Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why healthcare is so short staffed.

111 replies

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 17:56

I'm a new-ish AHP and starting a new job in September. It will be my 2nd role since graduating. I'm not in nursing but I am aware of the stresses of that job.

I do like my role but have experienced some bullying but most people have been lovely, the pay is ok, the pension is good and there will always be jobs in pandemics and recessions. The degree course was especially interesting.

Of course I have some idea why there are staff shortages and subsequent workload but just wanted to gather your thoughts and see if my suspicions are correct.
Would also be great to hear from people who actually did leave and reasons why.

OP posts:
The3Ls · 06/08/2022 09:17

I have just moved into the independent and charitable sector as a senior ahp after twenty years. Once you move the pay scales you spend your time on compliance/ management too much. I was lucky to see two kids a week. I had remote flexible working and no shifts so a cushy number if you like. But all the joy was sucked out managing staff. Even when I saw patients usually the most complex presentations I did not have the head space to work out what they needed. Loving having time to clinically reason again. Not deal with staffs problems - I was reported to be an excellent line manger I just didn't get joy from it

Cornettoninja · 06/08/2022 09:14

MolliciousIntent · 05/08/2022 18:40

Shit pay
Overwhelming responsibilities
Lack of emotional support
Inept and inefficient management
Absurd bureaucracy
Inflexible shift patterns
Incompatibility with family life
Poor treatment from patients
Despicable treatment from management

Yup. This about covers it.

I’ve worked in various roles in the NHS for approximately a decade and a half across various trusts and sadly this list is a recurring one.

I finished in the NHS in an admin role just after the very last full lockdown we had. Working during the worst of it was pretty grim but what finally pushed me over was the complete lack of accountability management had for their staffs well-being. My role was completely computer based I.e perfectly suited to wfh, but instead I was put in a small room converted to office space with eleven other people which was used as a high traffic corridor to equally stuffed offices. We had to have Skype team meetings at our desks like this ‘because of covid’. It was absurd and any questioning of it was slammed down with the force of Thor.

On top of everything else listed above that was enough to make me run as fast as I could as soon as I could.

I’d never say never, but things would have to be really bad for me to consider touching the NHS or that particular Trust again.

drinkingwineoutofamug · 06/08/2022 09:05

@Jolinar the running joke in our trust is the only thing that works is the staff.
Every shift is a blue Peter moment, I'm surprised with don't have double sided sticky tape lying around in the clinic room.

drinkingwineoutofamug · 06/08/2022 09:02

MolliciousIntent · 05/08/2022 18:40

Shit pay
Overwhelming responsibilities
Lack of emotional support
Inept and inefficient management
Absurd bureaucracy
Inflexible shift patterns
Incompatibility with family life
Poor treatment from patients
Despicable treatment from management

This with bells on.
Can I add the bullying culture that seems to be ignored.
And if you say something, you're the bully.
And if you whistleblow you loose your job.

LashesZ · 06/08/2022 08:51

NHS manager here. Completely disengaged senior teams who haven't spoken to a patient in years and lost sight of the real reason we all come to work.
Expectations of additional work without additional resource - there is no other profession where if we don't do everything we need to, people will clinically suffer. The pressure of that and work expectations is not valued or even regarded.
Oh, and bloody cost savings come March. They let us have an overspend on essential COVID incurred costs then ask us to recoup the overspend in the next financial year by cutting back. FFS

Friendship101 · 05/08/2022 19:56

I’m a nurse (band 6) earning 39k if I was full time. I work overtime most days (unpaid). I don’t have the IT equipment I need for my job. The IT equipment I have doesn’t work. I regularly have extra tasks added that need completing but never had anything removed or that can be delegated in my speciality. I dream about work and my to do list. I go on leave and come back to more work as we don’t share caseloads. We have 5 desks in out office for 17 members of the team.

My husband earns 60k, is qualified to the same academic level as me. He works 9-5 with no overtime ever. He has all the equipment he needs for work and it works. He regularly gets thanked for his work and small rewards or bonuses for pieces of work. He isn’t stressed ever as can say no to work when he has more important work and stops taking on pieces of work when going on leave.

Im currently looking to leave to work for a company like my husbands.

