Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering why there's so much hate for teachers?

708 replies

Nannyogg134 · 05/08/2022 12:18

I've just been reading some responses to another thread concerning teachers and working over summer and there's a real mix of thoughts. I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I'm always very taken back by the amount of negative comments regarding teachers (especially regarding workload and school holidays.)

I've taught in a state secondary school for almost 13 years and I came to the job after working in a care home for a few years. There are pros and cons; the school holidays are great (and yes, they are unpaid- teachers are paid per day of their contract, this is term time only, the wage is delivered over 12 monthly payments for ease of life.) However, there is no flexibility, so I rarely see my own children in sport's day, nativities, or even on parent's evening (if it clashes with something at my school.) Overall, I feel very passionately about giving my best to my students and extra time I spend on them feels mostly worthwhile.

However, whenever there is chat about teaching, the general feeling seems to be very negative. I'm just wondering where this seems to come from? Is it the classic 'horrible teacher' stereotype we see on TV etc.? Or is it a leftover from some of our own school days?

I suppose it's not really AIBU, more of a wondering where this issue comes from and if public view can ever be shifted?

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 05/08/2022 14:03

It's a free for all here for abusing certain professionals, wc, people on benefits,
smokers, obesity, refugees.

I think teachers are brilliant and deserve more resources to work with.

SparklyLeprechaun · 05/08/2022 14:01

I've got no strong feelings pro or against teachers, but certain things repeated ad nauseam on these boards do get tiring: no other profession is as hard or stressful, school is not childcare, if a child complains about the teacher then the child must be lying. During the pandemic I've heard that teachers can't teach online/provide teaching materials because they've got their own children at home - so like the rest of us then who had to work from home with children around.

antelopevalley · 05/08/2022 14:01

worriedniece · 05/08/2022 13:58

That's true, but teachers don't get paid what surgeons do. I think the problem is that teaching holds a lot of responsibility, demands a lot skills and is mentally exhausting as you are dealing with so many people and also managing their expectations and problems all day long.

Lots of jobs do not get paid what surgeons get paid and have a lot of responsibility and lots of stress.
Your response is a perfect example of why so many people get annoyed with teachers. Your response seems totally ignorant about other jobs.

35965a · 05/08/2022 14:01

As others have said, on MN it’s the moaning. Not all but so many moany teacher posts. Nobody has ever worked long hours or taken work home or has to deal with difficult situations in their job. Some of my friends are teachers and they aren’t like this, yes it is a hard job but so are thousands of other jobs.

worriedniece · 05/08/2022 13:58

Whadda · 05/08/2022 12:26

I’m not in the UK and don’t have children so MN is probably my only time interaction with UK teachers so I think it’s fair to say I don’t have any skin in the game.

That said, based on some of the things I’ve seen on MN over the years, British teachers often seem to be of a certain mindset I haven’t seen elsewhere.

I genuinely think there could be a thread on here that starts with-
“I’m a brain surgeon and today I did 24 hours of surgery on 4 premature babies while standing up in a dust camp in a third world country, using nothing but my bare hands and a butter knife”

and within five responses you’d have-

“Well, try being a teacher and then you’ll understand hard work!”

That's true, but teachers don't get paid what surgeons do. I think the problem is that teaching holds a lot of responsibility, demands a lot skills and is mentally exhausting as you are dealing with so many people and also managing their expectations and problems all day long.

Overthebow · 05/08/2022 13:57

I have lots of teacher friends and they all work very hard. It’s an important job which has to be done. But they certainly don’t work harder than myself or my other non-teacher friends. They also get decent salaries, pensions and of course the holidays (yes, they do some work in the holidays but still get plenty of free time to spend with their families).

On Mumsnet it just seems to be teachers moaning about how hard they work, how much harder they work than others and how little they get paid for it. They seem to have no understanding that actually their job isn’t harder or more hours than many other jobs, and compared to others they do get decent salaries when you take into account the pension and holidays.

The other annoying thing is when some teachers moan about hitting the top of their pay band with no room to go up unless they take on more responsibility. We’ll yes, that is the same everywhere. You have to want to step up into more challenging roles with more responsibility to get the higher salaries. If I had chosen not to take on more responsibility at work and not worked towards that then I would still be in my £30k role.

TroublesomeLuck · 05/08/2022 13:56

"I think teachers moan so much more than ANY other profession. It gets peoples backs up sometimes."

SOME teachers. Essentially it's the generalising about anyone that annoys me more than anything else.

antelopevalley · 05/08/2022 13:56

mumsneedwine · 05/08/2022 13:54

Teachers are paid for 1,265 contracted hours a year, over 195 days. So at £26,000 ish a new teacher earns about £20 an hour. However most teachers work many more hours during term time so that is a maximum. Equivalent roles on £20 an hour equates to £36,000 for a 35 hour week.
Just as a comparison.
Reading some of the comments I really don't understand why people send their kids to school as teachers as so useless. And lazy. And moaning.

I do not know anyone who only works a 35 hour week as full-time. And I am not as well paid as teachers.

Minikievs · 05/08/2022 13:55

Jumpstark · 05/08/2022 13:35

I think it's because several things teachers regularly say just aren't true.

They have more stressful jobs than people in the private sector - have you ever done a stressful job in the private sector?

They're poorly paid. Not well paid but it balances out. A teacher's pension is worth £500k - £1 million whereas the average pension pot in the private sector is £50k.

They have less flexibility than others - you do realise many people only get 4-5 weeks holiday per year.

Yes it's a tough job, but so are loads of others.

So to summarise, it's not teachers themselves but the amount of moaning!

Totally agree with this.

I think teachers moan so much more than ANY other profession. It gets peoples backs up sometimes.

I saw a Facebook post last year where someone was musing about whether it would be better to spread terms/holidays over the year and maybe go back to school in august. One of my acquaintances (teacher) was up in arms about it. "I CANNOT be expected to work on August, with NO air conditioning, it's inhumane" etc etc
Millions of people go to work in August in non air conditioned work places Confused But teachers couldn't possibly

Mumofsend · 05/08/2022 13:55

I think mumsnet teachers are a bad representation of teachers.

Comments like not being able to go to the toilet when you want to, I've worked in several minimum wage zero-hour jobs and unable to just go to the toilet whenever I fancy. None of it is special to teachers.

mumsneedwine · 05/08/2022 13:54

Teachers are paid for 1,265 contracted hours a year, over 195 days. So at £26,000 ish a new teacher earns about £20 an hour. However most teachers work many more hours during term time so that is a maximum. Equivalent roles on £20 an hour equates to £36,000 for a 35 hour week.
Just as a comparison.
Reading some of the comments I really don't understand why people send their kids to school as teachers as so useless. And lazy. And moaning.

Lovetogarden2022 · 05/08/2022 13:49

I think teachers do have it tough - I know A LOT of teachers, most of which were the full A* students at school, with excellent degrees and extremely conscientious etc. The majority have quit their jobs in the last 3 years as the amount of pressure and stress (and with every single one of them, serious issues with parents and PTA committees etc!) and now do something different, though usually still working with children in some capacity.

However, to caveat that, a lot of my friends and family members have had horrendous experiences with their children with extremely poor teaching, even at the top state schools and extortionately expensive private schools too. I think the training that teachers get is very poor, and doesn't necessarily prepare them very well to a) teach their subject well enough and b) cope with the amount of work that needs to be done.

Every single person I know with children in school (even with kids aged 4 in reception, and even one who is paying about £15K a year for private school) is paying for private tuition for their child. Every. Single. One.
It's also the route I'm taking with my children as the general standard of teaching just isn't working. Maybe class sizes are just too big?

DdraigGoch · 05/08/2022 13:46

Testina · 05/08/2022 13:06

I already replied that pedantry over the holidays payment makes some teachers look ridiculous, and now we see it on this thread 🤣

Google tells me starting teacher rate is £25,714.

If someone works in a call centre and says, “I earn £25K pa”, you show me a teacher anywhere who would reply, “I’m on £34K pa equivalent, though actually the same as you in reality because it’s 9 months pay.”

You can’t have it both ways - either you don’t get paid for holidays, or your salary is too low.

Because I think £25K is too low for a qualified professional teacher. £34K though? Perfectly good salary to start on.

Exactly. Those making the "we aren't paid for the holidays" argument even though they are salaried and the pay is distributed through the full year are effectively saying that salaried teachers only work part time if you look at the average hours through the year. The FTE salaries don't look so bad in that context.

Obviously that doesn't apply to those who are paid by the hour, or by the day, such as those working in supply.

Newrumpus · 05/08/2022 13:40

In my experience it goes like this:

non-teacher: Teachers get paid for their summer holidays and yet I know loads of teachers who don’t do any work during the summer holidays

teacher: Actually we don’t get paid for all the school holidays and we do do some work outside of term time

non-teacher: Teachers are always moaning and nit-picking, why don’t you just quit if you don’t like it. Why do you think nobody else has to work hard?

Over and over.

Jumpstark · 05/08/2022 13:35

I think it's because several things teachers regularly say just aren't true.

They have more stressful jobs than people in the private sector - have you ever done a stressful job in the private sector?

They're poorly paid. Not well paid but it balances out. A teacher's pension is worth £500k - £1 million whereas the average pension pot in the private sector is £50k.

They have less flexibility than others - you do realise many people only get 4-5 weeks holiday per year.

Yes it's a tough job, but so are loads of others.

So to summarise, it's not teachers themselves but the amount of moaning!

Makegoodchoices · 05/08/2022 13:34

I found it eye opening to speak to American teachers who also ‘don’t get paid for holidays’ so supplement their income with another job over summer. I’ve never heard of U.K. teachers doing this although presumably there must be some out there. The six teachers in my friendship group certainly don’t - they have a lovely summer with their families mostly!

I don’t think teachers are hated - I just think people feel like they understand the job better than most as everyone has had experience in schools. Doesn’t mean they know what they’re talking about or see the work that happens outside of 8.50-3.30

These days though, it seems almost all professional roles require additional work outside hours. Mine certainly does.

Putonyourshoes · 05/08/2022 13:34

I feel the same way about nursing. It really gets to me when I’ve had a tough shift and then read comments making sweeping generalisations. People hold really strong opinions on public sector workers and most of the time it’s ill informed, inaccurate and sometimes very offensive.

Cakeandcardio · 05/08/2022 13:33

I don't think it's true at all the teachers work 'harder' than other professions. But it is true that the work is very time-bound. For example, you have several deadlines a day to be met and there's not really much room not to. And then there's the admin side, which can often be very time-bound too. I've taught for 15 years. Had some time out for an office based job for a year and honestly could not believe how slow everything moved.
The reason for teacher bashing is that everyone has gone to school so obviously think they know best. We do have good conditions but it's clearly difficult to understand what goes on. I honestly couldn't work at the slow pace of the office so went back to the classroom and I love it.

angstridden2 · 05/08/2022 13:32

Ex teacher here. I agree some teachers come on here moaning that they work harder than anyone else but I think,part of the problem is that you could work 24 hrs a day and there would still be more you could do.Some heads’ expectations are ridiculous and the climate seems to be that in dealing with truly awful behaviour you often get no back up and criticism from parents.

Salaries are not great unless you take on additional responsibilities, certainly not in comparison to law, accountancy etc and other professionally qualified jobs. There’s obviously a problem in teaching as people are leaving not long after qualifying and retiring early. Recruitment in some areas is also a problem.

WhiskersPete · 05/08/2022 13:32

also not understanding that unions are not as strong in other sectors

I think there is actually a lot of envy towards the teaching profession's ability to unionise and demand fair treatment which leads to people not liking teachers.

MumofSpud · 05/08/2022 13:31

RedRobyn2021 · 05/08/2022 13:06

I think because teachers are civil servants people feel more entitled to an opinion on their holidays/hours/pay.

From the outside looking in teachers work short days, are paid well and have enormous amounts of holiday. But like any job, there's always more to it than people think. I know a few teachers (not well tbf) and I have been told about all the overtime that goes in to marking and lesson planning etc it's not a job I envy and if you're going to do it well, it's certainly not an easy job. Also from what I've heard there's a lot of bureaucracy.

I'm an Estate Agent so I get it. People think we just take a few picture and wack them up on the internet and that's it. I have learnt to ignore those kinds of people.

The last time I sold my house I had to take my own photos! Confused

Titsflyingsouth · 05/08/2022 13:31

Teachers and TAs in my son's school are exceptional. No teacher-bashing in my corner, OP. Tough but vitally important job....

DrMadelineMaxwell · 05/08/2022 13:29

VickyEadieofThigh · 05/08/2022 12:28

I see some teachers (I'm a retired one) still believe the old 'teachers aren't paid for their holidays' chestnut.

Yes, you ARE. You're salaried and it is NOT a pro-rata salary.

If you are a retired teacher then presumably you worked before the existence of supply agencies. How teaching was paid back then made it very clear that it is, in effect but not advertised as such, a pro rata salary. I still have the supply rate letter from my county in some folder somewhere so I'm not making it up.

If you worked a days supply when I started teaching you were paid 1/195 of the full salary because that's how many days we are employed for. If you worked just a month you would take home more than a full time teacher on the same pay scale. If you worked a full year, obviously not being able to work the holidays as a supply teacher, then you would earn the same because the full time teachers pay is spread out over the year.

Newrumpus · 05/08/2022 13:27

My work accumulates during the school holidays if I don’t keep on top of it. I agree that it is annoying that many don’t appreciate that regardless of what profession they themselves are in.

Cakeandcardio · 05/08/2022 13:27

VickyEadieofThigh · 05/08/2022 12:28

I see some teachers (I'm a retired one) still believe the old 'teachers aren't paid for their holidays' chestnut.

Yes, you ARE. You're salaried and it is NOT a pro-rata salary.

I'm not sure what part of the UK you are from but teachers here are paid for 40 days holiday. That doesn't equate to the full amount so, yes, some days of the holidays are unpaid. I imagine it is probably the same UK wide.