Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do the huggers always win?

169 replies

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 04:02

I don't like hugging outside of my immediate family and in certain circumstances like grief. It feels forced and unnatural to me.
So why do I end up having to give out hugs like they are candy? People I don't know well, forcing themselves into my personal space and trying to create an intimacy that isn't there?
Can't the huggers ask consent?
Do people actually like hugging or do most people just do it because it is expected? I think it's a female socialisation thing and we should cut that crap, DH doesn't get strong armed into forced hugs nearly as much as me.

Yabu- hugging is great and everyone should do it.
Yanbu- everyone should cut it out and I only hug because it's expected.

And no, I do not need a hug.

OP posts:
malificent7 · 06/08/2022 10:18

Love this picture of determined huggers!

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 10:17

Adversity · 06/08/2022 10:11

I have never minded telling people to not embrace me. Who cares what people think.

There is cultural hugging and then there is also unwanted hugging such as the very sweet ladies who used to be in my bible study class, it was non threatening but I told them please not to. Then there is what you are describing which is actually dirty men copping the odd feel.

You don’t have boundaries at all, what was your childhood like as it often stems from your upbringing.

Men can sniff out vulnerable women. Before people start accusing me of victim blaming I was told this when doing fund raising work for a DV charity.

My childhood was fine. My family aren't overly buggy just where it is necessary.
I don't think I have a problem with setting boundaries. I have a problem with people ignoring my boundaries. That's why it's not just dirty old men, but old ladies and family members.
As I said, I'm petite and young looking and not overly assertive so I would say I look an easy target.
I also don't think my experience is unusual. Certainly many people on this thread seem to agree. But I differ from you to where you see a victim I look to the opportunists. If people create loose barriers around consent they'll use it.
And yes, in the case of men probably on the ones who they think they can overpower, intimidate or silence.
But it doesn't mean that it's up to the recipient of unwanted touching to be more assertive. If we had a consent model I wouldn't have to assert myself.

OP posts:
PancakesWithCheese · 06/08/2022 10:15

There was a similar thread a few years back.

One poster who was a hugger was so adamant that she had to hug people and that they would realise how much they liked a hug once she’d hugged them.

The lack of self awareness was quite unbelievable, like her supposed entitlement to hug people somehow overrode anyone’s feelings.

gannett · 06/08/2022 10:12

Please just say no!

I'm not a hugger per se but it doesn't bother me, and sometimes I'll go for a hug. A friend once just stopped me in my tracks and said "sorry I don't do hugs". And that was that. No hug, no offence taken, we're still friends.

Exactly what kind of greeting people expect or enjoy is a bloody minefield tbh.

Sandinmyknickers · 06/08/2022 10:12

And people who don't like hugging often have high anxiety about social stuff and getting things wrong.
As the huggers are claiming this position of greater social confidence I think it's up to them to lead the way and listen to signs.

To be honest I couldn't take you seriously after this OP. Are you one if those that thinks noone else has social anxiety and loads of people are just sailing through life confident internally just because you see it externally? I would say you are also not great at reading other people

Adversity · 06/08/2022 10:11

I have never minded telling people to not embrace me. Who cares what people think.

There is cultural hugging and then there is also unwanted hugging such as the very sweet ladies who used to be in my bible study class, it was non threatening but I told them please not to. Then there is what you are describing which is actually dirty men copping the odd feel.

You don’t have boundaries at all, what was your childhood like as it often stems from your upbringing.

Men can sniff out vulnerable women. Before people start accusing me of victim blaming I was told this when doing fund raising work for a DV charity.

JustlookingNotbuying · 06/08/2022 10:10

I have never been a hugger. Maybe it was the way I was raised? My family are very loving but we’ve never done the hugging thing.
I first came across other people outside of family hugging when I first started working in an office with lots of women. We would work together all day then sometimes all meet up in the evening for drinks/meals etc and as soon as we all met up in the car park they would all start hugging each other. I thought it was weird as they’d only been together just an hour or two earlier and they were all hugging like long lost friends at the arrival area of an airport.
I have a few ‘huggy’ friends but they don’t hug me anymore. I go as stiff as a board when someone hugs me, I think they get the message that way lol!

MiauzenKatzenjammer · 06/08/2022 10:08

I’m going to be blunt, but it’s not meant unkindly - if you have to choose between being hugged and being thought to be odd, what would you choose?

Definitely the latter. People already think I'm odd and it bothers me not at all.

Gatehouse77 · 06/08/2022 10:08

I get your frustration.

I once had a colleague give me a hug (not offer) and say that it was for her benefit but I was the one who was in a state. I completely stiffened and stood there thinking WTF!

I am not comfortable with hugs and kisses from people I don’t know well or only just met. But my upbringing, and being female, put me in the ‘be kind’ box. I’ve broken out! I try to keep a civil distance and avoid.

With my husband and family I’m very tactile so it’s not about touching, it’s who. And I’ve no trauma attached to this, no diagnosis, no issue. Just like my own space and to choose who comes into it. (Also the reason I don’t like animals who, obviously, don’t understand the concept of ‘my’ space.)

Positivelypatient · 06/08/2022 09:58

Hugging seems to be more of this generation to me, growing up in the 70s 80s you didn't hug anyone apart from your mum or dad and even then it wasn't that often (maybe my family was the exception I dunno) and I absolutely never used to hug friends. I remember when my kids were in primary school in the early 2000s it started being a thing they'd all hug when they met eachother. That caused a big spike in headlice as I recall!

I am not a hugger and I'd rather not if at all possible.

howdidigethere · 06/08/2022 09:58

A friend of my DH who I hardly know and tbh don't like much, lunged at me once to hug me goodbye. I stepped back and told him he was being too familiar! He looked aghast but said nothing. Obviously went home to tell his wife though. Some time after when I met him and his wife, the man kept his distance but his wife very purposefully lunged at me for a hug before I could deter her. I truly believe she knew damn well I wasn't a hugger (especially of people I hardly know) but wanted to 'get even' on the hug front!! Never met them again or I would have had to say something choice.

Crochetandcoke · 06/08/2022 09:58

People think I'm absolutely nuts because I'm constantly thinking about and talking about consent, outside of certain circles I'm in talking about and thinking about consent is really not a big thing and not something people think about in day to day functioning. It seems to only be people with experience of safeguarding, abuse and/or neurodiversity who consider consent at all, and even then not as robustly or consistently than is ideal. Mumsnet has a lot of really clued up people parents and professionals (I'm 2 of the 3 so far but going for the 3rd as well!) on this issue, but the number of teachers, therapists, social workers, health workers etc. I come into contact with who seem to really struggle with the issue of consent (and these are fields where people at least do receive training around this, which is not compulsory) is really quite shocking to me, when consent is something that I think about in all my interactions including with my children, in my work, in my social interactions. I feel like you either 'get it' or you don't, but most people really don't. And will put social convention and their personal wants, over the other persons bodily autonomy without seeing an issue, whilst feeling offended if the other person reacts negatively in any way

chaosmaker · 06/08/2022 09:50

The cup of tea thing is interesting. People push unwanted alcohol if you're out at a pub and fags if you're an ex smoker and you're also considered weird if you don't want to join in with it. Also holidays such as xmas and all that tat.

With hugging, could you make yourself more weird by being very vocal at saying no. As in 'Don't touch me!' as the hugger is coming in? Or 'What are you doing?' as if they are being the weird one? I love hugging but usually approach with open arms giving the choice rather than just grabbing the other person into a hug.

Not sure if my suggestions are helpful but then I'm quite good at telling others where they stand with me (not always liked for that but it makes me a happier person overall).

Shodan · 06/08/2022 09:49

I choose who I want to be hugged by. Family, close friends- and that's it.

But there was one woman, at my club, who insisted on trying to hug me. I didn't even know her that well- she was from a different area- and yet she was trying to envelop me in her arms.

I did the whole crossed arms, turn my body away- just as my 6'2" instructor did. As she went up to him (which was disrespectful anyway) he just said "No" so she desisted. But when I said the same, she said "Oh I'm just being friendly! It's just a hug! Come on, don't be mean!"

That just annoyed me even more though so I said no, I don't 'do' hugs, please leave me alone.

Somehow this meant that I was mean, harsh and unfriendly. But she never tried it again, so I was the winner.

As I explained to a few people- it's not on to invade someone's personal space just because you feel like it. It's not on to insist on full body contact. And if someone doesn't welcome your attentions, you should respect that, because one day someone might be a whole lot more forceful than I was in their refusal of them.

Viviennemary · 06/08/2022 09:48

I am not a hugger But I dont't feel its a big deal either way.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 09:46

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/08/2022 09:42

Maybe that's just my experience then. I have certainly never hugged friends and friends my own age have never expected me too.

I wish I could swap in someone who gets boundaries like you into my circle.
The problem is you are stuck with who you get.

OP posts:
Paranormal · 06/08/2022 09:43

maddy68 · 06/08/2022 06:11

Gosh I am a hugger I also live in a country where a hug and a double cheek kids is a normal greeting

I love it

Good for you. Glad you're happy. Has reading this thread made you understand a bit more when some of us wouldn't enjoy your unwarranted hugs and kisses AT ALL?

Trainham · 06/08/2022 09:42

In UK any unwanted touch is an assult so you could always threaten to take it further if people don't listen to you.

I am a huggy person but wouldn't dream of doing it to those who don't like or want a hug as I respect them as an individual to have their own feelings taken into account.
People I don't know or just met I would just ask them if they wanted a hug and respect their reply.

EllaB22 · 06/08/2022 09:42

OP I try to give the don't hug me signals but I have now taken to saying 'I don't do hugs' which sometimes gets sniggers but I do not care! Obviously different with DC!

Also very vocal when family try to strongly encourage kids to hug - I say be thankful for a high five do not force a hug.

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/08/2022 09:42

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 09:40

Interesting . One of the biggest offenders is seventies. One is thirties.
I'd say for me it's been particularly prevanat with older men 40-60 when I was younger. Especially the more.problematic ones.

Maybe that's just my experience then. I have certainly never hugged friends and friends my own age have never expected me too.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 09:40

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/08/2022 09:39

The whole hugging thing is quite new. I am in my late 60s and didn't grow up with it. I don't think I even hugged grandparents, aunts and uncles etc. although they lived some distance away and I rarely saw them. It is certainly a 21st Century thing anyway and, as far as I am concerned, it can go back in its box.

Interesting . One of the biggest offenders is seventies. One is thirties.
I'd say for me it's been particularly prevanat with older men 40-60 when I was younger. Especially the more.problematic ones.

OP posts:
Isitsixoclockalready · 06/08/2022 09:39

I never really thought about people that hug as being a distinctive group. I don't mind hugging personally although I usually wait for someone to initiate (unless it's my wife or children or someone that I know will usually greet with a hug). Hugging as a greeting is definitely something that has become more popular over the decades. Here in the UK growing up, it used to be a handshake or hugs with immediate family. I noticed it as a standard greeting when I went to the US. Personally I'd rather not get to the stage of having to ask if it's ok to hug as it's a spontaneous greeting and shouldn't have any sexual overtones. In the OP's situation it wouldn't happen anyway as I wouldn't dive in with a hug or kiss with someone I don't know. That's probably more to do with the British culture that I grew up with as I know that in other countries it's more of a normal greeting.

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/08/2022 09:39

The whole hugging thing is quite new. I am in my late 60s and didn't grow up with it. I don't think I even hugged grandparents, aunts and uncles etc. although they lived some distance away and I rarely saw them. It is certainly a 21st Century thing anyway and, as far as I am concerned, it can go back in its box.

GetYourSeasideArmsOffMe · 06/08/2022 09:34

ClinkeyMonkey · 06/08/2022 09:13

@ThinWomansBrain Good grief. What on earth is wrong with you? You are actually suggesting that rape victims who didn't fight off their attackers are at fault. AND you're comparing it to consent around hugging. You are a disgrace.

Its interesting though because quite a few people have said it's my fault people hug me without consent because I wasn't clear enough, explicit enough etc.
But have said the sexual assault wasn't my fault. I was silent through shock and fear.
So why does one require me to actively go out of my way to Barr consent and the other consent is not assumed? And in my case the sa led from the hug so I do think it's worth considering what having different consent rules can lead to.

It'd be much better if we adopted a do not assume consent approach. If asking was the norm then I'd have felt comfortable speaking out before it progressed.

OP posts:
Staynow · 06/08/2022 09:31

I love hugs but don't go round hugging random people as they might not appreciate it!