JessicaBrassica · 05/08/2022 19:50

I've 3yrs experience as an AHP. Still have an unsafe case load (about 30 people more than I can cope with), no support when I started and no one to learn from, which means for every single patient I have to go back to the evidence base so my interventions are bombproof but take time to put together. This means I mostly work 50hr weeks. I rarely see my 10yo in the week, and tend to pick my teenager up from activities at 9.30 on my way home.
I'm still here because I'm stubborn and I can see that eventually it will be better. I also now have good management. Most sane people would have quit months ago.

loopylum · 05/08/2022 19:46

What do you currently practice as?

Jolinar · 05/08/2022 19:42

Poor pay, poor conditions and a crap work force. Bureaucracy and lack of autonomy. Virtually no ability for a department to adapt to it's workload.

I've worked in private and public sectors and whilst private sector has its stresses you can move company and know it is likely to be different. Private businesses can get rid of crap employees who don't pull their weight. Decent private companies will expand and collapse their work force to meet demand. In public sector, particularly healthcare and statutory services, if you have 50% of your workforce they still have to do 100% of the work otherwise people die. You end up with serious burnout because of it.

I'm talking like for like roles e.g. both need a genetic degree and x years experience or both roles are admin. Not talking private Dr Vs NHS Dr etc.

For example, I work out of a dilapidated building with currently no working toilets and limited running water. We pay for our own tea, coffee, mugs, milk, cutlery and bought our own kettle and fridge. I'm a project manager and on around £40k, so not a bad salary, but I'm doing 2.5 people's jobs and working the hours to evidence that. We get maybe 1 or 2 applicants per job, and they are usually lacking experience or not qualified for the job. I wanted to make a difference, I wanted to be part of the solution to societies ills so took a public sector role. We offer no incentives to get people to stay when they leave despite knowing we can't recruit to fill them, there's no negotiation on salary, there's no benefits beyond the pension and sick pay.

My old job - same salary, fancy city centre office with cleaner, free tea and coffee and filtered water on tap, negotiable pay rises based on performance. There were times I worked waaay over my hours but when it became evident my role had grown to more than one person's ability, we recruited. When we didn't get suitable applicants we increased the starting salary and benefits package and offered better pensions and maternity packages. When staff handed in notice if we felt they were good we would offer incentives to stay. We valued the work force.

The NHS and most public sector is essentially operating like a minimum wage business and expecting excellence. It's not going to happen.

I'm going back to private sector!

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 19:24

It's heartbreaking really. I did care work in the past and that was gruelling and pay was even worse!

OP posts:
theniceunderstandingone · 05/08/2022 19:21

I really feel that the healthcare service could get their numbers up with making the degree a little easier.

Do away with the blasted essays and dissertation (that caused a woman I was studying to attempt suicide as she failed it twice)
Do patients care if their nurse can write a glowing essay with Harvard referencing?! No they bloody don't
The course should be about human biology and drug calculations and emergency procedures not research proposals
Shift patterns are so bad.
Bring back term time for parents or single parents who cannot do nights and weekends
And don't get me started on the pay 🤬🤬

KohlaParasaurus · 05/08/2022 19:19

The NHS is an institutionally abusive employer. Senior management seem to be able to float between roles, never taking the consequences for failure, collecting golden hellos and golden goodbyes and bonuses and gongs from Her Majesty. Those at the coal face are never allowed to feel as if they're doing a good enough job. Meeting performance targets results in tighter targets. An effective working department will be punished for its success with "efficiency savings". Systems and regulations and procedures seem to change every five minutes. Frustration at not being able to give patients, for whom we DO care, the sort of treatment we would ideally like to give them and the constant worry that we'll make a mistake due to exhaustion or trying to juggle multiple tasks. There is little official support if something goes wrong and there will always be someone prepared to stick a knife in your back for no reason other than to entertain themselves. Pay is down in real terms and we turned up, masked and gowned up, and worked during the pandemic and those Thursday claps is the only reward we've ever had. Is that enough?

(Recently left the NHS workforce after 36 years and currently very angry about some of the things I've experienced or had to do over that time.)

Atomicspider · 05/08/2022 19:17

The nhs recruitment process has so many challenges for people that have had a more unconventional career background (self employed for instance) Particularly their very stringent referencing requirements.. often difficult to obtain for eg , sahms . Also the amount of time to train in an academic setting whilst not being paid, with few options to fast track.
The apprenticeships are a good start but hugely competitive to get places.

Ginfilledcats · 05/08/2022 19:09

Not clinical but the dark side (management)

for me and my peers:


  • under resourced

  • under paid

  • over worked

  • too high expectations (ie “here’s an hours notice to provide a detailed plan for cancer improvement and we’re going to hold you to whatever you commit to”, what do you mean you haven’t done it? Also within this hour have you gone round the wards chasing discharges despite not being clinical, several other more competent, qualified people have already been round doing the same thing).

  • bullying from more senior colleagues

  • constant fire fighting

  • No job satisfaction

  • not enough staff

  • not paid for overtime


and for my clinical colleagues, the above x100 plus the added terror of a mistake could harm a patient!

i complain, a lot. But never to my clinical colleagues because I don’t know how they come in every day. They’re heroes.

BaileySharp · 05/08/2022 19:09

It's hard work, underpaid for the level of responsibility (yet some people disagree and think we get paid well - would like to see them pull off a nursing shift), often staffing levels are dangerous due to not enough staff, many jobs are unsocial hours and childcare doesn't cover it

Anon778833 · 05/08/2022 19:06

12 years of a bastard Tory government, worse than Thatcher quite frankly.

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 19:06

I think the high stakes worries me the most tbh.

OP posts:
Techno56 · 05/08/2022 19:05

After ten years of hearing it'll be better when x,y,z happens and it never being true, I left a job I thought I would love and do until I retired.

I am so sad about it but it was damaging me. I am not sure I'll ever feel ok about it.

AlansFungalFootPowder · 05/08/2022 19:01

Most patients are nice but the horrible experiences really stay with you.

Constantly worried about hundreds of peoples’ health/life, even during out of work hours.

The targets are always changing, due to new evidence about safety/cost saving/green agendas on top of just trying to do the basics.

The pressures with lack of staffing means I’m being pushed to work in ways outside my competence and it’s exhausting having to constantly push back and affects working relationships.

I’m paid plenty but I DREAM of a low stakes job. One where the worst mistake has negligible consequences.

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 19:00

Related*

OP posts:
malificent7 · 05/08/2022 19:00

I am no journalist but I am considering my future options. I got a 1st for my uni course and feel that I could put it to good use earning more in a relatedd field but I do love my chosen field...it's the conditions that concern me.

The " getting treated like shit by management" rings true for me.

OP posts:
Society · 05/08/2022 18:58

MolliciousIntent · 05/08/2022 18:40

Shit pay
Overwhelming responsibilities
Lack of emotional support
Inept and inefficient management
Absurd bureaucracy
Inflexible shift patterns
Incompatibility with family life
Poor treatment from patients
Despicable treatment from management

This sums it up perfectly. Your post is a little naive OP. Slightly disingenuously.

fairgame84 · 05/08/2022 18:55

It's shit. I've been nursing 13 years. I work in a niche area where retention is slightly better but we are constantly short staffed due to sickness/mat leave and we are pushed to continue maintaining the same level of care. 4 of us are going on mat leave this month which means 7 on mat leave in total plus 4 off long term sick, so instead of reducing beds to make it safe, they are plugging the gaps with agency and newly qualified staff. This is an area that offers intensive care, it's not appropriate at all. The stress that we are under is leading to burn out. Even when we are full and closed, we are still accepting admissions.
Days off it's constant WhatsApp messages begging for staff to pick up extras and reminding you how short staffing is ready for your next helllish shift.
Unpaid breaks are more and more scarce. Im 30 weeks pregnant and only got one half hour break on a 13 hour shift on Sunday instead of the 2 unpaid half hour breaks I'm entitled to. We often finish late. It's relentless.
It's always been the same but its worse at the minute because we are having massive issues with supply of equipment, medication and consumables which makes the job harder. Stuff just isn't available, including essential kit.

DontKeepTheFaith · 05/08/2022 18:52

Pay does not always reflect responsibility and level of accountability
LacK of support
Pay isn’t always that great and the banding system is shit and does not value experience. You have to climb the ladder quickly, do it very slowly like me and you get a pittance of a payrise when you go up a band because you were top of the previous band.
Unsocial hours
Not always enough flexibility
Endless responsibility.

I came home from work in tears today, the level of responsibility I have feels unsustainable and I am usually very resilient.

Fluffycloudland77 · 05/08/2022 18:51

Your relatively new, we’ll come back to this is 20 years time and see how you feel then.