Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner refusing to wear bike helmet

204 replies

Minky719 · 05/08/2022 17:15

Hello Mumsnet,

I’m fairly sure I’m not being unreasonable here but wanted to get some further opinions on this.

DP purchased a bike recently and has been enjoying going for bike rides after work in the good weather. We live in the middle of a large City, so much of the cycling is done on main roads.

The issue I’m having is he just refuses to wear a helmet. He didn’t originally purchase one when he got the bike which I called him up on, and he did then buy a helmet soon after. It fits fine so no issues there, but he’s probably worn it once.

He’s just gone out on a bike ride and yet again is not wearing a helmet. I told him before he left now that I’m not happy about it and asked him why he can’t just wear one when he can see it bothers me (not to mention the very obvious dangers associated with not wearing one). His response is that’s he’s a competent cyclist, he’ll be fine etc. Of course I do not want him to have an accident, but I don’t know how to make him realise it’s important to wear one!

I completely get it’s his choice and there’s no legal requirement to wear one but AIBU here?

Thanks

OP posts:
OneTC · 08/08/2022 14:39

(so gloves would actually offer more appropriate protection)

And that's the one thing I won't ride without. Most people don't realise that's what gloves are for

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 08/08/2022 01:38

Do you wear a helmet when you're travelling in a car?
Statistically you are more likely to suffer a head injury in that situation.
If not, YABU to expect your partner to wear one...
Unless he's participating in downhill mountain biking/ other racing/ circus tricks, the chance of him falling off his bike and hitting his head is extremely low. There is evidence that people who wear bike helmets are more likely to let their heads hit the ground, and those who don't are more likely to put their hands out (so gloves would actually offer more appropriate protection). And there's a possibility that wearing a helmet makes it more likely that you suffer from rotational spinal injury.

I ride a bike pretty much every day, and having assessed the risks for myself, don't even own a helmet. Most of the cyclists who have been killed while riding in London in recent years were crushed under HGVs, something a helmet would not have prevented.

The Bicycle Helmet Research Foundation used to compile links to lots of factual information and proper research on this website: https://www.cyclehelmets.org/ which might be better that relying on assumptions and anecdata.

I agree with PPs who have pointed out that what we need is well-designed cycling infrastructure, that people of all ages can use to make journeys without having to share space with larger, heavier, much faster vehicles.

We could also do with more training, for drivers as well as cyclists. In places where everyone is sharing the same road space, adopting an assertive position (usually in the centre of the lane), riding in a predictable way, making eye contact and clearly communicating intentions to other road users are all ways that people can reduce the risks.

Mischance · 07/08/2022 23:07

Lunar270 · 07/08/2022 22:16

Except it's not blindingly obvious as studies show that drivers react differently to cyclists who do/don't wear helmets.

Statistically you're still unlikely to be involved in an accident so it's really not an obvious decision and down to personal preference.

There were around 4000 serious injuries in 2019 vs around 6 million cyclists. That's a really small percentage.

I am not talking about what drivers do or not do but about what happens to your unprotected head if you come off a bike!!

It is a no-brainer - if you come off a bike and hit your head you are in the shit in a big way. Wear the blessed helmet!!

StripeyDeckchair · 07/08/2022 22:40

Well I hope he's written his will and that you have good life insurance on him.
id also ask him to leave instructions on what to do if he incurs life changing / ending injuries.

Yeezytiger · 07/08/2022 22:34

Tirednorthener, i'm sure you have plenty of car drivers/ passengers in icu as well

Tirednortherner · 07/08/2022 22:28

ICU nurse here.

A bike rider will always come off worse in an accident. I witnessed a bike vs van with no helmet and the man’s brains covered the road.

Bike vs van or car with helmet is the difference between life and death.

If he wants to be that stupid, he needs to put the finances in order and decide what organs he wants to donate. No one thinks it will happen to them.

YANBU x

Lunar270 · 07/08/2022 22:16

Mischance · 07/08/2022 18:06

As I said above, if a car runs over your body, a helmet will not help. If a car causes you to bash your head on the kerb, then a helmet will help.

It just seems so blindingly obvious to me. Wear the blessed helmet! You do not know which bit of you will be traumatised in an accident - you do not get to choose.

Except it's not blindingly obvious as studies show that drivers react differently to cyclists who do/don't wear helmets.

Statistically you're still unlikely to be involved in an accident so it's really not an obvious decision and down to personal preference.

There were around 4000 serious injuries in 2019 vs around 6 million cyclists. That's a really small percentage.

Needthesun · 07/08/2022 18:16

Rodion · 05/08/2022 17:27

I'll preface this by saying I always wear a helmet BUT I was reading a few years ago that there is a school of thought against helmets. It relates to risk from cars etc rather than risk of falling off by yourself.

Research has shown that other vehicles will give a much wider berth and behave more carefully around cyclists that are not wearing any protective gear, particularly helmets. Cyclists that did wear helmets were therefore more likely to be struck by a car as the cars drove closer to them. Obviously once you're at the point of being knocked off you'd rather be wearing a helmet, but (apparently) statistically you were at a greater chance of suffering fatal or life- changing injuries if you wore a helmet. There were even some a&e consultants championing the no helmet idea!

This is very interesting as I was just saying the same thing to DH recently.

Whilst I’m always careful driving around cyclists, I give those without a helmet a much wider berth in that I won’t even attempt to overtake, even if safe. Not because they’d be more hurt by being hit but because I simply don’t trust the judgement of someone who cycles without a helmet. I don’t trust them not to swerve into my path or to stop at lights/ follow the rules of the road.

Yeezytiger · 07/08/2022 18:12

Usa - motorbikes are not comparable as they are much more powerful and faster

Yeezytiger · 07/08/2022 18:11

Rampantivy - the the statistic about car drivers giving helmetless cyclists more space came from various studies including this one
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0001457506001540

Mischance · 07/08/2022 18:06

Lunar270 · 07/08/2022 18:02

But what @Dotjones is saying is correct. Helmets only work in low speed impacts.

I know a disproportionate number of people who have been killed whilst cycling and a helmet made no difference in all cases because being run over by a car trump's a bit of polystyrene.

I wear a helmet but do this knowing that it'll only work in a limited number of instances. Therefore it's all about your attitude to risk. Nothing else.

As I said above, if a car runs over your body, a helmet will not help. If a car causes you to bash your head on the kerb, then a helmet will help.

It just seems so blindingly obvious to me. Wear the blessed helmet! You do not know which bit of you will be traumatised in an accident - you do not get to choose.

USaYwHatNow · 07/08/2022 18:06

My husband rides a motorbike. He is a competent and confident rider. If it was up to him he'd never come off, but he wears the gear for all the knob heads that seem to like to drive to close etc etc. Same for cyclists, you can be as confident and confident as you like but you can't account for people not looking where they're going etc.

Lunar270 · 07/08/2022 18:02

FlippertyGibberts · 07/08/2022 16:33

You're entitled to make your own decision regarding whether you wear a helmet or not, but you're categorically not entitled to your own facts 😄.

Bike helmets reduce the risk of serious injury or death.

But what @Dotjones is saying is correct. Helmets only work in low speed impacts.

I know a disproportionate number of people who have been killed whilst cycling and a helmet made no difference in all cases because being run over by a car trump's a bit of polystyrene.

I wear a helmet but do this knowing that it'll only work in a limited number of instances. Therefore it's all about your attitude to risk. Nothing else.

megletthesecond · 07/08/2022 17:42

He should wear one on the road or if he goes fast.

Mischance · 07/08/2022 17:38

Look - let's be clear about this .....if you fall off or are knocked from your bike and your back/leg/arm take the impact then a helmet will be no help. If you fall or are knocked from your bike and your head takes the impact, then a helmet will be of help and could save your life - or a lifetime as a head-injured invalid.

Unfortunately the choice of which portion of your anatomy takes the impact is not yours to make - you have to take what you get.

Just wear a helmet - the consequences of head injury are both awful and far-reaching.

