Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want the smaller house

71 replies

Jacketandbeans · 04/08/2022 19:06

I'm really interested in opinions on space VS location as DH and I can't agree. We are looking at houses and I'm tempted by a house that is a stone's throw from a station and 20 minute walk to the beach, and walking distance to nice parks, cafes, pubs etc.
The house has no garage, no loft (converted to 4th bedroom) and is 1300sq feet including a conservatory off the back. It does have off road parking for 2 cars. Only one bathroom, no downstairs loo, no ensuite.
The other option is a 5 bed detached house with ample storage, much bigger kitchen and living space, 2 bathrooms and a separate toilet. You'd need to drive to go anywhere in reality and it feels very quiet, but still a lovely area.
We have 3 boys.

What would you choose? I'd love to hear from people with experience. As kids get older what becomes the priority? At the moment they are newborn, 2 and 6 and I'd love more space for all their crap, but the appeal of walking or cycling to the sea, and walking distance to cafes, restaurants etc really appeals.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
carefullycourageous · 05/08/2022 03:44

Location first, especially if you have to drive everywhere from the bigger house as that becomes a major PITA when kids are older. A house you can walk from is bliss and such an advantage financially and socially.

alanabennett · 05/08/2022 03:39

Johnnysgirl · 05/08/2022 00:55

(though not as small as yours, admittedly.). Hardly necessary?

Necessary in the sense that the size of the house matters. I went for the smaller house, but it was still larger than 1,300 square feet. If I'd had to make a choice with 5 people in 1,300 square feet I may have chosen differently.

Rainbowqueeen · 05/08/2022 03:36

Location for me too.

Minniem2020 · 05/08/2022 03:35

Location for me. I grew up in a village with limited public transport to the main town where my friends all lived and as a teenager I disliked it. I often had to stay home when my friends were all meeting as I couldn't get to and from.
We're a family of 5/7 at the weekends and only have 1 bathroom and very limited space. We manage just fine, you just have to be more savvy with storage solutions and a bit more ruthless with not hanging on to things you don't really need. We're walking distance to the station/town centre and beach and wouldn't give that up.

bumbledeedum · 05/08/2022 03:01

Location for me all the way, we've just done similar.

The 'big' house doesn't actually look that much bigger when you knock off the basement storage area. Less liveable space on the ground floor and I would not be keen on sleeping on a different floor (two floors away especially) to any of my kids at those ages so you'd only have 3 bedrooms on the same floor with is another PITA. Can't see the appeal of option 2 at all seeing those floor plans.

wombat1a · 05/08/2022 02:50

Defn #2, beach and parks are only attractive to kids when they are very young - as soon as they get phones/tablets they are more interested in those.

ultraviolet4753 · 05/08/2022 00:57

Location. If you're ever unable to drive due to illness etc, or can't afford a car one day, you're stuffed.

Johnnysgirl · 05/08/2022 00:55

(though not as small as yours, admittedly.). Hardly necessary?

alanabennett · 05/08/2022 00:50

We had a similar decision to make recently and went with the smaller house in the better location (though not as small as yours, admittedly.) As the kids get older (I have three) location will become even more important. I felt so incredibly isolated in the suburban neighborhood and would hate to live somewhere I had to drive everywhere.

Johnnysgirl · 05/08/2022 00:46

There's that obsession with toilets again... Lovely house but needs two more toilets 🤣

PeekAtYou · 05/08/2022 00:45

I would pick the first house and add a toilet (or two)

oviraptor21 · 05/08/2022 00:41

You don't say anything about the location of the bigger house so it's impossible to judge.

Assuming it's not on a sink estate and can still reach facilities reasonably quickly I'd go with bigger every time. The smaller one may be OK now but as the boys get bigger that extra space will be a godsend.

Johnnysgirl · 05/08/2022 00:33

What's the "basement" floor? Is it just a lower floor leading into the back garden or is it all below ground? The "basement storage area" would suggest the latter 😬

Jacketandbeans · 05/08/2022 00:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

calmlakes · 04/08/2022 22:45

Although we are moving to a central small location with our teens we have had much larger more rural properties when they were smaller.
That is nice for small kids I don't regret that but we are having to move now because running teens around is a pain for all of us.

HandScreen · 04/08/2022 22:44

Location!

Blondeshavemorefun · 04/08/2022 22:36

It’s always location hence the programme location x3

a park beach shops all close when young is fab

when teenagers they can go by selves

bigger house but needing to drive everywhere and be mums cabs not so good

how big is garden in smaller house

do you have floor plan

Blossomtoes · 04/08/2022 22:29

Nobody I know! Mind you, that’s coming from someone who thinks putting a new loo in is impossible.

Johnnysgirl · 04/08/2022 22:25

The idea of choosing a house far away from most amenities so there'd be room to store hand me down clothes is literally making me laugh 😆
Who thinks like this?!

Lubdeness · 04/08/2022 22:17

Re extending downstairs to add a bathroom/loo, piping water to it is usually relatively easy but waste removal is a whole other matter. Personally I would choose the larger house. I have 2 sons, so had a lot of hand me down clothes to store for a couple of years. By the time they are about 13 they are adult sized so imagine 5 adults in the smaller house.

Conservatories are mainly unusable, sometimes they work as an extra room but often they do not.

Think about everything you currently store in your loft, where will you put it? Paid for storage is not cheap. A shed is not the same as a loft. We chose a house that could grow with us. My children are teenagers, they have their own room each as well as a bedroom each. They have a bathroom between them and Dh and I have an en-suite plus we have a downstairs loo. Everyone showers for work/school in the morning. Lovely to only share with one other person.

saleorbouy · 04/08/2022 22:17

Smaller house but with well designed storage and function would be my preference.
Heating, running and maintaining a smaller house is cheaper.

cocktailclub · 04/08/2022 22:01

Definitely the one which has easy access to shops and entertainment. Been in a more rural house with three kids as teenagers. Until they can drive your evenings are ruined by lifts.

TheNoodlesIncident · 04/08/2022 21:56

I would go for the better located house but add a downstairs toilet and shower room, without a doubt. We are a family of three and sometimes we need to go to the outside toilet as the bathroom is being used - and I love having that back-up toilet even if it's only accessible from the garden!

Assuming that living expenses aren't going to go down anytime soon, you don't want to be moving again in a hurry, so you need to make sure the house you get now will suit your family's needs for the foreseeable. So not having to use petrol to get everywhere all the time is a big plus and if you can add another loo and shower and there's space in the garden for a big shed (for bikes and Christmas decorations, etc) it should be fine. But aren't there any other houses that will work for you better than these two?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 04/08/2022 21:55

Stones throw from the Station.
Off Street Parking for 2 cars

Unlimited potential for CF blocked my drove and buggered off to the Station threads .
We'll send round Barry, Larry, Garry ,Harry etc

MichaelAndEagle · 04/08/2022 21:49

ComtesseDeSpair · 04/08/2022 21:34

Location all the way. When you have space you fill space just because you can; when you don’t have it, you don’t, and from experience, you don’t miss it.

I don’t understand why so many people compromise on things like location or amenities to choose a larger house so they have space to store “stuff” and have spare bedrooms. Maybe that’s partly due to being a Londoner, and so prices here mean that it would end up being among the most expensive storage units and occasional hotel rooms in the world! But we’ve never regretted going for smaller, making it work for us, being somewhat disciplined about differentiating between useful stuff and junk, and have a great life with everything we want on the doorstep.

Absolutely! Housing costs are astronomical. Paying more every month just to keep a load of stuff you barely use is not something I'd ever do.
Not when I can be at the beach in 10 minutes.
I have a tween and a teen, and when I've asked if they mind living in a flat when we could have a house in xyz they are both aghast at the idea!!
Clever storage, regular clear outs, that's the answer for us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread