Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering why there's so much hate for teachers?

708 replies

Nannyogg134 · 05/08/2022 12:18

I've just been reading some responses to another thread concerning teachers and working over summer and there's a real mix of thoughts. I know that everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I'm always very taken back by the amount of negative comments regarding teachers (especially regarding workload and school holidays.)

I've taught in a state secondary school for almost 13 years and I came to the job after working in a care home for a few years. There are pros and cons; the school holidays are great (and yes, they are unpaid- teachers are paid per day of their contract, this is term time only, the wage is delivered over 12 monthly payments for ease of life.) However, there is no flexibility, so I rarely see my own children in sport's day, nativities, or even on parent's evening (if it clashes with something at my school.) Overall, I feel very passionately about giving my best to my students and extra time I spend on them feels mostly worthwhile.

However, whenever there is chat about teaching, the general feeling seems to be very negative. I'm just wondering where this seems to come from? Is it the classic 'horrible teacher' stereotype we see on TV etc.? Or is it a leftover from some of our own school days?

I suppose it's not really AIBU, more of a wondering where this issue comes from and if public view can ever be shifted?

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 10:59

SandieCollins · 07/08/2022 10:40

Aah, just seen the previous posts 😂

but I still don’t get why teachers moan about this then

Explaining isn’t moaning.

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:49

So the question is why do teachers believe they should be exempt from what is the norm for most of us

it's because it's the 1 job people just see the holidays and the 9-3 days and think teachers only work these hours and are blind sided to the reality. In other words, it is the only profession people think they know everything about because we all went to school but never saw what goes on behind the scenes.

That and in the past 20-30 years the workload has increased significantly so people's experience of school memories will be radically different to what happens today. There is much more bureaucracy, red tape, inspection, etc today.

The days of coming in and working out of a text book are long gone yet people still have this memory in their head.

Shinyandnew1 · 07/08/2022 10:47

SandieCollins · 07/08/2022 10:40

Aah, just seen the previous posts 😂

but I still don’t get why teachers moan about this then

It usually comes in response to being told you’re lazy and do fuck all during the 6 weeks. Teachers usually reply saying that the holiday is unpaid.

Virtually all of what is perceived as ‘teacher whinging’ comes as a response to being criticised. It’s mostly just pointing out the truth.

SandieCollins · 07/08/2022 10:40

Aah, just seen the previous posts 😂

but I still don’t get why teachers moan about this then

SandieCollins · 07/08/2022 10:36

they are unpaid- teachers are paid per day of their contract, this is term time only, the wage is delivered over 12 monthly payments for ease of life.

can someone explain to me why this is trotted out to make teachers seem hard done by? All it does is show that they’re really highly paid (in comparison to other ‘similar’ professions) for the hours they do get paid for as opposed to paid a similar rate to other professions over a full year.

I don’t get it and no one has ever explained it to me.

xJoyfulCalmWisdomx · 07/08/2022 10:36

As said before, teachers seem shocked sometimes that their job is hard, that they have to experience stress, long hours, work above and beyond what's understood to be expected. Every time I read one of these threads where a teacher is shocked about their workload/stress, there are so many people going through the same thing. So the question is why do teachers believe they should be exempt from what is the norm for most of us?

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:35

*I'm a teacher/SENCO. I don't work after 6pm or during the holidays. There's lots of brilliant things about teaching:

It's never boring*

some of the curriculum actually is boring and tedious to teach at times.

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:33

people who cause damage because they don’t click with a student or students etc. but don’t realise they have the power to effect that person for life

or maybe the student doesn't click with the teacher. A relationship is a 2 way street.

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:31

*The other thing is teaching is a profession which is largely made up from women. People love to hate women.

Whenever I read posts by those who seem to have irrational hatred for teachers - my main reaction is that they've probably got something to work on in therapy*

Your theory fails that so many male dominated professions like lawyers, politicians, government ministers,bankers, police etc are hated too.

stayathomer · 07/08/2022 10:31

Personally I think teachers do an amazing job. At all pt meetings their observations were spot on and showed they actually knew the kids’ issues well. BUT I have experienced, as we do in all walks of life, people who cause damage because they don’t click with a student or students etc. but don’t realise they have the power to effect that person for life. my favourite teacher was horrendous to one of my best friends, under the guise (or not, I don’t know) of ‘you could do so much better’. My son’s best teacher, who I hold responsible for changing things for him for the better in school, used to make other children cry and dread coming into school. The people on mn who hate teachers could be dealing with their children being affected by teachers such as this🤔

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:26

I think a generation or so ago teaching was a fairly attractive job. Very little of the time consuming red tape and box ticking that goes on nowadays; parents in general supported teachers and respected their decisions and, as a result,pupils overall were better behaved

Agreed, I think what fucked England was ofsted, it just made it far too stressful. There is no ofsted in other countries so when people say teaching is harder in England they are correct.

