Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is a choice for teachers to work during summer holidays?

213 replies

antelopevalley · 04/08/2022 18:41

I know five teachers in primary and secondary schools. During this summer holiday, two are doing work during the summer holidays. These two teachers are younger and very ambitious. The other three openly say they are doing no work over the summer.
So AIBU to think working over the summer is a choice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
saraclara · 05/08/2022 18:31

As one of my colleagues said when we were both in during the holidays:
"Isn't school great with no children in it?"

PeachCottonTree · 05/08/2022 17:35

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/08/2022 10:17

I find a lot of teachers really resent going in to school to sort things out for the new year. They say they’re not paid for it.

They are paid for it: it’s exactly why they are on much larger wage scales than the TA’s who do much the same work as them in the actual class once kids are in.

Teachers are not all the same, blah blah, and the education system calls for a lot of unnecessary make-work, but I find they’re increasingly entitled and blinkered to the reality of others.

I obviously can’t speak for everyone but I don’t resent going in over the holidays. I quite like organising my stuff and setting up fun learning areas for the children. All my colleagues I’ve bumped into in school over the summer seem happy to be there too, bringing in new purchases and making their classroom environment a more pleasant place to be. It also saves us rushing around in the 90 minutes we’ll get to set up our classrooms the day before the children start back.

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/08/2022 17:28

To add, in terms of holiday clubs, I don't use them as I am at home. When DS was small, I would just work when he was in bed or when DH could occupy him. Occasionally, my parents were available to have him for a day and generously did so.

He is 8 now and I manage fine. We do lots together during the holidays but mostly, we will do something in the morning/over lunch and then he is happy to play at home and I work in between. Today for instance, I took him to a trampoline park this morning and then we did a bit of shopping and had lunch out. He was tired once home so has chilled/played his games etc.

seraandmum2 · 05/08/2022 17:15

"DenholmElliot1
Teachers always maintain that they do work in the school holidays.

However, in my 15 years of helping out at out-of-school clubs, i've not once seen a teachers kid attend."

Depends on the stage that the teacher is at. Although in my 24 years of teaching I've never put my children into summer camps over the holidays. Why would I when I'm home all day and can work around the children?

When I first started teaching, I used to do a lot over the hols just to keep afloat.

A few years down the line, I had children and when they were little, I only worked 2 days a week, so it was easy to over the holidays to work when the kids went to sleep at 7 or when they were napping, or I'd work on a Saturday when DH took the kids to the park for a few hours.

As the children got older, I'd take them to soft play and do some work there whilst they were off on a play date.

Now they're teens, I just work as and when. They come and go, but I work in the mornings when they're still in bed, or when they're out with friends.

But it also depends on the stage you're at for teaching. When I was new to teaching, I'd do loads over the hols, a few years down the line, most of my resources are prepped and then there's not so much that needs doing.. but a change of course spec and you're back to the beginning again, planning a lot during the hols. I'm working a fair bit this holidays as I've recently changed specs but in a couple of years, when it's calmed down, I'll do less again.

mumsneedwine · 05/08/2022 16:58

I'm not resentful about going in for results days - it's part of my job I believe. As is sorting out my new classes - I have 17 next year. I need to know every ECHP, every SEN and any safeguarding issues. I better print some resources off for at the least the first day and have some vague idea what I'm teaching them.
And I will repeat. Teachers are paid for 1,265 hours of directed time a year, over 195 days. With the legal holiday time which amount to 5 weeks. So the remainder of the holiday time we are not paid for - that's about 8 weeks. But a lot of us work in that time because we want your kids to learn and enjoy school.
And yes, there are rubbish teachers, just like there are people rubbish at all jobs. But most are trying their hardest through what have been a v difficult few years.
Be kind seems to have disappeared.

justfiveminutes · 05/08/2022 16:52

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/08/2022 13:37

I knew I’d get crap. I wonder how and why.

Yes I work as a TA. I trained as a teacher but I will not play the politics, can’t manage the required hours, and have to give my own kids extra tutoring to make up for the education that schools in their infinite wisdom have failed to give them. I work in alternative education now.

Around here, TAs are sometimes advertised as graduate positions, and many in mainstream are required to plan. They take classes and are treated badly. You can say that they are on wildly inappropriate contracts if you like, but that does not change practical reality.

As for the whole old rubbish about teachers not being paid for holidays, you are paid to do a job. That job requires work outside school hours which is why it is paid more. TAs are not paid for the holidays. Teachers are.

