressing, casual sexism or male violence against women. The onus is always on women to find solutions or workarounds, to change our behaviour or remove ourselves from certain situations. Fuck that.

UnimpeachableBravery · 06/08/2022 12:08

If he can't see the problem then he's part if it.

Alfenstein · 06/08/2022 11:57

ShahRukhKhan · 06/08/2022 11:55

Some people on here are not understanding what you were trying to say to your DH (ironically just like your DH)! You were trying to talk about lad culture and misogyny using stag parties as an example of this. Your DH took it personally like you were saying ALL MEN. Mine was like this for ages, it took so many heated arguments for him to understand and even now he is a bit prickly over it.

You can apologise for shouting but don't apologise for the point you were making because you are right- whether he likes it or not. It can be difficult for many people to understand and uncomfortable. Even I used to get annoyed about feminism because I didn't want it to be true, what they were saying. But once you have seen it, you can't unsee it.

He should also apologise for being so defensive. Then maybe it will be a step towards increased understanding.

The op started by saying no one liked being around stag do's

ShahRukhKhan · 06/08/2022 11:55

Some people on here are not understanding what you were trying to say to your DH (ironically just like your DH)! You were trying to talk about lad culture and misogyny using stag parties as an example of this. Your DH took it personally like you were saying ALL MEN. Mine was like this for ages, it took so many heated arguments for him to understand and even now he is a bit prickly over it.

You can apologise for shouting but don't apologise for the point you were making because you are right- whether he likes it or not. It can be difficult for many people to understand and uncomfortable. Even I used to get annoyed about feminism because I didn't want it to be true, what they were saying. But once you have seen it, you can't unsee it.

He should also apologise for being so defensive. Then maybe it will be a step towards increased understanding.

Alfenstein · 06/08/2022 10:45

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 10:17

This 100% I've only been attacked out by lone men. Its never subsequently made me fearful of either going on more nights out or stag dos. If you're intimidated by stag dos you shouldn't be out, simple.

Very much this

If you're so delicate that a group of people on a night out intimidates you seek help or stay away

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 10:44

I never said women or gay men should stay in 🤔🤣 I said if you find stag dos intimidating your probably not cut out for a night out. That goes for anyone man, woman whatever.

Shamoo · 06/08/2022 10:37

(To add, there are stag parties when they just go and play golf and abseil etc etc and I wouldn’t find that group of men in any way intimidating, so I think it’s the behaviour that comes out when in a pack and pissed that causes the issues.)

Shamoo · 06/08/2022 10:35

I find both drunken stag dos and drunken hens unpleasant to be around when sober. The person who referenced being on public transport with either gave a good example, generally loud and irritating and thinking they are the only thing that matters - women covered in dicks with little kids around etc etc. I just don’t really like that culture.

But as a woman I would only be intimidated by one of them - and that’s the large group of men. Not just stag dos, but any large group of men who are drunk. I actually find large groups of football fans worse, as they also have the added aggressor of tribalism built in. And I say that as a massive football fan. Travelling in London on public transport is frequently horrible for this, and I have been seen - and been the subject of - all sorts of harassment. Especially to gay men (or men perceived to be gay) actually.

So I don’t think it’s stag dos per se, but large groups of drunk men are often intimidating.

JustOneDD · 06/08/2022 10:29

OP, I have a DD and have had similar frustrating conversations with my husband about lad culture (not stag dos) - as he sees himself as a “good guy” he gets very defensive about the conversation, as if it’s a personal attack. I think the idea of the “good guy” is actually very harmful as it makes it difficult for men to accept that they still might be part of the problem by not actively standing against misogyny or just by some of their more mild behaviour. It all normalises misogyny. I think the “lived experience” comments by PP are very true but men should be able to listen and try to understand instead of turning it into an argument where you have to apologise!

Comtesse · 06/08/2022 10:25

No sorry Sunny I think you are dead wrong on that - why should women or gay men or anyone else stay in because stag dos can be obnoxious?

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 10:17

This 100% I've only been attacked out by lone men. Its never subsequently made me fearful of either going on more nights out or stag dos. If you're intimidated by stag dos you shouldn't be out, simple.

RiojaRose · 06/08/2022 10:14

I tend to think that men who deny the problem are likely to be part of the problem.