CulturePigeon · 07/08/2022 10:22

Also, as a weary teacher friend once suggested to me after one too many run-ins with horrible parents, teachers are the authority-figures most people can easily encounter nowadays and take out their frustrations on.

In past eras there would be the local vicar, the local big-wig etc, but now there's just the poor old teacher for most people. They represent authority (although the profession doesn't help itself by seeming desperate to relinquish a lot of this) and disaffected parents, who might have been disruptive themselves in their school days, see teachers as punch-bags sometimes.

When I did my PGCE, we had a lecture on the social standing of teachers and teh lecturer pointed out that, of all the professions, teachers are treated with far less respect (than doctors and lawyers, for example). Having worked as a teacher for many years I have been frustrated at the way teachers do themselves down and seem willing to accept blame for so much that's wrong in society. I've sat in so many staff meetings where the old chestnut 'the school has failed such-and-such a child' is trotted out when it's clear to anyone with half a brain that the school is probably the ONLY element in that child's life which hasn't failed it.

After long years of thinking about this, I really do think that if the teaching profession was a bit more self-interested and not such a walkover for government and parents, they would help themselves and ultimately the children they serve. Remember - parents and government need teachers more than teachers need them...so use that power to stand up for better conditions for YOURSELVES (not just the kids, which is what teachers always do), insist on being treated as professionals just as docs and lawyers do. If this happened, I think more good people would come into the profession, working conditions would have to improve and teachers would be less stressed and better equipped to help the children, rather than running themselves ragged to please everyone (parents, kids, government) and burning out before they accrue the experience which makes them really valuable members of the profession.

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 10:20

Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 09:57

The latter

So it’s not really pro rata - it’s the salary for a contract of 195 working days per year? And then it’s divided into 12 and they’re paid monthly?

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:20

They're poorly paid. Not well paid but it balances out. A teacher's pension is worth £500k - £1 million whereas the average pension pot in the private sector is £50k

only very few make it to retirement age these days so the whole pension is a big faux ami.

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 10:17

Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 09:59

That’s an extremely generous non-teaching allowance. I can assure you, this is not usual.

That’s the contracted non-teaching time here Confused I know for a fact they’re not teaching for anything like 35 hours a week with their timetables set as they are.

SurfBox · 07/08/2022 10:09

Plus the teaching my DC received at primary level was atrocious

and how exactly did you come to this conclusion? So all teachers in her 8 years were terrible?

I used to work in teaching but had to leave due to a terrible illness. I taught 2 girls who were sisters;neither were submitting homework so I politely informed mum through the school system as part of my job and that I did to everybody else as school policy asked.

Said mum had an issue with this and wrote a huge email to the slt about how I was a bully etc, was a terrible teacher and how I deliberately were trying to get her daughters into trouble and wasn't happy with what I was doing and saying in the class etc.

It was during lockdown, she said she wasn't happy how I was teaching on the online teams-this was during lockdown and that I was aggressive and forceful teaching and intimidating. I was completely puzzled as was my partner as he was usually in room when I was delivering lessons and neither of us could think of anything that I did that was aggressive. He said I was always so calm and asked me how I remained so calm...

Head called me to a meeting and as there was nothing specific in the email that could nail me I was asked to ring the mum and ask what I was doing that was so wrong. I did and the mum couldn't give 1 example of anything wrong/inappropriate/unprofessional I had done.

I even asked her what I had done during the online teaching thinking she must have seen it but she hadn't even seen it herself. She just seemed to be irked that I flagged her daughters were not submitting homework and again could not give me 1 specific thing or example of bad quality in my teaching or tratement of her daughters.

But because of this, she would and tell everybody I was the worst teacher ever.

At GCSE exams a few months after the daughter was 1 of the few in the class who hadn't submitted her project for my subject but the mum would likely delude herself that it was my fault somehow.