It's a shame you didn't continue as a teacher so you could change the system from the inside instead of working as a TA whilst feeling so dissatisfied with your role, their role and the state of the education system generally.

justfiveminutes · 05/08/2022 16:47

"I find the conversations with my family/friends who teach go something like this."

It takes all sorts I guess. You shouldn't read too much into what the three teachers you know say. I can see how they might have a moan if they're all together maybe.

"I find a lot of teachers really resent going in to school to sort things out for the new year. They say they’re not paid for it.

They are paid for it"

We are not paid for the holidays. Or do you know teachers who are resentful of doing those jobs during term time?

PumpkinPie2016 · 05/08/2022 16:34

I could choose not to do anything in the holidays but it would leave me on the back foot in September and make things stressful.

I am 10 years in and about to start at a new school as a head of department (can't say too much as it's outing) - if I do nothing over summer, we won't have all curriculum plans in place etc.

My previous school has one INSET day in September, the day before pupils arrive. In all the time I was there, the vast majority of that day was taken up with various meetings. So we would end up with maybe an hour and a half 'free' which isn't a lot of time to sort your room/do displays/class lists etc.

I always find INSET and the first week pretty exhausting 😴 so want to be ahead.

mumsneedwine · 05/08/2022 16:32

@Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks let's hope her kids aren't expecting exam results this year as no one will be collating them if it's optional 😂.

Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 05/08/2022 16:26

Tell you what OP, I will mKe.the choice not to.do.any planning this holiday. You can then hope that it's not your children in critical exam years that I haven't bothered to prep for come September Confused

mumsneedwine · 05/08/2022 16:20

I'll be in day before and results days. I could make it optional but then the students don't get their results - they don't jump into the envelopes & emails do t wire themselves 😂.
I could not bother doing any planning before I go back but then they'll be no lessons for the first week. And I could ignore the transition stuff for new year 7s with extras needs but as we don't yet have a complete list yet I'd better not.
Happy holidays teachers.

Wavygravy1 · 05/08/2022 16:14

DenholmElliot1 · 04/08/2022 18:45

Teachers always maintain that they do work in the school holidays.

However, in my 15 years of helping out at out-of-school clubs, i've not once seen a teachers kid attend.

My mum was a single parent and a teacher. I went into school with her in the holidays.

fussychica · 05/08/2022 16:05

DS is a teacher. He says he'll be working most of the final week of the holiday this year, mainly planning and prep. He'll also probably be going in for results days. He does some work during almost every holiday but it's now a bit less as he's become more experienced.

PeachCottonTree · 05/08/2022 15:44

@antelopevalley “But that does not mean I believe the picture painted either of teachers having to work every school holiday and rarely having a day off.”

There’s a huge difference between working a few days every holiday and rarely having a day off. Most teachers I know do the former. I have never met nor seen a teacher on here claiming to work nearly every day of the year.

saraclara · 05/08/2022 15:01

TAs are not paid for the holidays. Teachers are

Teachers aren't paid FOR the holidays, but they are paid DURING them. That's because their pay for the weeks they work is smoothed over the year, and divided into twelve equal parts, which are paid monthly.

antelopevalley · 05/08/2022 13:50

Teachers are not paid for school holidays.

OP posts:
TailSpinner · 05/08/2022 13:49

That job requires work outside school hours which is why it is paid more. TAs are not paid for the holidays. Teachers are.

Working outside of school hours is not the main reason for the difference in pay though - to think that is just plain daft.

Abraxan · 05/08/2022 13:47

Dd never went to ASC on the holidays even when I was working in the holidays as I could mainly work from home or around her, especially taking into account play dates, seeing her grandparents etc. I would prep in evenings or when she was busy playing or elsewhere.

There are certain things that just need doing, ime. My tech lead role means I need to do things after the children finish for the summer but before the new cohorts begins, aka the summer break.

New to the job teachers will often need to work more in holidays than more experience fed staff.
Those changing year groups and key stages may need to do more than those
staying in the same year group/classes. Those changing classrooms will need to do more than those staying in the same room.
Those with new curriculums in their subject will need to do more than those where the curriculum stays the same that year.
Those that are given time at the end of the school year and time ion the first day or two (if INsET) will need less time than those who don't have that time during those days.

It varies how much is needed sometimes.

I could do nothing in the holidays - no one is going to force me. But it will mean a much harder start to the school year and everything not working quite right for myself, the children, other staff and the parents if I don't.

So yes, it's a choice. But one with consequences that will affect not just me.

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/08/2022 13:37

I knew I’d get crap. I wonder how and why.

Yes I work as a TA. I trained as a teacher but I will not play the politics, can’t manage the required hours, and have to give my own kids extra tutoring to make up for the education that schools in their infinite wisdom have failed to give them. I work in alternative education now.

Around here, TAs are sometimes advertised as graduate positions, and many in mainstream are required to plan. They take classes and are treated badly. You can say that they are on wildly inappropriate contracts if you like, but that does not change practical reality.

As for the whole old rubbish about teachers not being paid for holidays, you are paid to do a job. That job requires work outside school hours which is why it is paid more. TAs are not paid for the holidays. Teachers are.

boopdeflouff · 05/08/2022 12:43

I was also a TA before retraining as a teacher.

I loved being a TA and they are very important and valuable, but it's not the same job at all.

BeanieTeen · 05/08/2022 12:18

@Nannyogg134 you would send children to a holiday club because real work cannot be done with children around. so if you are able to look after primary school aged children while you are working, you are not really working.

I wfh. That means no interruptions, head down at my desk, 8 hours a day. Real work cannot be done with children around.

There’s a lot of generalising on this thread. Surely it all depends on the person. I for one do need my children out of the way to get work done - I work part time Mon-Wed and Thursdays at home I get marking and planning done, sometimes other bits of admin, when the older kids are in school and my littlest one does an extra day in nursery for this - I personally do need the childcare to get things done. The marking I could probably do with the kids pottering about and interrupting from time to time, but not the planning, I need to be fully focussed for that. During very busy periods DH will take the kids out on a Sunday afternoon as well so I can get some more stuff done in peace. And yes, I book them into holiday clubs too.
That is not to say that Nannyogg isn’t working as hard - they may have more chilled out kids than mine or simply be better at multitasking. Or might not mind taking longer to get things done with interruptions - I prefer to get things done quickly without.
Not everyone is the same.
Incidentally my DH works from home sometimes too - he’s not a teacher - and doesn’t mind the kids pottering about when he’s doing so. He’s even taken the kids to work with him in the holidays while I’ve worked from home, because I’m the one that really needs the peace and quiet. I can assure he’s still doing ‘real work’ … I should hope so anyway, he earns more than double my salary 😂

Nannyogg134 · 05/08/2022 11:59

HeartofTeFiti · 05/08/2022 07:05

@Nannyogg134 you would send children to a holiday club because real work cannot be done with children around. so if you are able to look after primary school aged children while you are working, you are not really working.

I wfh. That means no interruptions, head down at my desk, 8 hours a day. Real work cannot be done with children around.

If no-one can work with children around, then that means I've no hope when I get to school eh? I've got 1000 of them walking around outside my door at lunch, coming in asking questions, sorting out scuffles between them etc. I somehow manage to get my marking and paperwork done at the same time. By comparison, having 3 primary kids at home is a breeze. It's a shame that you have such narrow vision tbh.

MardyBumm · 05/08/2022 11:24

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/08/2022 10:17

I find a lot of teachers really resent going in to school to sort things out for the new year. They say they’re not paid for it.

They are paid for it: it’s exactly why they are on much larger wage scales than the TA’s who do much the same work as them in the actual class once kids are in.

Teachers are not all the same, blah blah, and the education system calls for a lot of unnecessary make-work, but I find they’re increasingly entitled and blinkered to the reality of others.

I worked as a TA before I trained to be a teacher and I remember being naive as you as to the amount of work they did and the impact it had on the children. Many TAs are worth their weight in gold but the reality is most do not do the same work as the teacher when actually in the classroom. The teacher makes evidence based decisions on how best to move the children on in their learning, will have researched misconceptions and how to overcome these, will spot that the children haven't quite 'got it' and will regroup and try again in a different way. I don't see (most) TAs doing the same. Teachers are paid more because they are more experienced in how to teach and (usually) have deeper subject knowledge, not because they have to back some boards and label some books over the summer holidays.

42isthemeaning · 05/08/2022 11:17

ParsleySageRosemary · 05/08/2022 10:17

I find a lot of teachers really resent going in to school to sort things out for the new year. They say they’re not paid for it.

They are paid for it: it’s exactly why they are on much larger wage scales than the TA’s who do much the same work as them in the actual class once kids are in.

Teachers are not all the same, blah blah, and the education system calls for a lot of unnecessary make-work, but I find they’re increasingly entitled and blinkered to the reality of others.

Are you a teacher or a TA as I suspect you don't actually know what you're talking about? Hmm

Italiandreams · 05/08/2022 11:05

I don’t know any teachers say they rarely have a day off. The holidays are one of the only reasons I stay in job! I do have to work some of the holidays though.