Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect DH not to be annoyed by my anxieties and sadness?

67 replies

PinchOfPepper · 05/08/2022 11:49

Hello mumsnetters. I need advice regarding men's emotional language.

Whenever I am worried or sad my husband seems to make weak attempts at comforting me/ convincing me that there's nothing to worry about, but if his words don't magically work by making my mood shift entirely he becomes instantly frustrated and complains that I worry too much.

Another frequent complaint of his that I shut him out when I am feeling like this, but how could I not? I get nothing resembling understanding or comfort from him. I don't feel safe exposing my feelings to him, because on top of whatever is worrying me, I then also have to handle his judgement of me and his suddenly sore feelings because a) I am excesively anxious and it's unreasonable (his words) and a burden to him (this is implied) and b) I isolate and don't rely on him enough (according to him, if I would, I wouldn't be so anxious). It's like me being sad makes him angry.

This attitude only leads to me isolating more from him—I literally hide from him when I am crying. I don't want or demand to be comforted if he's not capable of providing comfort, but I expect to at least be given space to process my feelings in peace without triggering his anger. The last thing I need when I am in that state is for someone else to make me feel inadequate. Is this unreasonable?

I just need to break out of this dynamics ASAP because it's hurting our relationship and our trust. I need to understand why he feels that way and how I am contributing to his feelings with my behaviour. Any tips?

FTR I don't want it to sound like I am having breakdowns all the time, but it is true that I am more anxious while he is more laid back. I think that the kind of stuff that makes me anxious or sad would make many women feel the same way (e.g. we got worrisome results during my last pregnancy ultrasound).

He's also a good, self-less, caring husband in general and we are very close. He has a bit of an anger issue, but that's for a different thread.

Thanks in advance for your input.

OP posts:
Jobsharenightmare · 05/08/2022 15:35

My take on this is that he cannot handle these emotions in himself so shuts them out. When you present them to him, it is overwhelming and he tries to fix it then if this doesn't work immediately, shut it down by minimising. It's basically nothing to do with you at all. These are his issues impacting on his ability to be an emotionally supportive partner. I would suggest you need to give up on him fulfilling this role and find alternatives such as friends or a therapist.

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 05/08/2022 15:32

PinchOfPepper · 05/08/2022 14:55

Hi FictionalCharacter, thanks for replying. Well, I guess I said "a bit" because I am happy in the relationship speaking in general terms. But the anger thing does bother me. It certainly makes me anxious, although it doesn't happen so often thank goodness.

So what happens is when he is hurt (usually because he feels like I have dismissed his feelings, humiliated him or treated him like his opinion is wrong or doesn't matter and mine "is superior"), he has what is perceived by me as an anger outburst. He will yell, he will drive very fast even though he knows it scares me, he will say mean things, he will bang doors... I told him in no uncertain terms that I would not tolerate insults or physical intimidation, such as walking towards me angrily and grabbing my arms. We've come a long way in that sense. But the angry reaction is still there.

I want to make it clear that he has never hit me, obviously, but I have felt scared and intimidated. I have felt the opposite of love.

When he's like that, anything I say or do is interpreted by him as an attack, even things he would normally not read too much into. My strategy is to apologise for whatever I said or did that was upsetting (normally it was something I did in an anxious/ sad state, because I let my guard down and was too self-absorbed and not my kindest), and I ask for an explanation about how my words or actions hurt him. At which point he will insist that he already explained it to me SEVERAL times and I refuse to acknowledge his feelings and choose to humiliate him further by making him explain it again. If I insist that he explains it again because I didn't understand the first time(s), it makes him angrier. There's just no way out. All I want is to know how I hurt him so that I can apologise and be kinder in the future but it's like we speak different languages.

Another thing he does when he's in this state is change subjects. I want to focus on what hurt him and my role in it and how we can prevent it from happening again, one topic at a time. Instead of talking through each issue, he will often bombard me with the many things I've done wrong, even if they are totally unrelated, I suspect because those things made him angry at the time and he didn't speak up, so he just bursts. He will also sometimes insist that I yelled at him when I didn't? But I know he perceived it as yelling. It's utterly frustrating.

Oh, and I appreciate everyone suggesting therapy, but he refuses.

After one of those outbursts, I just find it very hard to accept his gestures of affection because I just don't understand. Why would you be so unkind to someone you love? I can be angry or disappointed in him but I would never be mean like that, literally just irate.

Again, I don't want it to sound like we have a terrible marriage because that's far from the truth. But there's certainly room for improvement.

This is why I think therapy will help you both (and I am not dismissing the fact that his behaviour is far far more wrong here when he is speeding, making you scared etc)

It sounds like what you are both saying is that you feel like the other person doesn't hear you properly and dismisses your feelings. It really does feel like there are some fundamental communication issues coming out here, which in you manifest themselves in sadness and him in anger.

It would be best to tackle this now before you have a small baby thrown into the mix. Smaller issues with communication will become much worse when you throw sleep deprivation etc into the mix.

You need to come up with some healthier reactions and ways of communicating which you can then model to your child.

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 05/08/2022 15:26

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 15:03

@PinchOfPepper you need therapy

Not him

I totally agree that the OP could benefit from therapy. But if the OPs DH is getting frustrated, he appears to be turning that frustration to anger and therefore therapy could benefit him as well.

Although I think most people benefit from some therapy at some points in their lives so I could be biased!

PinchOfPepper · 05/08/2022 15:24

Lydia777 · 05/08/2022 14:11

Hi OP.

At the moment I am going through this issue with a friend. I have a very very anxious friend who is so lovely but I have made the decision to distance myself a bit as I am just so drained.

I am not unsympathetic to mental health issues - I am on Sertaline long term for OCD.

I understand that it is normal to be anxious about certain things but is your level of anxiety in the normal range? My friend will admit she is an anxious person but will still be of the opinion that the things she is so worried about are normal worries. It can be normal to worry about these things but not to the extent she does and I wonder are you the same?

For me as a friend it is hours and hours on the phone of me listening to these worries that most of us have had to deal with or similar at some stage - part of life. Solutions don't work, the only thing you can do is sympathize but it gets so so draining. I have been so supportive, literally giving hours and hours of my time for years now.

I have advised her that she needs to go on medication for anxiety - she doesn't agree as to her, her worries are legitimate. But once this worry is over, it will be something else and it will take her over. She went to a counsellor but it is not a counsellor she needs (another person to listen to her worries). She needs medication and cognitive behavior therapy but she won't see it.

I'll be honest, I realize now I could not be in a relationship with someone like that. It is so so draining and people like this are self absorbed without seeing it as they are so wrapped up in their own head/worries. It is very hard to live with - your husband's anger issues are not ok but a separate issue. You need to deal with this anxiety yourself and see it as a problem that needs to be fixed.

Hi Lydia, thanks for your reply.

I'm sorry to hear about your friend's struggle. I completely agree that anxiety makes you self-absorbed and just unable to provide others with the attention they need and expect. It's hard to know when/ if one's anxiety is justified or a problem. I would say that the health of one's baby is a valid reason for concern for many mothers-to-be, but I could be wrong. I try not to worry about mundane things and try yo remember that everyone has their own struggle.

In my case, I don't have the kind of anxiety that paralises you. I'm going about my daily life pretty normally I would say, making plans on the weekends and so on. But I do have my broody moments, specially if I haven't had time to process the bad news. I am not one to call friends and talk their ear off either. I will mention my worries over coffee but more casually and I become very uncomfortable when the conversation is all about me. This applies to conversations with my husband as well. I honestly don't know what I'm doing wrong, but I suppose I have a better understanding of the situation after reading the many replies you all have so kindly shared.

OP posts:
Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 15:03

@PinchOfPepper you need therapy

Not him

2bazookas · 05/08/2022 14:58

I need to understand why he feels that way and how I am contributing to his feelings with my behaviour.

Here's what he feels and why, from your OP

"I shut him out when I am feeling like this"

"I am excessively anxious"

" I isolate and don't rely on him enough"

Clear as day. That's what he feels and how you're contributing.

Maybe if you demonstrated listening to and understanding HIM, and his needs, you'd understand each other better.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 05/08/2022 14:58

I wonder if you're both stuck in a bit of a never-ending cycle.

He doesn't know how to stop you feeling sad, and his frustration comes out as anger. You then feel even more anxious (as he's angry), he gets more frustrated and more angry, which makes you more anxious...

I would say you both need to get separate therapy. It's not really fair to expect him to be your sounding board all the time, but equally you should be able to talk to him without him getting angry and frustrated.

I say all this as someone who has been diagnosed with both anxiety and depression. It can be really, really hard to be the person who's constantly expected to listen to you and help you, and it's not fair to expect one person to take on all those stresses.

PinchOfPepper · 05/08/2022 14:55

FictionalCharacter · 05/08/2022 13:50

I agree. @@PinchOfPepper you say He has a bit of an anger issue, but that's for a different thread. His anger issue can’t be separated from your anxiety and his response to it. Does his anger issue impact on your anxiety and your emotions?
Saying “a bit of” looks like a way of dismissing it as trivial. It isn’t.

Hi FictionalCharacter, thanks for replying. Well, I guess I said "a bit" because I am happy in the relationship speaking in general terms. But the anger thing does bother me. It certainly makes me anxious, although it doesn't happen so often thank goodness.

So what happens is when he is hurt (usually because he feels like I have dismissed his feelings, humiliated him or treated him like his opinion is wrong or doesn't matter and mine "is superior"), he has what is perceived by me as an anger outburst. He will yell, he will drive very fast even though he knows it scares me, he will say mean things, he will bang doors... I told him in no uncertain terms that I would not tolerate insults or physical intimidation, such as walking towards me angrily and grabbing my arms. We've come a long way in that sense. But the angry reaction is still there.

I want to make it clear that he has never hit me, obviously, but I have felt scared and intimidated. I have felt the opposite of love.

When he's like that, anything I say or do is interpreted by him as an attack, even things he would normally not read too much into. My strategy is to apologise for whatever I said or did that was upsetting (normally it was something I did in an anxious/ sad state, because I let my guard down and was too self-absorbed and not my kindest), and I ask for an explanation about how my words or actions hurt him. At which point he will insist that he already explained it to me SEVERAL times and I refuse to acknowledge his feelings and choose to humiliate him further by making him explain it again. If I insist that he explains it again because I didn't understand the first time(s), it makes him angrier. There's just no way out. All I want is to know how I hurt him so that I can apologise and be kinder in the future but it's like we speak different languages.

Another thing he does when he's in this state is change subjects. I want to focus on what hurt him and my role in it and how we can prevent it from happening again, one topic at a time. Instead of talking through each issue, he will often bombard me with the many things I've done wrong, even if they are totally unrelated, I suspect because those things made him angry at the time and he didn't speak up, so he just bursts. He will also sometimes insist that I yelled at him when I didn't? But I know he perceived it as yelling. It's utterly frustrating.

Oh, and I appreciate everyone suggesting therapy, but he refuses.

After one of those outbursts, I just find it very hard to accept his gestures of affection because I just don't understand. Why would you be so unkind to someone you love? I can be angry or disappointed in him but I would never be mean like that, literally just irate.

Again, I don't want it to sound like we have a terrible marriage because that's far from the truth. But there's certainly room for improvement.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 05/08/2022 14:34

Would he see a therapist separately?

My Dbro was always angry if DSil was unwell he reacted awfully.

He worried my DM would die when he was a child when she was ill.

DM suffered from depression as he was the eldest he would shout at the younger ones who didn't understand why they had to be good, it became his reaction to illness.

He didn't know how to show SIL kindness when she was ill he jumped into controlling angry mode.

Cameleongirl · 05/08/2022 14:28

I read once that if you tell a women a problem she will sympathise and share your feelings. If you tell a man, he will try to fix it/give you a solution.

^ The above is certainly true with my DH, he’s a lovely person but not the right person to share my worries with unless I’m looking for a practical solution. I was diagnosed with GAD a few years ago, have had some counseling and take medication, so I’m far less anxious now. But prior to that, I had some really anxious times and my DH also got frustrated with me, partly because he felt I might be blaming some of it on him-or situations that he’d created, e.g., moving for his job, which we’ve done a few times.

Nowadays, I unload to one of my closest friends and she does the same to me. I don’t have much family and she’s like a sister to me. We have a proper moan fest sometimes. 😂

If your anxiety occurs regularly, I’d speak to your GP about it. I’d also confide more in someone other than your DH whom you’re close to ( you said your family’s great). Your DH may simply not have the emotional capacity to deal with your anxiety, so there’s no point confiding in him. My DH’s family, for example, doesn’t talk about problems so he has no experience of it and he struggles with it. We all have weak areas and this is one of his, IYSWIM. My friend is much better. Good luck💐

EmeraldShamrock1 · 05/08/2022 14:24

I think that you have very high expectations.

I personally wouldn't be able to constantly talk about anxiety or walk on eggshells in the relationship.

He has learned how to deal with emotions from a young age, this is out of his league or experience.

Softplayhooray · 05/08/2022 14:20

OP he can't exist around your anxiety, he has his own personality, life and experiences, too. He's obviously doing his best to be kind and try to help but it can often feel like being sucked into an emotional black hole when you live with someone much more anxious than you (especially of he's a naturally laid back chilled guy), and it's even worse when that person is constantly critical of your efforts to help their low mood. It might be that he needs to safeguard his own mental health too.

I'm not saying that to apportion any blame to you, and I'm very sympathetic to the fact that it must be very hard for you!

Lydia777 · 05/08/2022 14:11

Hi OP.

At the moment I am going through this issue with a friend. I have a very very anxious friend who is so lovely but I have made the decision to distance myself a bit as I am just so drained.

I am not unsympathetic to mental health issues - I am on Sertaline long term for OCD.

I understand that it is normal to be anxious about certain things but is your level of anxiety in the normal range? My friend will admit she is an anxious person but will still be of the opinion that the things she is so worried about are normal worries. It can be normal to worry about these things but not to the extent she does and I wonder are you the same?

For me as a friend it is hours and hours on the phone of me listening to these worries that most of us have had to deal with or similar at some stage - part of life. Solutions don't work, the only thing you can do is sympathize but it gets so so draining. I have been so supportive, literally giving hours and hours of my time for years now.

I have advised her that she needs to go on medication for anxiety - she doesn't agree as to her, her worries are legitimate. But once this worry is over, it will be something else and it will take her over. She went to a counsellor but it is not a counsellor she needs (another person to listen to her worries). She needs medication and cognitive behavior therapy but she won't see it.

I'll be honest, I realize now I could not be in a relationship with someone like that. It is so so draining and people like this are self absorbed without seeing it as they are so wrapped up in their own head/worries. It is very hard to live with - your husband's anger issues are not ok but a separate issue. You need to deal with this anxiety yourself and see it as a problem that needs to be fixed.

FictionalCharacter · 05/08/2022 13:50

Maunderingdrunkenly · 05/08/2022 13:12

So when you’re sad he gets angry at you essentially?

not ok.

I agree. @@PinchOfPepper you say He has a bit of an anger issue, but that's for a different thread. His anger issue can’t be separated from your anxiety and his response to it. Does his anger issue impact on your anxiety and your emotions?
Saying “a bit of” looks like a way of dismissing it as trivial. It isn’t.

MarshaMelrose · 05/08/2022 13:47

Because he's caring, he doesn't want to ignore you when you're down. But at the same time he can't understand why you get anxious about so many things, which is frustrating. So he tries his best and when he can't make it better, he feels frustrated with himself and you. Himself because he failed. You because you just followed his advice, you'd feel better (by his reasoning).
And frustration often comes out in anger.

lucylooareyou · 05/08/2022 13:44

Have you tried telling him how he can be supportive in your eyes?

It doesn't sound like he is getting angry per se, but perhaps fustrated that he feels he is trying to be supportive but it's not working. In a relationship you always like to think you know your partner better than anyone and want to be the person to help pick them up when their down - if they constantly feel like whatever they do to be supportive is not working, it can be fustrating to try and keep supporting someone who you know you can't actually help.

I say this as my partner is you, he is very glass half empty and can be very synical. I am very glass half full and try my hardest to put a positive spin on whatever he offloads/ is worried about etc. I also feel myself getting fustrated sometimes when it seem's that everything is just consant doom and gloom, almost like their is no attempt from the other person to feel better or ease their issue - could your partner be feeling this?

