Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do the huggers always win?

169 replies

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 04:02

I don't like hugging outside of my immediate family and in certain circumstances like grief. It feels forced and unnatural to me.
So why do I end up having to give out hugs like they are candy? People I don't know well, forcing themselves into my personal space and trying to create an intimacy that isn't there?
Can't the huggers ask consent?
Do people actually like hugging or do most people just do it because it is expected? I think it's a female socialisation thing and we should cut that crap, DH doesn't get strong armed into forced hugs nearly as much as me.

Yabu- hugging is great and everyone should do it.
Yanbu- everyone should cut it out and I only hug because it's expected.

And no, I do not need a hug.

OP posts:
balalake · 06/08/2022 07:19

I was hoping that one of the few positive legacies of the pandemic with all its awfulness would be less hugging.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 07:17

Asking is perfect. That's all im asking.
If you ask you are giving me permission to say no.
If you launch then I have to make a scene to say no and you've already made it clear you don't really care if the other person wants it.
Lots of mental health professionals agree the default should be don't assume consent.

OP posts:
GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 07:13

DeePlume · 06/08/2022 07:08

My ex MIL was a militant hugger. I absolutely hate it but she insisted on it. I used to hate going there and got really anxious in the car on the journey as I knew it was coming. When we split my ex cited it as a reason he left. He said it upset his mum and that wasn't ok. What about how it made me feel?!?!?!?

Totally agree with you!!

That is awful. I can see why he's an ex being insensitive like that.

OP posts:
JasmineVioletRose · 06/08/2022 07:11

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 06:19

It's totally ruined my hug radar. I think it's sad not to hug friends & family.
I wouldn't hug strangers though.

Perhaps.it could be an idea that you ask breezily if you can hug.
I don't think it's right that your need to hug someone overrides their comfort and if your radar is broken you need to take that into consideration.
And some members of family may not like hugs either. There are other ways of showing love. This isn't just about launchy strangers and actually I can see with my toddlers ignoring your own boundaries starts with pushy relatives and the difficulty parents have when they say no to said relatives.

I don't launch myself at people.
I often just ask "are we hugging?" Before going for it. Because I'm nit sure if people want to hug.
But really it's on the non huggers to say isn't it? I'm not psychic!

DeePlume · 06/08/2022 07:08

My ex MIL was a militant hugger. I absolutely hate it but she insisted on it. I used to hate going there and got really anxious in the car on the journey as I knew it was coming. When we split my ex cited it as a reason he left. He said it upset his mum and that wasn't ok. What about how it made me feel?!?!?!?

Totally agree with you!!

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 07:00

My fuck off glare is terrible. Never been able to pull it off.
I had a bit of a younger than I look, innocent vibe when I was younger and I think a lot of people read it as you can treat people like a child and unfortunately for some people that means putting their comfort ahead of your consent.

I also found the boundaries got crossed more with my pregnancies. Again, something about it makes people think your right to consent to be touched has vanished.

I might be better off now I have a good collection of lines and wrinkles though!

OP posts:
Heyisforhorses · 06/08/2022 06:57

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 05:58

. I am in the US and it’s considered rude to stop someone mid hug in the south.
Yes, it's the same in a lot of places and this is what I think people are missing. You can't stop someone hugging you it's seen as the height as rudeness.

Course you can stop someone, both hands up, "nooooo I'm not a hugger" and step back. They might be a bit embarrassed but it may make them think next time.

I'm a hugger but only with certain people, defo less than I used to, years ago I'd have hugged everyone, now I only do it when I am genuinely happy to see someone/comforting someone. I would have no problem saying to someone "eh no" if rhey went to do it, doesn't happen though so I must give off very "try it and see what happens pal" vibes!

ThinWomansBrain · 06/08/2022 06:53

I agree that the huggers should read the signs, but plenty of people aren’t able to
It's a case of getting the fuck off glare right - I never have a problem with it😆

When lock down, or a variation of it ended a year or so ago, the FT had a brilliant cartoon that was essentially a newspaper hoarding saying "you can hug again" and a guy walking past with a T Shirt with "Don't even think it" - It was my screensaver for quite a while.
I also got irritated with people (mostly work) who made a big show of 'elbow bumps' - sort of instead of a handshake, but people I'd never dream of shaking hands with except maybe the very first time I met them. They got pretty short shrift too - they'd end up doing elbow dives after I'd walk past, looking as if they were attempting some kind of mad 'funky chicken' dance.

BottlingBurpsForGrandma · 06/08/2022 06:52

My best friend isn't a hugger, so I just don't hug her. She has given clear non verbal cues (like physically standing away from the "hug circle", carrying her coat, and once she physically stepped back and waved goodbye instead when I went in for a hug in our early friendship)

She knows exactly when a meaningful hug is necessary though ❤

I do think it's a bit like the introvert / extrovert thing - extrovert is always seen as the norm, like pro-huggers. Annoying

OP posts:
GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 06:48

I think the elbow thing only works.for acquintenes tbh. As soon as it's colleagues, in laws, auntie, pervy uncle, whatever the expectation for hugs is there and bumping could not be well received.

OP posts:
Embarrassed22 · 06/08/2022 06:45

I feel you.

For a long time I couldn't bare to be touched, for MH reasons. The amount of people who forced themselves on me, from a hugging perspective, was ridiculous.

After lots of therapy and healing I now love a good hug BUT having been through a time where I couldn't stand it I always ask consent.

I agree about the socialisation thing. The amount of parent I have had trying to get their children to hug me as I come and go. I always put my foot down and say they don't have to, that they're allowed their own bodily autonomy.

wohmum · 06/08/2022 06:34

What’s the cup of tea analogy?

daisychain01 · 06/08/2022 06:30

Ive found the COVID elbow bump has become a very helpful weapon against unwarranted hugging. It creates a useful bit of distance by sticking your elbow out and turning your body sideways on. It gives all the right signals for keeping someone you don't want invading your personal space and getting too close.

Absolutely agree with you OP it should involve consent but often doesn't.

KeyboardWarriorsUnite · 06/08/2022 06:29

You have made it difficult to vote, as those are not the only options.

YANBU to not want to be hugged. YABU to make it seem like the only options are everyone hugs or nobody hugs.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 06:27

I did go with the being considered odd thing for a while(handshake, explicit don't hug me stage)
I found it didn't solve the problem and I needed up being thought of as weird as well.
I've always found people have been very willing to trample my boundaries, but I guess my irration at it has ramped up both after coming to the realisatio that it is ok to be odd and also that people will use a low guard to take liberties.

I also am at the point where I think I could share my feelings about it on social media and include some of the darker details why, but I also don't think it's right that I should have to disclose sexual assaults to be allowed boundaries.

OP posts:
Trivester · 06/08/2022 06:21

I’m going to be blunt, but it’s not meant unkindly - if you have to choose between being hugged and being thought to be odd, what would you choose?

In my forties I’m leaning into my oddness a lot more! I am odd at times, so what? I just said to my dd this evening “well at least I’m not normal, that would be terribly boring” when she called me weird and I could see it made her think (she’s 12 and waking up to the complex churning sea of social expectations).

The opinions of people who judge you or call you mean names, or trample your boundaries don’t count for much.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 06:19

It's totally ruined my hug radar. I think it's sad not to hug friends & family.
I wouldn't hug strangers though.

Perhaps.it could be an idea that you ask breezily if you can hug.
I don't think it's right that your need to hug someone overrides their comfort and if your radar is broken you need to take that into consideration.
And some members of family may not like hugs either. There are other ways of showing love. This isn't just about launchy strangers and actually I can see with my toddlers ignoring your own boundaries starts with pushy relatives and the difficulty parents have when they say no to said relatives.

OP posts:
JasmineVioletRose · 06/08/2022 06:18

maddy68 · 06/08/2022 06:11

Gosh I am a hugger I also live in a country where a hug and a double cheek kids is a normal greeting

I love it

Me too 🤗

PineForestsAndSunshine · 06/08/2022 06:17

I also hate hugging, but I've always assumed I'm the odd one so I tolerate it. It's creeping back now after covid and I'm finding it difficult.

JasmineVioletRose · 06/08/2022 06:14

I mean, be glad you don't live in Spain or France op! 😘😘

I think it's weird not to hug sometimes. Covid was horrible. It's totally ruined my hug radar. I think it's sad not to hug friends & family.
I wouldn't hug strangers though.

maddy68 · 06/08/2022 06:11

Gosh I am a hugger I also live in a country where a hug and a double cheek kids is a normal greeting

I love it

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 06:08

Yes, I was hoping COVID would have changed the way we do things and put more emphasis on consent but I think if anything people are ignoring the signals.more because they missed out on physical contact in the pandemic. Sorry, their need for physical closeness doesn't trump mine. Go hug a tree.

I don't think using hugs as a gateway is uncommon for assault, after all people that are looking for boundaries to cross will look for weaknesses. All the more reason consent shouldn't be assumed.

I saw the cup.of tea analogy a lot during me.too on social media, so it is getting out there but not quick enough.

OP posts:
JuneJuly · 06/08/2022 06:08

Snog · 06/08/2022 05:33

It's the kissing I dislike

Username does NOT check out!

sammylady37 · 06/08/2022 06:06

I absolutely hate huggers, unless they’re close family or friends. I find them intrusive and overbearing. I used to politely grin and bear it but not any more, I find covid was the perfect excuse and I’ve kept it up so now I just step back, put up my hands as a deterrent and say ‘no, no hugs’. It has worked thus far.