Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone else hoards their 'nice' things and buys/uses new not so nice ones?

152 replies

ThatBliddyWoman · 05/08/2022 04:45

For example-for my birthday a couple of months ago I got bought all sorts of lovely things including nice wine, nice beauty products etc

Even further back than that, for birthdays and xmasses I've been bought similar lovely things, I've got some expensive vodkas and gins, gift boxes with all sorts of perfumes and beauty products, ornamental candles, slippers, photo frames,note books, gift sets

My sister bought me a lovely miniature wooden set of drawers, each drawer containing a perfume, make up or beauty product, little candle...in 2017. I've not even opened it.

If I fancy a drink I buy myself some cheap wine or prosecco-I've got stacks of wine and prosecco given as gifts for me, in lovely bottles on top of my fridge or on shelves in my kitchen-untouched some for years. When people came over for a recent family 'do' I bought aldi gins (perfectly nice by the way!)instead of opening the other ones I've already got that are in nice ornamental bottles!

I buy cheap body lotion when I must have 50 bottles of luxury lotion in my bathroom from birthdays and xmasses of the past.

I've got so many eyeshadow palettes of various expense, but if I need an eyeshadow palette I'll get a cheap one from eBay.

WHY do I do this?! I am sure when I die there will be a load of lovely things in their boxes.

When my Grandmother died they found that she'd done the same. Boxes and bags of things she'd 'saved for best' including clothes (I don't do that at least) make up, perfumes and beauty things. BUT she was a 1920s baby, brought up in poverty. I understand that. I was born in the 80s and although we weren't rich, I never wanted for anything.

Does anyone else do anything like this, or do I have some sort of problem?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThatBliddyWoman · 08/08/2022 22:57

I am so sorry It’s taken me until now to return to my thread! Weekend was very busy unexpectedly. I will try to respond to points made and I apologise if there’s any substituted ones!

@Pinkspice that sounds infuriating! Towels are one thing I could do with more of actually. I often dye ones that are just losing their colour a little, but Dylon seems to have gone downhill (as do so many things, I find!) since they ‘improved’ their formula.

That is a good ‘mantra’ @Trying20 I am going to try to use that. Ask myself before I open some new make up or product ‘would this be better suited to a different day/time/event’ and if not, I will just use it. I will try anyway!

I haven’t opened any nice wine etc yet but I DID use a Burberry eyeshadow palette I had for a birthday a while ago! It's in such a cute box and pouch but I needed one of its colours. I would have ordinarily just gone without until I could pick up a cheaper one!

@IAmAWarrior yes that’s another point. I feel a bit guilty that, some people would love this stuff and here I am wasting it. ☹

@Kiitos I did that as a child too. I didn’t want to ‘ruin’ cute soaps so I didn’t use them. I never wanted for anything, although I wasn’t well off, I wasn’t deprived by any stretch. I don’t know why I did that. But It’s clearly a developmental habit that has formed into a lifetime one. I am definitely going to ty to reframe it, and switch my guilt to ‘I MUST use that lovely X that Y bought me!’

It does seem such a common habit

That’s sad @SomePosters and I can see why it was hurtful. I hope I don’t hurt people but I really must

@NeverDropYourMooncup yes, I was. I feel like I was always breaking things as a child. I was clumsy (perhaps still am) and anything delicate I’d not dare touch. I’d not be allowed near anything ‘special’ often.

I lost a family heirloom aged about 3 (a precious ring that I realise a ‘baby’ shouldn’t have been allowed to wear to go out in, at all)! I always felt very guilty for breaking things. Perhaps other more fundamental things also occurred that I don’t remember. I wanted to open some chocolates before Easter once and was told no because ‘it would spoil it’ (it wasn’t an easter egg)! I do remember that and thinking how silly it was, but I also remember the following Easter when I’d been bought an Easter egg and (the same family member!) was intrigued by the contents and nagged and NAGGED for me to open it! I really didn’t want to. Odd.

Thank you @QueSyrahSyrah
I will definitely be doing that. I’ve got piles of things in almost every room as well as things ‘on show’ that look nice.
I will start to go through them all. I may try to dedicate a special few hours for it. I might need longer! I live alone in a smallish house and I may feel a lot better once things are more organised and I know what I've got.

