Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expecting working 18 year old to pay his way

181 replies

Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 01:36

My 18 year old son finished college this year and is now working at a local hotel. It was a part time job but is now supposed to be full time as he won’t be going to higher education - so this is it, he’s now in the workforce and is an adult. At home there is myself, my husband and a 16 year old in further education and we are finding money is really tight at the moment.

At what point do we stop paying for our son? I don’t mean food and household stuff, I mean his haircuts, clothes, prescriptions etc? He is working and wants to be treated as an adult, I think he should pay for anything that’s for him. We used to pay his gym and rugby membership before covid but think if he decides to rejoin now he should pay for it himself. We also had to cancel Disney+ and Netflix etc because of the expense, so if he wants to sign up again himself then that’s up to him.

He already pays for his own social stuff and transport to work. We will keep paying his phone for the next year until the contract runs out. He also has access to our car which we obviously pay for.

I have told him he will need to contribute in some way as child benefit stops this month. We wouldn’t expect him to pay a lot in the way of board (any suggestions?) but we aren’t rolling in money.

We had a rare family holiday this year and also had several big family events and weddings that had rolled forward because of Covid, so it’s been a hefty year financially. The family commitments involved long weekends away, suit hire/purchase, meals out, stag dos etc and we’ve paid for all of it; all we asked was that our son buys his own beer.

So:

AIBU for asking for a contribution to board now he’s working and left education?

How much would people suggest we ask for?

When should we stop paying for all the stuff that’s just for him likes clothes etc? Obviously we will still feed him!

I would really love to just keep supporting him but it’s a struggle. Thanks for taking the time to read.

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 11:42

My point is that this 18 year old

seems to have a serious skin condition
failed his course and so seems to have no qualifications to his name
has entered one of the lowest paid industries in this country

The world is not exactly his oyster and if i was his parent, I would probably be supporting him saving at this time of his life as much as possible.

but that seems to irritate some posters 😐

Mrsjayy · 07/08/2022 11:41

I didn't pay for anything outwith .birthdays,Christmas the odd treat for dc past 18 . He wants a haircut he pays for it , why are you still paying out for him?

excelledyourself · 07/08/2022 11:38

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 07:49

It is one thing not to go to university OP

But if he failed his course, then it is quite another to have no qualifications whatsoever to your name

Give it a rest.

He's 18 and gaining work experience. He can come back to qualifications if and when he feels ready.

Plenty of people do very well in life without a uni or college education at 18, or indeed any age.

LynetteScavo · 07/08/2022 11:30

My son actually brings home more than my husband who can only work part time due to ill health.

I think in that case it's reasonable to make your DS aware of how much bills cost and ask him to contribute - especially with the raise in fuel bills. I think possibly a % of the food and fuel bill as they would be less if your DS would be living elsewhere.

I do think some people on this thread must live in cloud cooktop land - not everyone is academically able enough to go to uni or pass maths and English GCSE, but it doesn't mean they can't work their way up to a reasonable level in the service industry, and will one day be able to support themselves financially. These people walk amongst us in society and every day Hmm

MorningtonCroissant · 07/08/2022 10:01

Marvellousmadness · 06/08/2022 23:05

Bit harsh imo
I would have resented my parents for it for sure and moved out

And what do weddings have to do with it.

The suggestions given on this thread, as well as what OP has suggested, mean the son would still be getting a better deal living at home than moving out.
Why on earth is it "harsh" to expect him to pay his way, now he's an adult and earning? No wonder so many people have zero money management skills, end up in debt, can't budget.

This thread has gone bananas. I wonder how some posters think people manage on low incomes when they have rent and bills to pay alone? Or why the pressure to immediately go into education or training aged 18 as if there's never going to be another chance, or before they're really committed to what they want to do (/have the motivation after living on a low income!)

OP, your sone sounds great. Getting on with what he can do at present - upping his hours at work - whilst he figures out what to do next, after a difficult setback. There's plenty of time for further education or training. Maths and English might be the thing to focus on first, and anything more specific when he's figured out what. It's ok if he doesn't have his entire life plan figured out at 18. 🙄

madasawethen · 07/08/2022 09:26

He should pay for his own things.

Does he have a LD?
You might encourage him to try another course for something in a year or two.
Not everyone's brain matures at the same time and he may be able to successfully do a course in a year or two.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 09:19

Sorry that was for @Adversity

don’t charge rent or do charge rent.

but to squirrel away money that your adult child gives you for board and then present them with it as a nest egg is hardly teaching them the value of things!

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 09:17

But what are you actually teaching them? Mum and dad won’t tell you how they are managing your finances and then give you a lump sum when they think you’re a big enough boy to handle it (despite fact you are employed and being paid).

Adversity · 07/08/2022 08:21

They need to pay something to learn the value of money. All families circumstances are different. You don’t have the luxury of letting him stay for free.

If your DS has below a grade C in maths and English he should be able to study these for free at an adult/further education centre.

We do charge DS and we don’t need to, I know we are lucky. I’m sure some will view this as harsh. He will be given it back towards his house deposit but we haven’t told him.

