Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner refusing to wear bike helmet

204 replies

Minky719 · 05/08/2022 17:15

Hello Mumsnet,

I’m fairly sure I’m not being unreasonable here but wanted to get some further opinions on this.

DP purchased a bike recently and has been enjoying going for bike rides after work in the good weather. We live in the middle of a large City, so much of the cycling is done on main roads.

The issue I’m having is he just refuses to wear a helmet. He didn’t originally purchase one when he got the bike which I called him up on, and he did then buy a helmet soon after. It fits fine so no issues there, but he’s probably worn it once.

He’s just gone out on a bike ride and yet again is not wearing a helmet. I told him before he left now that I’m not happy about it and asked him why he can’t just wear one when he can see it bothers me (not to mention the very obvious dangers associated with not wearing one). His response is that’s he’s a competent cyclist, he’ll be fine etc. Of course I do not want him to have an accident, but I don’t know how to make him realise it’s important to wear one!

I completely get it’s his choice and there’s no legal requirement to wear one but AIBU here?

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1471447863 · 10/08/2022 22:10

All those that think wearing a helmet is embarrassing or somehow uncool, remember they are probably an overweight middle aged man wearing lycra so the helmet isn't going to be the make or break decider in the cool/uncool argument.
Also, nobody is really noticing you that much - it's hardly like everyone you pass is going to point and laugh at you for wearing one.

And as for cool - how cool do they think they are going to look spending the rest of their life drinking out a sippy cup and waiting for a carer to come and change their nappy? Because sadly that's the reality of a head injury, one that could be reduced or avoided by wearing a helmet. If you've ever spent any time in a hospital neuroscience ward you'll see how life changing brain injuries can be - even in the lucky ones that 'get better'.

RampantIvy · 09/08/2022 08:13

As almost all Dutch cycle, they're just better drivers when it comes to sharing roads with cyclists.

Becasue the roads are wider and there are more cyclists in the Netherlands, and maybe they are better and more considerate drivers and more used to seeing cyclists on the road.

In the UK you just have to (unfortunately) assume that all motorised vehicles are arseholes (I know they aren't) and cycle accordingly.

I guarantee if every driver in the UK was forced to ride a bike for a few months, we'd have much more tolerance between road users.

I agree (as a cyclist and car driver)

Lunar270 · 09/08/2022 07:58

It's not just the infrastructure though. As almost all Dutch cycle, they're just better drivers when it comes to sharing roads with cyclists.

Winding narrow roads are simply not an issue though, if you know how to drive properly in the first place. I manage quite well as a cyclist and driver.

I guarantee if every driver in the UK was forced to ride a bike for a few months, we'd have much more tolerance between road users.

RampantIvy · 09/08/2022 06:56

Marvellousmadness · 09/08/2022 00:36

Go visit Holland for a bit. Noone wears a helmet there.

Their infrastructure for cyclists is far superior to here though. You can't compare a wide flat road to the hilly, winding lanes where I live.

Marvellousmadness · 09/08/2022 00:36

Go visit Holland for a bit. Noone wears a helmet there.

Lunar270 · 09/08/2022 00:32

Neither can I, given that all the posters who work in healthcare at the sharp end are saying the opposite.

But with due respect, most Dr's and nurses aren't specialists in dynamics so aren't typically qualified to judge the relative merits of a myriad of accidents involving head impacts. It's largely conjecture whether the same person would've been significantly better off with/without as helmets are mostly only tested up to 14mph and using a drop test method. Unlike car NCAP tests, dummies aren't used and realistic (high speed) road accidents aren't simulated, essentially because they're not designed to provide that level of protection.

Helmets are a massive compromise and not all helmets are equal. Most people I see riding look like they've spent the least amount of money possible and don't even wear them properly. I'd imagine most don't even change them regularly, rendering them useless. Drop one accidentally and they're also useless and need replacing straight away. That tells you a lot about the limitations of cycle helmets.

I wear one and spent a lot of money on a highly rated Specialized but am under no illusions that it'll do anything as I'm mostly cycling well above 14mph.

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 09/08/2022 00:24

Watchkeys · 09/08/2022 00:07

Ah, well, @Caramelsmadfuzzytail , if it says it on Bored Panda, it must be true.