@FinallyHere that’s what I did with the body lotion. Not particularly luxurious but my absolute favuorite, that I opened 😊 that is sad about MIL/DM ☹

@sheepandcaravan perhaps that is my issue too. I am thinking if I figure out exactly WHY, I can work on it and the habit may be much easier to break for good. I am sorry you struggle with it too.

@CoodleMoodle that does ring quite true actually. I was an 80s baby, child in the 90s obviously and yes, things were more cosseted as they were more expensive I suppose.

@ScoobyDoNot I hope you’re okay now! Yes, I can see why you’d be much more open to using things now too.

@EmergencyHepNeeded (that username is intriguing!) very true, and seems to be a bit of a consensus. I think I may find it helpful to think that way.

@Amigobay where do you think it comes from with you?

@ChallengeSep -this is what I am asking myself. I have
not come up with anything yet. Therapists are notorious for being able to help others but rubbish at helping themselves.. I am determined to get to the bottom of it, but I think a starting point is feeling undeserving. Overwhelmed that someone would think I deserve something luxurious/beautiful/expensive-why do they think so highly of me? Humbled I suppose?

@Cognacsoft I like this ‘What's a broken glass really?’ a lot 😊

It is a very interesting topic I realise, now I've seen so many similar tales on this thread. Why are people like this, It’s sad but yes, interesting too.

@needthezzzzz thank you for your input. I am glad things have changed for you, gives me hope!

@Herecomestreble1 guess yes, knowing I have a lot of lovely things on display at home does bring me joy, when I look at them. But some of the things just aren’t display worthy-and that’s more of an issue isn’t it. Nobody displays a gift set or a make up product, no matter how luxurious it may be or how much it cost. That’s where I will start definitely. I feel bad that I don’t even know what I’ve got with some of those types of things!

I've also got OTHER people’s gift sets/make up etc. My friend’s girlfriend gets them for xmas a lot but doesn’t use any beauty products and wears very minimal make-up. She gives them to me each xmas/birthday in return for me buying her a couple of bottles of prosecco when we next meet! I take them but don’t use them. … Or seldom do anyway… I am a weirdo, aren’t I! Grin

@BitOutOfPractice thank you, and yes, it does help, although I don’t know you, as I wouldn’t like to feel the same if it was the other way around either.
@ChocolateHelps thank you, I will. 😊

@MrsClatterbuck that’s sad too ☹

@Lakeyloo more enjoyment in drinking it than looking at it! Definitely! I am not very creative but I will see what can be done with the nicer
bottles 😊

@Hippywannabe so many sad stories, thank you for sharing. It’s a very good point, we’re not promised tomorrow are we. I am sorry for your loss ☹

@Mummyoflittledragon I hear you on that. With clothes.

My partner is helping as she’s very ‘proud’ and wouldn’t dream of wearing anything with even a tiny blemish to it, and ‘tells me off’ if I do. I do wear new things to go out, but I keep old ones. I very rarely buy myself new, but she buys me a lot of clothing as presents and is quite pushy about having me wear them (not in a nasty way but a positive one). I am glad you're managing to work on it for yourself and haven’t projected the habit onto your DD 😊

@CamoTeaLaLa t is a nice thread, and I am very glad I started it. It is definitely very helpful.I am glad It’s served as an inspiration to others too.

@Elleherd very similar to me. Definitely felt like possessions were more important than me at times, growing up. I was a speak when spoken to child with my Dad, definitely. Felt like a secondary member of the family (If that) although my mum was great, she wasn’t around a lot (worked very hard). I am also afraid of forgetting good memories. If I wasn’t busy, I’d probably write every joyous moment down (I do sometimes, and used to more often). Definitely food for thought, and I am sorry to hear about your circumstances. I hope you’re healing.

@FloozingThePlot no, not poor or miserly really. My parents weren’t well off then, but they’re very well off now. My dad is a bit of a spendthrift and my Mum is more careful but very generous. It’s a bit of a fog, why I am like this, honestly. I’d LOVE to have a lightbulb moment about it but haven’t as yet

@Cinemaandsweets s it is confusing isn’t it? As a therapist I have learned how nature and nurture both have an impact on why we become the way we are. Every time I address this with someone, they assume I was brought up in poverty and I wasn’t. My Mum was, but she’s never been like this at all. Even as a child-we have discussed it, she’d embrace anything given use it an enjoy it. But she is a much more ‘logical’ and pragmatic person than me.

@CentralPerk18 your Grandmother sounds amazing! I am glad it has been an interesting read for you. It’s common isn’t it!?
@Bernadinetta
thank you for sourcing that poem. I kind of want it on my wall!

I will come back to the thread soon and respond to more. So much to think about. I hope It's helped others.

OP posts:
CookPassBabtridge · 08/08/2022 11:57

I did when I was young, same with clothes and jewellery etc. In my 20s I switched and thought life is short, why am I hoarding this stuff? It's like a comfort thing. But I'd rather go out every day wearing the nice dress, eartings, my favourite perfume etc
We are only here once and time flies by, USE THE NICE STUFF ♥️😆

Wilburisagirl · 08/08/2022 03:49

I used to do this but not anymore. You're essentially telling yourself you're not worth of the good stuff. You are. Use it, wear it and enjoy it before it goes stale/out of fashion/you die and it gets sent to the op shop.

MargaretThursday · 08/08/2022 01:45

My gran did that. I have some beautiful unused (when I got them) towels which were a wedding present she'd saved. She had the most harsh threadbare towels she used.

Don't be like that. I wish she'd used the towels and enjoyed them.

calmlakes · 08/08/2022 01:27

I was gifted a pair of liberty pj's it took a Mumsnet thread to encourage me to actually wear them.
I have really enjoyed wearing them.

Willowthewispy · 08/08/2022 01:09

This is such a great and insightful thread. I buy or am gifted stuff and yet the items sit in a cupboard unused. I think for me it's because I don't want them to get damaged or worn and because I was so poor as a child with absolutely nothing that I am absolutely petrified of having nothing again.

Definitely going to try my best to use the things I have and not just let them sit unused. Even though the thought of using them causes me to tense up and get anxious.

Boxowine · 08/08/2022 00:40

I was doing this with my clothing. Going around looking like something the cat dragged in with loads of expensive clothes with the tags still on stuffed in the drawers and expensive make up in its packaging in my vanity.

No more. I've done my big Covid clear out and am fascinated by the concept of capsule wardrobes, which allows me to buy best quality but I'm forced to actually wear it. I won't let myself buy the cheap raggedy "filler" pieces anymore.

Whatup · 08/08/2022 00:36

Cant bare to wear my good pyjamas tho not happening or the dress i ordered two months ago

Whatup · 08/08/2022 00:31

I use all my stuff never have enough! I must be greedy or something

Lancrelady80 · 08/08/2022 00:24

I once read a very wise comment online that said if you value an item so much that you never use it, then it’s already broken.

Ooh, I like this!

Lancrelady80 · 08/08/2022 00:23

I buy nice things and use them because I grew up not having any.

See, I'm the exact opposite. I seem to have taken this to heart so don't use the nice things because then I won't have them any more.

I was really pleased when dh bought me a pretty pair of earrings and made a point of telling me he'd deliberately chosen an inexpensive pair because he really wanted me to wear them and not just tuck them away for best.

I'm trying to make myself get better with this!

historyofthefuture · 07/08/2022 23:44

I used to do this - all the reasons that folks have said (I was not worth it, not wanting the nice things to be gone), plus the feeling of having nice things around me made me feel...safe? The idea that I could buy more nice things if I used stuff up hadn't even crossed my mind. I'm now at the other end of the spectrum - actively make sure I use the good perfume, wear the fancy dress, etc etc. I am ruthless too about not getting back into my micro-hoarding ways, annual clearouts of stuff for the bin/charity shops/etc if it's not being used.

This completely comes from my parents - well-off but will.not.spend.money. if they can help it, and keep everything 'for best', 'just in case'; or, at best, just buy complete pointless occasional tat. One of the bathrooms at their home has conditioner in it from 20 years ago; a bottle of oil in the kitchen that is empty apart from a dribble and has been for years but can't be binned. It is infuriating and, as others have said, makes it pointless and miserable to buy presents for them (clothes unworn, food uneaten).

Honestly, after decades of that it is delicious to treat myself (and you too OP) with the lovely things, right now!

Lampan · 07/08/2022 22:51

I once read a very wise comment online that said if you value an item so much that you never use it, then it’s already broken.

