Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why healthcare is so short staffed.

111 replies

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 17:56

I'm a new-ish AHP and starting a new job in September. It will be my 2nd role since graduating. I'm not in nursing but I am aware of the stresses of that job.

I do like my role but have experienced some bullying but most people have been lovely, the pay is ok, the pension is good and there will always be jobs in pandemics and recessions. The degree course was especially interesting.

Of course I have some idea why there are staff shortages and subsequent workload but just wanted to gather your thoughts and see if my suspicions are correct.
Would also be great to hear from people who actually did leave and reasons why.

OP posts:
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 06/08/2022 14:03

Loads of reasons but where I worked there was a deliberate policy of not filling posts when a member of staff went on maternity leave, reduced their hours or retired. This was to save money.

The workload has also increased, I work in the community and the local population has grown, thousands more homes but no increase in nurses.

Now a lot of nurses leave as the workload is not manageable or safe as well as the terrible money.

I am in a specialist nurse post and hold my own caseload, I make autonomous clinical decisions and hold a high level of responsibility for around 30 grand a year (if I worked FT.)

Beanniebaby22 · 06/08/2022 13:57

KohlaParasaurus · 05/08/2022 19:19

The NHS is an institutionally abusive employer. Senior management seem to be able to float between roles, never taking the consequences for failure, collecting golden hellos and golden goodbyes and bonuses and gongs from Her Majesty. Those at the coal face are never allowed to feel as if they're doing a good enough job. Meeting performance targets results in tighter targets. An effective working department will be punished for its success with "efficiency savings". Systems and regulations and procedures seem to change every five minutes. Frustration at not being able to give patients, for whom we DO care, the sort of treatment we would ideally like to give them and the constant worry that we'll make a mistake due to exhaustion or trying to juggle multiple tasks. There is little official support if something goes wrong and there will always be someone prepared to stick a knife in your back for no reason other than to entertain themselves. Pay is down in real terms and we turned up, masked and gowned up, and worked during the pandemic and those Thursday claps is the only reward we've ever had. Is that enough?

(Recently left the NHS workforce after 36 years and currently very angry about some of the things I've experienced or had to do over that time.)

This is exactly why ☝🏼

Pasithean · 06/08/2022 13:52

Currently in hospital. There are three nurses doing their masters in nursing . They are all from the African continent and are planning to go to Australia as soon as they have qualified to join family.

BorisJohnsonsHair · 06/08/2022 13:47

Oh and charging for health professional degrees

BorisJohnsonsHair · 06/08/2022 13:47

Brexit.
Chronic underfunding.
Massive amounts of stress to staff.
Covid.

Cornettoninja · 06/08/2022 13:35

Topgub · 06/08/2022 13:04

@malificent7

You sound pretty money focused op.

I doubt the public sector is for you.

No one can afford to be completely altruistic when it comes to how they fund their existence. It’s gradually become the case that public sector jobs simply don’t afford a large percentage of employees the luxury of more than a basic (if that) standard of living.

Of course that’s a similar story across lots of industries but there’s a tipping point where people simply can’t afford to work in the jobs the rest of society needs to function. Not a great place to be generally when things like healthcare are crying out for staff.

SofiaSoFar · 06/08/2022 13:18

ifoundthebread · 06/08/2022 10:10

To me this is why. 5 years training to be paid the same as someone who picks knickers in a warehouse. I personally couldnt imagine putting myself through years of hard work to get a job with unimaginable amounts of stress, a work load thats unmanageable to be paid the same as someone who works 6-2, 1 weeks training and no crazy workloads.

I think £14/hr after tax for picking in a warehouse is pushing it a bit, but I get your point.

(£14/hr take home pay is ~£40k per year, gross.)

Topgub · 06/08/2022 13:04

@malificent7

You sound pretty money focused op.

I doubt the public sector is for you.

Hazelthecat · 06/08/2022 12:18

I used to work for the NHS and left due to very low pay, long inflexible shifts and regular unsocial hours, bullying and sexist culture, timed toilet breaks, high responsibility and blame culture for mistakes, few progression opportunities and lack of support for staff dealing with death and trauma on a regular basis. It wasn't hard to find a job with better pay and better conditions than that!

traintraveller · 06/08/2022 12:15

OP I knew this was going to be you when I read the title. You've started so many threads on your new career and job options - not that there's anything wrong with that. What is it you want us to tell you?

Lapland123 · 06/08/2022 12:07

Agree with all that’s been described above
i have very recently left as

no suppprt by management to staff a failing service
left to do loads of absent colleagues work for no extra pay
colleagues taking long term sick leave leaving those of us left behind with their work
patients and families then complaining about the service- but there is no service! If you’re the one at work you’re the one who gets it in the neck
huge real time pay cut since tories can in and kept us well below inflation rises for 12 years- so my salary had effectively dropped by 38%

malificent7 · 06/08/2022 12:03

I mean i hope i manage to stick it out for a bit as the pension is good but I am keeping my options open. It all sounds very familiar to me!

OP posts:
Jolinar · 06/08/2022 11:57

RuthW · 06/08/2022 11:51

This. Took us 6 months to replace one receptionist as no one wants the job

No-one wants the job with the current pay and conditions!

I remember when public sector jobs were highly sought after, valued and better paid than others.

RuthW · 06/08/2022 11:51

NeedAHoliday2021 · 05/08/2022 17:57

We lost 12 in one week to a local supermarket paying better.

