Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if people use she/him, other people shouldn't use they/them

114 replies

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:13

As the title says, aibu in thinking that if someone uses Dh/Ds/Dd and she/him in their op, regarding who they're griping about, other posters shouldn't refer to them as they/them?

If you do this, why do you do it?

How do you know you won't offend the op/subject of the post by erasing their sex/gender/identity/etc?

I would be very 🤨 if someone did this to me in real life.

OP posts:
SomePosters · 05/08/2022 07:51

You’re incorrectly slagging off posters intelligence due to your misunderstanding of grammar but I’m abusive because I said what exactly?

im glad you’ve had such a sheltered life and I hope you never have to find out what being abused feels like

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:48

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 07:24

Don't suppose it matters it's still correct. They/them are just neutral terms. Living with two teenagers with differing identities I try to use they/them as it's usually right

and living with a teenager with autism, I take care not to use language in a way which is confusing to him.
might be worth reminding the interestingly identitied that people like him exist, and need to be included too.

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:46

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 07:17

Literally is a singular pronoun if sex is unknown

the doctor prescribed x they thought it would help.

maybe, here’s a wild thought, it doesn’t fucking matter and people can use language however they want without having to justify it to you

where did I say I required justification? I don’t make the grammatical rules. (and I’m not sure why you felt the need to be abusive).
The OP is talking about circumstances where the sex is known. In those circumstances there is no reason at all not to use the appropriate singular pronoun and I agree it’s weird that people don’t.

OhGoodnessItsSoExhausting · 05/08/2022 07:44

Tigerteafor3 · 04/08/2022 21:22

I use DC or they/them when I can't remember what the OP was talking about and can't be arsed to look.

It's not that big a deal. Find something else to get on your soapbox about.

This

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:42

exnewwifeproblems · 05/08/2022 07:08

I have autism and probably adhd.

I'm also menopausal with brain fog.

The reply box on the app means I can't look at the op.

The mobile site on my phone is too difficult for me to navigate.
What do you suggest I do?

i am not sure everyone here has your reasons, though.
My DS is autistic and would have no problem at all, incidentally, as his memory of the OP would be pretty much photographic. But he does have problems when people start mucking about with pronouns. But as we know well, disability is the protected category everyone is allowed to forget about

Svara · 05/08/2022 07:33

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 07:24

Don't suppose it matters it's still correct. They/them are just neutral terms. Living with two teenagers with differing identities I try to use they/them as it's usually right

Yes, this is what DS does. His male friends don't care about being referred to as they, but his non binary female friends might get upset at being called she. I think it would be very easy for him to slip up otherwise when I present similarly but am a she!

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 07:24

Don't suppose it matters it's still correct. They/them are just neutral terms. Living with two teenagers with differing identities I try to use they/them as it's usually right

QuebecBagnet · 05/08/2022 07:18

SmallPrawnEnergy · 05/08/2022 06:51

That would be a silly assumption then, given “they” has been used as a singular pronoun for a long time. But you know what they say about assumptions….

It’s interesting isn’t it. I think it’s because in that sentence “her” has already been used. So it would appear the speaker isn’t referring to someone who is non binary or where there is uncertainty over gender. So to me it would be an odd sentence construction, almost a mix of styles.

More so than “ I saw Jack by the river, they were getting into a car”. With that I wouldn’t picture a second person.

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 07:17

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:01

so we have established that MN is full of people who think using they or them to refer to a single individual is grammatically correct and who also can’t retain the sex of the people under discussion in their brains long enough to use the correct singular pronoun in a reply.
blimey.

Literally is a singular pronoun if sex is unknown

the doctor prescribed x they thought it would help.

maybe, here’s a wild thought, it doesn’t fucking matter and people can use language however they want without having to justify it to you

saraclara · 05/08/2022 07:16

I've never noticed this at all, and would be very surprised if anyone's doing it for any other reason than they've forgotten the sex of the person or that for some reason 'they' flowed in a particular sentence.

The world simply isn't full of people who do this sort of stuff for any other reason. I'm assuming this OP is a very thinly veiled accusation of ultra 'wokeness' in those posters. Well I don't buy it.

Svara · 05/08/2022 07:11

My DS just does it automatically. There are non binary females in his social group and he says it's easier to just use 'they' for everyone.

exnewwifeproblems · 05/08/2022 07:08

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:01

so we have established that MN is full of people who think using they or them to refer to a single individual is grammatically correct and who also can’t retain the sex of the people under discussion in their brains long enough to use the correct singular pronoun in a reply.
blimey.

I have autism and probably adhd.

I'm also menopausal with brain fog.

The reply box on the app means I can't look at the op.

The mobile site on my phone is too difficult for me to navigate.
What do you suggest I do?

WaveyHair · 05/08/2022 07:07

Because people now have to choose between been woke vs grammatically correct.

Some of us are old school and opt for grammatically correct.

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:01

so we have established that MN is full of people who think using they or them to refer to a single individual is grammatically correct and who also can’t retain the sex of the people under discussion in their brains long enough to use the correct singular pronoun in a reply.
blimey.

arrogantorwhat37 · 05/08/2022 06:53

Using they/them to refer to a singular person if grammatically incorrect and really annoying. But, it is apparently ok if a person (singular) chooses to refer to themselves plurally i.e., them/they, despite the confusion it may cause

SmallPrawnEnergy · 05/08/2022 06:51

QuebecBagnet · 05/08/2022 06:46

saw her down by the river, they were getting into the car".

if someone actually said that I’d assume the woman was with a second person. So if she wasn’t with a second person it would be an odd sentence 🤷🏻‍♀️

That would be a silly assumption then, given “they” has been used as a singular pronoun for a long time. But you know what they say about assumptions….

QuebecBagnet · 05/08/2022 06:46

saw her down by the river, they were getting into the car".

if someone actually said that I’d assume the woman was with a second person. So if she wasn’t with a second person it would be an odd sentence 🤷🏻‍♀️

exnewwifeproblems · 05/08/2022 06:41

Sprogonthetyne · 04/08/2022 21:25

If I do it it's because I'm on the app and can't read the op whilst typing my reply. So if I have fogotten if it was a DD or a DS who is poorly/potty training/ not sleeping, I use them so I don't lose what I've already typing by going back to check.

If it's actually something where sex is reliving then it tends not to happen, as I remember the sex.

This is why I do it. And I say oh instead of partner or DH.

CourtneeLuv · 05/08/2022 05:43

If its so offensive to call people that use they and them, she or him, then that works both ways in my opinion. If someone calls themselves she/her, you shouldn't call them they.

I'm not 'so bothered' or 'wound up' or whatever the professional obtuse or cantankerous keep posting, it's just common manners to refer to people the way they refer to themselves.

OP posts:
Penguintears · 05/08/2022 04:00

If your "identity" is so fragile that it can be erased by a strange on an anonymous online forum referring to you as "they" then you have bigger things to worry about than other people's use of grammar.

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 03:55

I've always used they for strangers. They is acceptable. I was raised in the era of 'who's she - the cat's mother?'.

MangyInseam · 05/08/2022 02:17

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/08/2022 21:20

But isn't the OP talking about where the sex IS identified, e.g. if a poster refers to a DS or DD?

Mind, I've seen posters do that - refer to a DS or DD - and THEN use "their" instead of his or her. Which puzzles me deeply.

So I think this is becoming an increasingly common thing, people using they even when he or she has already been used. I've even heard people recently, and more than one example, say things like "I saw her down by the river, they were getting into the car".

I find it really jarring but I am sure it is totally unconscious. I think people are picking it up because they hear it around so much.

milesymoo · 05/08/2022 02:01

I do this all the time OP.

The poster could write a very lengthy post about an issue with their DS.

I'll start typing a reply and ...whoosh... I've forgotten whether the child is a son or daughter. And if I come out of my reply I'll probably lose what I've written. So I just change my response to 'DC' and 'they' as I don't want to get the sex wrong and simply can't remember

I've found it's got worse with age 😆

CourtneeLuv · 05/08/2022 00:16

😂😂😂

OP posts:
Roundandroundandroundwego · 05/08/2022 00:14

First of all it's a forum and every one and every one is anonymous and can claim to be anything from a straight human to a purple butterfly so I don't really care it's a chat forum and who or what you are in the real world is irrelevant to me.

Second while I still have some some degree of free speech I will type how I like.