Don't be mean.
I just happened to see it. Maybe it could be a visual aid to the argument of not wearing a helmet.
Personally I don't ride a bike because my knees are fucked.

Watchkeys · 09/08/2022 00:07

Ah, well, @Caramelsmadfuzzytail , if it says it on Bored Panda, it must be true.

Caramelsmadfuzzytail · 09/08/2022 00:02

There is a website called bored panda, I went on there yesterday and there was a thread showing various helmets of accident victims that basically showed the fact that helmets stop head injuries.

OneTC · 08/08/2022 22:40

I never argue against helmets, like I said before they make everything better all of the time, every activity you can think of, a helmet will always be a benefit except maybe diving.

But I do argue against making people wear them

RampantIvy · 08/08/2022 22:35

I can’t really understand why some posters are so determined to argue against helmets.

Neither can I, given that all the posters who work in healthcare at the sharp end are saying the opposite.

I wouldn't cycle on any of my local roads without a helmet. They are narrow, winding country lanes and the chances of being clipped by a car and knocked off my bike are higher than being on a cycle lane in a city.

It's obvious that ending up under the wheels of a lorry is going to be bad news regardless of what you are wearing, but in the main most people are thinking of more minor accidents where wearing a helmet would make quite a difference.

Claiming to be a careful cyclist is silly because an accident is something unexpected that you can't anticipate - like a pedestrian stepping in front of you or an animal running out in front of you.

Herejustforthisone · 08/08/2022 22:23

If you bullseye a windscreen because a driver hasn’t seen you, you really want to be wearing a helmet…

Herejustforthisone · 08/08/2022 22:21

He should spend a few hours in resus in A&E.m. The difference between a cyclist vs car if the cyclist was or was not wearing a helmet, is chilling.

Divebar2021 · 08/08/2022 17:33

God @Slowlyslippingaway what a terrible event for your family. I’m waiting for someone to post that your anecdote isn’t relevant as has been posted above.

I can’t really understand why some posters are so determined to argue against helmets. Cyclists know that if they end up under the wheels of an HGV that a helmet isn’t going to save them. However there are so many other ways that accidents can happen. My DH was wiped out by a pedestrian stepping out in front of him while on her phone. I’ve had drivers open their doors of parked cars in my path. Poor weather conditions, black ice. One cyclist was killed having slipped on gravel in Richmond park. ( no-one else involved) and the collision i mentioned previously with 2 cyclists hitting head on. ( one without the helmet died) I would have thought even if helmets offer only a slight benefit that it would be worth it given the risk of life altering injuries or death.

Slowlyslippingaway · 08/08/2022 16:18

Your DP is crazy and it is not just his life that he will affect if anything goes wrong.

My DH was still relatively young when he was knocked off his bike on a rural road one beautiful summer morning.

It was the back of his head that hit the road. His brain bounced, with mid line shift and he destroyed his frontal cortex. He survived 10 weeks in a coma before dying, but not before he had gone through surgery, had half his skull removed and we had gone through 66 days of uncertainty as to whether he would survive, or die. 66 days of stressing about whether he would live the rest of his life in a vegetative state, not knowing who we were and with very little quality of life.

The financial mess he left behind changed my life and that of our children irrevocably. With no life Insurance our home had to be sold and the emotional trauma and loss from what happened has never left me. To the extent that I have never had another relationship and I live my life constantly nervous about what else is just around the corner …..

I will never know why his helmet wasn’t on his head that day. He normally wore one. But no helmet meant no claim against the driver he who hit him, or rather no guarantee that a claim would succeed. It also meant that he was vilified by the press and even blamed by friends and family, despite the fact that the evidence was strongly supportive of my belief that he was not to blame for the accident.

Sorry OP. I don't think you are being unreasonable at all. Your DP needs to recognise that he is not invincible and if it all goes wrong it will very likely cause terrible trauma for you and your family as well as changing his life for ever.

RedRocketGirl · 08/08/2022 16:05

Abra1d1 · 05/08/2022 17:23

People in cities where cycling is a big part of life: Cologne, Amsterdam, etc, don't wear helmets. I wonder how their head injuries compare with ours. Or is it because they have more cycle-safe areas?

I don't wear one all the time on our quieter country roads.

There is some evidence to show that women cyclists are safer without helmets, because their hair makes them more obviously female and so drivers slow down. I don't know if that's been updated.

Very true but as you suggest the big difference is that those cities have a much better cycling infrastructure, along side a legal system that assumes an accident between a cyclist and a car is the fault of the car driver, so its much safer to ride there. I cycle regularly in the UK and abroad and won't get on a bike without wearing a helment - it's just common sense. I also ride with a women's cycling club that has very distinctive kit - there is no doubt that we are women and unfortunately it doesn't seem to make any difference to how car drivers pass us.

Watchkeys · 08/08/2022 16:04

@MaryBlighthouse

I came off my bike and ended up in hospital with a head injury. As I lay bleeding at the side of the road, another cyclist fell off in the same spot. He had a helmet on, so just got up and back on his bike

Your anecdote isn't really relevant. There are robust scientific studies on the subject.

WinnysPinny · 08/08/2022 15:39

He’s an adult

MaryBlighthouse · 08/08/2022 15:31

He’s an idiot. On the one day I didn’t wear a helmet, I came off my bike and ended up in hospital with a head injury. As I lay bleeding at the side of the road, another cyclist fell off in the same spot. He had a helmet on, so just got up and back on his bike. The ambulance man who took me to hospital said he is a cyclist and he never used to wear a helmet till he started that job and started seeing all the cyclists with head injuries.
A friend went over his handle bars after a pedestrian walked out in front of him and he crashed straight into her. He crashed head down onto spiked railings. The only reason he is alive/ not permanently brain damaged is because he was wearing his helmet.

Anythingbutsnow · 08/08/2022 15:26

My DH was like this but once he really got into it, he realized that it's not cool to ride without a helmet. No serious cyclist thinks it is.

gatehouseoffleet · 08/08/2022 15:25

bumblingbovine49 · 08/08/2022 15:23

Some male car drivers are quite aggressive to a man on a push bike with a helmet on. My husband always wore helmet when he cycled to work but on the odd occasion he didn't for whatever reason he said he always got less hassle . Maybe it's to do with that

I think drivers see someone in lycra and a helmet and think road hogging MAMIL.

Whereas if you wear normal clothes and no helmet you look like you are using a bike for transport rather than just blocking the road for the sake of it, so people are more patient.

gatehouseoffleet · 08/08/2022 15:24

Helmets also stick out a lot further than your own head, so more likely to actual hit the helmet into an object, hence all the "Helmet saved my life" stories

Also this. And I also think that people keep their helmets too long, so if they do have any sort of impact, they just collapse. I think you are meant to replace helmets every five years.

bumblingbovine49 · 08/08/2022 15:23

Some male car drivers are quite aggressive to a man on a push bike with a helmet on. My husband always wore helmet when he cycled to work but on the odd occasion he didn't for whatever reason he said he always got less hassle . Maybe it's to do with that

gatehouseoffleet · 08/08/2022 15:22

It is a no-brainer - if you come off a bike and hit your head you are in the shit in a big way. Wear the blessed helmet

If you get squashed by a car a helmet won't help you.

And the only time I've hit my head was when I slipped on some ice (on foot). Should all pedestrians wear helmets too?

It's not about infrastructure, it's about perceived risk. German kids walk themselves to school from a very young age. Dutch kids cycle all over the place from a very young age.

UK kids have to wear helmets and be driven to school in massive SUVs. Does nobody see the connection between the two?

AndreaC74 · 08/08/2022 15:13

@Longtimelurkerfinallyposts Actually you are spot on, even in pro racing, the number of head injuries pre and post UCI helmet introduction is pretty much the same.
Helmets also stick out a lot further than your own head, so more likely to actual hit the helmet into an object, hence all the "Helmet saved my life" stories.

Having said all that, i wear a helmet, modern ones have great air flow and in my particular Kask one, aid flow over my head in hot weather plus if you did have an accident, its likely any pay out etc could be less without one.

imho track mitts offer little protection & none for the back of the hand.