Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if people use she/him, other people shouldn't use they/them

114 replies

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 21:13

As the title says, aibu in thinking that if someone uses Dh/Ds/Dd and she/him in their op, regarding who they're griping about, other posters shouldn't refer to them as they/them?

If you do this, why do you do it?

How do you know you won't offend the op/subject of the post by erasing their sex/gender/identity/etc?

I would be very 🤨 if someone did this to me in real life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
arrogantorwhat37 · 06/08/2022 08:52

arrogantorwhat37 · 05/08/2022 06:53

Using they/them to refer to a singular person if grammatically incorrect and really annoying. But, it is apparently ok if a person (singular) chooses to refer to themselves plurally i.e., them/they, despite the confusion it may cause

*is grammatically incorrect

Svara · 06/08/2022 08:22

It's how I usually use pronouns too. Though, if it upsets a young person to be constantly reminded that they are female when they are struggling with that, then I am happy to go neutral. I don't agree with irreversible treatments or damaging binders or any of that and I am thankful that I was born a generation too soon.

TullyApplebottom · 06/08/2022 06:13

I think that’s how most of us use pronouns. The generally accepted meaning is a person of either sex. When we say he or she we are not implying anything g about anyones personality, skills, interests, sense of self, anything! But some people have decided that the sexist interpretations of these words - that a he or a she is necessarily a certain type of person - is the true one, and the rest of us have to get into line even we struggle for reasons not of our making.
fair?

5zeds · 06/08/2022 04:48

Possibly it’s just a misunderstanding. When I use a pronoun I’m not describing gender I’m describing sex. I’m not sure why that’s hard to grasp. Mostly surely peoples gender being a reflection of how they feel isn’t pertinent.

amicissimma · 05/08/2022 21:32

I wish people wouldn't use 'they' to describe one person when it makes no difference to use 'she'or 'he' even if they used the 'wrong' one for an attempt at privacy.

So often it stops being clear if more than one person is involved if use of plural pronouns doesn't necessarily mean that plural is meant. Were there more than one all along? Has someone else joined in?

Penguintears · 05/08/2022 21:14

Svara · 05/08/2022 07:11

My DS just does it automatically. There are non binary females in his social group and he says it's easier to just use 'they' for everyone.

What is a non-binary female other than an oxymoron?

Saracen · 05/08/2022 17:54

Sometimes I can't be bothered to keep track of whether your partner is male or female and whether you're married to them, or whether your baby is a boy or girl. If it isn't relevant to the thread, then I don't see why I should scrupulously check your OP rather than just saying "they".

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 17:05

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 15:35

Only 12 now but yes the voice may not help their identity in the years to come

what will help, do you think?

5zeds · 05/08/2022 16:47

For the autistic children surely it would be easier for them to just grasp 'they' too. Rather than he or she, they would be unchanging for everyone?? generally we avoid using pronouns at all but no changing them to an oddly placed “they” is jarring to most but total car crash to my child. Most autistics have some level of language disorder but it occurs in non autistics too.

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 15:35

Svara · 05/08/2022 15:33

@Looneytune253 Sorry, pressed post too soon! Are they still quite young? If my 16 year old DS introduced me to a child who looked and sounded like a much younger boy, then I'd assume they were female. Though, in isolation I may read them as male.

Only 12 now but yes the voice may not help their identity in the years to come

Bollocks989 · 05/08/2022 15:35

YABU

Svara · 05/08/2022 15:33

@Looneytune253 Sorry, pressed post too soon! Are they still quite young? If my 16 year old DS introduced me to a child who looked and sounded like a much younger boy, then I'd assume they were female. Though, in isolation I may read them as male.

Svara · 05/08/2022 15:29

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 14:27

And genuinely no, my child is defo male presenting. No one would guess girl (and no one has since they changed) even when they lived as non binary they got he all the time

Are they

Soontobe60 · 05/08/2022 15:20

CourtneeLuv · 05/08/2022 05:43

If its so offensive to call people that use they and them, she or him, then that works both ways in my opinion. If someone calls themselves she/her, you shouldn't call them they.

I'm not 'so bothered' or 'wound up' or whatever the professional obtuse or cantankerous keep posting, it's just common manners to refer to people the way they refer to themselves.

When the person being spoken about isn’t present, then it matters not one iota what pronouns people use when referring to them. If someone gets offended by being called ‘they’ instead of ‘she’ when they/she are not even present, then they/she have got bigger issues to worry about. Personally, I think that compelling someone to use specific language to appease someone’s feelings is frankly pathetic.
You’re the one coming across as ‘professionally obtuse’.

ProfessorFusspot · 05/08/2022 15:11

carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 03:55

I've always used they for strangers. They is acceptable. I was raised in the era of 'who's she - the cat's mother?'.

You've missed the point, though.

"Who's she - the cat's mother?" is used to remind children it's rude to use a third person pronoun when the person is present. For example, if you and your mother and father are in the same room and you point to your mum and say "she said to tell you dinner's ready". Traditionally, it's polite to say "Mum said to tell you dinner's ready." (Or "Jenny said to tell you dinner's ready" if you call your mum by her first name.) Saying "They said to tell you dinner's ready" is just as rude, and you'd get a "who's they - the cat's mother?" in return.

But since no other poster's "DH" or "DC" or whatever is here in the room with me while I'm typing, it's irrelevant to the OP's question.

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 14:27

And genuinely no, my child is defo male presenting. No one would guess girl (and no one has since they changed) even when they lived as non binary they got he all the time

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 14:26

@TullyApplebottom I just meant generally, in society if we all used they them it would just be easier for everyone, especially those who
might struggle

TullyApplebottom · 05/08/2022 13:56

What does “male presenting” mean though? Biological sex is something we generally perceive immediately even if a person has made efforts to adopt appearance stereotypically associated with the other sex. If my DS perceives someone as female, he’s going to find it tough to understand why that person is insisting on being talked about using male or plural pronouns when they arent even present!
It is impossible to generalise about kids with ASD; some learn language relatively easily, others never do. One area that frequently presents difficulty in relation to expressive language, coincidentally, Is pronouns. This was true of my DS who simply missed them out of sentences for quite a long while after he had acquired expressive speech skills in line with his age in other respects. Having struggled with that and succeeded, is it fair to place the burden on him of learning a new set of rules? He already struggles to access certain areas of life. Is it fair to make it harder?
you also need to bear in mind that for some autistic people, the concept of a “gender identity” which can differ from their sexed body doesn’t make much sense; it’s simply not the way their brains work (a difficulty I confess I share).
so before making demands in this area of others, it’s right to consider whether they are equipped to meet those demands, and be careful to balance interests of others with your own. That’s just being a decent person.

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 13:31

But also for what it's worth my own children are very understanding of children with other needs. There would be no need for anyone to get their identity wrong though as they're male presenting and prefer he/they. I think anyone would use he if they met them

Looneytune253 · 05/08/2022 13:29

For the autistic children surely it would be easier for them to just grasp 'they' too. Rather than he or she, they would be unchanging for everyone?? I made the original comment about my children with other identities and the conversation has branched off that but if we all use 'they' wouldn't that be easier in the long run?

Igmum · 05/08/2022 10:30

I do it. It's grammatically correct, it's not offensive, it occasionally covers up my forgetfulness. I really wish people would stop disingenuously reading 'literal violence' into perfectly polite posts and conversations.

User12398712 · 05/08/2022 09:07

I use "they" as a singular pronoun quite often, despite knowing the sex of the person being referred to. I consider it to be a perfectly acceptable alternative to he or she despite knowing it is grammatically incorrect. (I wouldn't use interchangeably in formal writing but, equally, I would never end a sentence with a preposition in formal writing but, in speech or informal writing, it's not something I'm fussy about.)

I suspect that it derives from growing up in the era when we moved from using the default male in all circumstances to being inclusive of women (eg "When a customer comes into the shop, ask them if they need help", rather than "...ask him if he needs help.") That change of usage, at a time when my language was developing and becoming cemented, means that I consider they interchangeable with he or she.

saraclara · 05/08/2022 09:05

I'm not annoyed at all. Is there something wrong with your comprehension? I just wonder why people do it.

This faux innocence is way more annoying than any grammatical error, or even deliberate use of they. At least be honest about your intentions when you start a thread to stir something up.

MistyFuckingQuigley · 05/08/2022 09:01

CourtneeLuv · 04/08/2022 22:37

I'm not annoyed at all. Is there something wrong with your comprehension? I just wonder why people do it.

I do it (in real life conversations too) because that is how I've always used the English language. I'm from the North East originally, we tend to use they/them a lot regardless of sex. No big deal. Language is used differently depending on where in the British Isles you are from. Shocking I know 🤣

knittingaddict · 05/08/2022 08:59

And like another person on here I grew up with "who's she, the cat's mother?" That stays with you.