Hbh17 · 07/08/2022 17:06

Ultimately it is his choice, so you need to respect that. The very distinguished Olympic cyclist & road safety campaigner Chris Boardman is opposed to helmets, so maybe you need to look at the alternative point of view too. I don't think it's as straightforward as most of us believe.

hotfroth · 07/08/2022 16:54

Eunorition · 06/08/2022 09:52

It's completely a personal choice. There's evidence and studies that show they have little to no benefit and can make cycling more dangerous as cars treat you even worse. I never wear one and would deeply dislike anyone trying to tell me to do so. Mind your own.

In all my 40+ years as a driver, I see the cyclist and the bike. I don't pay any heed to whether or not they are wearing a helmet, so I think these studies are misleading.

Besides, many of the accidents are where the vehicle driver hasn't seen the cyclist at all, so whether they were wearing a helmet or not had no effect on the driver's actions.

When I was 13 my best friend died of a fractured skull. I genuinely believe that anyone who doesn't protect their brains needs them examined. And preferably not when they are splattered all over the road.

SproutsAtChristmas · 07/08/2022 16:40

Hope his life insurance and will are written and take care of you accordingly!

AndreaC74 · 07/08/2022 16:35

RampantIvy · 07/08/2022 11:54

I really don't buy the idea that motorists give helmet wearing cyclists less room and consideration.

As a driver (and sometimes cyclist) I give all cyclists the same amount of room (lots) and consideration

Your not all drivers

I've short ish hair, my DD long, we've tried it, if she was behind me, less close passes.

I wear a helmet but if i was hit by a car/truck, its not going to make the slightest bit of difference.

I just wish drivers would slow down, being passed at 60mph 1.5m away is quite intimidating, why do you do it? Do you think its funny or some other kick?

FlippertyGibberts · 07/08/2022 16:33

Dotjones · 07/08/2022 15:51

Bicycle helmets are next to useless if you are hit by another vehicle. They're designed to protect the wearer from very low impact falls, basically falling to the ground from a stationary position. If a cyclist is competent enough to not fall off by themselves while not moving (eg by remembering to put their foot on the ground) then cycle helmets will not help at all. Even in a 20mph accident they are useless - they are just made of polystyrene.

You're entitled to make your own decision regarding whether you wear a helmet or not, but you're categorically not entitled to your own facts 😄.

Bike helmets reduce the risk of serious injury or death.

MrsAvocet · 07/08/2022 16:32

Fairly balanced article from RoSPA here, including an explanation of why "just" polystyrene is the material of choice for most helmets.
Obviously helmets perform better in some circumstances than others, and they are not a panacea, but I think it's unlikely that the UCI and, to my knowledge, every national cycling regulatory body, would mandate them for all forms of racing if they were of absolutely no use in anything other than very low speed impacts.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=www.rospa.com/media/documents/road-safety/cycle-helmets-factsheet.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwiazIivgrX5AhUGAsAKHXwjCTkQFnoECAsQAQ&usg=AOvVaw2pLTxL8Z82JBlbx7NWTZ0o

OurChristmasMiracle · 07/08/2022 16:23

Honestly I don’t understand why there is no law to make cyclists wear a helmet- moped, motorbikes and horse riders all have to wear helmets- It’s not seen as a choice for them so why is it a choice and not a requirement for cyclists?

so no YANBU to expect your DP to take a reasonable precaution to protect himself

LunaMuffinTop · 07/08/2022 16:02

YANBU I’ve had this same
argument for the last 5 years with my DH he just doesn’t seem to care about his own safety worst part is my grandad was knocked off his bike and killed by a car driver but my DH just keeps telling me he knows his routes and he’s careful but like I keep saying he might be being careful but how does he know that the car behind him or in front of him is being careful as well it only takes a split second for a cyclist to disappear from a drivers view for them to get hit.

ManateeFair · 07/08/2022 16:01

Loads of people don’t wear them and there’s no law that says you have to. He’s a grown man and it’s up to him so YABU.

Dotjones · 07/08/2022 15:51

Bicycle helmets are next to useless if you are hit by another vehicle. They're designed to protect the wearer from very low impact falls, basically falling to the ground from a stationary position. If a cyclist is competent enough to not fall off by themselves while not moving (eg by remembering to put their foot on the ground) then cycle helmets will not help at all. Even in a 20mph accident they are useless - they are just made of polystyrene.