This. Took us 6 months to replace one receptionist as no one wants the job

ChampagneCharlieIsMyName · 06/08/2022 11:45

My youngest daughter left the army (so she’s not afraid of hard work or long hours) and after a few years of being at home with her children she returned to work.

After a year or so working as a NHS nurse she left to pursue a complete change of career. She worked various wards and clinics, then A&E
Long hours, low pay, lack of appreciation from her colleagues, bosses and even patients (she was spat at, sworn at, threatened, punched and slapped etc)

She now works for a cleaning firm, she pretty much sets her own hours, never has to work a night shift, never finishes two hours after her contracted hours have finished and is on comparable money. After traveling to her local hospital 30 minutes + each way on the train, she is financially and mentally better off.

weird isn’t it, people leave jobs where they are not appreciated and not really paid appropriately to do lesser jobs but with different benefits.

her husband has his own business so between them childcare is much easier now he knows exactly what hours he is needed to be home with the children.

Technically she can still work bank shifts if she wants some extra cash, but I don’t think she misses it.

KangarooKenny · 06/08/2022 11:31

Because they don’t replace people to keep costs down.

ifoundthebread · 06/08/2022 11:30

Topgub · 06/08/2022 10:13

@ifoundthebread

The difference is the factory worker won't ever earn more.

The doctor will.

Theres nothing stopping a factory worker moving up the ranks?

missingeu · 06/08/2022 10:52

Shit pay for the expertise, knowledge and actual work we have to.
Under staffed
Under valued
Majority of patients are lovely.
Entitled patients.
Having to fight for equipment that's essential for your work.
Lack of equipement
Unsocial hours, I work 2 weekends in a month and it's meant to be only 1.
Unfair staff treatment -because I can do deal with the difficult patients - I'm the default person.
Constant messaging to work extra hours.
Never being able to take break due to the work demands.
High managers sending emails on Friday evening for urgent work to be covered over the weekend when theres no staff.
NHS England recevied NO special payout that Scotland and Wales received for there work they did over Covid.
Social care, how underfund it is and the knock on effect that has.
You can earn more money working for Aldi/lidl.

daffodilandtulip · 06/08/2022 10:40

I started in 2000 bringing home £1000 a month. I quit in 2018 and was bringing home around £1300 a month.

Management avoiding any responsibility and you getting the blame for everything.

Ridiculous and dangerous caseloads.

Zero flexibility in shifts, in fact so much so that it's clearly awkward on purpose. As a newly single mum with primary aged children and no support, I temporarily reduced to 3 days to help with childcare. I was given late Friday, late Saturday and early Sunday every week. I was not allowed requests and ended up going off sick in order to find a new job.

I worked in mental health and saw horrific things. I had no supervision or support.

Managers who have never been nurses, shouting at you in front of everyone else, like you're five years old.

It's not the job. It's just the system. It's toxic.

PancakesWithCheese · 06/08/2022 10:29

Never seeing management unless the shit hits the fan, then you just get the finger of blame.
No staff, everyone’s off sick or leaving.
Despite the workload being heavier, patients bring sicker, more and more extended roles, more paperwork the staffing template remains the same.
Lack of recruitment and retention.

One of my jobs is to support newly qualified staff but I’m constantly being pulled to work on the wards which means I can’t support them, so they leave because of lack of support. No one can win.

Everyone is burnt out and exhausted after covid.

Pay is shit so lots of staff do bank to earn extra to just stay afloat.

Paniniandsalad · 06/08/2022 10:26

It's been relentless for years with austerity and cutbacks bit the burnout is real atm. I've worked as an AHP for almost 20 years and hearing the stories of therapists qualified in the last 3 years and how they have treated is heart breaking. Many will leave and I don't blame them.

Paleshelter · 06/08/2022 10:26

I've been a qualified nurse for 30 years, part time since my children were born.
Looking at my wage slips the other day, realised my take home pay has only increased by around £200 or less per month in the last 12 years for my set hours, I've been the same grade.
I do extra shifts when child care allows and have just joined an agency that pays a lot more, at least double what I earn in the NHS.

Scepticalwotsits · 06/08/2022 10:24

From a relative that works in healthcare, (clerical)one of there hugest bug is that everything is so manual, there is a lack of joined up technology. It means they just throw budget and people at the problem, but invariably the budget isn’t enough so there isn’t enough people so people get stressed and burnt out.

if there was a better IT and people of the caliber to use it you wouldn’t need as many people, the ones working would be less stressed or more efficient and the budget saved could be put back into the front line.

cushioncovers · 06/08/2022 10:19

malificent7 · 05/08/2022 17:56

I'm a new-ish AHP and starting a new job in September. It will be my 2nd role since graduating. I'm not in nursing but I am aware of the stresses of that job.

I do like my role but have experienced some bullying but most people have been lovely, the pay is ok, the pension is good and there will always be jobs in pandemics and recessions. The degree course was especially interesting.

Of course I have some idea why there are staff shortages and subsequent workload but just wanted to gather your thoughts and see if my suspicions are correct.
Would also be great to hear from people who actually did leave and reasons why.

You will find out in time op.

SRK16 · 06/08/2022 10:18

Insane caseloads meaning carrying unsustainable levels of risk, patient safety an issue, not offering a good service, constantly chasing your tail. Shit management, money flushed down the toilet.
soul destroying.