Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

that the Man who killed a burglar he saw breaking into his house should not be jailed for 19 years

255 replies

LargeDeviation · 05/08/2022 17:59

He saw the man breaking into his house on a video doorbell, armed himself with a knife and went with his half-brother and killed the burglar. He has been jailed for 19 years.

Yes the violence he used was very extreme, but the burglar was breaking into his home! It is unreasonable to expect a dispassionate response. People should be able to defend their home and their family from intruders, including using force which would be considered unlawful or unreasonable in other settings.

Even if he must be found guilty by law, the sentence should take the circumstances into account and it should be a slap on the wrist.

OP posts:
LargeDeviation · 05/08/2022 18:19

If it's true that this was revenge for an attempt to steal drugs, that changes things. In that case it's just another violent encounter between criminals and this man should indeed rot in jail.

However if it was just a normal person defending their home, I think they are allowed to be 'unreasonable' in their behaviour. I think it's a very understandable reaction to defend your property, and to make a plan to defend your property.

Assuming it's not some drug feud, I agree by the way that the root cause is that people no longer trust the police and the courts and the justice system. If the police actually caught burglars promptly and the courts locked them up promptly, fewer people would feel the need to have-a-go.

OP posts:
TeapotTitties · 05/08/2022 18:16

Agrudge · 05/08/2022 18:15

Do you have a link?

Link to Express story

Sweatinglikeabitch · 05/08/2022 18:15

If they were home then I'd agree but he went out with the intention of killing someone that wasn't endangering his or anyone else's life. If he'd grabbed a knife during a tussle with someone who'd broken in it would be different but he wasn't protecting anyone he was punishing someone.

Agrudge · 05/08/2022 18:15

Do you have a link?

Kedece2410 · 05/08/2022 18:14

Even if he must be found guilty by law, the sentence should take the circumstances into account and it should be a slap on the wrist

Have you actually read the circumstances of this case?

cushioncovers · 05/08/2022 18:14

He deserves 19 years let's hope he serves all of them. The burglar didn't deserve to die although I wouldn't spend much time feeling sad for the him as he was no saint himself.

SleepingStandingUp · 05/08/2022 18:12

Is that the society you really want to live in @LargeDeviation ? Someone does something wrong so it's ok to set off and murder them? So I spot someone sneak their hand into my purse and take my bank card. I can wait until they have their back to me, then improvise with a broken bottle or rock and smash their head in? What if some kid at school pushes my son over? That's worse than theft. Can I arm my son and let him kill the other kid?

bubblescoop · 05/08/2022 18:12

SkiingIsHeaven · 05/08/2022 18:10

You break into my house, you leave your human rights at the door.

You can say that while you’re sat in a prison cell.

jetadore · 05/08/2022 18:12

Having just read the news article on this, I think you must be either trolling or actually crazy to think this man deserves a “slap on the wrist” for what he did.

bubblescoop · 05/08/2022 18:12

This is not self defence. His sentence is correct, if not on the lighter side.

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/08/2022 18:12

SkiingIsHeaven · 05/08/2022 18:10

You break into my house, you leave your human rights at the door.

Budget John Wayne arrived.

Hmm
mbosnz · 05/08/2022 18:12

He was with another person, another male, to defend his home. His response was disproportionate to the threat. The perceived threat was outside his home. There is no 'stand your ground' defence in the UK as I understand it. There is a difference between the sentencing for burglary, and for taking another person's life for a reason. He mades his choices, he paid the price. You could say the same about the burglar, I guess.

TeapotTitties · 05/08/2022 18:11

TwilightSkies · 05/08/2022 18:06

Repeatedly stabbing him in the face and neck?
Why didn’t he just phone the police!?
Its not as if he or any of his family was in the house. It was just possessions.
No, of course burglary is not OK but I don’t think viciously murdering someone fixes anything.

He didn't phone the police because the burglars were after his stash of class A & B drugs that he was dealing.

And after he stabbed him multiple times, he then chased him down the street when he tried to get away and continued to stab him repeatedly.

I'd say the sentence was spot on.

Horological · 05/08/2022 18:11

OP, these responses give really good reasons why he got that sentence. Perhaps you didn't know all the details when you wrote your first post.

Now you know the facts have you changed your mind?

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/08/2022 18:10

That is not in any way OK. That is psychotic.

This. I'm glad he's not walking around right now.

SkiingIsHeaven · 05/08/2022 18:10

You break into my house, you leave your human rights at the door.

TrippinEdBalls · 05/08/2022 18:10

He deserved to go to jail though as he was in no danger and the violence was extreme but not that long IMO as he's not a danger to people who aren't breaking into his house (I assume).

I would say that anyone who could pick up a knife and plan to go kill somebody is very much a danger to everyone.

user143677433 · 05/08/2022 18:09

Galliano · 05/08/2022 18:07

The motivation for the burglary was the drug stash the man convicted of the unlawful killing was believed to have in his house. This isn’t an example of a homeowner misjudging what’s reasonable in self defence for which some compassion might be required at all.

I didn’t know that, but suspected something like that.

So this was a violent man sending a message.

MolliciousIntent · 05/08/2022 18:09

Your reading comprehension and critical thinking skills need serious improvement if you can read this story and think this man's actions are in any way acceptable.

Hearing a noise at night, going downstairs and nailing an intruder with a cricket bat? Fine.

Realising your home is being burgled while you're not there, gathering backup, picking a weapon, going over there and stabbing a man in the face? That's murder.

Natty13 · 05/08/2022 18:08

This effectively means you think we should have the death penalty for burglary. Robbing someone's house is a crime that does not equate to murder.

Galliano · 05/08/2022 18:07

The motivation for the burglary was the drug stash the man convicted of the unlawful killing was believed to have in his house. This isn’t an example of a homeowner misjudging what’s reasonable in self defence for which some compassion might be required at all.

butterflied · 05/08/2022 18:07

He armed himself to kill. He's a killer. 19 years is fine. YABVU.

Staynow · 05/08/2022 18:07

This is what happens when the police are useless IMO. If he knew he could phone the police and they'd be straight round and arrest the burglar and he'd go to jail then he might have phoned the police instead. He deserved to go to jail though as he was in no danger and the violence was extreme but not that long IMO as he's not a danger to people who aren't breaking into his house (I assume).

SemperIdem · 05/08/2022 18:06

If he had been in the house at the time, then I would agree with you.

As it is, he wasn’t. He is a dangerous man who committed murder, and has been sentenced accordingly.

TwilightSkies · 05/08/2022 18:06

Repeatedly stabbing him in the face and neck?
Why didn’t he just phone the police!?
Its not as if he or any of his family was in the house. It was just possessions.
No, of course burglary is not OK but I don’t think viciously murdering someone fixes anything.