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 07:49

It is one thing not to go to university OP

But if he failed his course, then it is quite another to have no qualifications whatsoever to your name

Endlesslypatient82 · 07/08/2022 07:48

I missed that he has what sounds like quite a debilitating skin condition.

if he failed his course, does he have any qualifications to his name whatsoever?

perhaps offer to pay for him to at least retake gcse maths and English is he failed these two

Tangled123 · 07/08/2022 01:28

At 18, I would expect him to pay most of his own expenses like clothes, phone, days out, alcohol etc. If he borrows your car, I would expect him to put petrol or diesel in it too. I might cover insurance, but it depends on if it’s monthly or annually paid and who uses the car more. I would also expect him to sort out his own lunches for work, and potentially breakfast/ dinner if he doesn’t eat with family.
Rent is a bit different and depends what his long term plans are and how much you are struggling. I might give him a couple of months to build up a safety net, but a contribution is reasonable considering his salary and especially if he doesn’t plan on moving out any time soon.

Fisifoofoo · 07/08/2022 00:43

SueSaid · 06/08/2022 07:16

This.

I wouldn't ever charge a dc board and lodge to live in their own family home. Particularly as he will be on minimum wage.

Just agree he pays all his own way regarding social activities, phone, clubs etc and you pay the bills which you would do if he were living there or not.

He’s not on minimum wage, and we are finding things really tight just now. At the end of the month it’ll be even tighter when child benefit stops.

I would love to be able to afford to support him until he finds a place of his own in future, but we are not that well placed financially. My son actually brings home more than my husband who can only work part time due to ill health.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 07/08/2022 00:39

Marvellousmadness · 06/08/2022 23:05

Bit harsh imo
I would have resented my parents for it for sure and moved out

And what do weddings have to do with it.

Sorry, I was just giving context that we’ve paid for lots of big events this year and even though he’s working full time the only thing we’ve asked him to pay for is his beer.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 23:54

SueSaid · 06/08/2022 12:51

Why not just say he can pay for his own clothes, activities etc but tell him he must save say £200 a month. Has he got savings to add to? I presume as he's 18 you'll have had a child trust account for him so he'll have at least a couple of thousand saved?

He's 18 on minimum wage he needs your support like he would if were at uni and you'd be topping up his maintenance loan for living expenses.

Why would you presume he has a couple of thousand pounds in a child trust account? Hi

OP posts:
mogsrus · 06/08/2022 23:16

If he doesn’t start learning life ain’t free,when does it start?

Marvellousmadness · 06/08/2022 23:05

Bit harsh imo
I would have resented my parents for it for sure and moved out

And what do weddings have to do with it.

Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 23:04

Thanks for your message.

Working in hospitality was a part time job (albeit on plenty of hours), but will keep him going until he’s able to find a new path for his future.

Sadly he didn’t pass his course due to what happened with his health, so I expect he’ll try and find a new direction.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 23:00

Until last month he was still in college, under 18 and I’m still getting child benefit for him until the end of the month. So until now I haven’t even considered asking him for any money, as he was a child.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 22:57

Thanks, my feelings exactly 😊

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 22:55

SafelySoftly · 06/08/2022 07:18

Is higher education definitely not an option? Or a apprenticeship or similar? Many regret the decision and now is the time to opt for the opportunity of a higher wage in the future. I’d not be bank rolling him personally. I’d make him realise how expensive life is.

Sadly he didn’t pass his college course - getting his skin condition and his navy career going up in smoke knocked him for six.

An apprenticeship is a possibility once he has reset and found a new direction.

Thanks for your message.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 22:52

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:25

Netflix and Disney… do you still have or just took him off the account?

Rugby… I would 100% continue paying for.

He has joined a low paid industry even on management. He has no higher education. OP, the opportunities coming his way are likely to be limited. Personally at this stage, especially as he’s a saver, I would support him as much as possible. Because he does not sound like he will be anywhere near a decent salary to really get moving in life for a long time

I know this is going to sound very defensive, but he hasn’t ‘joined a low paying industry’ as a career move, he’s just upped his hours in the part time job he already had while he was at college (rather than being out of education and unemployed) and I don’t believe that going to uni is the be all and end all.

I am confident that plenty of opportunities will be available for someone that is still hard working and resourceful despite the setbacks he’s had.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 22:46

Endlesslypatient82 · 06/08/2022 15:34

But my perspective on my children isn’t so short term

Realistically this 18 year has very likited earning potential in the future. No high education and very low paid industry.

id went to support as much as possible especially as he’s a saver

Thanks for your message.

I don’t believe that not having a degree or other higher qualification means that my son will have limited earning potential. Several friends/family members didn’t go to uni but worked their way up to good jobs and have successful careers.

I’m confident that my son’s resourcefulness and determination will stand him in good stead once he finds his new path. In the meantime he’s working hard and keeping himself busy.

OP posts:
Fisifoofoo · 06/08/2022 22:25

redbigbananafeet · 06/08/2022 16:19

apply.army.mod.uk/how-to-join/can-i-join/medical

I would enquire further into the manageable skin condition now under control which is stopping him enrolling into the army. There could be possibilities.

Unfortunately there is no possibility of him being admitted (it was the Royal Navy). The condition and effect on his career plan knocked him sideways and he didn’t end up passing his course. He’s now working while he decides what direction to take for the future.

Thanks for the suggestion though, much appreciated

OP posts:
Sellie555 · 06/08/2022 19:02

Crikey, I stopped paying for both my sons personal things such as haircuts, clothes, mobiles etc as soon as they both got their first part time jobs at 16. One is now at Uni and the other in his last year of college and they still pay for their own personal item and social spending, inc petrol and their car insurance.

once they are both in full time work and, assuming they will live at home for a bit, they will defo be paying their way at home. I Won’t be asking to make a profit from them living at home but they 100% will be needing to contribute towards what they use in terms of food and household bills

Swipe left for the next trending thread