Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering why there's so much hate for teachers?

708 replies

Nannyogg134 · 05/08/2022 12:18

I've just been reading some responses to another thread concerning teachers and working over summer and there's a real mix of thoughts. I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I'm always very taken back by the amount of negative comments regarding teachers (especially regarding workload and school holidays.)

I've taught in a state secondary school for almost 13 years and I came to the job after working in a care home for a few years. There are pros and cons; the school holidays are great (and yes, they are unpaid- teachers are paid per day of their contract, this is term time only, the wage is delivered over 12 monthly payments for ease of life.) However, there is no flexibility, so I rarely see my own children in sport's day, nativities, or even on parent's evening (if it clashes with something at my school.) Overall, I feel very passionately about giving my best to my students and extra time I spend on them feels mostly worthwhile.

However, whenever there is chat about teaching, the general feeling seems to be very negative. I'm just wondering where this seems to come from? Is it the classic 'horrible teacher' stereotype we see on TV etc.? Or is it a leftover from some of our own school days?

I suppose it's not really AIBU, more of a wondering where this issue comes from and if public view can ever be shifted?

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 07/08/2022 08:59

Sluj · 07/08/2022 08:47

That's a ginormous hourly rate then !!

Yet there is a massive recruitment and retention issue.

Sluj · 07/08/2022 08:47

PriamFarrl · 05/08/2022 12:41

It is a pro rata salary. Teachers get the same number of paid holiday as everyone else. We get paid, if you are full time, for working 195 days in the year, with then the same number if paid holiday days as everyone else.

That's a ginormous hourly rate then !!

Scatterbrainbox · 07/08/2022 08:21

SlowingDownAndDown · 07/08/2022 06:45

Ok @Scatterbrainbox I’ll rephrase that. You agree with Testina that significant numbers of teachers remain in a job they dislike and then complain about it? It seems to me you do agree.
It also seems that however insightful anyone’s comments you refuse to give them credit for them.
I’m not suggesting teachers leave the profession or stop complaining or do anything in particular. Teachers aren’t the subject of the question. The question is why is there so much hate for them.

I don't need it rephrasing, thanks though.
The main point you keep making is (however phrased) that they are choosing to stay in a job (remain) and complaining (raising awareness of the poor working conditions and that this is affecting everyone, children and staff alike).
That's OK. People can try and raise awareness and want to improve things without leaving, that's actually a good thing.

I'm not ignoring the many insightful comments from other posters.

Just responding to your comments which really do read a bit as 'if you don't like it leave' whichever way you phrase it.

SlowingDownAndDown · 07/08/2022 06:45

Scatterbrainbox · 06/08/2022 21:59

Not really. Somebody who 'is stuck' (through circumstances) rather than someone who 'sticks' (makes a choice) are different scenarios.
Someone who is stuck, through personal circumstances(either due to financial commitments or a commitment to their profession) in a job that requires 3-4 years of vocational uni study and all the debt that comes with that, but has increasingly awful working conditions are allowed to vocalise their dissatisfaction (or whinge, as you so empathetically put it).
Suggesting that all of the dissatisfied teachers leave isn't really the solution...society needs teachers and there are already difficulties recruiting (and there would be none left!). You would be singing a different tune if your child's class couldn't recruit a long term or perm teacher. That is increasingly the reality in some areas.

I left teaching earlier this year, because of unbearable workload, from a SENCO role (SENCO, English subject lead and a full time class teacher for a 240 pupil school). My school still haven't managed to replace me. The deputy head is covering the senco role and is a heartbeat away from a breakdown, the class has had a string of supply teachers. People are voting with their feet.
Before I was a teacher, I worked in financial services (sales role) for 10 years, so I am saying the working conditions are unbearable in the context of having worked in other industries which are considered demanding.

Ok @Scatterbrainbox I’ll rephrase that. You agree with Testina that significant numbers of teachers remain in a job they dislike and then complain about it? It seems to me you do agree.
It also seems that however insightful anyone’s comments you refuse to give them credit for them.
I’m not suggesting teachers leave the profession or stop complaining or do anything in particular. Teachers aren’t the subject of the question. The question is why is there so much hate for them.

Scatterbrainbox · 06/08/2022 22:25

eastegg · 06/08/2022 22:17

You seem to be reading into Testina’s post a judgment about whether teachers should be complaining, when their point was to explain one statistical reason why teachers might complain more than people in some other jobs. Testina actually said that they thought that the complaints were justified, but you seem to be jumping to the conclusion that they are having a dig.

I was relying to Slowingdownanddown who used the word 'whinge' to describe teachers' complaints. I think the word 'whinge' implies a fair but of negative judgement. It's a word that would normally be used to describe a tantrumming toddler etc...

eastegg · 06/08/2022 22:17

Scatterbrainbox · 06/08/2022 21:59

Not really. Somebody who 'is stuck' (through circumstances) rather than someone who 'sticks' (makes a choice) are different scenarios.
Someone who is stuck, through personal circumstances(either due to financial commitments or a commitment to their profession) in a job that requires 3-4 years of vocational uni study and all the debt that comes with that, but has increasingly awful working conditions are allowed to vocalise their dissatisfaction (or whinge, as you so empathetically put it).
Suggesting that all of the dissatisfied teachers leave isn't really the solution...society needs teachers and there are already difficulties recruiting (and there would be none left!). You would be singing a different tune if your child's class couldn't recruit a long term or perm teacher. That is increasingly the reality in some areas.

I left teaching earlier this year, because of unbearable workload, from a SENCO role (SENCO, English subject lead and a full time class teacher for a 240 pupil school). My school still haven't managed to replace me. The deputy head is covering the senco role and is a heartbeat away from a breakdown, the class has had a string of supply teachers. People are voting with their feet.
Before I was a teacher, I worked in financial services (sales role) for 10 years, so I am saying the working conditions are unbearable in the context of having worked in other industries which are considered demanding.

You seem to be reading into Testina’s post a judgment about whether teachers should be complaining, when their point was to explain one statistical reason why teachers might complain more than people in some other jobs. Testina actually said that they thought that the complaints were justified, but you seem to be jumping to the conclusion that they are having a dig.

Scatterbrainbox · 06/08/2022 21:59

SlowingDownAndDown · 06/08/2022 20:52

If you have a mortgage, kids etc. You might not have the luxury of 'just changing jobs'. A predicament which is surely easy to understand and of course not unique to teachers.
You agree with Testina’s main point then, @Scatterbrainbox, significant numbers of teachers stick in a job they dislike and whinge about it.

Not really. Somebody who 'is stuck' (through circumstances) rather than someone who 'sticks' (makes a choice) are different scenarios.
Someone who is stuck, through personal circumstances(either due to financial commitments or a commitment to their profession) in a job that requires 3-4 years of vocational uni study and all the debt that comes with that, but has increasingly awful working conditions are allowed to vocalise their dissatisfaction (or whinge, as you so empathetically put it).
Suggesting that all of the dissatisfied teachers leave isn't really the solution...society needs teachers and there are already difficulties recruiting (and there would be none left!). You would be singing a different tune if your child's class couldn't recruit a long term or perm teacher. That is increasingly the reality in some areas.

I left teaching earlier this year, because of unbearable workload, from a SENCO role (SENCO, English subject lead and a full time class teacher for a 240 pupil school). My school still haven't managed to replace me. The deputy head is covering the senco role and is a heartbeat away from a breakdown, the class has had a string of supply teachers. People are voting with their feet.
Before I was a teacher, I worked in financial services (sales role) for 10 years, so I am saying the working conditions are unbearable in the context of having worked in other industries which are considered demanding.

SlowingDownAndDown · 06/08/2022 20:52

If you have a mortgage, kids etc. You might not have the luxury of 'just changing jobs'. A predicament which is surely easy to understand and of course not unique to teachers.
You agree with Testina’s main point then, @Scatterbrainbox, significant numbers of teachers stick in a job they dislike and whinge about it.

antelopevalley · 06/08/2022 20:35

Yes because teachers with a degree earn more than someone starting out in an area of work with a generic degree. Lots of people start on lower salaries than teachers do with a degree. So your choice is to do this or carry on doing a job you hate. Personally I would have thought it is a no-brainer if you are young.

Scatterbrainbox · 06/08/2022 19:05

Testina · 05/08/2022 12:38

On the complaining…
I’m in the private sector, generally if a role doesn’t suit you - you move, company or role. So you don’t long term complain about being an accounts receivable clerk, for example - you move.

My perception - which I’m happy to be told is wrong! - is that there’s a really high drop out rate in the first couple of years, but after that, there’s less movement out of teaching than other private sector roles. So it’s those long term teachers who are vocally complaining in person, on line. And those complaints are justified. But the volume of voices is high, because so many stay put. You don’t get the critical mass of A/R Clerks explaining their woes - because the change jobs! And also don’t have the same group identity that you have as “teachers”.

That's probably because they haven't got a degree in A/R Clerking which cost a fortune, took 3-4 years of work and isn't particularly transferable.
If you have a mortgage, kids etc. You might not have the luxury of 'just changing jobs'. A predicament which is surely easy to understand and of course not unique to teachers.

DrCoconut · 06/08/2022 18:53

I find a lot of it comes from the assumption that rank and file teachers make decisions about the running of the school, what they teach, how they teach etc. When those decisions are made higher up and the staff then have to implement them whether or not they agree. So if the French teacher tells your DC to put their blazer on it's not a personal vendetta, he/she has just been ordered to do that by the head. Likewise, your primary school DC's homework, what options are available at GCSE, whether your trip to see great aunt Ethel counts as authorised absence because she's 99 3/4 years old, how long the lunch break is, etc etc. The average teacher gets zero say. But 100% of the blame when parents don't like something.

cushioncovers · 06/08/2022 10:22

Nannyogg134 · 05/08/2022 12:18

I've just been reading some responses to another thread concerning teachers and working over summer and there's a real mix of thoughts. I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I'm always very taken back by the amount of negative comments regarding teachers (especially regarding workload and school holidays.)

I've taught in a state secondary school for almost 13 years and I came to the job after working in a care home for a few years. There are pros and cons; the school holidays are great (and yes, they are unpaid- teachers are paid per day of their contract, this is term time only, the wage is delivered over 12 monthly payments for ease of life.) However, there is no flexibility, so I rarely see my own children in sport's day, nativities, or even on parent's evening (if it clashes with something at my school.) Overall, I feel very passionately about giving my best to my students and extra time I spend on them feels mostly worthwhile.

However, whenever there is chat about teaching, the general feeling seems to be very negative. I'm just wondering where this seems to come from? Is it the classic 'horrible teacher' stereotype we see on TV etc.? Or is it a leftover from some of our own school days?

I suppose it's not really AIBU, more of a wondering where this issue comes from and if public view can ever be shifted?

It's not just teachers op. Doctors, nurses, police officers, council workers in fact most public sector employees seem to be hated by the general public. A feeling of being let down by the services they provide and jealousy over what they perceive as 'having it good' seem to be the main reasons afaics

Sunnyqueen · 06/08/2022 10:05

For me it's because I had really shit time off teachers at school myself, not one good or nice one then you think your free from it but it just starts up again through your children.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 06/08/2022 10:01

alltheevennumbers · 05/08/2022 12:24

OP, in the last week I've seen multiple abusive posts aimed at disabled children and refugees. So I don't think it's just teachers.

I think it's just that around Mumsnet - like the rest of the Net, the rest of the world - there's a high proportion of deeply unpleasant people.

Scepticalwotsits · 06/08/2022 09:53

Cayennelikethepepper · 06/08/2022 08:43

I think the term “teacher” needs to be a protected job title. if it is already - more needs to be done to protect it.

I am really sorry but when teaching assistants announce they’re the “teacher” (when they aren’t!) - I’m afraid it devalues the profession a lot.

Its the cause of most mocking amongst parents. Especially the admin / pastoral care lady stomps about like she’s the headteacher and then declares “this school wouldn’t be a school without me” - and we’re all there thinking “no, the school wouldn’t be a school without the teachers”…

Teachers are highly educated and professional. There’s a HUGE difference between roles. And there needs to be a firm separation between job titles.

I work with TA’s and they ALL refer to themselves as a teacher to parents / visitors / children. It’s really embarrassing for the school.

I don’t know any TA that calls themselves a teacher. A HLTA mug by say they also teach, which they can do.

what I have seen and also from directly from a parent who was a teacher is that a lot of teachers treat TA like they are their personal admin bitch.

Cayennelikethepepper · 06/08/2022 08:43

I think the term “teacher” needs to be a protected job title. if it is already - more needs to be done to protect it.

I am really sorry but when teaching assistants announce they’re the “teacher” (when they aren’t!) - I’m afraid it devalues the profession a lot.

Its the cause of most mocking amongst parents. Especially the admin / pastoral care lady stomps about like she’s the headteacher and then declares “this school wouldn’t be a school without me” - and we’re all there thinking “no, the school wouldn’t be a school without the teachers”…

Teachers are highly educated and professional. There’s a HUGE difference between roles. And there needs to be a firm separation between job titles.

I work with TA’s and they ALL refer to themselves as a teacher to parents / visitors / children. It’s really embarrassing for the school.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 06/08/2022 00:03

I suspect it's the self-referential nature of it all. You know, the endless marking, the nightmare parents, the emails that need to be answered, the parents who expect you to return their 'phone calls, the ungrateful children, grim staffrooms, TAs who expect to be shown your lesson plan, having to produce said lesson plan, parents' evenings spent with parents who have the temerity to question you, children asking questions that deviate from your lesson plan, it's just so unfair.
A bit like the neurosurgeon writing up her notes, dealing with traumatised parents, staying on at the end of a 24-hour shift to return 'phone calls, shitty break rooms, colleagues and family members who need you to explain why your child is dying in a language they understand, children not wanting your interventions.
And the fact that doctors can take cheaper holidays in term-time.
It really is a hard life.

NCNCNCN · 05/08/2022 22:49

echt · 05/08/2022 22:30

People saying other jibs are just as hard is not the same as people saying that it is easy!

But bringing in job comparisons on a thread that does not invite it is irrelevant. Yet every every time..........

@echt I am sure you’re not ignorant enough to think that individual teachers have never had another job/career to which they can compare?

NotTHEBupcake · 05/08/2022 22:47

Juicesausagecake · 05/08/2022 21:01

The first bit of this thread exposed the root of the problem:

teachers do not understand how they are paid and what they are paid for (despite it being published each year in the School Teachers’ Payvand Conditions document or your school’s equivalent).

This means that teachers resent workloads that they perceive as unreasonable; it also means that they find it difficult to challenge workloads that actually are unreasonable.

Also, there isn’t that much that unites us as a profession. My department doesn’t have much in common with other departments in the school; there’s independent vs maintained; maintained vs academy; MATs vs Federations; soft vs hard federations etc; there’s the suspicion around your training- was it PGCE? GTP? Teach First etc.

We all hate each other and we all work really hard for our students and then present ourselves appallingly to those outside the profession, undermining everything that we do and the reasons for why we do it.

I have no idea what the answer is, except that I am not surprised that the DfE don’t listen to us, and I think that the Unions have failed us on every single issue.

And attitudes to teachers that were exposed by the pandemic shocked me. It turned out that people didn’t respect teachers. I had thought that it was a widely respected profession. It isn’t.

See, this is something that mystifies me about teaching. Why does it matter if someone is in a different department? Or if they did PGCE or whatever? Why would you all "hate each other"?

I do a job that has lots of routes in; there are various departments which do very different things to mine, and there is a wide range of levels of qualifications. If I ever suggested that I couldn't work with someone because of any of those things, I'd get in trouble, and rightly so.

DH is a teacher, and the level of pettiness in his school is unbelievable to me. For example, a new teacher started a while ago, and DH was the only one who helped her out with resources, lesson plans etc. He said it's not generally "done"; people are expected to produce their own resources, kind of to "prove" that they can. I pointed out that in any other workplace you'd be disciplined for withholding information that would help a colleague to do their job. It all just seems to be weirdly competitive and everyone almost suspicious of each other. Every time someone volunteers to do something DH is all "Oh, she must be planning on going for promotion", like it's not possible that someone just saw something that needed to be done, and did it.

I'm sure it's not like that everywhere, obviously, but it definitely seems to exist.

echt · 05/08/2022 22:30

People saying other jibs are just as hard is not the same as people saying that it is easy!

But bringing in job comparisons on a thread that does not invite it is irrelevant. Yet every every time..........

SlowingDownAndDown · 05/08/2022 22:19

I think aspects of the job demand characteristics that are fairly obnoxious when viewed out of context, or employed elsewhere. You must need a certain self importance to impose your will on thirty potentially hostile adversaries every day.
Also, everyone has been to school and will have negative experiences. Who hasn’t been humiliated by a teacher? And who hasn’t been given duff information by one (eg birds aren’t animals).
I think teachers hanging around on this thread to point out that nobody can have a rational reason for hating an entire profession are being a bit of a pain. This isn’t a thread about teaching: it’s a thread about people’s perceptions of teachers. Let people answer the question.

NCNCNCN · 05/08/2022 21:30

Scepticalwotsits · 05/08/2022 21:22

Depending on the job a significant portion would not be able to accept a gift from a client without it either being declaired or handed over. Every FTSE 100 conpany I have worked for all gifts are handed over and then raffled off with proceeds going to charity

Most schools require staff to declare gifts over a certain value.

Scepticalwotsits · 05/08/2022 21:22

Snog · 05/08/2022 19:11

@Newrumpus it's sad that you don't consider receiving grateful presents from parents for your work a pro. Many of us who are not teachers absolutely would consider it a pro.

Depending on the job a significant portion would not be able to accept a gift from a client without it either being declaired or handed over. Every FTSE 100 conpany I have worked for all gifts are handed over and then raffled off with proceeds going to charity

eastegg · 05/08/2022 21:07

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/08/2022 13:15

I have massive respect for teachers and know they work very hard in difficult circumstances. You'll get no hate from me. I honestly don't think the hate for teachers is any worse overall than for other professions tbh, although I can understand how it felt like that during COVID.

Try being a journalist, a lawyer, an estate agent or a banker if you think teachers are a hated profession. (I've been one of these and almost everyone assumes you're an arsehole as a starting point).

I think what is true is that teachers touch most of the lives of most people on here, which is not necessarily the case if you work for a Big Four accountancy firm. So everyone feels they have a dog in the fight.

I think the debate around teachers and their roles and responsibilities became quite toxic during COVID. On both sides tbh. A lot of people who were forced to do FT work while they were looking after children found the patchy provision of online education and the lack of flexibility from employers that they were being forced to teach their own kids on top of a job quite frustrating, to say the least, but it wasn't directed at teachers. It was directed at the government and the broader educational teaching infrastructure. And to be honest some teachers on here gave as good as they got. I saw some teachers pitch up and be quite short and aggressive with parents who were clearly at the end of their rope trying to do too much.

That was a uniquely high octane situation and some people probably were quite unpleasant then but I don't think that's the normal, steady state view on the profession.

.

Your second paragraph (sorry don’t know how to quote that bit) is totally spot on! The stereotypes surrounding other professions I think are way more negative. Yes there is carping about teachers, and eye rolling, but ime in real life there is a bedrock of good-natured respect and a strong sense that teaching is a byword for slightly downtrodden decency. As I say, ime. Try, on the other hand, working in a profession thought of as arrogant, uncaring, money-grabbing and up-ourselves.

On the other hand, my experience of negative perceptions has shown me that these things really do have the power to get to you, so I get where teachers are coming from. It’s hard when people don’t ‘get’ your job.

Juicesausagecake · 05/08/2022 21:01

The first bit of this thread exposed the root of the problem:

teachers do not understand how they are paid and what they are paid for (despite it being published each year in the School Teachers’ Payvand Conditions document or your school’s equivalent).

This means that teachers resent workloads that they perceive as unreasonable; it also means that they find it difficult to challenge workloads that actually are unreasonable.

Also, there isn’t that much that unites us as a profession. My department doesn’t have much in common with other departments in the school; there’s independent vs maintained; maintained vs academy; MATs vs Federations; soft vs hard federations etc; there’s the suspicion around your training- was it PGCE? GTP? Teach First etc.

We all hate each other and we all work really hard for our students and then present ourselves appallingly to those outside the profession, undermining everything that we do and the reasons for why we do it.

I have no idea what the answer is, except that I am not surprised that the DfE don’t listen to us, and I think that the Unions have failed us on every single issue.

And attitudes to teachers that were exposed by the pandemic shocked me. It turned out that people didn’t respect teachers. I had thought that it was a widely respected profession. It isn’t.