Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult son wants to move back mon - fri to ‘get a night’s sleep’

762 replies

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 13:58

DS 27 and his gf recently had a baby. As you’d expect they are being woken up during the night. DS has asked if he can move back in mon - fri so he can get a proper night’s sleep so he can concentrate on going to work and do his job effectively.

DH thinks the idea is outrageous and he should just ‘get on with it’ , I feel a bit confused as to why he is even asking. Surely other new parents don’t do this? I get sleep deprivation is hard, but I am not overly enamoured with this idea. But I don’t want to be unsupportive either - how would you respond?

OP posts:
ShinyBeans · 06/08/2022 22:35

Snowpaw · 05/08/2022 18:38

If you're on your knees with sleep deprivation the answer is go to bed at 7pm when the baby does for a couple of nights to catch up. Its hard, and it means you get no down-time, but its life. Or you sleep in "shifts" so that you're both getting a decent chunk. Or one of you MAYBE goes and stays one night elsewhere as a one off to catch up, not Mon - Fri forever and ever!

My cousin's wife told me that she has always slept in a different room with the babies because my cousin is "awful if he's had no sleep" - aren't we all?! I felt really sorry for her.

We did the sleeping in shifts thing too. It was the only way we could both get a chunk of sleep. I would head to bed the moment DH got home, so around 7pm. At about midnight (or the nearest feed to then) DH would pop DS and the moses basket next to me in the bedroom and go to sleep on the sofa. We'd both get 5-6 hours each night. There was no "napping when the baby naps" in the day. DS would wake every 10 minutes unless he was being held and had undiagnosed cow's milk allergy so would cry for hours on end. Those first 12 months were the worst of my life and the sleep deprivation was largely responsible for that.

WhackusBonkus · 06/08/2022 22:29

Hang I think we are missing something here.. you say his gf recently had a baby. It is HIS baby, right? If so, that’s a strange way to word it. They’ve BOTH had a baby surely… if it’s his, it’s as much his baby as his girlfriend’s and to not be there with them is unthinkable

If, as occasionally happens, they’ve got together after she became pregnant by someone else and it’s not his child, if he wants the relationship to work, he STILL needs to be there as he’s taken them on as a package. Or if he can’t handle that package then yes it needs to end.. she needs a full time partner not a weekend boyfriend.

Teenagehorrorbag · 06/08/2022 22:28

Goodness - so much vitriol! If the OPs son does everything he says (and who are we to challenge that) then I think he is being a good Dad. Sleep is very important for many jobs, so it may not be unreasonable if he has the option of a peaceful place to kip, to suggest that (for one or two nights a week, anyway). Especially if they are staying with her sister so not even in their own home! Most babies sleep through after a couple of months so it's presumably a short term thing, and if GF is OK then why not?

Of course if there are other issues or she has PND or baby is difficult, maybe not ideal. But for a few weeks it might not be the end of the world

We had twins and I bottle fed, slept in with them and wouldn't have dreamed of disturbing DH unless we had to - he works with machinery but not a pilot or surgeon or anything. But he worked and I didn't, I could doze in the day or walk around like a zombie for a few weeks, I don't get this assumption people have that the working parent should 'suffer' as much as the non-working one just to show solidarity - sleep is important!

CheshireCat1 · 06/08/2022 22:28

That’s family life.

Rocky1989 · 06/08/2022 22:28

He is still your son and he is struggling regardless of what you or anyone else thinks of him or her tbh, it's really easy to judge. Bottom line is he's struggling BUT so is she! I wouldn't give him the easy option out because she doesn't even get an option! And it will only distance them as a family unit, But more of a guidance from you and your DH on teamwork and get them to have a good heart to heart and if they love eachother they will work out what they can do to help eachother and if not then they didn't really care that much in the first place (hopefully not)

YorkshireRog · 06/08/2022 22:21

No… also it would seem like you were implicit in removing her support as as also new parent

Dorabella6 · 06/08/2022 22:16

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 14:04

Yeah I agree - he should be sharing the work load, but his argument is when he gets back from work he does ‘everything’ for the baby- feeding, bathing, cleaning all the bottles, laundry, cooking etc. it’s difficult because he’s really struggling and does seem to be doing more than his fair share when he can

His GF is presumably still recovering from the birth and looking after the baby all the rest of the time. She will be Exhausted! I doubt he is actually doing more than his share, but it's concerning that this is an issue for him.

EL8888 · 06/08/2022 22:15

@HippPippy You're re-writing the narrative now. You started off saying it was understandable due to his job and you seemed inclined to let him stay

You are now re-working it to wanting to "give them support", after people on here have given you a reality check

mandlerparr · 06/08/2022 22:15

As a parent, you already know he is lying about do all those things every day, because not all of those things are everyday things. You don't bathe a baby daily; it is bad for their skin. He does what, 1 possibly 2 feedings a day if it is a newborn. What 3-person family has a load of laundry per day? If it is done at a laundromat, that will be hard for her with a baby all day and she would probably jump at the chance to leave the house if that were so. So, 2-3 times a week he is putting laundry in? Either at home, which is barely work for 1 load or away from home, meaning he can't possibly be doing all the other stuff he is claiming to do on those days. And how many of those dinners are takeout, pizza, canned, frozen, 20 minutes of work or less? I had two babies, 1 and newborn, worked full time after maternity, did all the cooking and cleaning and parenting. Then, when they got older, I did all that and added in a full-time student course. Tons of people do this. And frankly, if he is willing to sleep at your house, he should be willing to take the couch. My husband slept on the couch with earplugs. I sleep with headphones in and white noise on. Just enough to block the night noises that don't need attention but lets through anything louder. There are so many holes in his story and so many other solutions that he could have done first. I don't think he is trying to get some sleep. I think he is trying to escape. I think he is trying to ghost his family. He needs to see someone to talk to about why he overestimates his contributions and why his first solution was to run away.

Rocky1989 · 06/08/2022 22:14

I really hope they can sort it out between them 🤞🤞

Rocky1989 · 06/08/2022 22:08

It is hard work with a new born baby and the day passes by so quickly with what seems like not a lot done but survival mode (at least for the first few months I felt)I completely understand that he feels like he's doing everything when he is home and my husband felt exactly the same but that is what team work is alllllll about! We sat down and talked . . . . I suggested to my husband that I would let him have an hour or so downtime when he walked through the door as his job was very manual but then it was his turn.He would do the bath whilst I did dinner, then he would do dinner and bed so I could have a bath and down time myself even if it was just 1/2 hours to myself to feel human again lol and I would have a lie in saturday and him sunday, He would do a 10pm dream feed whilst I was in bed at 9pm and I would do the 3am night feed because he was working ect ect.However if she is on his case as soon as he walks through the door and through the night, that's really not fair eaither.I feel like that unless he is a brain surgeon ect, he shouldnt get a free ride.I feel like they both need to sit down with both yourself and your DH and given some guidance about "Teamwork" and speak to eachother because if they dont I don't feel like whatever they have will last.Parenthood was not meant to be easy but many people do it and it won't always be hard, actually very Michelle quite the opposite when the baby stage has passed 🙂

wentworthinmate · 06/08/2022 22:06

What an awful lazy selfish son you have. And he managed to procreate. Poor gf and poor gc. Let him do it so he can work harder to earn more money to pay maintenance for the child when the gf gets shot.

RedToothBrush · 06/08/2022 21:59

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 14:04

Yeah I agree - he should be sharing the work load, but his argument is when he gets back from work he does ‘everything’ for the baby- feeding, bathing, cleaning all the bottles, laundry, cooking etc. it’s difficult because he’s really struggling and does seem to be doing more than his fair share when he can

Hmm yes and?

Thats not an argument. Thats being a parent and not a deadbeat useless twat.

generalh · 06/08/2022 21:56

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 14:04

Yeah I agree - he should be sharing the work load, but his argument is when he gets back from work he does ‘everything’ for the baby- feeding, bathing, cleaning all the bottles, laundry, cooking etc. it’s difficult because he’s really struggling and does seem to be doing more than his fair share when he can

Oh bless! Imagine having to parent? Tell him to get a grip. He is probably embellishing his actual involvement to plead his case to have a child free week. Not a decent chap really is he?

Pants0nFir3 · 06/08/2022 21:52

Fooker needs to use his balls and step up. That's it.

lemmein · 06/08/2022 21:49

Iflyaway · 06/08/2022 21:10

Wow, we single mums had all that too.

Don't let him run back. He'll thank you eventually.

I agree with this. I mentioned earlier my DB wanting to do something similar, I said no, he stayed at home, they worked it out.

Now his kids are 12&15, he's a brilliant dad. He and my SIL eventually split 10 years later but it was an amicable split and they share responsibility of their DCs. Had my DB left when the DCs were little I doubt very much he'd have a relationship with them now.

ilovemydogandmrobama2 · 06/08/2022 21:47

As someone who works in safety critical work and a DH who does the same, it's really tricky. We are fortunate to be able to juggle rooms so we can both sleep and when the DCs were younger, it was mostly DH who was on shifts.

But there were numerous times when he went to his mother's house or his brother's after a night shift, for instance when the DCs were toddlers and impossible to keep quiet.

Is this about him getting sleep that he needs, or is this about his relationship with his girlfriend breaking down?

Lochjeda · 06/08/2022 21:40

Hope you can help them sort out some solutions. If the mum is struggling I don't think your ds being as yours every night is a good option.

Maybe he should stick some ear plugs in and at least if she really needs him one night and is struggling she can hand him over. Maybe she is struggling due to lack of sleep. It made me feel completely like I was losing the plot and although you say your ds is great when he gets back it doesn't sound like she gets much help at night.

My dh would stay up till about 11pm with our kids downstairs and id go to bed about half 8 or 9 and he would give the last feed. I breastfed so it was expressed milk in a bottle just incase she does. Then when they came up and I was woken for the first night feed id had a good 6 hours of solid sleep. Maybe a suggestion.

Kamenakawena · 06/08/2022 21:28

Set light to myself I meant 🔥

Kamenakawena · 06/08/2022 21:26

I haven’t read all 25 pages but get there are a lot of posters projecting their issues here.
No one knows what your son or his GF are actually going through or thinking of doing except them. Although you may have spoken by now so know more.

instead of making it about themselves why can’t posters just look at your post.

Your son wants to stay at home, it isn’t your job to sort his relationship- so why wouldn’t you say yes? You could also let his GF stay too when they feel she needs to.

Seems now all the snowflake mums want to stay at home with the baby but claim the dad’s who work must help because they can’t cope with staying home so dads have their share too.

sleep deprivation goes with new babies but sah patent should expect to have more than go to work parent.

i could set light to muse to save mums et doing it

but just help don’t try solve the relationship or this generation’s issues

MrsLeister · 06/08/2022 21:25

Scottishskifun · 06/08/2022 21:04

Your son needs to sort this out with his GF sort out shifts with the baby if baby doesn't sleep well. I'm in agreement with your husband.
I also find it disconcerting slightly OP that your opinion is that your DS "does everything" for baby when he gets home....I mean what do you think his gf has done all day whilst he's at work? The concept that because he's at a job he should come home and not be doing the nappies and bottles and giving his gf a bit of a break seems a bit old fashioned to me!

This!!

MrsLeister · 06/08/2022 21:19

I can’t see if anyone else has said this yet. But as a wife to a man with 4 brothers, a close relationship with my mother in law and my own son I could take a big guess that isn’t his partners take on it.
He may feel he is doing “more than his fur share” but honestly, it’s doubtful. If you asked her what she’s doing whilst hes
doing these tasks it’s unlikely she’s doing nothing. Try and set your mind back to how much you were doing with a new born and how you had to be on 24/7.
In my experience sons tend to exaggerate their contributions to their mothers (my MIL is very wise to it). This may not be the case but I’d get his partners perspective or take what he said with a pinch of salt.

Nanananananana99 · 06/08/2022 21:16

AnneLovesGilbert · 05/08/2022 14:00

DH is right. How would you have felt if he’d left you 5 days a week when DS was a baby?!

Have a word with your son and tell him to grow up.

This

His poor gf.

whynotwhatknot · 06/08/2022 21:14

sounds like not a stable relationship really what happened when they came round

S1m0nX · 06/08/2022 21:12

Perhaps you can suggest they both have one night a week to stay with you while the other looks after the baby - if his desperate for sleep imagine what it must be like for her x