So my point being is that some parents will blacken a teacher's name because they have complete unrealistic expectations and don't like the fact that their child has to follow the rules like everybody else does.

Arbesque · 07/08/2022 10:07

I think a generation or so ago teaching was a fairly attractive job. Very little of the time consuming red tape and box ticking that goes on nowadays; parents in general supported teachers and respected their decisions and, as a result,pupils overall were better behaved.

Nowadays teaching has become mired in bureaucracy, many parents are obstructive defensive and litigious, many more pupils have complex or chaotic home lives, discipline is very hard to impose and social media has brought new challenges.

It's not the job it used to be.

Shinyandnew1 · 07/08/2022 10:05

work on marking, planning etc during their contracted 12.5 hours non-teaching time,

Yes, I wouldn’t take much work home if I got 12.5 hours non-teaching time! The statutory PPA time is about 2.5 hours-that is what the majority of teachers receive. We receive ours in 30 minute blocks-it can be quite hard to get any substantial planning done in that time.

SlowingDownAndDown · 07/08/2022 10:04

The main point you keep making is (however phrased) that they are choosing to stay in a job (remain) and complaining (raising awareness of the poor working conditions and that this is affecting everyone, children and staff alike).

That's OK. People can try and raise awareness and want to improve things without leaving, that's actually a good thing.

However rational or ‘good’ it may be, complaining strikes me as seriously annoying behaviour in many situations. That’s what this thread is about: why what seems good and rational to teachers drives everyone else mad.

Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 09:59

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 09:47

On the flip side, it can be extremely stressful and giving up your evenings and weekends is non negotiable if you want to do the job properly. No one sees this side of it

I have friends who are teachers (STEM subjects, high schools, senior level and very well thought of) and none of them work every evening and all weekend on top of their contracted 35 hours per week. They don’t have classes from 8.45-3.45 so will work on marking, planning etc during their contracted 12.5 hours non-teaching time, or will work on until 5 or occasionally extra hours during the evenings or weekends if absolutely necessary, but it’s not a standard thing. They look at it as balancing out with similar level jobs over the year - and far prefer doing additional hours in a shorter period of time whilst benefiting from the longer holidays.

That’s an extremely generous non-teaching allowance. I can assure you, this is not usual.

Ilikecheeseontoast · 07/08/2022 09:58

I’m just talking about my own experience as a primary school teacher. It does seem that the more senior you are, the less hours you work at home though!

Newrumpus · 07/08/2022 09:57

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 09:37

How on Earth does this pro rata thing work? The advertised salary for a teacher here after 5 years is £42336. If it’s pro rata does that mean they don’t actually earn £42336, they’ll only earn a % of that given they only work 195 days per year?
Or does it mean that £42336 is the pro rata salary based on 195 days per year, and if they worked the standard 240 days per year they would be paid more?

The latter

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 09:47

On the flip side, it can be extremely stressful and giving up your evenings and weekends is non negotiable if you want to do the job properly. No one sees this side of it

I have friends who are teachers (STEM subjects, high schools, senior level and very well thought of) and none of them work every evening and all weekend on top of their contracted 35 hours per week. They don’t have classes from 8.45-3.45 so will work on marking, planning etc during their contracted 12.5 hours non-teaching time, or will work on until 5 or occasionally extra hours during the evenings or weekends if absolutely necessary, but it’s not a standard thing. They look at it as balancing out with similar level jobs over the year - and far prefer doing additional hours in a shorter period of time whilst benefiting from the longer holidays.

SirChenjins · 07/08/2022 09:37

Sluj · 07/08/2022 08:47

That's a ginormous hourly rate then !!

How on Earth does this pro rata thing work? The advertised salary for a teacher here after 5 years is £42336. If it’s pro rata does that mean they don’t actually earn £42336, they’ll only earn a % of that given they only work 195 days per year?
Or does it mean that £42336 is the pro rata salary based on 195 days per year, and if they worked the standard 240 days per year they would be paid more?

Ilikecheeseontoast · 07/08/2022 09:10

I’ve been a teacher for 13 years and as far as I’m concerned I get paid the same amount every months -holidays or not? A lot of teachers have no experience of another job so have nothing to compare it to, I have and am thankful of the pay, conditions, union support and obviously long holidays. On the flip side, it can be extremely stressful and giving up your evenings and weekends is non negotiable if you want to do the job properly. No one sees this side of it.