I know you mentioned baout removing yourself and having space which is a very valid thing to do, maybe explain this too him. Something to bare in mind is when you are in an anxious state it will be obvious to your partner, and it creates an atmosphere in the home. If its an atmosphere that he has tried previously to help you with but has been proven he cannot provide you with the support your looking for, it means he simply has to live in this atmosphere until you've self soothed. Depending how often this is (only you truely know this) but if its a near daily experience, this can be very mentally draining to your partner.

The truth of the matter is only you can ease your anxieties, I am also an anxious person and are currently pregnant and have had my moments. But i am also careful to not project this and ruin what could be my one and only pregnancy for us both because my head is stuck in negative thoughts.

YouAreNotBatman · 05/08/2022 13:44

DenholmElliot1 · 05/08/2022 11:52

Have you got any girlfriends? The men in our lives can't meet all our needs.

Do you take anything for your anxiety.

Why should friends carry this load?

Partners are supposed to help, to a point, after that, OP needs to do like rest of us responsible people: get a theraphist.

EvenMoreFuriousVexation · 05/08/2022 13:44

I really agree that couples counselling could have huge benefits here. Even one session.

It's not just a man thing BTW - I'm a "fixer" and when someone is sad or anxious, I feel it's my responsibility to solve. If I can't solve it I feel frustrated and have in the past been quite snappy with the poor person who was coming to me for support ☹️

I learned to stop trying to fix "the thing" and instead use reflective language like "it sounds like you feel very isolated" etc (rather than "well, I'd have told him to go fuck himself!")

I would then ask "what would you like to do? Do you want to talk some more, or shall we watch a bit of telly or go for a walk?"

Do you think your dh would be receptive if you suggested this strategy to him?

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 13:42

Being someone's emotional support can be draining

And when you're drained and tired you can maybe not act the way you'd like to all the time

You need to find a more suitable outlet, are you in therapy?

MarshaMelrose · 05/08/2022 13:41

My suster has anxiety and its just one thing after another. It's exhausting and I don't even live with her. Something happened late in the evening earlier in the week. A bit if a problem thar I sorted. My sister read into it all sorts of dire possibilities for it happening. I then had to talk her down and reassure her by which time I'm starting to think maybe shes right! And I got a bit cross with her because she'd started to affect my equilibrium.
I don't think this is your husband's problem. It's yours. You need help to learn how to assess the reality of your anxieties and how to handle dealing with them in a timely and effective manner. You need to learn to self soothe rather than requiring someone else to soothe you.

Sheepreallylikerichteabiscuits · 05/08/2022 13:32

I really think you should consider counselling together

It sounds like he needs to find ways to articulate around emotions better in order to deal with both his and your emotion better

And you discussing your emotions in a neutral place with a trained counsellor on hand may help him hear what you are saying better and may help you frame conversations in a way that is more conducive (I'm not saying you are doing it wrong, but everyone has communication styles and learning to adapt both of your styles to come to a mutually favorable way may be beneficial)

yetanothercleverusername · 05/08/2022 13:25

As someone else said, men like to fix problem so he is probably feeling a bit helpless and out of control as he knows that nothing he can say can magically fix the problem. Unfortunately, he is not very good at handling that helplessness and it is turning into frustration.
Not OK on his part, of course, however, (serious question, not meant to sound nasty) what is that you want him to do when you are upset?
It sounds like you've got into a loop of this behaviour, maybe some counselling would help, at least if it can tease out more about what you expect from him.

Maunderingdrunkenly · 05/08/2022 13:12

So when you’re sad he gets angry at you essentially?

not ok.

Hereforaccountability · 05/08/2022 13:12

I think this is really worth sorting out before the baby arrives. It may be that you need different techniques to manage anxiety, and it is definitely the case that he needs to stop reacting with anger so quickly. Couples counselling I reckon. Best of luck.

PinchOfPepper · 05/08/2022 13:05

10HailMarys · 05/08/2022 12:20

OK, so I can see both sides here.

I'm prone to anxiety and depression, and I do understand what you mean when you say he offers words of comfort and is then frustrated when that doesn't work. I have experienced that from the same position as you, and it is hard. There's nothing worse than being painfully miserable and being told to just stop being sad or to 'just don't worry about it'. I hear you. And then you have that added guilty feeling about your mood etc and it makes you feel worse.

However, it is also very frustrating to be on the other side - and I have been there too! When someone either tells you they are unhappy or worried (or doesn't tell you, but shows you through their behaviour/demeanour) and you try to be kind in response but then your attempts to offer comfort or advice or reassurance are rejected, you tend to wonder what exactly they really want from you. For the person in DH's position, it can feel a lot like this:

Person A: Everything is awful and I feel like shit.
Person B: Aw, don't worry, it will be OK - that awful thing really isn't bad and also think of all the lovely things we've got planned as well. You won't feel like shit forever.
Person A: You haven't made me feel better, everything is still awful.
Person B: Well ... how about doing this/that, so see if that helps, or thinking about it from a different perspective?
Person A: No, that won't help.
Person B: OK, well ... what can I do?
Person A: Nothing, either agree with me that everything's shit or fuck off and leave me alone.

Obviously that isn't exactly how it is! But it can absolutely feel like that from Person B's perspective and it can be very, very draining when someone is expressing anxieties all the time that are irrational and disproportionate, and is then annoyed when the other person won't pretend and nod along with them and say they're right to be worried. To Person B, it feels like they're being asked for help and then when they offer help, it's never good enough.

Person A might say 'Well, I just want Person B to listen to me'. But actually, Person B can't just keep listening and validating all the time and pretending that it's rational or normal to be anxious/depressed for no real reason. Subconsciously, Person A wants Person B to be anxious and depressed along with them so they feel less lonely - Person A probably isn't even aware of that feeling themselves, but it is there, and clearly Person B can't fulfil that wish.

So yes, it's very hard to be in your position and I sympathise. But it's also very hard to be the other person and be essentially told that every attempt you make to comfort someone is wrong.

Thanks for explaining this from your perspective(s).

I understand that trying to comfort someone who is down in the dumps can be absolutely draining, and it is not on him to make me feel better. I know I and only I own my feelings. However, it's the angry response that I don't get. I wish he'd just leave me alone and would not react emotionally to my emotional reaction about something that is completely unrelated to him. Is that even normal? I can't imagine myself getting ANGRY about the fact alone that he's sad or worried. If I lashed out at him, I would understand, but I don't. Sometimes I just crave some space to be alone and not feel like my feelings impact someone else.

To those who asked if I have family or friends I can rely on: yes I do, but the situation isn't ideal. My support net has seen better times though due to a number of circumstances—moving away from my hometown, some friends going through enough in their lives atm and I feel guilty to seek support from them, covid/ w@h straining budding relationships... For a while now I have an increasing feeling that people use me to unload their problems on me and don't give me enough conversational space to talk about my own stuff. I consider myself a good listener and I have always tried to make myself available specially to more introverted individuals because I know it can be hard for them, but lately I feel... exploited I guess would be the word. My friendships are not very rewarding. My family is great though.

I don't rely on my partner to fulfill all my emotional needs. I am often fine just sharing my thoughts with my family and a friend or two. However, if I have a bad day and what I consider to be a legit concern, like the ultrasound results, I expect my partner to "get" that I am sad. Simply that, just get it, not share the feeling, or say any words of comfort. I wish he'd just think "she's sad because of the ultrasound results and will be alright after she comes to terms with it" and that's it. Oh well.

To those who asked what am I doing to manage my anxieties: I started seeing a therapist a little over a month ago but she's not available at the moment. I'm hoping to book another session after the summer. It's tough because my hormones are all over the place with the pregnancy but I do not jump from anxiety to anxiety like someone commented. It's just that I feel more vulnerable and so many things can wrong during a pregnancy. I would assume that a little anxiety is normal. Usually I am just relaxing and focusing on preparing the nursery, so nothing insane.

I said his complaint was "frequent" because we've been together for a long time, so we've been through this many times over an extended period. It doesn't mean that it happens often, but that I can predict his reaction based on my experience.

Anyways, thanks to all for your words, really appreciate it.

OP posts: