Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want the smaller house

71 replies

Jacketandbeans · 04/08/2022 19:06

I'm really interested in opinions on space VS location as DH and I can't agree. We are looking at houses and I'm tempted by a house that is a stone's throw from a station and 20 minute walk to the beach, and walking distance to nice parks, cafes, pubs etc.
The house has no garage, no loft (converted to 4th bedroom) and is 1300sq feet including a conservatory off the back. It does have off road parking for 2 cars. Only one bathroom, no downstairs loo, no ensuite.
The other option is a 5 bed detached house with ample storage, much bigger kitchen and living space, 2 bathrooms and a separate toilet. You'd need to drive to go anywhere in reality and it feels very quiet, but still a lovely area.
We have 3 boys.

What would you choose? I'd love to hear from people with experience. As kids get older what becomes the priority? At the moment they are newborn, 2 and 6 and I'd love more space for all their crap, but the appeal of walking or cycling to the sea, and walking distance to cafes, restaurants etc really appeals.

OP posts:
dhair · 04/08/2022 21:45

lol

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 21:44

dhair · 04/08/2022 21:43

Like any teenager would actually choose to live off the beaten track to gain a bigger bedroom!

As a teenager I spent most of those years at my friends house. It was a flat but z1.

Most teens would live in a tent if they could pitch it in Zone 1.

dhair · 04/08/2022 21:43

Like any teenager would actually choose to live off the beaten track to gain a bigger bedroom!

As a teenager I spent most of those years at my friends house. It was a flat but z1.

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 21:43

freesolo · 04/08/2022 21:39

I couldn't agree more! We are a family of 5 with one bathroom, it really isn't an issue.

Agree with this as well. Multiple bathrooms being seen as an "essential" is a relatively recent phenomenon.

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 21:42

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/08/2022 21:34

Location all the way. When you have space you fill space just because you can; when you don’t have it, you don’t, and from experience, you don’t miss it.

I don’t understand why so many people compromise on things like location or amenities to choose a larger house so they have space to store “stuff” and have spare bedrooms. Maybe that’s partly due to being a Londoner, and so prices here mean that it would end up being among the most expensive storage units and occasional hotel rooms in the world! But we’ve never regretted going for smaller, making it work for us, being somewhat disciplined about differentiating between useful stuff and junk, and have a great life with everything we want on the doorstep.

Yes, all of this.
Like any teenager would actually choose to live off the beaten track to gain a bigger bedroom!

freesolo · 04/08/2022 21:39

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 04/08/2022 19:36

I don't get why people 'need' more than one bathroom or loo. You wait your turn!

I'd go for smaller. The kids will move out and otherwise you'll be stuck with a massive house in the middle of nowhere. Or have to move again.

I couldn't agree more! We are a family of 5 with one bathroom, it really isn't an issue.

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/08/2022 21:34

Location all the way. When you have space you fill space just because you can; when you don’t have it, you don’t, and from experience, you don’t miss it.

I don’t understand why so many people compromise on things like location or amenities to choose a larger house so they have space to store “stuff” and have spare bedrooms. Maybe that’s partly due to being a Londoner, and so prices here mean that it would end up being among the most expensive storage units and occasional hotel rooms in the world! But we’ve never regretted going for smaller, making it work for us, being somewhat disciplined about differentiating between useful stuff and junk, and have a great life with everything we want on the doorstep.

calmlakes · 04/08/2022 21:09

We are moving to a small house for location.
Dc are teens and want to get themselves around.
I'm quite enjoying the massive declutter, shedding of stuff( DH really isn't)

bloodyunicorns · 04/08/2022 21:01

Bigger house for me. How far is it from the beach?

Holidaydreamingagain · 04/08/2022 20:57

1300 square feet Is pretty small with 3 kids. I would look for something else or go for The other house. I would also want more than 1 bathroom and a downstairs loo is non negotiable.

10”% with young kids I would absolutely go for space

ivykaty44 · 04/08/2022 20:53

id choose the location

as the boys get older they will appreciate living walking distance from the beach and amenities

living where they always have to ask for lifts everywhere is not great

an extra toilet can be added somewhere to a house but you'll not change the driving age below 17

have you just got the floor plan of the location house?

DaisyWaldron · 04/08/2022 20:52

I gave teenagers now, and I'm so glad that I went for a smaller house in a central location. The children can take themselves to their activities and back; there are plenty of part time jobs available and they can meet up with friends easily. There are teen-friendly places they can go to to socialise outside the house. No need for constant lifts; and lots of stuff to do that isn't drinking/drugs in a field.

Silvercatowner · 04/08/2022 20:47

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 04/08/2022 19:36

I don't get why people 'need' more than one bathroom or loo. You wait your turn!

I'd go for smaller. The kids will move out and otherwise you'll be stuck with a massive house in the middle of nowhere. Or have to move again.

... until you all get noro or something equally unspeakable.

Baxdream · 04/08/2022 20:45

Personally, as soon as children start at senior school, location is everything! Walking to and from school with friends, meeting friends at the weekend etc
We very nearly bought a house in a village which would have meant lifts everywhere- work, clubs, social life etc. I am so glad we chose location!

But if you only plan on being there for 5 years then space would take priority...!

felulageller · 04/08/2022 20:44

If you have your own car then the bigger house.

BluOcty · 04/08/2022 20:39

Location for me

PeppaPigStinks · 04/08/2022 20:37

if There is scope for extending abd the garden has space for sheds for storage location.
we have three kids and extended and it’s made the world of difference.
the walk to the beach and parks means you won’t be a taxi as kids get older and they can be more independent.

but, if you can’t extend to get the extras I think with three boys I would need or want the space.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/08/2022 20:25

Always location… I’d hate to live in a suburb where I had to drive everywhere, and more space just means more crap

.. as long as you can add a shower room with a loo.

if there’s a compromise position look at that

dhair · 04/08/2022 20:24

1300 sq ft isn't even that small. It's the same size as millions of London terraces that cost millions!

possiblypassable · 04/08/2022 20:22

Five people in the smaller space wouldn't be for me, but it depends on your lifestyle. If you're the type who will be out and about whenever possible, it might not matter so much. I prefer to stay home most of the time, so having room to stretch out and breathe is important to me.

I'd insist on a second bathroom, if you take the smaller house. Five people needing to use a single loo every morning before school or work is not great, not to mention how unpleasant it is when someone is ill and needs the toilet frequently and urgently.

yonce · 04/08/2022 20:22

I'd pick the larger one tbh! You'd feel on top of each other imo and extra bathrooms are a godsend.

"I don't understand the 6 footer thing either, do tall people really take up more actual space than shorter people?"

Of course they do....if someone is 6ft6 they take up more space than someone who is 5ft 😂

Nandocushion · 04/08/2022 20:21

Get the first one but I'd add a full bathroom/shower room, not just a loo if you want it to last you longer. Location is 100% more important than space for crap, but it does have to meet your needs.

I'd be tempted to factor in converting the conservatory to a proper room as well, depending on how much outdoor space you have.

Oldrockingchair · 04/08/2022 20:19

Where do you live?! I love the sound of it!!

dhair · 04/08/2022 20:17

I'd hate to have to drive everywhere personally

parietal · 04/08/2022 20:15

go with the location. If in 8 years time when the kids are teens, you find it is too small then you could look to move again. but being in a good location for yourself and the kids right now where you can walk to shops / parks / station is a BIG plus.

Being tied to your car is expensive (petrol prices) and means you will end up being a parent-taxi driving your kids everywhere.