Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel I should be allowed personal things kept personal

93 replies

Heatherhazel · 05/08/2022 08:06

Last night my husband and I had a difference of opinion and its unsettled me a bit.
I might be totally wrong and please tell me of I am.
First I was waiting for the shower and naked and culed in a ball on the bed watching something on my phone and he came out of the shower and jumped on top of me. My legs and arms were beneath me and he put his hands round me and startedd squeezing my boobs I told him to stop. But he kept on I couldn't move and felt really helpless.
I told him after I was disspointed he didn't stop when I told him to but he said its just boobs and it would be like me touching his nipple... 😒
Anyway we lay in bed later and he was asking me if I masterbate at all. How often. Where. What do I think of. I told him I felt uncomfortable and that if like to keep it private but he said he is my husband and should know.
Aibu or uptight?

OP posts:
HotDogKetchup · 05/08/2022 16:52

It’s entirely up to you, me and my DH have never discussed it. I wouldn’t object if he raises it but just don’t think it’s necessary to discuss and tbh I think it might spoil the illusion if he told me in such detail!

Other people might like to discuss it - that’s up them.

entropynow · 05/08/2022 16:49

I've read all your posts and there's a pattern, so knock off the disingenuous "who me"?

entropynow · 05/08/2022 16:48

Which I have reported

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 16:47

entropynow · 05/08/2022 16:45

@Alfenstein
You imagine you're an oh so sophisticated grown up lecturing us all on how to loosen up.
You're not. OP clearly describes an unwanted assault and you are actively and repeatedly miscasting it.
Talk about worrying. That's your posts btw

Who said to loosen up?

Do you think touching your wife's boob is rape?

As I was merely replying to someone making an incorrect claim when you jumped on my comment.

entropynow · 05/08/2022 16:45

@Alfenstein
You imagine you're an oh so sophisticated grown up lecturing us all on how to loosen up.
You're not. OP clearly describes an unwanted assault and you are actively and repeatedly miscasting it.
Talk about worrying. That's your posts btw

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 16:44

Quartz2208 · 05/08/2022 16:30

@Alfenstein she then says sterner.

It is ok to like playfulness in your relationship that is fine. Everyone is allowed to have boundaries and different lines in the sand. As long as it is respected that is fine.

Any situation where you are made to feel helpless is not ok

At which point he stopped Confused

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 16:44

@entropynow

Maybe read comments before replying to them in future

No one said the op isn't allowed body autonomy

I was replying to someone claiming this was rape or attempted rape

It is not

Christ almighty

entropynow · 05/08/2022 16:41

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 09:10

Touching a boob is never and will never be rape or attempted rape

Jesus Christ some on here have no clue

Well you certainly don't have the first clue that a woman has any rights to bodily autonomy.
OP said she said stop 7 or 8 times and you think it's play?
Christ in heaven.

Quartz2208 · 05/08/2022 16:30

@Alfenstein she then says sterner.

It is ok to like playfulness in your relationship that is fine. Everyone is allowed to have boundaries and different lines in the sand. As long as it is respected that is fine.

Any situation where you are made to feel helpless is not ok

SpidersFuckOff · 05/08/2022 16:24

stayinghometoday · 05/08/2022 15:29

Would it help if you discussed a random safe word, like yellow. If you say : no, yellow, that means that any going on after that phrase is sexual assault. Spell that out for him. Also, if he does keep assaulting you seriously think about leaving him. That means that he doesn't love you, only wants to use you.

She has done this already. When he always says he didn't think she was serious she has told him she is and that when she says stop he needs to stop immediately. She's essentially told him her safe word is stop and he pretends says he didn't realise she was serious and continues to keep her pinned down, groping and grabbing here while she's naked beneath him and couldn't see why she was upset because it's just boobs.

If he's ignoring her when she she's clearly told him stop means she wants him to stop why would he listen and respect her saying "stop yellow" he shouldn't need anymore words, it's not a mutually consensual act which what safe words are for, safe words are for kinks like BDSM, dominations stuff, or edgy role play type stuff where both parties are respectful of each other's boundaries before introducing them, safe words are used with someone you already trust to stop, and as this man has shown, he doesn't.

Op doesn't like she want to pretends her no and stop means yes. She wants him to stop when she says stops and has told him that.

stayinghometoday · 05/08/2022 15:29

Would it help if you discussed a random safe word, like yellow. If you say : no, yellow, that means that any going on after that phrase is sexual assault. Spell that out for him. Also, if he does keep assaulting you seriously think about leaving him. That means that he doesn't love you, only wants to use you.

TedMullins · 05/08/2022 15:22

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 09:24

@35965a

It's really not, have you never had loads of compliments and said 'oh stop stop' and it's clearly not a case of stop but please continue but I can't seem to be liking it too much.

Or someone interrupting a task by kissing your neck and making a move, and saying 'stop' but really not meaning it. You're more saying it to remind yourself you're working you can't bugger off and have sex.

The fact you see in black and white is very concerning for a grown adult. The word stop will have different implications depending on tone and context.

Errrm, no, i don’t think this is normal or healthy. If I told someone to stop I would mean stop, and they should stop. Unless there is a pre-agreed non-consensual kink that has been discussed at length beforehand with safe words etc, I would expect someone to say stop if I said stop, and I wouldn’t say it if I didn’t mean it.

TedMullins · 05/08/2022 15:18

OverrunWithPigeons · 05/08/2022 08:19

With a good husband, I actually think it would be a shame not to have a relationship where talking about masturbation was relaxed and easy. What woman ever wanted to chat to her partner about his masturbation habits?

Isn’t this pretty normal? It can be a turn on to discuss masturbating with a partner and even doing it together.

but that’s beside the point, because it isn’t what happened here. He should’ve respected you saying no and stopped manhandling you. If he is generally a sex pest (and I’m going to assume there’s a high chance he is) then I can see why this is not the kind of relationship in which you’d want to discuss masturbation.

Heatherhazel · 05/08/2022 15:15

Thanks for all the replies. Just wanted to hear people's opinion so thank you

OP posts:
Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 12:59

Topgub · 05/08/2022 12:04

@Alfenstein

There's lots of things people do that are represented in the media.

It doesn't make them right.

The awful stereotypes of coquettish women who need coaxing into sex, squealing no when they mean yes need to stop.

Your beliefs are damaging to men and women.

No one has mentioned being coaxed into sex except you

Some people like a bit of playfulness in their relationships

The words no and stop don't have a standard meaning regardless of context or tone: just like every other word in the English language

Topgub · 05/08/2022 12:04

@Alfenstein

There's lots of things people do that are represented in the media.

It doesn't make them right.

The awful stereotypes of coquettish women who need coaxing into sex, squealing no when they mean yes need to stop.

Your beliefs are damaging to men and women.

SpidersFuckOff · 05/08/2022 12:04

I’ve not voted as I do think if you’re a couple then it’s important to be open about masturbation and things.

There's a difference between open and then being intrusive and behaving like you have a right to know everything about someone's private moments and not respecting their boundaries and OPs dh seems to fall into the latter.

I had a boyfriend who did the grabbing thing and would pretend he didn't know I was being serious telling him to stop, eveb with me telling him when I say stop or no, it means stop or no and he'd "forget" and just do it again next time.

He'd do the same for sex, especially if I laid away from him, he'd grind into my back, be told to stop because I have an early morning and am going to sleep and then five minds later he'd be trying to "tickle" my pubic area and get huffy and shitty if I moved his hand because he found the stroking my pubic area "relaxing".

He ask me masturbation questions like this and it felt very intrusive, he'd ask at weird times like when I was reading a book, or washing up, I'd answer some of his questions because when I'd said I'd rather not he said "good" relationships are fully open about this stuff and share what they think about, and he'd even said the fact I was so hesitant to tell him what I thought about during masturbations makes him think I was fa at asking about real life men or "had something to hide" He hated the thought of me using a vibrator without him too.

This is a made up example, but let's say I'd said my fantasy was with a waiter in an empty restaurant, if I so much as smiled at a waiter on a meal out he'd get very annoyed and ask if I'm sat there getting wet thinking about said waiter fucking my brains out. That type of stuff. He had this weird idea of "saving" my orgasms for him and if I masturbate when he was away then I'd not enjoy sex as much when he came back home.

I've been married over 20 years now to a totally different type of man and have never had my husband behave like he has some kind of right to know my private thoughts, we can talk about masturbation in a respectful way and if I'd said I don't want to talk about that then he respects that. When I say "I don't like being pinned down or jumped on" he doesn't forget and keep going when he's been asked to stop. I also don't have him asking if I'm getting wet watching a neighbours house burn down because I've said I like a fireman's uniform.

Bootothegoose · 05/08/2022 11:23

35965a · 05/08/2022 08:09

He sexually assaulted you. Has he done this before?

I'm sorry, this.

You asked him to stop and he didn't. You have a right to be naked in your own home without being groped. You have every right to feel angry, betrayed, violated etc. None of this is your fault, it is his. You being naked was not an open invitation. Has this happened before?

GooglyEyeballs · 05/08/2022 11:12

OP do you feel like you were assaulted? I think is going to come down to your relationship dynamics and how comfortable you feel with this man. Doesn't sound like you're on the same page at all.

Beamur · 05/08/2022 11:06

Your DH has behaved in an immature and thoughtless way.
He's not entitled to know your thoughts or feelings around personal things unless you choose to share them.
The precise lines and boundaries here are for you both to agree on.
I don't agree that this is deal breaking behaviour but you do need to talk about this.

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 11:00

Quartz2208 · 05/08/2022 10:14

@Alfenstein in this instance he jumped on her, she said stop 7 or 8 times and she ended up feeling helpless.

You are right everyone has boundaries - the important thing is in any relationship is to know what those boundaries are - what is playful and what isnt. It is an entirely personal thing.

He also jumped on her to the point she couldnt move - none of your examples have that.

You are right tone and context matter - both here (her stern tone and the fact she was unable to move and felt helpless) mean it was assault

The Op herself said it was a tired tone, not stern.

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 10:58

Topgub · 05/08/2022 10:24

@Alfenstein

And that's why we need to stop teaching kids that sex is something women have to be coaxed and coerced into.

That women really mean yes when they say no.

Its so damaging

No / stop does and should mean exactly that.

Nothing from the op has indicated she didn't mean what she said.

What an odd comment

Have you never even seen someone say no or stop and not actually mean it?

I have, seen it many times irl, and in the media

I've done it myself as do my friends and family members

Tone and context are key.

MN is a strange place sometimes

Alfenstein · 05/08/2022 10:57

Triffid1 · 05/08/2022 10:34

Amazing how @Alfenstein seems to think s(he?) knows that you weren't saying "stop" firmly enough. If I'm naked, and I say stop, unless I'm laughing hysterically while saying "stop" then I think it's pretty clear that stop means stop. And you are just perpetuating these ridiculous ideas that no really means yes. OP was uncomfortable. Her HUSBAND should know her well enough to know the tone of her voice when she says no in such a situation. DH is a bit of a cuddler/groper but he is very very finely tuned to me and even if I'm not actively saying no, he can pick up immediately if I'm not into it and stops. OP's husband is clearly not interested in actually listening to her actual words, never mind her more subtle signals.

OP - is this a regular thing? Because I agree with other posters... it feels like the tip of the iceberg.

The OP admits herself she didn't say it firmly

As expected

Notanotherwindow · 05/08/2022 10:37

I thought it was illegal to marry a 12 year old?

Triffid1 · 05/08/2022 10:34

Amazing how @Alfenstein seems to think s(he?) knows that you weren't saying "stop" firmly enough. If I'm naked, and I say stop, unless I'm laughing hysterically while saying "stop" then I think it's pretty clear that stop means stop. And you are just perpetuating these ridiculous ideas that no really means yes. OP was uncomfortable. Her HUSBAND should know her well enough to know the tone of her voice when she says no in such a situation. DH is a bit of a cuddler/groper but he is very very finely tuned to me and even if I'm not actively saying no, he can pick up immediately if I'm not into it and stops. OP's husband is clearly not interested in actually listening to her actual words, never mind her more subtle signals.

OP - is this a regular thing? Because I agree with other posters... it feels like the tip of the iceberg.