Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Classical music preferences

112 replies

millymog11 · 05/08/2022 09:24

My ex husband could only listen to Bach or some kind of baroque.

I used to be of his view but listening to Piano Concerto No.5 in Eb major Opus 73 (2/3)
Ludwig van Beethoven on the radio how could anyone not get the subtle tones the beauty? I don't like rachmaninov but I think I am being converted.
Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ParasiticMicrowasp · 08/08/2022 19:28

warmeduppizza · 05/08/2022 09:51

Anything from Beethoven onwards is a bit too modern for me, but people look at me like I have three heads when I say that.

You are my people Grin

Igneococcus · 08/08/2022 19:20

I don't much care for anything before Beethoven with the exception of Bach and really early music, and I absolutely can't stand opera.
My favourite composers are: Beethoven, Bartok, Mahler, Schubert, Shostakovich, Copeland, Mendelson.
Have a look at the you tube site of the HR Rundfunk Orchestra they have a fantastic selection of music, brilliantly performed and recorded.

HesterShaw1 · 08/08/2022 19:11

Also yes, I can't stand it when different performers over interpret the music in an effort to be different. Just play it how the composer intended for god's sake. How many recordings of the bloody Four Seasons do there need to be?

"Pulling it around" is a good description.

HesterShaw1 · 08/08/2022 19:08

Malbecfan · 07/08/2022 11:00

@forinborin I'm just not an Elgar fan. The cello concerto is too schmalzy for me, and it is over-played, much like the bloody Lark Ascending. People pull it around too much - the nicest version I heard was someone who hardly varied the tempo at all.

@HesterShaw1 I'm not trying to be patronising at all, but the Trout Quintet is only named that because the 4th movement is a set of variations on one of his songs, "Die Forelle" (The Trout). It's such a lovely piece

Ah that's why! Thanks 👍

forinborin · 07/08/2022 11:08

Malbecfan · 07/08/2022 11:00

@forinborin I'm just not an Elgar fan. The cello concerto is too schmalzy for me, and it is over-played, much like the bloody Lark Ascending. People pull it around too much - the nicest version I heard was someone who hardly varied the tempo at all.

@HesterShaw1 I'm not trying to be patronising at all, but the Trout Quintet is only named that because the 4th movement is a set of variations on one of his songs, "Die Forelle" (The Trout). It's such a lovely piece

I see. I am not from the UK so Elgar was a relatively late discovery for me - strangely enough, much less prominent outside of Britain. But I can totally see how it is massively over-played.

Malbecfan · 07/08/2022 11:00

@forinborin I'm just not an Elgar fan. The cello concerto is too schmalzy for me, and it is over-played, much like the bloody Lark Ascending. People pull it around too much - the nicest version I heard was someone who hardly varied the tempo at all.

@HesterShaw1 I'm not trying to be patronising at all, but the Trout Quintet is only named that because the 4th movement is a set of variations on one of his songs, "Die Forelle" (The Trout). It's such a lovely piece

HesterShaw1 · 07/08/2022 10:13

Malbecfan · 06/08/2022 13:41

My favourite Shostakovich is his 5th Symphony. I love listening to it and playing it. I'm not a massive fan of impressionist music at all (Debussy/Ravel); I prefer Rachmaninov and Mahler. I really dislike Elgar's Cello Concerto (sorry to whoever suggested it) but Dvorak, Schumann and Saint-Saens wrote brilliant ones. I also like the Haydn C major one. Vivaldi wrote a really good concerto for 2 cellos in G minor which I have played a few times.

If you have the time and are a fan of Romantic music, try some of Richard Strauss' symphonic poems. I like all of them, particularly Ein Heldenleben, Don Juan and Death & Transfiguration. I also love his Four Last Songs.

My favourite chamber music is probably by Schubert. I love the Octet and have happy memories of playing it a few years ago. I also love the Trout Quintet and his Quintet in C, the one for string quartet and an extra cello. The slow movement is sublime...

I heard the Trout while I was driving last night. Not for the first time I wondered how a trout could inspire five movements of chamber music!

forinborin · 07/08/2022 08:26

MrsAvocet · 06/08/2022 23:52

I have no musical education at all so may be completely wrong here, but I think this is to a degree at least, a function of the instruments that were current at the time. My teenage DS plays the piano and we recently visited a historic house where they had a harpsichord. DS asked a few questions and the gentleman who was playing offered him the chance to have a go himself. He played a few pieces and commented how different it was to the piano - it's basically impossible to introduce any dynamics so everything does sound a bit mechanical. I would hazard a guess that the invention of the piano was a real game changer for composers as it became possible to introduce a lot more emotion into music written for keyboards anyway. Similar thongs may apply to othet instruments. I have no idea really, but I've listened to the Academy of Ancient Music playing on period instruments and the music does sound different

This is a very interesting observation. I think it is partially that (they still had violins and cellos to add emotion) and partially the required aesthetical standard of the time (baroque has a strong connection to religion, Vivaldi was a priest himself, Bach we all know about, Handel was actually criticised for being too pop at that time, if you read contemporary reviews you could bet the critics went to a Spice Girls concert, not Messiah). The only love is love for God, and austerity is a virtue.

I also noticed a strong correlation between liking Bach specifically and being mathematically inclined, but maybe just an anecdote.

FatOaf · 07/08/2022 07:47

with regard to Vivaldi, I know what you mean about not standing it.

Try this...

MrsAvocet · 06/08/2022 23:52

ladygindiva · 06/08/2022 22:50

I hate Bach and Baroque. Soulless and unemotional to me. Love Beethoven amongst many others.

I have no musical education at all so may be completely wrong here, but I think this is to a degree at least, a function of the instruments that were current at the time. My teenage DS plays the piano and we recently visited a historic house where they had a harpsichord. DS asked a few questions and the gentleman who was playing offered him the chance to have a go himself. He played a few pieces and commented how different it was to the piano - it's basically impossible to introduce any dynamics so everything does sound a bit mechanical. I would hazard a guess that the invention of the piano was a real game changer for composers as it became possible to introduce a lot more emotion into music written for keyboards anyway. Similar thongs may apply to othet instruments. I have no idea really, but I've listened to the Academy of Ancient Music playing on period instruments and the music does sound different

ladygindiva · 06/08/2022 22:50

I hate Bach and Baroque. Soulless and unemotional to me. Love Beethoven amongst many others.

bigbeautifulmonster · 06/08/2022 22:37

millymog11 · 06/08/2022 10:18

bigbeautifulmonster · Yesterday 16:51 I don't want to "achieve" anything. I was just reflecting on my own response to a style of classical music. If it offends you no need to look?

🙄
You posted in "AIBU" which in its nature asks others a question. Your question was ambiguous so I asked you to clarify.

This is a discussion board, not a personal diary.

Shortbread49 · 06/08/2022 22:25

I agree about the Lark Ascending and the way Classic FM promote it all year so it stays at the top of the Hall of Fame. I live Rachmaninov I tried to learn it on the piano but it’s difficult apparently he had really big hands I can’t even reach an octave. I have found my tastes have changed with age I now like organ and choral music especially Widor toccata

forinborin · 06/08/2022 22:16

I really dislike Elgar's Cello Concerto (sorry to whoever suggested it) but Dvorak, Schumann and Saint-Saens wrote brilliant ones.
Genuinely dislike, or just due to over-exposure to it? I can't really stand the lark ascending as it is everywhere, although I appreciate objectively it is an excellent piece.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/08/2022 20:34

A few already mentioned that I love. 'Danse Macabre' is a great tune, likewise Mozart's flute concerto, and Berlioz is also great, especially 'Symphony Fantastique' (the Dies Irae from Witches Sabbath is that creepy-as-sin opening score from 'The Shining'). Vivaldi wins the baroque competition for me.

Mendelssohn's string symphonies are a big favourite, haunting yet upbeat at the same time. The fact that he was a child when most were written blows my mind every time I hear them. His violin concerto is also sublime.

Favourite operas are 'La Traviata', 'Carmen', 'La Boheme', and 'The Marriage of Figaro'.

Love this thread!

millymog11 · 06/08/2022 19:45

"Well, Shostakovich at his most serious is very aggressive and hard-hitting; bare in mind he was living under Stalin after all but in his lighter moments he can be great fun. Try the Jazz Suites or the arrangement of Tea for Two which he calls Tahiti Trot and wrote in an hour in response to a challenge."

This is really interesting about Shostakovich thank you. I'd not listened to him before, my boss who is really into Tai chi raves about Shostakovich I have no idea why.

OP posts:
Clarinet1 · 06/08/2022 19:41

millymog11 · 06/08/2022 12:55

My boss likes Dmitri Shostakovich.

I have no knowledge and don't really know much about this. Is this a more masculine or a more femine kind of music? Ive never worked it out.

Well, Shostakovich at his most serious is very aggressive and hard-hitting; bare in mind he was living under Stalin after all but in his lighter moments he can be great fun. Try the Jazz Suites or the arrangement of Tea for Two which he calls Tahiti Trot and wrote in an hour in response to a challenge.

millymog11 · 06/08/2022 17:55

What is about Shostakovich you love?

OP posts:
Figmentofmyimagination · 06/08/2022 15:56

Vikingur olaffson yes indeed. Fell in love with him slightly over lockdown.

SwimmingOnEggshells · 06/08/2022 15:46

Was Shostakovich's Jazz Suite discovered posthumously?

For me it's Rachmaninov 4eva! Can't be dealing with the frilly baroque stuff.

GuyMontag · 06/08/2022 15:14

Agree that Shostakovich's output is really varied. He was active for a long time and worked with a lot of different styles.

Also is a fascinating person - loads written about him, with various motivations pinned on him by all sorts of people as he lived and worked right through the thick of all the Russian tumult of the twentieth century. Back in the 1980s it looked like we'd got the answers when a biography said to be dictated by him was published but that's since been said to be a fake, and now that the claims of fake are a double bluff ... Doesn't help that no one in charge in Russia has told the truth for over 100 years, about anything.

My favourite of his symphonies is number 11, and I like the cello concerto as well.

millymog11 · 06/08/2022 13:53

He also loved Borodin. Very of type. I'm going to branch out.

OP posts:
Malbecfan · 06/08/2022 13:41

My favourite Shostakovich is his 5th Symphony. I love listening to it and playing it. I'm not a massive fan of impressionist music at all (Debussy/Ravel); I prefer Rachmaninov and Mahler. I really dislike Elgar's Cello Concerto (sorry to whoever suggested it) but Dvorak, Schumann and Saint-Saens wrote brilliant ones. I also like the Haydn C major one. Vivaldi wrote a really good concerto for 2 cellos in G minor which I have played a few times.

If you have the time and are a fan of Romantic music, try some of Richard Strauss' symphonic poems. I like all of them, particularly Ein Heldenleben, Don Juan and Death & Transfiguration. I also love his Four Last Songs.

My favourite chamber music is probably by Schubert. I love the Octet and have happy memories of playing it a few years ago. I also love the Trout Quintet and his Quintet in C, the one for string quartet and an extra cello. The slow movement is sublime...

Softplayhooray · 06/08/2022 13:36

Also classical music from movie scores like Lord of the Rings and anything John Williams does.

Softplayhooray · 06/08/2022 13:32

millymog11 · 05/08/2022 09:49

FatOaf · Today 09:47

OK lets just shut this thread down right now. Thanks for your thoughts.

I only love classical music I've heard from adverts that I really liked, like the one for British Airways a couple of decades ago.