Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this is a dealbreaker

159 replies

TeaFiend100 · 04/08/2022 19:43

Woke up this morning to text from boyfriend of 6 months saying I'd upset him with a (goodnatured) little ribbing last night about him spelling something wrong. Said he felt patronised, and that he's 'good at spelling' so it especially annoyed him. I tried to call him and he didn't answer, sent a text saying sorry, acknowledging he had the right to feel that way and saying I wouldn't have ribbed him if his spelling was actually ever an issue. I said I loved and respected him, and wanted to chat through in person. Tried calling again, no answer.

He then sends me a long text saying he's finding the way I talk about money a lot 'unattractive', that he feels I've 'lost sense of reality' because I earn more than the general population does (I'm London based though) and I'm still worried about money (I'd been talking about budgeting the night before as we were going to move in together in September, and I'm generally finding money hard at the mo as have taken a 50% paycut for a job with better longterm prospects than my last), and that I must think he 'shouldn't bother getting out of bed each morning' because of his wage (I earn double the amount he does). He also called me a 'plastic liberal'.

I felt really attacked, and disliked, and I said that over text, and that he should think about whether or not he actually does want to move in with me or not, or even be together, as it doesn't feel like it. He has expressed being insecure about earning less than me a few times, and money DOES come up a lot in our relationship (just as much led by him as it's this weird elephant in the room - it's not come up for me in other relationships so it's not just me) and I have done SO much to reassure him I don't care he earns less, there's different ways of bringing value to a relationship etc. I have said in the future I would see our money as OUR money, not mine vs his, etc to make him feel better and like it's on the same team.

He also can be bitter about his place in life, lack of career (he works quite a menial job in his late 30s), blaming his parents or having a go at 'people with deskjobs' (I have a deskjob!). Again I've been nothing but supportive, telling him I'm proud of him and would support him to retrain in the future if we wants as that's what couples do - they're a team.

Anyway he called, apologised, and we talked for a bit and he agreed he shouldn't have texted that and should have instead thought about what he needed from me (ie talk less about money) and then to me calmly to discuss it. I said it felt like sometimes he was bitter and it was affecting his behaviour, and he said 'oh women, they always like to call men bitter. Fuck off' and put the phone down.

He then instantly called back and apologised. I was very upset. I was honest with him that I felt I needed to walk on eggshells around him in the sense of it's really obvious he is very insecure about his status, and that I didn't like that he criticised people, bringing them down to make himself better, and had now done it to me. I said he hardly ever actually builds me up, or says he's proud of me (and I've worked HARD to have a house on my own in London, I grew up on a council estate, parents have no money and I've put myself through one of the best unis in the country etc all without any financial or other kind of support (I come from a very dysfunctional family). He knows this yet he seems to put me in the same box as all of the 'middle class' entitled people he criticises alot). That I feel I need to play down and pander to him.

He said he was glad I had said that, that he hadn't realised, and that he can see my point. He said he had been a dick, and that he was really sorry. That he had been feeling awful this morning and shouldn't have taken it out on me. He admitted he thinks he's pushing me away because he doesnt think he deserves me, that his friends say things like 'how did you manage that?' when he tells them about me / my achievements, but that he hadn't realised he never tells me how lucky he feels (I sometimes have to ask him for reassurance or praise). I asked him if he wants to be with me, and he said yes, and that he loves me, and that he 'just wants me to be happy' (I think this was code for 'I worry I won't make you happy and maybe breaking up now will mean I won't disappoint you further').

I said I needed some time, and he said he understood. He hasn't been in touch in since we chatted at 1pm, and I wish he had at least texted to say he was really sorry. I imagine he feels ashamed.

The thing is, I'm about to be 38 and want a child. I have been dating for years, and had several boyfriends who are just not right, or don't want kids on the same timeline, or have issues, etc etc. Some of these people had lots of money, but with this guy I chose him for what I thought were the same values and was fine with the idea that we would never be well off and I would just have to work harder (freelance work on top of full time job) to bring money in when needed, as I am lucky enough to be able to do that. We had been planning a future together, which I feel very invested, and I feel so hurt that he's said all this. I don't like his immature approach to conflict, I don't like the swearing and name calling, and I don't like the fact he takes out insecurities on me.

He has acknowledged these are his issues though. So maybe there's hope?

Obviously there are loads of good things about this man that it would take ages to list. I felt like I'd found someone who got me in ways others find hard to, we generally have a lovely time together and he's always made me feel very safe, unlike lots of other guys. He is very emotionally available usually, always there for me and generally good at talking things through. There have been no major conflicts other than this.

WWYD?

OP posts:
TeaFiend100 · 06/08/2022 15:12

And by the way. This def doesn’t mean I will get back with him! Just that I need to think. I think a bit of space will help my feelings settle down so I can realise how I truly feel as aware at the mo it’s still very fresh and a part of me will obviously want to just pretend it never happened and go back to normal as a self protection mechanism.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 06/08/2022 15:09

OP,

You are a bright young woman who deserves the best.

You were brave to post and you have been given anonymous views a plenty.

Many have spelt out their views on him but of course the decision is yours to make.

I wish you the very best and hope you will post again should you feel the need to.

Good luck.

TeaFiend100 · 06/08/2022 14:48

Thank you everyone for your comments and experiences. I know I’m going to get flamed for even wavering over this, but I am going to take some time to think after last night.

He said all the right things, in that he admitted that what he did was abusive, immature and 100% driven by his insecurities. He recognises swearing is an absolute boundary for me and deeply regrets what he did and the way he made me feel. There was no excusing or minimising of my feelings and he understands my need to take some time as he knows I deserve a lot better.

In terms of the insecurities, he said he gets triggered when I say I worry about not saving enough money as it makes him worry what he earns isn’t enough (I don’t really care what he earns) and that he worries for my mental health and feels I have the weight of the world on my shoulders when I should be enjoying a healthy salary, not doing freelance work on my side and grinding myself down (to be fair a few friends have said this to me too, and I have made the decision to stop as it isn’t good for my health and I do earn enough to get buy and put a little extra into the mortgage each month).

He said he wants us to feel like a team and that he can contribute financially to take some of my worries away, and when I talk about my finances in a way that portrays I’ll always have to be planning for kids etc on my own (my default position as I had resigned myself to it if I didn’t find the right person to have them with) he feels like he’s entirely redundant. It’s true, I do always assume he’ll contribute nothing as I’m so used to doing things on my own when he always makes a point of being generous and paying for things etc. He also realises it’s early to be thinking like that but would want that for our future.

As to the ‘women always’ stuff he totally admits it was a misogynist comment and actively wants to tackle this. He said that he knows he’s probably picked up some shitty attitudes from growing up where he did and the job he does (I would definitely agree he hasn’t been exposed to a fraction of the education around this I’ve had) and that he really does want to let all of that go. To be fair to him, we regularly have conversations about feminist issues and he is always on my side and points stuff out himself when it’s not okay on tv or in general culture etc. I’ve noticed he’s been reading more stuff about patriarchy etc and educating himself since we got together, and I do think that’s a really good sign that he can improve, but obviously it doesn’t mitigate the fact he said something really toxic.

On being bitter about his ex, I probably didn’t paint the whole picture. He’s generally really nice about her and open about their time together. It seems they had a generally nice relationship, but he says when they argued they did swear at eachother (he had mentioned this before so I know he’s not making it up) and he now knows this is not the way I roll. The only thing he has expressed regret about is moving to London for her, but he’s also said he couldn’t go back because he loves London so it’s not a simple one.

To the people saying he’d leave me alone to do housework etc, I really don’t think that
the case. He loves making himself useful and doing housework and diy for me. He clearly gets a kick from helping me out. Almost the first thing he does at mine when he arrives is my washing up because he says he enjoys it. He is also very happy to be a sahd if it was best for finances, and admitted last night that for him being a dad has always been his only real ambition. He felt ashamed to admit that but tbh it’s attractive to me because I am quite ambitious and type a and I probably prefer men that aren’t the same as me. I like someone who is homely and chilled, like him.

He also knows that retraining in something would be good for his self esteem. He did start a degree in mental health nursing but stopped during the pandemic as he just found it too lonely doing it from a bedroom in a city he didn’t know. He has successfully volunteered for St. John’s ambulance for quite a while and has a nurturing, gentle quality and is good in a crisis.
He admits dropping out really affected his self esteem and he needs to think again about next steps and not let lack of confidence get in the way.

To the person who said this sounds like a business transaction, if I saw it that way I would have settled for one of the many men I’ve dated with lots of money. I decided to date according to my values and emotional needs and that’s why I love this man. He is generally soft and gentle with me, good when I’m having anxious moments (very rare I’ve found) and has generally made me feel totally accepted. I have found myself feeling like I need to be sensitive around money stuff (ie the walking on eggshells comment) but I don’t mean every day, just around that issue as I know he worries he’s not good enough on that front.

He seemed to finally hear last night that I genuinely don’t mind what he earns and that that’s not why I decided to date him - it was for who he was. He said he’s got so used to being judged for his job (ie women deleting him on dating apps when they find out what it is) he has learned to be ashamed of it. I do believe him on that. I have seen people try and hide their surprise when he tells them what he does as he doesn’t come across as typical of the industry.

Anyway, sorry, I’m going on. Just trying to paint a fuller picture. I’m going to see how I feel in a week or so. I did come out of the conversation feeling heard, and really loved. But I also know that if I decide to give it a go moving in is off the table (it was me that bought it up in the first place anyway) and it’s a two strikes and you’re out situation. He seems terrified of losing me but also fully prepared to let me go if that’s what I feel is right for me which leaves me feeling unpressurised either way from him.

I hope I don’t get too much of a flaming as I don’t want to feel I can’t come back here. I know how many women have been abusive situations and am on hyper alert for it hence posting at the first sign he might be a shit. If I do decide to give him another go, I won’t be posting again, I’ll be dumping him. But I do need to have a think and make sure I’m doing what feels right for me.

OP posts:
TeaFiend100 · 06/08/2022 12:18

Oh my god.. just drafted a really long message and then something happened and lost it!! Thanks for those checking in. Am just about to go into Pilates class but will update later x

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 06/08/2022 11:37

This sounds like a business deal tbh.
You sound like you feel you’ve settled. He must sense it too.
His behaviour would raise red flags for me tbh

I6344 · 06/08/2022 11:27

Sorry I hadn't read the full thread. Did you break up with him last night?

I6344 · 06/08/2022 11:24

Deep down, is this really someone you would like to be the father of your future children? What happens when he is not feeling well around them? Will he tell them to fuck off and be nasty to them? He sounds very insecure and aggressive but quite frankly that isn't your problem. You've only been together 6 months and he is already showing multiple red flags. I can guarantee it will get worse as time goes on.

PlanetNormal · 06/08/2022 11:21

Over the last 20+ years, DP and I have had our ups and downs like any couple in a long term relationship. But he has never, ever told me to ‘fuck off’. Not once. And I have never said anything of the sort to him, and never would. If he ever did, I would dump him, and that is what you should do, OP, to this pathetic insecure little loser.

greatblueheron · 06/08/2022 11:16

Dealbreaker.

You don't want to marry or co parent with this man. You really don't.

Look into having a child on your own. I know someone who has done this, she's now had 2, and is perfectly happy with her decision and life. And you, frankly, are better placed financially to go it alone by the sound of it.

Itsnotallblackandwhite · 06/08/2022 11:12

How did it go last night @TeaFiend100? Are you okay? X

FictionalCharacter · 05/08/2022 15:52

Bingo @AchatAVendre “I suspect its because a lot of men in the past didn't actually have to work that hard at all in order to walk into quite a well paid job for life.”
Indeed - and those jobs were considered to be for men, not for women.

Well done @TeaFiend100 . This isn’t easy but you’ll feel better without him after the initial sadness.

billy1966 · 05/08/2022 15:40

OP, get into therapy quick.

It reads like you want to marry down to fit in with your dysfunctional family.

Wtf are you thinking.

Why would you want anyone who fits in with them?

You have worked hard, you deserve your success.

Don't sabotage yourself by marrying an insecure, bitter oaf, just because he fits in with your fxxked up family.

There are lots of men out there, the choice isn't pompous arse/bitter insecure oaf.

Expect him to turn all apologetand try to hoover you back in when he realises how upset you are.

He told you to fxxk off.
A icky little bitter man who is still bitching about his lucky girlfriend who escaped 8 YEARS AGO.

Ffs ........8 years ago. Lucky girl.

You will bitterly regret giving this idiot a second chance.

Unforgivably silly to even consider moving in, having babies with an angry man who has you walking on eggshells.

What an awful mistake that would be.

Snoredoeurve · 05/08/2022 15:24

Theres a lot of that attitude about though, especially amongst some men, or at least those are the people I've heard it from. Especially in Scotland...sometimes one of them you don't know all that well will come out with something like "rich people buying fancy Mercedes" or "the privileged rich" when talking about a professional job thats required a lot of training. And it really just sounds like sour grapes. I suspect its because a lot of men in the past didn't actually have to work that hard at all in order to walk into quite a well paid job for life.

I think its because they feel, as men, that they are entitled to have a great life, job etc and there is a huge amount of sneering and negativity to people , particularly women who have done well.
How dare you do better than him.
I work with a man like this who pretends to be nice,liberal etc but who is the most PA and bitter person.
He has a huge chip on his shoulder regarding anyone who owns a house, despite him frittering away 40K redundancy money.

You have seen this man for who he really is now,also in the lovebombing stage of abuse they mirror everything , your likes and opinions.
6 months and moving in is fast tracking the relationship, was this his idea?
Be wary because he will likely be round swearing undying love later.
Base your next action on his behaviour not his words

TeaFiend100 · 05/08/2022 11:35

He's coming over for 7. I'm going to see what he has to say, and then probably dump him. Feeling a bit sick. But also like I can't even bear the idea of him ever touching me again.

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 05/08/2022 11:09

I've said to boyfriend a few times he needs to stop demonising people that have more money than him, and that in my experience there's no correlation between kindness and wealth. One of my richest friends is also the most aware of his privilege, and he is a thoughtful and generous person that relates to people just simply as fellow humans. I don't think boyfriend believes that on one level, possibly because he's in a job where he feels people treat him badly because of his status (to be fair they probably do) and it's given him a bit of a complex.

Theres a lot of that attitude about though, especially amongst some men, or at least those are the people I've heard it from. Especially in Scotland...sometimes one of them you don't know all that well will come out with something like "rich people buying fancy Mercedes" or "the privileged rich" when talking about a professional job thats required a lot of training. And it really just sounds like sour grapes. I suspect its because a lot of men in the past didn't actually have to work that hard at all in order to walk into quite a well paid job for life.

TBH whereas I know i've done well I also sometimes regret going to Oxbridge and 'moving class'. I come across as quite middle class, and pretty much all of my exes have been, but I never feel quite at home with their families and I am always super nervous of what they'll think of mine - a couple have been quite snobby, and it's always an anxiety when I'm dating.

You sound as though you lack confidence and snobbishness is extremely low class. Avoid middle class families and maybe try to meet someone with similar aspirations and motivations to yourself who doesn't spend half his life either with his family or worrying about what they think. Someone a little more independent. Although be wary of the so-called "landed gentry" type - a lot of them are looking to marry into money. My friend was told, somewhat sorrowfully by one that although he really liked her, he was really looking for someone with a grouse moor or equivalent Grin

Ivyruin · 05/08/2022 10:10

My ex was like this. Used to try and belittle me each time. Would question how I got my career being a single parent. Like I didn't deserve it or something. He had a good job but lived beyond his needs. Whereas I have what I need and don't throw money away. I bought myself a new car and I was so proud of myself as I never thought I'd ever have a car like this. So he went out and bought a fancy Mercedes on his credit card as he wanted a better car than me. My dad raised me better than to put up with that crap. I lasted less than a year with him!! It's been 3 years and he still hovers around!!

Best advice I can give, give the closure then cut contact. Don't try and be friends, you'll never get rid of him. These type of people with drain the life out of you.

Good luck. I hope you meet someone who deserves you x

Exhaustedcog · 05/08/2022 09:54

This reminds me of that Maya Angelou quote- when someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time.

TheWrongAllmanBrother · 05/08/2022 09:49

Honestly, chuck this one back in the sea. More red flags than a Liverpool FC match.

Sounds like he has some seriously off and deep-seated insecurities, bitterness and misogynistic views around women. None of this is your problem to fix and will only make you miserable in the long-run. You deserve much, much better.

Phosphorescent · 05/08/2022 09:43

curiouslypacific · 04/08/2022 20:40

This man is following the script for being abusive. He'll be nice to you for a little while now so you think he's changed. Then he'll find some other reason to take issue with you, probably over something entirely trivial, just to keep you off balance. One day you'll wake up and realise you're always on edge, watching what you say and do so as not to upset him. That you can never relax in your own house; that whatever you do, it's never quite enough to make him happy. Even worse you'll watch your kids grow up tiptoeing around daddy, fearful and trying not to upset him - learning that their needs are secondary to those of an angry insecure man.

This 100%
Run

TeaFiend100 · 05/08/2022 09:42

@Itsnotallblackandwhite totally agree. I've said to boyfriend a few times he needs to stop demonising people that have more money than him, and that in my experience there's no correlation between kindness and wealth. One of my richest friends is also the most aware of his privilege, and he is a thoughtful and generous person that relates to people just simply as fellow humans. I don't think boyfriend believes that on one level, possibly because he's in a job where he feels people treat him badly because of his status (to be fair they probably do) and it's given him a bit of a complex.

I realise the irony of me saying it was nice to be going out with someone from a similar background to me. I just find it hard to meet someone who feels comfy with my family. And there's so much crap in my family that it can be embarrassing - they're not a very functional bunch. But I guess I have to remember they don't define me, and you get loads of dysfunction at all levels of society.

OP posts:
Itsnotallblackandwhite · 05/08/2022 09:33

Honestly @TeaFiend100, I’ve been lucky enough to have met people from all walks of life (from titled aristocracy to working with homeless men and women). When I first met lords, ladies, admirals and the like I felt a bit out of my depth and was sure they’d look down on me. None of them did. My role involved arranging events and sitting down to dinner with them afterwards. They were all lovely, easy to talk to and interested in me (or did a good job of feigning it). My sister is ‘new money’ worth millions and is frankly quite horrid to people she sees as beneath her now. She also thinks I’m a snob because I’m educated (I think my educational success makes her feel inferior). God forbid that I ever mention in company the disadvantaged northern town that we grew up in!

i understand completely where you are coming from, but not all families from upper classes (for want of a better phrase) are snobby, just as not all mc/wc people are ‘salt of the earth’.

your BF sounds like an inverted snob, which is as bad as regular snobbery in my mind.

whumpthereitis · 05/08/2022 09:20

His mask has started to slip. He’s apologizing not because he means it, he’s apologizing because he hasn’t fully secured you yet. As much as he resents you for it and intends to drag you down, he wants what you can offer him. Hence the cleaning and the ‘thoughtful’ behaviors, they’re not for your benefit, but his. I imagine he wants to marry (even if he’s currently playing cool on the subject), so he’s in a position where he could take at least half of everything you have. Maybe more if he sets himself up as primary carer. Any children you had he would be the main influence over, and don’t think he wouldn’t weaponize them against you. He would instill his misogyny.

If you went ahead, moved in with him and got pregnant, you would see the man he really is and wish you had paid attention to these red flags. You risk losing everything you’ve ever worked for.

Run.

TeaFiend100 · 05/08/2022 08:54

@Itsnotallblackandwhite Thank you, that's really kind of you to say. TBH whereas I know i've done well I also sometimes regret going to Oxbridge and 'moving class'. I come across as quite middle class, and pretty much all of my exes have been, but I never feel quite at home with their families and I am always super nervous of what they'll think of mine - a couple have been quite snobby, and it's always an anxiety when I'm dating.

So I was really relieved to have found a nice man who came from a similar background to me who said that he was attracted to strong, ambitious women. And he was the first to really get on with my family - they were so excited about him.

Sorry, realise this has turned into a woe is me. Of course I don't date for class, I date for the person. But it's quite a common experience for people to 'move classes' to feel they don't fit in anywhere, and I definitely do relate to that, and I think it makes it hard to find someone who's really suited to me - because I can relate to so many kinds of people, I find it hard to filter! And to know what's actually right for me. This man reminded me of home. We had the same sense of humour. The same music taste. We could relate on lots of levels I haven't had before about our families. It's such a shame.

OP posts:
Sartre · 05/08/2022 08:24

Ahh it’s totally obvious what is happening here. He’s extremely insecure about himself, his life, his job, his income etc and you only make this worse because you’re more successful than he is so it highlights the insecurities. Your relationship won’t work long term I’m afraid so don’t move in with him, I’d just end things now tbh.

Longdistance · 05/08/2022 08:21

Gosh, that’s awful. Imagine having kids with this pos and being saddled with him for life.
Go meet someone. 6 months in shouldn’t be this hard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread