Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expecting working 18 year old to pay his way

181 replies

Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 01:36

My 18 year old son finished college this year and is now working at a local hotel. It was a part time job but is now supposed to be full time as he won’t be going to higher education - so this is it, he’s now in the workforce and is an adult. At home there is myself, my husband and a 16 year old in further education and we are finding money is really tight at the moment.

At what point do we stop paying for our son? I don’t mean food and household stuff, I mean his haircuts, clothes, prescriptions etc? He is working and wants to be treated as an adult, I think he should pay for anything that’s for him. We used to pay his gym and rugby membership before covid but think if he decides to rejoin now he should pay for it himself. We also had to cancel Disney+ and Netflix etc because of the expense, so if he wants to sign up again himself then that’s up to him.

He already pays for his own social stuff and transport to work. We will keep paying his phone for the next year until the contract runs out. He also has access to our car which we obviously pay for.

I have told him he will need to contribute in some way as child benefit stops this month. We wouldn’t expect him to pay a lot in the way of board (any suggestions?) but we aren’t rolling in money.

We had a rare family holiday this year and also had several big family events and weddings that had rolled forward because of Covid, so it’s been a hefty year financially. The family commitments involved long weekends away, suit hire/purchase, meals out, stag dos etc and we’ve paid for all of it; all we asked was that our son buys his own beer.

So:

AIBU for asking for a contribution to board now he’s working and left education?

How much would people suggest we ask for?

When should we stop paying for all the stuff that’s just for him likes clothes etc? Obviously we will still feed him!

I would really love to just keep supporting him but it’s a struggle. Thanks for taking the time to read.

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 16:27

my parents were very comfortably off.

my first job was a graduate training scheme!

i lived briefly at home (no rent or anything charged) and then moved out when I’d saved enough.

so by many of the standards on this thread - I should be incapable to siping my own bottom as an adult let alone standing on my own two feet.

Instead I am a well paid professional single mother with absolutely not support network (parents deceased but not before most of estate spent on care home fees and rehab)

ChampagneCharlieIsMyName · 06/08/2022 16:27

He’s a working adult. He pays for everything himself now.
You can undercharge him his rent and board, but he buys his own toiletries, clothes, bus pass/petrol, phone etc.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 16:24

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 16:14

No-one in my extended family is living at home last twenty. The graduates I employ at work rarely are.

The OP’s son is on £9 per hour, plus tips. Fir a 40 hour week that’s £20,000 per year. Suggesting that the OP should continue to struggle while her son lives the high life is not reasonable.

What you have described is utterly at odds with what is being reported and the stats.

Heard of the “Returners”? All the grads returning to family home because can’t afford to move out and on.

i take it you’re not in the SE or London @StillHappy because around here - the majority return to family home from university these days.

redbigbananafeet · 06/08/2022 16:19

Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 11:51

Thanks so much for all your comments, I’m sorry I can’t reply to them all individually.

So, higher education isn’t an option as college didn’t work out for him. His career path of joining the armed forces was ended when he developed a skin condition a year ago - even though its now under control he will never be able to sign up. So it’s time for a plan b, but he’s working in the meantime which is good.

He earns £9 per hour plus tips, I reckon he’s bringing home around £1000 a month but it varies due to how many shifts he gets (and he’s not started paying into a pension yet). I don’t think this is bad for an 18 year old - he’s worked part time since he was 16 and since he was 17 he has been on many more hours as college was only 3 days a week.

I know he puts money away and he is saving up to eventually buy his own car, apart from socialising (limited because of his weekend bar work) he doesn’t seem to spend an awful lot.

I know it will come as a shock to him that he will have to start paying his way. When I cancelled Netflix and told him he could sign up himself he was gobsmacked! But, having read your messages I think it is time.

Thanks again, very much appreciated. 💚

apply.army.mod.uk/how-to-join/can-i-join/medical

I would enquire further into the manageable skin condition now under control which is stopping him enrolling into the army. There could be possibilities.

ChocoButterfly · 06/08/2022 16:17

Personally I wouldn't pay for anything for him anymore but I wouldn't charge for board.

redbigbananafeet · 06/08/2022 16:15

MintJulia · 06/08/2022 01:46

He's earning full time, so he pays for everything for himself, ie clothes, dental etc, and contributes £50 a week to general household bills, to begin with.

He's not earning full time yet.

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 16:14

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:51

May I ask how old you are?

i was a teen in the nineties. A world away from todays economic landscape and job market.

most bizarre to think otherwise!

No-one in my extended family is living at home last twenty. The graduates I employ at work rarely are.

The OP’s son is on £9 per hour, plus tips. Fir a 40 hour week that’s £20,000 per year. Suggesting that the OP should continue to struggle while her son lives the high life is not reasonable.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 16:10

FreezerOrgReq · 06/08/2022 16:10

A quarter of take home pay I believe has long been the recommended amount.

By whom?

FreezerOrgReq · 06/08/2022 16:10

A quarter of take home pay I believe has long been the recommended amount.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:59

Tiani4 · 06/08/2022 15:55

Wow, my nearly 20 year old at uni has been buying his own clothes, his haircuts, paying his own gym membership and travel since he was 18. Students don't take home anywhere near as much as someone working part time or FT! He paid his travel to and from his part time job 16-18 , half his haircuts (he wanted haircut every 6 weeks), and his socialising money. He took over his own mobile phone bill from 19 when the contract I had ran out but he'd been paying me to contribute towards it anyway from aged 17 (was back then 4x cost of my mobile bill at £44 p month , per month as he wanted a new iPhone on contract at the time, when he took over it was £16 month for sim only )

I buy his food in general when home (he buys extras when he's out if he fancies something I'm not making (he buys his food term time up at Uni but I do a big food shop for him at start of each term)

So all that would be left is when he's working full time he will need to pay some nominal rent at home (which I may set aside for him). I'm surprised your boy thinks he shouldn't have to pay for any of that

My DCs couldn't wait to work part time aged 16 to start to pay for some things themselves and expect to be independent in some areas once 18 even if at uni.

What opportunities lay before you university student? What degree? Decent uni?

The possibility of your son earning substantially more than the OP’s son - no HE, entering a very low paid industry on the bottom rung, is…. Likely

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:57

USaYwHatNow · 06/08/2022 15:50

From about when I was 16 (I'm the eldest) our parents would pin their bills to the fridge to give us an idea of how much it cost to run the house. When we had part time jobs anything we wanted in terms of extras we covered, day to day expenses were still covered by our parents.

When we qualified in our respective professions (Midwife and Scientist) 10% of our monthly wages went on 'keep'. It was a % as my brother, although 3 years younger, had a higher wage than me lucky bugger, so this was to make it as fair as possible. I bought a house and moved out at 25,and my brother did the same at 24.

A midwife buying a property at 25?

Surely you can see that this is a world away from what a 25 year old midwife could possibly afford.

alwaysmovingforwards · 06/08/2022 15:56

excelledyourself · 06/08/2022 01:48

If he's earning full time, why would you even think to be buying his clothes?

He should be taking on all of his expenses now, phone included. Get that transferred.

And he should be paying dig money. Especially if you're struggling. Depends what he's earning, but something should be paid to cover his share of food, gas/electric, etc.

Exactly.

Tiani4 · 06/08/2022 15:55

Wow, my nearly 20 year old at uni has been buying his own clothes, his haircuts, paying his own gym membership and travel since he was 18. Students don't take home anywhere near as much as someone working part time or FT! He paid his travel to and from his part time job 16-18 , half his haircuts (he wanted haircut every 6 weeks), and his socialising money. He took over his own mobile phone bill from 19 when the contract I had ran out but he'd been paying me to contribute towards it anyway from aged 17 (was back then 4x cost of my mobile bill at £44 p month , per month as he wanted a new iPhone on contract at the time, when he took over it was £16 month for sim only )

I buy his food in general when home (he buys extras when he's out if he fancies something I'm not making (he buys his food term time up at Uni but I do a big food shop for him at start of each term)

So all that would be left is when he's working full time he will need to pay some nominal rent at home (which I may set aside for him). I'm surprised your boy thinks he shouldn't have to pay for any of that

My DCs couldn't wait to work part time aged 16 to start to pay for some things themselves and expect to be independent in some areas once 18 even if at uni.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:51

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:48

Of course it isn’t. There was no minimum wage back then, so first jobs were often paid much less than the OP’s son is getting and than is now normal.

If your children haven’t been brought up to be capable of standing on their own two feet as young adults then you have my sympathies, but I stand by my view that it’s not to be encouraged.

May I ask how old you are?

i was a teen in the nineties. A world away from todays economic landscape and job market.

most bizarre to think otherwise!

USaYwHatNow · 06/08/2022 15:50

From about when I was 16 (I'm the eldest) our parents would pin their bills to the fridge to give us an idea of how much it cost to run the house. When we had part time jobs anything we wanted in terms of extras we covered, day to day expenses were still covered by our parents.

When we qualified in our respective professions (Midwife and Scientist) 10% of our monthly wages went on 'keep'. It was a % as my brother, although 3 years younger, had a higher wage than me lucky bugger, so this was to make it as fair as possible. I bought a house and moved out at 25,and my brother did the same at 24.

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:48

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:40

@StillHappy unless you’re under 25, what happened “in your day” really is irrelevant to today given the economic landscape

Of course it isn’t. There was no minimum wage back then, so first jobs were often paid much less than the OP’s son is getting and than is now normal.

If your children haven’t been brought up to be capable of standing on their own two feet as young adults then you have my sympathies, but I stand by my view that it’s not to be encouraged.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:40

@StillHappy unless you’re under 25, what happened “in your day” really is irrelevant to today given the economic landscape

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:37

SueSaid · 06/08/2022 12:55

'My 18 year old is about to start an apprenticeship. Hes going to pay about 1/4 of his wages for house keeping.'

A quarter of his wages?! Omg and then people wonder why youngsters can't get on the property ladder. Deposits. They need to be saving for deposits, parents should be helping not charging their kids who are earning peanuts.

Parents “should” be helping?

Why? Pretty much everyone I know moved away from home at eighteen for education and then never went back. There was no expectation after that that they’d be subsidized by their parents, the view was that their parents had given them all of the tools that they needed by eighteen, and that it was time to leave the nest and learn to fly.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:36

It would be a peppercorn contribution here

with his very limited earning potential at the front of my mind

If saw him pissing it up the wall, I would re evaluate!

Jux · 06/08/2022 15:35

When I had holiday jobs when I was 14, 15 and 16 I had to contribute a bit to my keep - mum just put it in PO account and when I was struggling to save for something later she took all the money out and gave it to me!

Once I was working ft of course I contributed and paid for everything else myself. Don't treat him like a child, he wants to be treated as an dult - do so.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:34

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:32

He’ll be on a minimum of £1,100 per month after tax. For someone with no dependents and who isn’t paying board that’s a lot of money. Asking for £2-300 per month for the room and a share of the bills would not be unreasonable.

But my perspective on my children isn’t so short term

Realistically this 18 year has very likited earning potential in the future. No high education and very low paid industry.

id went to support as much as possible especially as he’s a saver

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:32

CakeCrumbs44 · 06/08/2022 07:01

I wouldn't charge for food or rent unless he is on a pretty good wage (I assume he is on the under 21s minimum wage so not a lot)

He’ll be on a minimum of £1,100 per month after tax. For someone with no dependents and who isn’t paying board that’s a lot of money. Asking for £2-300 per month for the room and a share of the bills would not be unreasonable.

StillHappy · 06/08/2022 15:28

Not only is he now an adult with a proper job, he’s also receiving subsidized or free lodging (and board?) from you.

It’d be absolutely normal for him now to pay for absolutely everything that’s just for him (clothes, haircuts, medicine, entertainment, holidays with friends etc) and for him to make at least a nominal contribution to the household for rent, bills and board.

On the other hand, it’d still feel reasonable for you to provide some meals, do some laundry, give him lifts out, take him on family holidays etc.

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:25

Netflix and Disney… do you still have or just took him off the account?

Rugby… I would 100% continue paying for.

He has joined a low paid industry even on management. He has no higher education. OP, the opportunities coming his way are likely to be limited. Personally at this stage, especially as he’s a saver, I would support him as much as possible. Because he does not sound like he will be anywhere near a decent salary to really get moving in life for a long time

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:21

I have told him he will need to contribute in some way as child benefit stops this mont

but what was his response?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread