Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girl tried to pull down my son’s shorts

297 replies

dontwanttooverreact · 05/08/2022 14:10

My son is 4 and he went to a 3 hour camp at our sport’s club today. He had been yesterday with a school friend and today with the same friend. After pick up today he told us that a 10 year old girl had tried to pull down his pants and shorts “to see if he was a girl or a boy”.

he is upset, this was his first experience of camp and he is quite shy. Additionally the school friend independently told her mother the exact same story so i believe it (I believed it anyway but you never know with 4 year olds and details.

he told the supervisor who apparently said something to the girl but no one told us at pick up.

AIBU to be furious? I had assumed initially the girl was also 4/5, but 10?!? Surely that’s not on? What, if anything, can I do?

[Title edited by MNQ at poster's request]

OP posts:
Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 20:02

Cr22345678990 · 05/08/2022 19:53

Call the police and call ofsted it all needs investigating. It doesn’t matter who said what and what this supervisor has to say even if it is her son don’t worry about that. Don’t send your son there anymore either. You need to be thinking the worst really what if he goes back and he is sexually assaulted next time. My son is the same age and I would be absolutely fuming I wouldn’t give a shit what any of the staff had to say I would be reporting it end of.

What would you hope the police would do? What would you hope ofsted would do? If she takes her son out and it happens again in another club (as its common), what then? What would you hope an investigation would do? If the children where supervise and there is CCTV proof where do you think the investigation would lead?

Cr22345678990 · 05/08/2022 19:53

Call the police and call ofsted it all needs investigating. It doesn’t matter who said what and what this supervisor has to say even if it is her son don’t worry about that. Don’t send your son there anymore either. You need to be thinking the worst really what if he goes back and he is sexually assaulted next time. My son is the same age and I would be absolutely fuming I wouldn’t give a shit what any of the staff had to say I would be reporting it end of.

LittleHeapOfBooks · 05/08/2022 19:53

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 05/08/2022 16:16

Exactly right! My 10 yo DS pull the trousers of a younger girl down and everyone kicked off..

Just a practical joke ... God. I told him not to worry about it . ..

Would it just be a joke when the mother or father of the next little girl you've given him the green light to abuse gives him what he deserves?
(I.e. a good thumping, perhaps a cast, maybe a trip to the dentist. Suppose it depends how angry the are their daughter was violated by the little sicko...)

Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:52

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:48

@Greenleaf22

I asked you "Be honest - would you actually say to your four year old daughter, if she came to you upset and told you a ten year old boy had pulled her skirt down because he wanted to see if she had boy or girl privates, "it isn't anything to be worried about and he only did it once so it's a joke, not bullying"?"

And you said "Yes of corse I would" followed by some questions you'd ask, but you've said yes you would respond that way.

I hope it never happens to a son or daughter of yours then as dismissing upsetting behaviour that involves someone double their age pulling their pants down (which was the example I asked you about) is pretty vile.

It's scary you work in schools tbh.

100% I would as it’s happen once not many times so it’s not bullying. You can’t protect kids for every situation and things will happen when they mix with other kids. It’s not “pretty vile” at all it’s inappropriate but it stops there there’s no sexual assault or harassment. I think you need to get your head out the clouds as the things kids know and do is scary tbh.

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:49

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:47

@wellhelloitsme who said I didn't grasp anything?

I never said this was ok

I never said this particular incident was teasing

I mentioned pantsing to people claiming 10 year olds would never do it to other 10 year olds and there must be a sexual element to this. Whereas that's clearly not true in all cases

Also as an FYI -

'Laws surrounding sexual harassment generally do not prohibit simple teasing, offhand comments, or minor isolated incidents'

This definitely counts as a minor isolated incident, therefore illegal this wouldn't be

As a PP said, your posts on various threads today are bizarre. Enjoy your evening 👍🏻

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:48

@Mookie81 and you clearly don't understand sarcasm

The poster you jumped on was joking Confused

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:48

@Greenleaf22

I asked you "Be honest - would you actually say to your four year old daughter, if she came to you upset and told you a ten year old boy had pulled her skirt down because he wanted to see if she had boy or girl privates, "it isn't anything to be worried about and he only did it once so it's a joke, not bullying"?"

And you said "Yes of corse I would" followed by some questions you'd ask, but you've said yes you would respond that way.

I hope it never happens to a son or daughter of yours then as dismissing upsetting behaviour that involves someone double their age pulling their pants down (which was the example I asked you about) is pretty vile.

It's scary you work in schools tbh.

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:47

@wellhelloitsme who said I didn't grasp anything?

I never said this was ok

I never said this particular incident was teasing

I mentioned pantsing to people claiming 10 year olds would never do it to other 10 year olds and there must be a sexual element to this. Whereas that's clearly not true in all cases

Also as an FYI -

'Laws surrounding sexual harassment generally do not prohibit simple teasing, offhand comments, or minor isolated incidents'

This definitely counts as a minor isolated incident, therefore illegal this wouldn't be

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:44

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:32

@StillHappy who is minimising bullying?

I'm simply stating this isn't a crime

He tried to pull OP's four years old son's shorts down and specifically said it was because he wanted to see if OP was a boy or a girl - by looking at his genitals.

The fact he was unsuccessful is lucky, but it doesn't change the fact that he attempted it, does it?

And it is illegal. Because technically sexual harassment and is explicitly described as such in guidance to schools and pupils.

It's important children feel able to tell grown ups when the pants rule has been broken. That's why it's taught in education settings across the UK. OP has done the right thing taking this seriously rather than shrugging it off.

A ten year old tried to pull her four year old son's shorts down, specifically to expose his genitals. It's bizarre you don't seem to grasp that the size, age and power disparity between them, and the fact they don't really know each other, means that this is nothing like a couple of older kids who are mates doing something that is an in joke / something they both find funny.

Her four year old was understandably upset and confused. Thank god some adults don't tell children they're silly to be upset and confused if a stranger double their age and size tries to pull their trousers down.

Girl tried to pull down my son’s shorts
Girl tried to pull down my son’s shorts
Girl tried to pull down my son’s shorts
Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:44

TailSpinner · 05/08/2022 19:41

Kids do silly things, in my school many children hit each other on the backside, one had a dress on and a little boy pulled her pants down, boys hit other boys in the Willy in my other school the boys have taken to pulling each other’s trousers down but none of this is sexual assault or harassment unless it was target at a specific child every time.

I hope you mean in your school when you were a child and not one you’ve worked in recently - because times have very much moved on from when this was seen as just ‘silly’ behaviour. Bums and genitals are off limits, simple as that. Fact is, in ten years time if the child behaved that way they may well end up getting arrested - so these aren’t classed as ‘silly things’. We teach them that it’s unacceptable in the same way that punching someone in the face or using racist language is unacceptable.

No I mean in the schools I work in currently, so no times haven’t moved on as children will be children and do touch each other’s bums/genitals, simple as that. So yes they are classed as silly things that kids find funny.

Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:41

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:35

@Greenleaf22

Children are learning and find things funny, but pulling another child’s trousers down once isn’t sexual harassment it’s just funny to kids,

Be honest - would you actually say to your four year old daughter, if she came to you upset and told you a ten year old boy had pulled her skirt down because he wanted to see if she had boy or girl privates, "it isn't anything to be worried about and he only did it once so it's a joke, not bullying"?

Really?

Bullshit would you.

Yes of corse I would, I would ask has it happen before? No. Did he touch you? No. Does he ever play any games with you? No. Does he sit next to you? No. Does he ever hold your hand? No. Does he ask for a cuddle? No. I would then explain to my child that the boy was being silly and I will make sure i speak to the teacher about it.

TailSpinner · 05/08/2022 19:41

Kids do silly things, in my school many children hit each other on the backside, one had a dress on and a little boy pulled her pants down, boys hit other boys in the Willy in my other school the boys have taken to pulling each other’s trousers down but none of this is sexual assault or harassment unless it was target at a specific child every time.

I hope you mean in your school when you were a child and not one you’ve worked in recently - because times have very much moved on from when this was seen as just ‘silly’ behaviour. Bums and genitals are off limits, simple as that. Fact is, in ten years time if the child behaved that way they may well end up getting arrested - so these aren’t classed as ‘silly things’. We teach them that it’s unacceptable in the same way that punching someone in the face or using racist language is unacceptable.

Mookie81 · 05/08/2022 19:39

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:33

@Mookie81 I guess you don't understand the concept of posters joking

Not interested in engaging with you, your responses on a number of threads has concerned me.

Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:37

Mookie81 · 05/08/2022 19:27

Completely agree.
As a teacher (who has taught 10 year olds) and a safeguarding officer I'm appalled at the responses downplaying what has happened.
This boy will probably do it again to another small child who won't be able to get away.
I'd be speaking to the police.

What would you say to the police? What would you expect the outcome from the police to be? What would you do if the child that pull the trousers down parents put a complaint in? Complain about you personal for exaggerating? In your school what happens to a child if they do such a thing?

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 19:35

@Greenleaf22

Children are learning and find things funny, but pulling another child’s trousers down once isn’t sexual harassment it’s just funny to kids,

Be honest - would you actually say to your four year old daughter, if she came to you upset and told you a ten year old boy had pulled her skirt down because he wanted to see if she had boy or girl privates, "it isn't anything to be worried about and he only did it once so it's a joke, not bullying"?

Really?

Bullshit would you.

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:33

@Mookie81 I guess you don't understand the concept of posters joking

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 19:32

@StillHappy who is minimising bullying?

I'm simply stating this isn't a crime

Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:31

wellhelloitsme · 05/08/2022 15:34

Pulling down someone's clothing to show their genitals is defined as sexual harassment legally speaking, if you'd prefer that term?

Kids do silly things, in my school many children hit each other on the backside, one had a dress on and a little boy pulled her pants down, boys hit other boys in the Willy in my other school the boys have taken to pulling each other’s trousers down but none of this is sexual assault or harassment unless it was target at a specific child every time. Adults cannot do anything about it as kids can’t be watched all the time as there’s far to many of them. Children are learning and find things funny, but pulling another child’s trousers down once isn’t sexual harassment it’s just funny to kids, if it happened every time OPs son went to the club then yes that would be bullying as well as sexual harassment but one time isn’t anything to be worried about.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 19:30

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 17:10

There is a difference when looking at this as a crime though

Which is what many posters are trying to do

Maybe you can read the context of replies before quoting them

Those trying to minimise this sort of bullying, as you are doing, must come from a very different background to me.

Mookie81 · 05/08/2022 19:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lacey247 · 05/08/2022 19:28

Oh god I would absolutely hit the roof over this!!!

Mookie81 · 05/08/2022 19:27

SofiaSoFar · 05/08/2022 16:11

I'll tell you what is typical MN: people minimising this because the victim is a boy.

If the thread was about a 10yo boy trying to pull down a 4yo girl's shorts and pants "to see whether they're a boy or a girl" I really don't think you'd be so dismissive.

Appalling that this is being played down so much by some people.

Completely agree.
As a teacher (who has taught 10 year olds) and a safeguarding officer I'm appalled at the responses downplaying what has happened.
This boy will probably do it again to another small child who won't be able to get away.
I'd be speaking to the police.

StillHappy · 05/08/2022 19:23

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 15:28

@wellhelloitsme pantsing is a known 'practical joke'

It's not right nor appropriate but this is a far cry from sexual assault

They did it, explicitly, to see his penis.

Greenleaf22 · 05/08/2022 19:14

namechanged4it · 05/08/2022 14:40

And also perhaps training needs to be given to staff and procedures put into place so this doesn't happen again.

What procedures should you suggest as kids are kids and do silly things within seconds for no reason? For it not to happen each child would need to be supervised by an adult each at all times and that’s never going to happen.

Mookie81 · 05/08/2022 19:13

namechanged4it · 05/08/2022 14:38

I agree. Police at that age is way too much but certainly camp shod be looking into it. No way should parents details be passed on.
4 and 10 is a bit old to mix but sometimes ar camp they have breaks and lunch all together to allow the supervisors to have a break.

It is inappropriate but they are all kids at the end of the day, the girl just needs to be told.

Would you say it's way too much to Jamie Bulger's mum?
10 years old is more than old enough to know that's massively wrong.