Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult son wants to move back mon - fri to ‘get a night’s sleep’

762 replies

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 13:58

DS 27 and his gf recently had a baby. As you’d expect they are being woken up during the night. DS has asked if he can move back in mon - fri so he can get a proper night’s sleep so he can concentrate on going to work and do his job effectively.

DH thinks the idea is outrageous and he should just ‘get on with it’ , I feel a bit confused as to why he is even asking. Surely other new parents don’t do this? I get sleep deprivation is hard, but I am not overly enamoured with this idea. But I don’t want to be unsupportive either - how would you respond?

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 05/08/2022 20:02

I'm sympathetic to them for finding it hard, we found our first very difficult, and that was in a stable committed marriage with our own house. It sounds like their circumstances are more difficult.

However, he needs to decide what kind of partner and father he wants to be. Moving out five nights a week and leaving his child's mother to do all the groundwork is deadbeat dad territory.

Again, it sounds like your husband would be well placed to talk to him.

namechangetheworld · 05/08/2022 20:02

How so? I've read through the whole thread and I didn't see anything about the baby having extra needs or being paticularly demanding

Peashoots · 05/08/2022 20:01

You don’t seem to like your grandchild’s mum very much. Not believing for a minute that he’s as hands on and supportive as you would like to believe. Maybe she “scowls” a lot because she’s had a baby with a pathetic boy who wants to run back to mummy because he’s tired?

EgonSpengler2020 · 05/08/2022 19:57

IrisVersicolor · 05/08/2022 19:12

So all the doctors, nurses, pilots, emergency workers need to move out when they have a baby for public safety? What about the women? What do they do?

I’ve never heard anything so ridiculous in my life.

If their house is big enough that they can go somewhere quiet and get adequate sleep to be able to do their job safely then they don't need to move out, if not then parents house, caravan outside, b&b is the next best option. They are paid to do a job and do it safely. If you spend a little time googling I'm sure you'll find examples of members of those professions you've listed who have fucked up, someone has died and they've ended up in prison.

My DH slept in a different room the night before his long commutes (and spent two night per week away for work) because people do fall asleep and crash their cars and if that had happened my DD would not have had a father to worry about whether he did the correct share of her care or not.

H3ll00 · 05/08/2022 19:57

Haven’t read the full thread but could you offer to have the baby one night a week/fortnight so they can both get an undisturbed nights sleep? This stage wasn’t too long ago for us and it went on for over a year. It was awful and we look like absolute shells of our former selves.

AchatAVendre · 05/08/2022 19:42

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 17:30

I’m really starting to wonder this myself. The baby was completely unplanned. She got pregnant as soon as they met. He was over the moon, but I’m not sure she was. He seems a lot more excited generally. She just scowls a lot - I know it’s hard but she doesn’t say much.

She scowls and doesn't say much? Really? Have you tried making conversation with her in the normal manner?

She doesn’t work, has no interest in working

Well, like it or not, thats the type of woman your son is attracted to and the type of woman he sleeps with without using protection. If he really got her pregnant "as soon as they met", you better procure an STD test for him because its quite likely he is doing it with other women as well, and if you indulge him by housing him when he runs away from his baby son, then you might have future babies and scowling girlfriends to deal with.

Presumably your parenting covered using protection and getting STD tests before sleeping with new partners, along with not getting women your son barely knows pregnant?

Cherrysherbet · 05/08/2022 19:37

I’m going to be honest and go against the grain here.

If it was me, I would let him stay. It wouldn’t be up to me to dictate how my Son handles this situation.

If he is struggling, then I would help.

He will still be doing all the things he normally does in the evenings.

If you force him to stay in this situation, then he could make a mistake at work.

If his GF is doing the days, he’s taking over in the evenings, then sleeping at yours once everything is done. Where’s the issue?

Stripedbag101 · 05/08/2022 19:37

And if he truly in a job were he is response for multiple lives (train driver, pilot, air traffic controller, surgeon) then he should be able to afford rent for a home for his family, rather than staying with his girlfriends sister!

he can also afford noise cancelling headphones for one or two nights a week if he is really struggling.

Ihadenough22 · 05/08/2022 19:37

My feeling is that your son always had you there to Molly coddle him. You were there to do everything and make his life easier.
He got his gf pregnant. He may have had no idea of the reality of a new born baby or had much experience with babies up to now.
Having a baby is hard work and it takes time to adjust and to get use to the reality. So you work out between you when one person can sleep for a few hours when the other minds the baby.
You just don't run back to mammy asking can you sleep in your childhood bed for 5 nights a week.
I was surprised that your husband did not tell your son to go home and grow up.

My feeling is as well that you don't like your son's girlfriend but she is the mother of his child.
Why don't you call over some day to see her and ask her how she is? See if you can help her out or even bring the baby for a walk when she has a shower.

Call over in the evening just to see if your son it doing all he says because my feeling is that he is doing the bare minimum.

He is a grown man with a baby so it's time for him to grow up and pull his weight with his gf and baby.

achillestoes · 05/08/2022 19:30

‘Someone who has a full time, high pressure job (which they potentially drive to and from) needs more sleep than a SAHM. Much of being a SAHM to a newborn is zonking out on the sofa while a baby feeds or sleeps on you.’

Really not the case here.

HungryandIknowit · 05/08/2022 19:29

Given people's safety depends on his alertness at work I think there could be a compromise. He could manage a few nights per week by sleeping in separate rooms and doing 'shifts' with his gf so that each person gets 4 - 5 core hours uninterrupted sleep. He could then stay with you a couple of nights per week to catch up, provided his gf is genuinely happy with it (I'd suggest speaking to her directly to check).

Macaroni1924 · 05/08/2022 19:28

amatsip · 05/08/2022 17:36

By the tone of your posts you don’t seem to like the baby’s mum much.

This it’s glaringly obvious. Yes he may be struggling and yes it is hard but that’s what happens when you don’t wrap it. Now he’s with a girl who you clearly don’t like and tied to her for life.

Adult son wants to move back mon - fri to ‘get a night’s sleep’
stress22 · 05/08/2022 19:28

Motherofalittledragon · 05/08/2022 19:25

Who's supporting the gf? Poor woman, if my dp left to go to mummy's 5 nights a week for sleep I wouldn't be wanting him back, regardless of his job!

This! My DP could fucking stay there for good if he'd done that to me! OP your son is entirely selfish and I feel sorry for the baby's mother.

TowerRavenSeven · 05/08/2022 19:26

I’d say no way!

Motherofalittledragon · 05/08/2022 19:25

Who's supporting the gf? Poor woman, if my dp left to go to mummy's 5 nights a week for sleep I wouldn't be wanting him back, regardless of his job!

Harrysmummy246 · 05/08/2022 19:24

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 14:04

Yeah I agree - he should be sharing the work load, but his argument is when he gets back from work he does ‘everything’ for the baby- feeding, bathing, cleaning all the bottles, laundry, cooking etc. it’s difficult because he’s really struggling and does seem to be doing more than his fair share when he can

Yep, this is what dads do......................

Stripedbag101 · 05/08/2022 19:24

So here we have your son and his girlfriend living with the girlfriends sister and the son wants to move back in with you?

I think he and his girlfriend need to decide if they are a family and stand on their own two feet.

you sound like the stereotypical blinker mother. I doubt your son is as wonderful or as important as you think. I also doubt his girlfriend is as awful as you think!

achillestoes · 05/08/2022 19:23

Would have ended up divorced if my husband had moved out 5 days a week and left me with a newborn.

Runmybathforme · 05/08/2022 19:22

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 14:04

Yeah I agree - he should be sharing the work load, but his argument is when he gets back from work he does ‘everything’ for the baby- feeding, bathing, cleaning all the bottles, laundry, cooking etc. it’s difficult because he’s really struggling and does seem to be doing more than his fair share when he can

Seriously ? So glad you aren't my MIL. On no account get involved with this madness, you will alienate your DIL forever and enable an entitled, selfish man/child.

namechangetheworld · 05/08/2022 19:21

I don't think he should move back in, but given his job role should probably find somewhere else in the house to sleep, so he's still around if she needs his help. Is there room for that in her sister's house though?

And I agree that people are being overly harsh. Someone who has a full time, high pressure job (which they potentially drive to and from) needs more sleep than a SAHM. Much of being a SAHM to a newborn is zonking out on the sofa while a baby feeds or sleeps on you. Hardly high pressure stuff, no matter what some of the "keeping a baby alive" brigade like to claim.

NumberTheory · 05/08/2022 19:19

I see why you’re conflicted. It does seem outrageous for him to seemingly abandon the mother to sleep deprivation. But if he’s pulling his weight around the home when he’s there, maybe it’s more a matter of compartmentalizing and specializing.

I think what this illustrates is how unsuited modern life is to the newborn stage. With extended families the extra hands can help make lighter work of this, sharing out some of the pain so that it’s easier for everyone to get through. But that’s not what we have.

I think you should have some concerns about 5 nights a week leading to a rift in their relationship that just grows and you end up with him staying more and more.

I would propose a conversation with all of you to talk about what’s happening and what you can offer. That may be 1 or more nights at your house, or help setting up a spare room, some babysitting time so the two of them can reconnect together, a friendly ear, etc. And I would put an end date or a peter out clause so that it isn’t indefinite (at least on any offer for him to sleep at yours). The point would be to make sure you are actually providing help towards a stable family life and not just an escape route for him.

A sympathetic but worldly talk from his dad about how hard this period is might also help (assuming his dad was actually useful when DS was a baby).

surreygirl1987 · 05/08/2022 19:18

So all the doctors, nurses, pilots, emergency workers need to move out when they have a baby for public safety? What about the women? What do they do?
I’ve never heard anything so ridiculous in my life.

Do the women go back to work immediately after having a baby??

I actually found your outrage to this comment the ridiculous thing. I think it is utterly irresponsible for someone to attend work, in a role that involves public safety, in a seriously sleep deprived state. In many jobs this is dangerous. Just driving a car when seriously sleep deprived is dangerous. My husband kept nodding off at the wheel on his commute to and from work after having our first baby. He shouldn't have been driving. People die because of this. The important thing is that this young man is recognising an issue and trying to find a solution. Paternity leave really does need to be longer.

Algbu6 · 05/08/2022 19:16

How old is the baby? Could you have the baby one night a week? Perhaps alternative with the other grandparents?

I was shocked to read your post. 5 days is a lot I thought he was going to suggest 1 night.

Plenty of nurses juggle with their kids.

Could they afford a cleaner so perhaps your DS is doing less? I've never heard anything like this.

Nothappyatwork · 05/08/2022 19:16

HippPippy · 05/08/2022 17:32

She doesn’t work, has no interest in working

she won’t have any interest in working will she when she’s just had a baby ff sake

GG1986 · 05/08/2022 19:16

Wow sounds like he has a lot of growing up to do! Personally i would say no and talk to him about being a good dad and a partner, if sleeping is that much of an issue then maybe he could sleep downstairs if it's a particularly bad night with the baby. What is his job?

Swipe left for the next trending thread