Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if people use she/him, other people shouldn't use they/them

114 replies

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:13

As the title says, aibu in thinking that if someone uses Dh/Ds/Dd and she/him in their op, regarding who they're griping about, other posters shouldn't refer to them as they/them?

If you do this, why do you do it?

How do you know you won't offend the op/subject of the post by erasing their sex/gender/identity/etc?

I would be very 🤨 if someone did this to me in real life.

OP posts:
Dahliasrule · 05/08/2022 08:55

As an English teacher, I would say that slipping into they/their, when the singular pronoun would be the more appropriate one, is a very common grammatical mistake. I don’t think, in the majority of posts, it would be a conscious decision.

knittingaddict · 05/08/2022 08:45

I've honestly only seen this in the opening post to hide the sex of the person concerned, never in replies. If people do it in their replies it's usually the grammatically correct version as an alternative to saying something like "husband" all the time.

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 08:45

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 08:24

Firstly you’re just wrong. It simply is not that straight forward. If you think it is then I would advise you to seek your biology education from someone educated beyond secondary level, ideally who is associated with an academic institution and not just on YouTube

secondly when someone’s sex is unknown they is the convention

dr brown is new, they only started here on Monday.

it’s really not new or complex

This physician needs to heal herself first, I reckon.

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 08:44

5zeds · 05/08/2022 08:27

You obviously don’t have contact with anyone with more than a mild language deficit. @SomePosters your prioritising of ramps and access for physical disability speaks volumes. If you choose to embrace a language style that excludes those already struggling on the fringes of the group then you are just as responsible for excluding them as you would be if you refused guide dogs or ramps or hearing aides. If you choose to describe supporting disabled people as “shielding them from the world” then I’d say you are SO privileged that you can’t even see how revolting that is.

This is strongly worded, but I agree with it.

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 08:43

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 08:19

Make it like that if you want but I’m not ashamed actually

I’m a disability parent. I know what it is to have to world be inaccesible to your child for a variety of reasons

much as you might like to you cannot make the world to suit only you
People often have conflicting needs and while we can expect (or rather fight for) reasonable adaptations like ramps/lifts, quiet shopping hours and much wider use of social stories to aid community access

you absolutely cannot expect people en masse to change the language they use about themselves to suit you or your dc.

it’s a big confusing world, shielding them from use of the word they is the least of their problems frankly

If this is true, I am all the more surprised that you seem to believe that the claims of one group to change language to suit them should be accommodated automatically, and the claims of those who struggle with that should be completely disregarded.
it only makes sense if you accept that the first group has a right to be privileged over the other. That is ableism in its purest form.

Strugglingtodomybest · 05/08/2022 08:41

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 03:55

I've always used they for strangers. They is acceptable. I was raised in the era of 'who's she - the cat's mother?'.

Me too

orangeisthenewpuce · 05/08/2022 08:36

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:59

I'm talking about when people make a concerted effort not to use she/him/whatever the op used, but use gender neutral, even though the op clearly stated she's talking about her husband, for example.

You can tell when people are doing it.

I'm not wound up by it at all, I just wondered why people would tie themselves up on knots not to use terms clearly used by the op.

You can't tell when people are doing it because it's something only a tiny tiny minority people give a shit about

SleepingStandingUp · 05/08/2022 08:34

Soontobe60 · 05/08/2022 07:56

They’re still ‘shes’ though. Your Ds shouldn’t have to police his own speech in order to go along with other people’s ideologies.

If your friends given name was Stephanie but she recently had started going by her middle name Brianne, would you insist on using Stephanie because you prefer to and it's her given name and you don't have to police your own speech?

And honestly OP if someone using they on a thread about you makes you feel they're denying your sex you need to have a word with yourself

5zeds · 05/08/2022 08:27

You obviously don’t have contact with anyone with more than a mild language deficit. @SomePosters your prioritising of ramps and access for physical disability speaks volumes. If you choose to embrace a language style that excludes those already struggling on the fringes of the group then you are just as responsible for excluding them as you would be if you refused guide dogs or ramps or hearing aides. If you choose to describe supporting disabled people as “shielding them from the world” then I’d say you are SO privileged that you can’t even see how revolting that is.

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 08:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Firstly you’re just wrong. It simply is not that straight forward. If you think it is then I would advise you to seek your biology education from someone educated beyond secondary level, ideally who is associated with an academic institution and not just on YouTube

secondly when someone’s sex is unknown they is the convention

dr brown is new, they only started here on Monday.

it’s really not new or complex

Icecreamandapplepie · 05/08/2022 08:24

I get what you mean op.

I agree.

You aren't speaking about when it's grammatically correct to use theirs, but when it would've been grammatically correct to stick to his/hers.

It's very confusing and jarrs.

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 08:19

Make it like that if you want but I’m not ashamed actually

I’m a disability parent. I know what it is to have to world be inaccesible to your child for a variety of reasons

much as you might like to you cannot make the world to suit only you
People often have conflicting needs and while we can expect (or rather fight for) reasonable adaptations like ramps/lifts, quiet shopping hours and much wider use of social stories to aid community access

you absolutely cannot expect people en masse to change the language they use about themselves to suit you or your dc.

it’s a big confusing world, shielding them from use of the word they is the least of their problems frankly

richmondway · 05/08/2022 08:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Quia · 05/08/2022 08:16

Soontobe60 · 04/08/2022 21:14

Er, because it’s grammatically correct?

But it obviously isn't.

RoomOfRequirement · 05/08/2022 08:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

booboo24 · 05/08/2022 08:12

I understand what you're saying op, it doesn't wind me up particularly either BUT it is noticeable. When it occurs the other way around and someone uses a 'they' in the op, and then someone refers to them as he/she there is usually a spiky remark made somewhere along the way.

It seems some NHS departments are asking staff to sign off emails with their name and then underneath whether they are he she they etc. I've had colleagues refuse to do this as they don't feel they should have to if their names are for eg Catherine or Steve. These things work both ways.

However I also get that sometimes you just forget in amongst the various references to different people within
the op, and if you're typing a quick reply, its sometimes easy to forget, and I think sometimes you just make an assumption (not a conscious one) so it is just an innocent error

5zeds · 05/08/2022 08:09

they will have to get to grips with outside not followings the rules of home at some point. It’s not about being ableist, we can’t expect the whole world to conform to the norms you use at home to be less confusing to our children.
FFS. If only those pesky autistics would just “get to grips” with their language deficits eh? I mean they should just TRY HARDER not to have their disability. Shame on you @SomePosters

sorrynotathome · 05/08/2022 08:09

her’s is never grammatically correct

phishy · 05/08/2022 08:06

I can’t always remember if the OP said her boss/partner etc was male or female, so much easier to day ‘they’ rather than scrolling up to check mid-post.

Nothing to do with mis-gendering.

Svara · 05/08/2022 08:03

Soontobe60 · 05/08/2022 07:56

They’re still ‘shes’ though. Your Ds shouldn’t have to police his own speech in order to go along with other people’s ideologies.

He's okay with it. I agree when it's calling people the opposite to what you see, I'm autistic and find this extremely difficult, but 'they' is neutral. If I had been born 20 years later I'd have been one of those girls.

hattie43 · 05/08/2022 07:58

QuebecBagnet · 05/08/2022 06:46

saw her down by the river, they were getting into the car".

if someone actually said that I’d assume the woman was with a second person. So if she wasn’t with a second person it would be an odd sentence 🤷🏻‍♀️

This

I also find the use of they / them ridiculous. There was a post the other day about whether a birthday gift was suitable for ' them ' . No mention of boy / girl . The gift was body lotion and afternoon tea .

Well it's great for a girl but prob not for a boy . All the responders had to ask who it was for to device if it was suitable .
It also reads really weirdly and quite offensively like a non person

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:57

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 07:54

That’s only going to work in your home though isn’t it?

they will have to get to grips with outside not followings the rules of home at some point. It’s not about being ableist, we can’t expect the whole world to conform to the norms you use at home to be less confusing to our children.

wish we could. Then my 2yo wouldn’t have told me that girls can’t be drs

So no one should be expected to make any accommodations to include people with ASD?
but those who want to alter the rules of language to accommodate their “identity” get to do that, irrespective of whether that makes life difficult for a protected group?
nope. Can’t agree with that.
the fact you feel able to suggest that does illustrate my point about disability not mattering perfectly, though

Soontobe60 · 05/08/2022 07:56

Svara · 05/08/2022 07:33

Yes, this is what DS does. His male friends don't care about being referred to as they, but his non binary female friends might get upset at being called she. I think it would be very easy for him to slip up otherwise when I present similarly but am a she!

They’re still ‘shes’ though. Your Ds shouldn’t have to police his own speech in order to go along with other people’s ideologies.

SomePosters · 05/08/2022 07:54

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 07:48

and living with a teenager with autism, I take care not to use language in a way which is confusing to him.
might be worth reminding the interestingly identitied that people like him exist, and need to be included too.

That’s only going to work in your home though isn’t it?

they will have to get to grips with outside not followings the rules of home at some point. It’s not about being ableist, we can’t expect the whole world to conform to the norms you use at home to be less confusing to our children.

wish we could. Then my 2yo wouldn’t have told me that girls can’t be drs

midgetastic · 05/08/2022 07:54

Actually I would sometimes use they - like the doctor example below - even if I knew the sex of the doctor because the sex is irrelevant