I also think that as soon as you start using the good things, not only does it feel good but you don’t worry as much about them anyway

LadyWithLapdog · 07/08/2022 07:49

I’ve been using my fancy glasses received as wedding presents and I can confirm it takes a good 20 years to get down to the last few. The wine sized ones are long gone, and the champagne, we are down to some piddly schnapps (?), sherry (?) ones. Anyway, it took a long time.

Londonrach1 · 07/08/2022 04:46

Used to then we sadly lost my gran and found all her wedding present s in a drawer waiting for best...some due the fact she was 90 fell apart when we touched them. Every day is best now and I don't save something for best. X

portinahurry · 07/08/2022 04:40

burnoutbabe · 06/08/2022 08:37

Though to be fair stuff like our fancy champagne flutes, if we use then I worry they will smash when used. They can't go in the dishwasher so wait ages to be washed.
I'd prefer not to have them (were an engagement gift) so maybe lots of these un-used wedding gifts are similar. We are perfectly happy with our ikea cheap stuff and won't actually get any more enjoyment with the fancy stuff that may smash.

(It just seems different to nice wine and bath stuff)

"I'd prefer not to have them" and "I worry they will smash"! Definitely use them everyday until they break and then you don't have to worry any more!

drinkstoomuchwine · 06/08/2022 11:16

*really happy …

drinkstoomuchwine · 06/08/2022 11:15

Is this not dissimilar to the thought process of ‘My proper life - when I’ll be ready happy - will start when I’m two stone lighter’.
(I won’t start the diet today though… maybe next week).

ThinkingForEveryone · 06/08/2022 09:24

I grew up without things (80's) as my mother preferred to ensure she had money for cigarettes than bother making sure her kids had clothes that were suitable.
It has made me go the opposite way!
If someone gifts me something lovely I use it straight away, it is a joy to have received something nice just for me😊 Even more so because the person giving it to me thinks I deserve it (more than my mother ever did).
Anything new I buy for the kids is opened and enjoyed straight away, I would hate for them to feel they had to keep something for 'best' (when does this mythical 'best' happen.....are we waiting to meet the queen? Is a trip to the local restaurant enough to declare 'best'?)
Absolutely no one is unworthy of their possessions (that is all they are after all) so if my daughter wants to go to tesco in her nicest dress, why the hell not! And the same applies to me, you and everyone else posting on this thread!

burnoutbabe · 06/08/2022 08:37

Though to be fair stuff like our fancy champagne flutes, if we use then I worry they will smash when used. They can't go in the dishwasher so wait ages to be washed.
I'd prefer not to have them (were an engagement gift) so maybe lots of these un-used wedding gifts are similar. We are perfectly happy with our ikea cheap stuff and won't actually get any more enjoyment with the fancy stuff that may smash.

(It just seems different to nice wine and bath stuff)

purplerobes · 06/08/2022 08:30

My mum used to do this, she also to take our best Christmas presents and put them on a shelf so they were 'kept nice'.
It was so depressing seeing your favourite toys still boxed on a shelf,
That taught me all I needed to know about hoarding the nice things. Why. Who gains from it? Are you not worth the best things?

I used everything and buy myself nice things: I'm worth it, even if my mums lessons was effectively that I wasn't.

FinallyHere · 06/08/2022 08:24

Congratulations @ThatBliddyWoman

It's good for your self esteem to treat yourself well. Being kind to your self is IMO an important life skill. All the best.

Frenchfancy · 06/08/2022 08:22

I try not to be like this, but sometimes I have to remind myself. Like others we have had family members die much too young and it definitely focuses the mind.

We do have one lovely set of glasses bought for our wedding 29 years ago that we only use at Christmas, but that is mostly because they are too big to fit in the dishwasher. And I have champagne in the fridge waiting for a special occasion, but I'm actually not that keen on champagne so prefer a cheap glass of white.

FourChimneys · 05/08/2022 21:58

No. I was brought up like that and refuse to do the same.

For example, I inherited solid silver cutlery which had hardly been used for 50 years. We use it every day.

Misty84 · 05/08/2022 21:49

I am exactly like this OP. So many nice beauty gifts that are still in packaging. Nice bottles of wine and champagne sitting there for years. I feel like I’m wasting them if I don’t save them for something special- but what is that exactly?! Reading this thread has encouraged me to actually use and enjoy some of these lovely things.