Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if people use she/him, other people shouldn't use they/them

114 replies

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:13

As the title says, aibu in thinking that if someone uses Dh/Ds/Dd and she/him in their op, regarding who they're griping about, other posters shouldn't refer to them as they/them?

If you do this, why do you do it?

How do you know you won't offend the op/subject of the post by erasing their sex/gender/identity/etc?

I would be very 🤨 if someone did this to me in real life.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 05/08/2022 00:13

Thelnebriati · 05/08/2022 00:10

I really struggle to see why you are offended by how other people write or speak. English might not be their first language. They might be dyslexic.
I was taught not to use someone's name or 'he' twice in a sentence, so I guess I might use 'he' once and 'they' a second time, depending on the grammar.

OP claims they aren't offended, they just wonder why people use language differently to them. Apparently if you don't specify sex, you're erasing their identity and op doesn't want their identity erased

Thelnebriati · 05/08/2022 00:10

I really struggle to see why you are offended by how other people write or speak. English might not be their first language. They might be dyslexic.
I was taught not to use someone's name or 'he' twice in a sentence, so I guess I might use 'he' once and 'they' a second time, depending on the grammar.

FrancescaContini · 05/08/2022 00:00

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:25

I mean like when an op refers to her husband, as a husband several times, calls him he/him throughout her post and then in the replies someone does not use he/him at all in their lengthy reply, but instead use 'they' even at points where it sounds odd compared to 'he/him. As I said in my op.

OMG
Does it really matter?

SleepingStandingUp · 04/08/2022 23:55

You're overthinking.

My DH always puts butter on after the jam, aibu to think he's bu?
Have they always done this?

That's perfectly fine. It isn't trying to erase his identity or suggest he hasn't settled on one yet. It's just an acceptable way to refer to someone else.

Davyjones · 04/08/2022 23:54

Just put actual words then

ProfessorFusspot · 04/08/2022 23:52

It can be confusing to switch grammatical gender for the same person midsentence, because it reads like different people: my nephew's the youngest of five children and they always get babied. I don't think it's much of an issue on MN beyond that.

You're right that it can be upsetting in real life, though. A friend who is part of a WLM couple complains that she's constantly being referred to as they while her girlfriend is she, apparently because she dresses like a twelve year old boy and has short hair while her girlfriend's often in skirt suits and heels and has long hair. They're both she, though, and both have fairly common trad women's first names. It's rude to "they" a specific individual without being asked.

I believe it’s commonly done when talking about someone you don’t personally know CourtneeLuv Which is generally the case when discussing people’s DH, Dsis or whoever on MN. It also fits well when talking about a hypothetical person.

Hypothethetical/non-specific person, sure: If the doctor suggests bedrest, you should take their advice. When the new baby comes, they'll sleep in our room until the nursery's done. If a Canadian enters on a tourist visa, they can only stay for three months. Not someone you don't know, though - you wouldn't say Joe Biden is giving their speech at 11 just because you don't know him personally. Same concept with your husband needs to improve their attitude.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 04/08/2022 23:24

More annoying is when you start reading a thread about DS and thinking it's son but it's sister or DF is friend not father.

Queenoftheashes · 04/08/2022 23:16

Who cares

BeanieTeen · 04/08/2022 22:54

I just wonder why people do it.

I believe it’s commonly done when talking about someone you don’t personally know @CourtneeLuv Which is generally the case when discussing people’s DH, Dsis or whoever on MN. It also fits well when talking about a hypothetical person.

I hope that’s helpful and you now have one less nagging thought to keep you up at night. But if you still can’t sleep I’m sure you can do some further research on your phone - or start this thread again and use the title ‘Any linguists out there?’ Then you might get the detailed answer you seem to be craving. Otherwise my interpretation and ‘it’s the English language’ will have to do.

TailSpinner · 04/08/2022 22:42

As the title says, aibu in thinking that if someone uses Dh/Ds/Dd and she/him in their op, regarding who they're griping about, other posters shouldn't refer to them as they/them?

If you do this, why do you do it?

How do you know you won't offend the op/subject of the post by erasing their sex/gender/identity/etc?

I would be very 🤨 if someone did this to me in real life.

Its just the English language - are you not a native English speaker? Otherwise I don’t understand your confusion.

How do people have the time and energy to mull over this? There was a thread the other day about whether a chickpea curry should come with both rice and nan bread, or just the one. That’s worth significantly more headspace than this non-issue.

CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:41

I just wonder why people do it

Oh well your question has been answered then.
Forgetfulness is one reason.
It's correct use of the words is another.

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:37

CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:28

But they are not using the word incorrectly so why are you so bothered?

You seem to be annoyed by something you belive is wrong when it isnt, that is odd.

I'm not annoyed at all. Is there something wrong with your comprehension? I just wonder why people do it.

OP posts:
minuette1 · 04/08/2022 22:34

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:59

I'm talking about when people make a concerted effort not to use she/him/whatever the op used, but use gender neutral, even though the op clearly stated she's talking about her husband, for example.

You can tell when people are doing it.

I'm not wound up by it at all, I just wondered why people would tie themselves up on knots not to use terms clearly used by the op.

I guess you can't always tell what sex someone's partner is, or even guess the sex of an OP all the time. In terms of children once you've scrolled down a thread it's hard to remember whether it was a DS or a DD,similarly whether it was a DH or a DP, and I certainly can't be bothered to scroll back up.

CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:28

But they are not using the word incorrectly so why are you so bothered?

You seem to be annoyed by something you belive is wrong when it isnt, that is odd.

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:25

I mean like when an op refers to her husband, as a husband several times, calls him he/him throughout her post and then in the replies someone does not use he/him at all in their lengthy reply, but instead use 'they' even at points where it sounds odd compared to 'he/him. As I said in my op.

OP posts:
CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:21

In point?
What do you mean?

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:18

Sometimes people do t use 'they' correctly though. It sounds odd and overly contrived.

As I said, you can tell when it is being used in point and when people are just using it normally.

OP posts:
CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:12

it's jarring and very odd

Really?

People using words correctly is jarring and odd?

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:11

zurala · 04/08/2022 22:09

On Mumsnet, if people don't like the topic you raise you are either worked up or fretting 🙄

I've noticed this too OP, it's jarring and very odd but I've mostly seen it by OPs who talk of, say, their DS and then conspicuously do not use his or him for the rest of their replies, instead saying their or theirs. It's so weird.

Yes, there's a lot of obtuseness and faux misunderstanding, as usual.

OP posts:
zurala · 04/08/2022 22:09

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:05

Why do you have to be worked up about something to post about it? Confused

Very odd take on things there 🤔

On Mumsnet, if people don't like the topic you raise you are either worked up or fretting 🙄

I've noticed this too OP, it's jarring and very odd but I've mostly seen it by OPs who talk of, say, their DS and then conspicuously do not use his or him for the rest of their replies, instead saying their or theirs. It's so weird.

CrossStichQueen · 04/08/2022 22:08

Using sexed pronouns is correct but so is using their/theirs. All are acceptable so I don't see your issue?
I dont think anyone ties themselves in knots when replacing hers/he's with theirs do they?

maddening · 04/08/2022 22:06

She/he, him/her, his/her's, they/them/their are all interchangeable where grammatically correct as it is Language not a deep, psychosocial inspection of the person's soul.

AppleKatie · 04/08/2022 22:06

And in other things that haven’t happened this week?

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:05

Why do you have to be worked up about something to post about it? Confused

Very odd take on things there 🤔

OP posts:
willingtolearn · 04/08/2022 22:05

You do know it's okay to offend people - it's not a crime. (yet)

Some people are much more easily offended than others.

I'm not sure I have the power to erase people's identity. I think I'd need a magic wand for that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread