Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

that the Man who killed a burglar he saw breaking into his house should not be jailed for 19 years

255 replies

LargeDeviation · 05/08/2022 17:59

He saw the man breaking into his house on a video doorbell, armed himself with a knife and went with his half-brother and killed the burglar. He has been jailed for 19 years.

Yes the violence he used was very extreme, but the burglar was breaking into his home! It is unreasonable to expect a dispassionate response. People should be able to defend their home and their family from intruders, including using force which would be considered unlawful or unreasonable in other settings.

Even if he must be found guilty by law, the sentence should take the circumstances into account and it should be a slap on the wrist.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 05/08/2022 20:41

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 20:12

That's why family members aren't the judge or on the jury. Because you can't make rational or reasonable decisions if your child is involved.

Absolutely. But when arguing that a disproportionate response of violence, resulting in death, should be deemed perfectly acceptable, hypothetically speaking, I would argue, that a person should be able to envisage that the person that was killed was their loved one. Hypothetically speaking. Not 'them or theirs'. But 'ours, and mine'.

To be fair, I never heard yet parents of murderers saying, he's always been bad. They always say he was loveable and lit up a room. Thugs that go round terrorising others. You're right that if one of those thugs was mine, I wouldn't want them hurt. But do my feelings override those of others whose own loved ones are being terrorised by my child or being threatened into criminal situations that could effect or ruin the rest of their lives. I'm not sure why it's always the honest, law-abiding people that are told to make allowances for scummy, illegal behaviour. Because you can bet your life those thugs aren't making any allowances for decent, good people.

ilovesooty · 05/08/2022 20:38

bubblescoop · 05/08/2022 18:12

This is not self defence. His sentence is correct, if not on the lighter side.

Agreed. He's lucky it's not longer.

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 20:37

LargeDeviation · 05/08/2022 19:12

@carefullycourageous I used to vote Labour until Corbyn. Then I didn't vote at all.

I think crime is a much bigger political issue than it was even a few years ago - probably third just behind the economy and NHS, and just ahead of education and defence.

The politicians need to get the police to stop filling in paperwork and instead catch shoplifters, burglars, and muggers and the courts to actually lock them up for long prison sentences. Whoever actually has a plan to do that could win a lot of votes.

The police are not filling in paperwork, there are just insufficent police. The Tories cut 21,000 officers.

Every party bar the Tories would invest in more policing.

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/08/2022 20:28

If someone broke into my house I too would kill them as I’d want to protect my DD at any cost

Most burglars only attempt to enter empty houses and normally leave immediately they discover someone is inside asleep. This happened to me and he left very quickly.

In this situation, the drug dealer should have been sent down for murder.

giffyg · 05/08/2022 20:28

I can understand the knife because if you go to confront a burgler how do you know what they have or how they fight etc. I could understand a fracas that resulted in a stab wound but not chasing him down to keep stabbing however this is why it's not wise to steal from a drug dealer.

I think 19 yrs is fine but there is such a variety in sentences. Look at those teens who attacked Jack Woodley for fun, some got a minimum of 8 years.

BakewellGin1 · 05/08/2022 20:24

In this case I think it was unnecessary. The home owner was not present, not at risk and planned the attack, arming himself before going to the scene.

However I can honestly say if someone broke into our home whilst my young children were present they would be getting stopped by any means possible.

Cricket bat is a permenant fixture under the bed. DH does actually play that and golf so perfectly acceptable to have them in the house.

My DF has a cricket bat, however to be fair he is a gun owner (due to his hobby) so a 999 call results in the firearms team arriving. We actually found this out by chance when a call was made from a concerned neighbour in the street about my DP next door neighbour and they gave wrong house number to the call handler.

Thinkbiglittleone · 05/08/2022 20:21

If you broke into our house and went near our DS, I would try my upmost to ensure you never got out alive.

If you wanted any of my things, take them, it's stuff I'm not concerned, but I can't differentiate between that, so I will treat you as a threat to our DS if you break in.

Would I plan to go and kill someone, absolutely not. This man deserves to go to jail, he is a murderer.

Sagealicious · 05/08/2022 20:21

user143677433 · 05/08/2022 20:09

@Sagealicious you are quite right and I genuinely and profusely apologise.

I used the older “popular” meaning without thinking. I should have known better, and I will be more careful with my words in future.

Thank you that means a lot. I also apologise if I came across sounding defensive.

user1471453601 · 05/08/2022 20:18

In some American states there is a law of "Stand your ground", which, in its more extreme forms seems to say that there is no legal requirement to withdraw yourself from a situation like burglary.

This person seems to fail, even on that. He didn't withdraw, he actually went there with a deadly weapon.

19 years seems a little on the short side to me.

Gymrabbit · 05/08/2022 20:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 20:12

That's why family members aren't the judge or on the jury. Because you can't make rational or reasonable decisions if your child is involved.

Absolutely. But when arguing that a disproportionate response of violence, resulting in death, should be deemed perfectly acceptable, hypothetically speaking, I would argue, that a person should be able to envisage that the person that was killed was their loved one. Hypothetically speaking. Not 'them or theirs'. But 'ours, and mine'.

user143677433 · 05/08/2022 20:09

Sagealicious · 05/08/2022 19:10

I think if his life had been in danger then it would have been understandable that he reacted the way he did but this is different. His actions are more methodical and calculating and he was aware of what he was doing so was not psychotic - no reports of him suffering delusions, hallucinations or thought disorder which is what psychosis is. It's not a byword for violent.

Sincerely someone who suffers from actual psychosis and who has never been violent.

@Sagealicious you are quite right and I genuinely and profusely apologise.

I used the older “popular” meaning without thinking. I should have known better, and I will be more careful with my words in future.

StickWithYSL · 05/08/2022 20:08

I think it’s right.

it was premeditated. It would be very different if they were at home and it was used as self defence.

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 20:08

YABU

You'd expect the opposite of a disproportionate response

The law is very clear on this

MarshaMelrose · 05/08/2022 20:08

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 19:56

Something I've found quite a useful exercise, is envisioning that the intruder was in someone else's house, and it was your kid.

That's why family members aren't the judge or on the jury. Because you can't make rational or reasonable decisions if your child is involved.

malmi · 05/08/2022 20:07

SaintHelena · 05/08/2022 18:23

The answer is to kill them and dump the body somewhere where it hopefully won't be found. That's my plan.

Hahaha!! Good one!

Or:

Lock them in the cellar as a sex slave!! Forever!!

They leave their human rights at the door lol

dropthevipers · 05/08/2022 20:06

It's all gone a bit Sweeney round here, hasn't it?

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 20:04

I'm talking about personal hypothetical responses, rather than judge and jury. It's important to realise that sometimes (I know, I know!), people you love and care about can do really shit things that if it weren't your loved one, you'd be baying for blood.

It can create perspective and balance.

Frequency · 05/08/2022 20:02

Agrudge · 05/08/2022 19:59

Should we do that with all crimes

All crimes which may motivate you to commit pre-meditated murder.

Agrudge · 05/08/2022 19:59

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 19:56

Something I've found quite a useful exercise, is envisioning that the intruder was in someone else's house, and it was your kid.

Should we do that with all crimes

mbosnz · 05/08/2022 19:56

Something I've found quite a useful exercise, is envisioning that the intruder was in someone else's house, and it was your kid.

Brefugee · 05/08/2022 19:55

Bet you're relieved he didn't find your stash, OP.

You break into my house, you leave your human rights at the door.

Oh you're hard. [eyeroll]
the sentence should be much longer and i hope there is an appeal for it being too lenient

MarshaMelrose · 05/08/2022 19:54

Galliano · 05/08/2022 18:07

The motivation for the burglary was the drug stash the man convicted of the unlawful killing was believed to have in his house. This isn’t an example of a homeowner misjudging what’s reasonable in self defence for which some compassion might be required at all.

I'm not that bothered what happened to either of them, then.

rumplestiltskinp · 05/08/2022 19:51

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at request

PonyPatter44 · 05/08/2022 19:48

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/08/2022 19:41

Why would assume a criminal a better fighter .

Than a random poster on MN? I'm willing to bet quite serious money.

I've worked with offenders up to an including several murderers, a few of whom had killed more than one person. I think I know a few more criminals than most on here.

Exactly this.