Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wedding, husband and flower girls

337 replies

Harrishoole · 05/08/2022 10:43

Brother in law is getting married in an hour and a half; never been on mumsnet, don't know what to do. Feel as if I am going to vomit.

Checked into hotel to find sister-in-law with her cousins and bridesmaids and two bloody flower girls.

Our two girls are not invited.

It became very obvious to me and mother-in-law that my children were not going to be invited to the wedding, logically none of our business but it was hurtful and upsetting. I thought my husband would be accepting but he was completely offended. He approached Brother-in-law who spoke to sister-in -law. Kids not invited.

Pandemic took over and when wedding was planned again both MiL and husband spoke again but no kids. BiL admitted this was SiL as he had left all planning to her.

Husband is best man. I don't know if I should ring him and warn him and MiL. I am scared there will be an atmosphere when they walk in.

OP posts:
KnockedInn · 09/08/2022 17:33

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 16:58

I think that tradition is long forgotten, the Duchess of Cambridge and the Duchess of Sussex both seemed to manage with flower girls from the groom's side, in fact I think all of the Duchess of Cambridge's flowergirls were from Prince William's side.

The Royal Family really need some etiquette advice from people on this thread.

Lots Of Differences Between A Royal Wedding and A Commoner's Wedding Dingdong LOL

The Things People Come Up With SMH

Meanderingpuppy · 09/08/2022 17:24

@Harrishoole glad it went well. It was a difficult situation, but it sounds like you handled it well 💐

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 17:18

Ohahjustalittlebit · 09/08/2022 17:16

I had three flower girls at my childfree wedding. No other kids there. It was my day so not sure why anyone else would have been offended. I do not get this post at all.

Do you have a niece? If you do did it occur to you that she might love to be your flowergirl and her mother and grandmother might feel sad for her that her auntie didn't include her?

Ohahjustalittlebit · 09/08/2022 17:16

I had three flower girls at my childfree wedding. No other kids there. It was my day so not sure why anyone else would have been offended. I do not get this post at all.

ancientgran · 09/08/2022 16:58

I think that tradition is long forgotten, the Duchess of Cambridge and the Duchess of Sussex both seemed to manage with flower girls from the groom's side, in fact I think all of the Duchess of Cambridge's flowergirls were from Prince William's side.

The Royal Family really need some etiquette advice from people on this thread.

KnockedInn · 09/08/2022 16:41

I figured that would work

10HailMarys · 09/08/2022 16:29

Your update doesn't really make you look any less entitled and if your MIL cried because your kids weren't the bride's flower girls, she's being utterly absurd. Your husband is absurd to be 'angry' that his children were not invited to a child-free wedding. You still don't seem to understand that the flower girls were chosen by the bride as part of the wedding party because they are close to her. Your children are related to her husband, not to her, so they were not in the wedding party.

Your MIL already knew your kids weren't invited and had already made a fuss about that so why did she then think the flower girl dresses were for them?

I feel incredibly sorry for your SIL. You're all bonkers.

Grapewrath · 09/08/2022 16:14

*well done for

Grapewrath · 09/08/2022 16:13

Sounds like you managed the whole thing really well OP and well don’t fit managing the awkward questions about your kids not being there
I agree with previous poster who said the less said the better in terms of what is said. If the bride was deliberately excluding your kids then breezing over it will be more satisfying than making a big deal.

MaggieFS · 09/08/2022 16:07

HoppingPavlova · 09/08/2022 13:37

@Harrishoole Flower girls traditionally come from the brides side. They don’t have to be direct nieces of the bride, just from the brides side. Given there were flower girls it was obviously a traditional wedding, so why would your MIL assume the flower girls would be from the grooms side instead, that’s odd? Sure, if someone wanted flower girls desperately and didn’t know any young girls on her end then they would search further afield but that’s not the case here.

So, as it turns out it was indeed a child free wedding in terms of wedding guests.

Not in my experience. Traditionally girls of the appropriate ages from both sides would be the flower girls and bridesmaids.

As an aunt once said "a wedding isn't as much about the bride and groom as the joining of two families". (FWIW, I don't agree)

Tessasanderson · 09/08/2022 16:01

Time to move on. In fact the less you mention their wedding the more it will grate with the bride if she made the choice for any spiteful reason.

You know where you stand. Be civil but lifes too short to give a toss tbh

MichelleScarn · 09/08/2022 15:15

Bonheurdupasse · 09/08/2022 13:02

Bloody hell - your MIL actually cried about it at the wedding?!

Also can't believe this! Surely she can just buy them pretty dresses and take them for a treat, unless it is actually about her wanting for them and by extension her, to get more attention at the wedding? Was being mother of the groom not enough?. I really hope that her behaviour like this hasn't got passed back to the bride and groom. How upsetting would it be for them that his mothers tears on his wedding day were due to this!

LadyDanburysCane · 09/08/2022 14:19

DappledThings · 09/08/2022 13:31

Rehearsals are standard for a church wedding but it's a quick run through. Not a big social event with a dinner like it is in the US.

We only had purselves though, not any of the wedding party.

I’ve only been to two non church weddings all the others have been in churches (mainly RC or CofE but a couple of URC as well). We did have pre marriage lessons (Roman Catholic) ourselves but no run through. I went to meet with the priest who was doing one of the services where I was reading but he just wanted to make sure I was comfortable with what I was reading, and procedure on approaching the altar etc.; he was happy once I told him I was a regular reader at my own church.

HoppingPavlova · 09/08/2022 13:37

@Harrishoole Flower girls traditionally come from the brides side. They don’t have to be direct nieces of the bride, just from the brides side. Given there were flower girls it was obviously a traditional wedding, so why would your MIL assume the flower girls would be from the grooms side instead, that’s odd? Sure, if someone wanted flower girls desperately and didn’t know any young girls on her end then they would search further afield but that’s not the case here.

So, as it turns out it was indeed a child free wedding in terms of wedding guests.

DappledThings · 09/08/2022 13:31

LadyDanburysCane · 09/08/2022 13:16

Plus, every wedding I have been involved in has some sort of rehearsal a couple of days beforehand to make sure the key players know where to stand / how long it takes to walk down the aisle / where people will then sit / what people will be asked to do and say and when / etc.

I’ve been a bridesmaid/ MOH several times, I’ve done readings at three weddings, DH has been best man twice, I’ve got married once - NEVER known of any form of rehearsal ……..

Rehearsals are standard for a church wedding but it's a quick run through. Not a big social event with a dinner like it is in the US.

We only had purselves though, not any of the wedding party.

Kite22 · 09/08/2022 13:25

Oh! How strange.
I love MN for learning how differently things happen for different people Smile

Seems odd (to me) that people would just rock up to a day that is so meticulously planned in so many ways, without any sort of run through though.

Not, of course that this means arrangements / plans wouldn't have come up in conversation when you are close to the couple getting married Smile

LadyDanburysCane · 09/08/2022 13:16

Plus, every wedding I have been involved in has some sort of rehearsal a couple of days beforehand to make sure the key players know where to stand / how long it takes to walk down the aisle / where people will then sit / what people will be asked to do and say and when / etc.

I’ve been a bridesmaid/ MOH several times, I’ve done readings at three weddings, DH has been best man twice, I’ve got married once - NEVER known of any form of rehearsal ……..

Kite22 · 09/08/2022 13:06

Appreciate you coming back to update the thread, OP

In my original post I seemed to suggest that I was criticising them for not having a Rehearsal Dinner; I was merely responding that we are English and there was therefore no opportunity for my husband to know who was in the wedding party prior to the actual day.

Well, except that old fashioned thing called chatting to people.
Not only as his brother, but also as his best man, you'd surely have had conversations about the plans.
Plus, every wedding I have been involved in has some sort of rehearsal a couple of days beforehand to make sure the key players know where to stand / how long it takes to walk down the aisle / where people will then sit / what people will be asked to do and say and when / etc.

Bonheurdupasse · 09/08/2022 13:02

Bloody hell - your MIL actually cried about it at the wedding?!

SuperPets · 09/08/2022 12:57

I still have no idea why you were so dramatic, talking about vomiting and stress and exclusion.

The only kids invited were in the weddign party. It's totally normal. You massively over reacted

Harrishoole · 09/08/2022 12:51

I am utterly stunned that so many people responded to this thread.

Well the wedding went off beautifully, somebody did vomit but it was a + 1 of brother-in-law's friend and they did it into a loo!

My initial intention to ring husband and mother-in-law was never to 'stir', it was to simply prepare them for the presence of children when the only two children in the family were excluded. Their lack of an invitation was contentious in my husband's family, upsetting and my husband was angry.

Many people who responded questioned what I said about its being my first time on mumsnet; I don't know why this would be an issue for anybody. What I meant was while I had frequently read posts on the site I had never registered; this was my first time of registering.

I am a GP. Vomiting is a very common response to stress and while I have actually never vomited I was very 'queezy' when I saw those two girls, who were actually lovely by the way. I was also very jealous and upset that the groom couldn't have extended the same courtesy to his own nieces.

Even in my original post I accepted that they could of course do exactly what they wanted at their own wedding.

The bride is Irish and has no direct nieces but calls her cousins' children nieces and nephews; the flower girls were the children of one of her cousins who was accompanied by her breast fed baby as well. No other children were present.

I am not judging her use of the titles nephews and nieces for these relatives, my best friend does it who is English as well as many colleagues from different cultures.

The girls were not taken away after the ceremony but stayed up all night and danced and danced, they showed no sign of boredom and were even going to be taken into the residents' bar after but were stopped by stopped.

Three people came up to me to ask where my children were and I said that they wanted a child-free wedding. They did not make any comments. In conversation with people I had never met before children and child care came up and one of these women when she realised how I was related did say it was unusual for them not to have been invited.

My husband's uncle is married to an Irish woman and when my mother-in-law was sitting on a terrace after dinner her sister-in-law did say that the bride had shown her the flower girl dresses on her phone at a BBQ and she had assumed that they were for our girls and MiL did start crying; it was discrete and lots of people are emotional at weddings.

In my original post I seemed to suggest that I was criticising them for not having a Rehearsal Dinner; I was merely responding that we are English and there was therefore no opportunity for my husband to know who was in the wedding party prior to the actual day.

I have always been nice to the bride who is a medic too so we bond over that kind of chat.

We all behaved superbly and will not ever mention our children lack of invitation again.

It was painful to me when people suggested that my children were 'brats'; they are not and at eight and four are similar ages to the flower girls.

I hope I have clarified a few things for people who cared.

OP posts:
KnockedInn · 09/08/2022 11:42

The op [and the minority of people supporting her], are making much ado over nothing. Celebrations are shared with our peers. And this is not a child's birthday party where other children should come help to celebrate!!!
The reception more than likely includes plenty of adult activities. Like drinking (too much), dancing (too provocatively), speaking words (inappropriate for children's ears), etc. Not to mention the long-standing tradition of the groom reaching under the bride’s dress to remove the garter and throwing it to the male wedding guests. With lots of cheering and adult fun. And the ceremony itself should be quiet and without distraction, leaving all eyes on the bride and groom! As well as the "decked out" wedding party.
It's selfish and immature to want to use their celebration to show off your kid(s)! Grow up and get with the program!

P.S. I suspect the op hasn't returned to post because she can't handle being told she's wrong. But I have no doubt she's returned to read. And even sent friends (or used her own alternate account) to occasionally write something in support of herself.

Pst..The reason I know this is because she would surely vomit if there wasn't some support for her in the thread.

HoppingPavlova · 09/08/2022 07:54

I think if both sides aren’t treated equally it can create issues. If my husband invited his nieces and nephews to our wedding but I didn’t mine then I think a lot of people would read into it. How could they not?

OP hasn’t returned to clarify things, but as long as there were not kids there who were not in the actual wedding party then there was no unequal treatment. The wedding party is a seperate entity and of course flower girls and page boys would be there as they are fulfilling a role. It’s just like saying ‘I went to a wedding as a guest but I noticed there were bridesmaids there and I wasn’t a bridesmaid, I was just a guest, that’s unfair and I was not treated equally’, so really everyone invited would need to be a bridesmaid as theoretically they are not capped as such. A wedding party is different to guests. Here, there were no children as GUESTS so no unequal treatment.

Kite22 · 08/08/2022 22:49

LP91 · 08/08/2022 10:14

I get that people would like their children invited, but at the end of the day this is their wedding not yours or your partners, I hate when other people try to force what they want on others. This is there day, they can invite who they want, they are footing the bill, and it should be exactly how they want it. No one else has any business in being upset about how the day is planned; the day is about celebrating their love and their union, all you have to do is show up and be supportive, please remember it’s not about you, your partner, your MIL and all of your feelings and opinions, it’s about them!

I agree.

@Harrishoole - are you coming back to update us ?
Did you vomit ?
Did you phone your dh to stir "warn" him ?
Did you MiL hold it altogether ?
Was there "an atmosphere" or did you manage to behave like adults ?

Flutterbybudget · 08/08/2022 22:37

The only kids at my own wedding were my own son, and my flower girl. Her siblings weren’t there, neither were my younger cousins, nor any other children.
live since been invited to weddings, both with and without my children, and enjoyed all of them.
I don’t understand why this is even a big deal to people tbh. You’ve obviously got childcare sorted out, so just enjoy the child free day.