Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult son wants to move back mon - fri to ‘get a night’s sleep’

762 replies

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 13:58

DS 27 and his gf recently had a baby. As you’d expect they are being woken up during the night. DS has asked if he can move back in mon - fri so he can get a proper night’s sleep so he can concentrate on going to work and do his job effectively.

DH thinks the idea is outrageous and he should just ‘get on with it’ , I feel a bit confused as to why he is even asking. Surely other new parents don’t do this? I get sleep deprivation is hard, but I am not overly enamoured with this idea. But I don’t want to be unsupportive either - how would you respond?

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 05/08/2022 15:02

If he says he does more than his fair share when he gets home from work, I'm not sure how his GF will be happy for him to not be there during the week. That doesn't seem to add up

Eeksteek · 05/08/2022 15:01

I would explore the terms a bit. If he’s expecting to turn up at 10.30pm, crash out go to work, go home to his family, give mum a proper break until 10.30pm, and literally just sleep at yours, maybe. But she also gets some protected sleep time. Equal if she’s working, but still some if even if she isn’t. GF would still be
parenting alone 20 hours a day. Pretty sucky. He doesn’t work 20 hours a day, even on call.

If he’s literally expecting to live with you Mon-Fri and only parent at all at weekends, while having lots of lovely adult free time weekdays, no fucking way. That’s not how this works, kiddo.

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 05/08/2022 15:01

OP do you not remember how hard those early weeks and months are? Just wondering if you’ve forgotten as your concern mainly seems to be for your son when it’s his partner that, in reality, likely needs the support.

My husband worked most days and evenings when our children were babies and I was on my own a lot with them. I also did all the night feeds and DH slept downstairs for a good few years. For all intents and purposes…not there…but I would have been devastated if he had physically moved out for a portion of the week. Where’s the solidarity, the love and care, the companionship, the emotional support just by being there. It’s awful that he would contemplate such a thing.

Denny53 · 05/08/2022 15:00

One thing we did for our son and DIL when they had their 4 th baby and were very sleep deprived, was we booked mum and dad into a local pub for the weekend
We had the 4 children overnight, mum and dad were able to have some lovely together time, some decent food - without the preparation and washing up and more importantly could stay in bed all day if they wanted. They said it was the best baby present ever. Maybe you could do something like that OP?

RoseslnTheHospital · 05/08/2022 15:00

@converseandjeans "sleep when the baby sleeps" is fine if you have a baby that will be put down and left, and sleeps for a decent chunk of time! I would have burst into tears if someone had suggested that with either of mine, who would never be put down in the day. I remember watching one of my NCT friends just put her asleep baby down on a sheepskin in the middle of the room and leave him for a nap at a few weeks old. I was amazed as mine would only nap when mobile in the pram or being held.

AquaticSewingMachine · 05/08/2022 15:00

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 14:42

I think the job is very important here.

Actual brain surgeons do shifts and on-calls and operate on broken sleep alllllllll the time.

Wheresthebeach · 05/08/2022 14:58

I think that's an appalling suggestion. To absent himself for the week?? He's trying to duck out of the relationship and fatherhood IMO.

NerdyBird · 05/08/2022 14:58

Are you sure she isn't kicking him out? But anyway, even if GF is fully happy I'd say no. He can go to a hotel.

If you think GF isn't really ok with it then offer help to both but not in the form of your son just opting out for most of the time.

WhimsicalGubbins · 05/08/2022 14:58

I’d respond by verbally supporting his poor partner! I’m outraged on her behalf that he thinks his sleep is more important than supporting a new mother. When exactly does she get to have a full night sleep? Given that she’s got to be coherent enough to safely look after a newborn all day?
Id tell him in no uncertain terms to grow the F* up. If he’s not mature enough to be a supportive dad then he should have thought about that before making a a baby.

Ponderingwindow · 05/08/2022 14:54

I would tell him that if he has a job where people’s lives are on the line, he should get some earplugs or some noise canceling headphones. However, the mother of his child needs to be able to tag him in if she needs him, which means he must be present in the home.

Mummyoflittledragon · 05/08/2022 14:53

If you and your dh have the time and energy, I’d think it would be more productive to help them out or help them get in into a routine with the baby than to facilitate this request.

Moonandstars2118 · 05/08/2022 14:53

Looking after a baby is a “safety critical job” though!!
It requires the parent to be rested enough to stay awake especially if the baby will only contact nap…

Whammyyammy · 05/08/2022 14:52

Your son is a selfish, self centred dick. I feel sorry for his gf and child. What's he going to do when the child is teething, or unwell? Run home to mummy's every time?

LIZS · 05/08/2022 14:50

Yes it is critical he is alert and can concentrate- other peoples safety is at stake

At what point would he feel ready to return home though, many children do not allow their parents a proper night sleep for months or even years. Meanwhile she is left to struggle. If he has used his paternity leave already maybe he needs to plan in some days' leave to catch up on rest or as others suggest use ear plugs, sleep in another room, sleep in shifts and take turns for lie ins on days off etc. How recent is the baby?

Goldfishjones · 05/08/2022 14:50

Well his suggestion is ridiculous but you can point that out and still be supportive. They could take it in turns for the odd night of uninterrupted sleep (if the gf is not bf) but you could also do some cleaning for them, take round some meals, do a supermarket shop, nip over during the week and hold the baby or walk it round the block whilst gf has a hot cup of tea/ takes a shower/loads the dishwasher etc. All those things are so helpful and make you feel less alone and more rested as a new parent.

If your son has the odd night at yours it needs to be on the basis that he gives his girlfriend equal respite in whatever way she needs, it's hard to believe he is the kind of person who would recognise this and actually carry it out tho. Probably worth a chat with his girlfriend to find out what's really going on.

KettrickenSmiled · 05/08/2022 14:49

But I don’t want to be unsupportive either - how would you respond?

"Son, I don't want to be unsupportive - of your post-partum wife - so stay the fuck at home & act like a parent you unutterably precious little twat."

That should fix it OP.
You might also want to check in with your DiL why he is being such an arse, & how much support he is actually giving her.

PurpleFlower1983 · 05/08/2022 14:49

Jesus Christ tell him no! He can sleep in the spare room or on the sofa if he needs uninterrupted sleep but he needs to be on hand when he’s needed! What a selfish man!

converseandjeans · 05/08/2022 14:49

I think maybe he could do a night midweek. But Monday to Friday is ridiculous.

Going against the general opinion here but I found being on maternity with a baby much easier than working full time as a teacher. If his job genuinely means others are at risk if he's overtired then maybe something needs to change. His GF can sleep when baby does - I used to do house chores when mine were awake but go back to bed at lunch when mine were napping. It is possible to keep up with housework and shopping with one baby. Maybe she's not keeping up and he has to do loads when he gets in.

Could you support in a different way? My parents used to have my niece & nephew most Saturday afternoons & then all day Sunday so my brother and his wife had time off. I never got that but think that you could maybe consider it to support him if you're able to? I know some grandparents have baby for sleepover a night a week. Can they afford a day with childminder?

Also maybe they need to work on getting baby into a routine so it sleeps & isn't keeping him awake. Again I realise that's an unpopular view on MN but I don't think it's sustainable to go for months sleep deprived.

Sartre · 05/08/2022 14:47

Your DH is right and I feel very sorry for your DIL, your DS is being a selfish prick.

smileandsing · 05/08/2022 14:47

carefullycourageous I don't agree. Many many people in safety critical jobs manage this issue without moving back to their parents house and becoming part time dads

Lifeisonhold · 05/08/2022 14:47

I’m so sad for his gf! :( what a selfish pleb.

Goldbar · 05/08/2022 14:45

If he moves in with you Mon-Fri, you may end up having to house him full-time when his girlfriend realises that actually he's useless and she can parent just as well on her own without a man child in the house. There's no guarantee she will let him come back.

They need to have a sensible conversation. I'm a bit sceptical of the "he needs to sleep so he can do his job safely" argument because you generally find that many women doing these sorts of jobs also have caring responsibilities and suffer from interrupted sleep and yet they cope. However, assuming he has a point, it might be reasonable for girlfriend to do most of the weeknight feeds on the basis that he takes over from her when back from work and does the evening stuff while she sleeps. What is not reasonable is for her to do all evenings and all overnight wakings... they need to take turns and do shifts.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/08/2022 14:45

I would be saying absolutely no way and be having some very strong words with him.

I cannot fathom any other response. Are you not embarrassed that a son you raised even considered asking?! I suspect your husband is giving you the side eye wondering just how far you’ll go to coddle your son.

smileandsing · 05/08/2022 14:42

PeekAtYou's suggestion is the answer, along with separate rooms if possible, and ear plugs. You can support by babysitting when your grandchild is older.
The first few weeks and months are hard on all parents. New dads either get on with it, regardless of their work demands, or decide it's not for them and wind up single seeing their children every second weekend. He needs to step up, but I doubt he will.

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 14:42

I think the job is very important here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread